[BUG] Clover unreliably or even unusable booting from AMIBIOS on ASUS B75 MBO

[succeedmr123]

Describe the bug

Clover versions newer than r5165 (specifically r5172g tested) fail to boot properly on an ASUS P8B75-M LX Plus (B75 chipset) motherboard using latest 0906 AMIBIOS firmware in a legacy-era mid-UEFI environment 2.10.1208 (2014.)

(Ventoy-> memdisk mode on both for least usb interaction IMO)
Important clarification:

This motherboard does support UEFI boot

However, the firmware cannot boot NVMe devices natively

Pretty good, but can not get PCI NVme disks natively and  with some unreasonably tricky ASUS BIOS anti-mod protection for us owners/modders and no possibility to do our own tricky lock options for us as well (c)

Clover is therefore used as a bridge/bootloader to chainload and boot an NVMe-installed OS

Behavior observed:

r5165: partially functional but unstable/fragile

    intermittent boot success

    random hangs/freezes before showing blue/gray boot menu

    inconsistent behavior across reboots

    sometimes succeeds in chainloading NVMe OS

r5172g:

    fails to boot reliably at all (black screen, cursor blink)

    freezes before usable Clover GUI or before successful NVMe chainloading

    effectively unusable on this platform

This appears to be a regression affecting older AMIBIOS-era UEFI implementations used specifically for NVMe boot bridging.
How to reproduce

Steps to reproduce the behavior:

Use an ASUS B75 chipset motherboard with AMIBIOS firmware

Install OS on NVMe SSD

Configure Clover as NVMe boot bridge/loader

Boot system in UEFI mode

Attempt boot using Clover r5172g

Observe freeze/hang/failure before successful NVMe boot

Comparison:

Replace Clover with r5165

Repeat same process

Observe partial functionality with unstable/inconsistent behavior

Expected behavior

Expected:

Clover should initialize correctly on older AMIBIOS-era UEFI firmware

Clover should reliably chainload/boot NVMe-installed OS

Newer Clover revisions should maintain or improve compatibility relative to r5165

Actual:

r5165 = unstable but partially functional

r5172g = complete or near-complete boot failure on this platform

Screenshots

No screenshots currently available because boot failure often occurs before GUI becomes usable.

Can provide:

BIOS screenshots

Clover configuration

boot media layout

debug logs if required

Environment

OS: NVMe-installed OS booted through Clover

Boot mode: UEFI

Clover versions tested:

    r5165 → partially works

    r5172g → fails

Hardware:

    ASUS B75 chipset motherboard

    AMIBIOS firmware (B75-era)

    Intel Xeon E3-1275 v2 (Ivy Bridge)

    NVMe SSD (non-native BIOS support)

    SATA boot helper / Clover boot media

Additional information

This motherboard generation supports UEFI but lacks native NVMe boot support in firmware.

Clover is specifically being used as:

NVMe boot bridge

UEFI chainloader

compatibility layer enabling NVMe boot on older firmware

Older Clover versions appear more tolerant of this firmware environment.

Possible regression areas:

legacy AMI UEFI compatibility

NVMe initialization

UEFI memory mapping changes

driver loading order

boot services handling

GOP/graphics initialization

DXE interaction with older firmware implementations

Potentially affected platforms may include:

Intel B75 / Z77 / H77

Ivy Bridge-era AMIBIOS UEFI boards

systems using Clover specifically for NVMe boot bridging on unsupported firmware generations

[SoffQoffWord]

Hi, try 5171, Its better work than newer version for me (ASUS AMIBIOS B450)