From 503f9f69f8a7d6d5c4c2bc030861bd03f47305f3 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: blakinio <75369544+blakinio@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Sun, 16 Aug 2026 14:33:59 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 1/3] docs(track-a): claim coverage audit refresh --- ...20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md | 121 ++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 121 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/agents/tasks/active/OTC-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md diff --git a/docs/agents/tasks/active/OTC-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md b/docs/agents/tasks/active/OTC-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..b23fbca2bc --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/agents/tasks/active/OTC-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md @@ -0,0 +1,121 @@ +--- +task_id: OTC-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh +status: investigating +agent: ChatGPT +session_id: chatgpt-coverage-audit-20260816-1427 +session_role: researcher_auditor +project_lane: otclient +lane: COVERAGE-AUDIT +track_id: official-client-re +task_kind: audit +phase: investigate +branch: research/OTC-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh +base_branch: main +base_main: ddf7dd9408116fbeaca05bfeb69663f30f7cd34f +current_main: ddf7dd9408116fbeaca05bfeb69663f30f7cd34f +created: 2026-08-16T14:27:00+02:00 +updated: 2026-08-16T14:35:00+02:00 +risk: low +researcher_delivery: draft_only +implementation_authorized: false +owned_paths: + - docs/agents/tasks/active/OTC-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md + - docs/agents/reports/OTCLIENT-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md +modules_touched: [] +reuses: + - docs/agents/prompts/OTCLIENT_TIBIA_RE_COVERAGE_AUDIT_ALIAS.md + - docs/agents/programs/OTCLIENT_TIBIA_RE_EXPERIMENT_EXECUTION_MODEL.md + - closed Draft PR #304 accepted bounded coverage-registry evidence + - current Track A coordinator checkpoint on main + - current exact heads of active Track A Draft PRs, read-only +depends_on: [] +blocks: [] +policy_version: 2 +prompting_standard_version: 2.1 +prompt_contract_version: 1.0.0 +execution_mode: github-only +execution_reason: quantitative coverage, contradiction review and evidence-index auditing are deterministic repository work and must run GitHub-hosted without physical runtime access +run_scope: single_task +continuation_policy: continue_until_real_stop +task_completion_policy: draft_pr_only +user_communication: low_noise +decomposition_decision: single +decomposition_reason: one cohesive cross-lane evidence audit with no implementation or runtime ownership +context_pressure: medium +context_growth: stable +context_score: 8 +estimate_confidence: high +validation_level: focused +session_rotation_count: 0 +stale_takeover_count: 0 +human_interruptions: 0 +track_a_runtime_agent_admission_version: 1 +routing_contract: docs/agents/programs/OTCLIENT_TIBIA_RE_HYBRID_EXECUTION_ROUTING.md +execution_class: github_hosted +runtime_access: none +runtime_owner_task: NOT_APPLICABLE +runtime_namespace: NOT_APPLICABLE +canonical_registration: NOT_APPLICABLE +canonical_lease_generation: NOT_APPLICABLE +registration_lease_generation: NOT_APPLICABLE +gate_a: NOT_APPLICABLE +generation_rebind: NOT_APPLICABLE +gate_b: NOT_APPLICABLE +bootstrap: NOT_APPLICABLE +target_uniqueness: NOT_APPLICABLE +mutation_authorized: false +persistent_session_role: consumer_of_runtime_evidence +physical_e2e_required: false +owner_funded_ai_api_authorized: false +feature_scope: + type: documentation + user_facing: false + backend_required: false + frontend_required: false + integration_required: false + e2e_required: false + completion_claim: internal_only +invocation_started_at: 2026-08-16T14:27:00+02:00 +last_progress_at: 2026-08-16T14:35:00+02:00 +ci_checks_for_current_head: 0 +ci_check_generation: draft-audit +terminal_ci_wait_started_at: null +terminal_ci_checks_for_current_generation: 0 +unchanged_state_checks: 0 +identical_failure_retries: 0 +repair_cycles_for_current_gate: 0 +context_reconstruction_attempts: 0 +stall_warnings: 0 +runtime_nonclaims: + display_98_current_canonical_status: UNKNOWN + rfb_6082_current_backend_mapping: UNKNOWN + current_exact_client_pid: NOT_REGISTERED + current_exact_client_session: NOT_REGISTERED +last_completed_step: resolved live main, current Track A Draft ownership, historical accepted coverage baseline and current no-runtime routing boundary +next_action: audit exact current Draft heads plus canonical programme denominators, persist contradictions/missing-proof inventory, and validate the task-owned report before Draft handoff +--- + +# Track A coverage / contradiction / missing-proof audit refresh + +## Objective + +Falsify campaign completeness from current repository evidence. Reconcile quantitative inventory coverage with semantic proof, identify contradictions/supersessions and missing evidence, and produce bounded next experiments without taking ownership of P0, P1, P2, RUNTIME, QLibrary or viewport implementation/runtime surfaces. + +## Scope boundary + +This task is GitHub-hosted and `runtime_access: none`. It may consume durable runtime evidence and current Draft branches read-only, but it must not use Synology, inspect a live client/display/VNC surface, log in, mutate gameplay/session state, touch PR #303-owned runtime surfaces, or use owner-funded Codex/OpenAI API/paid AI quota. + +## Acceptance + +- [ ] exact current `main` and relevant Track A Draft heads are recorded; +- [ ] every percentage has an explicit denominator and evidence class; +- [ ] inventory completeness is separated from semantic/read/action completion; +- [ ] accepted #304 bounded baseline is reconciled without promoting its closed Draft as canonical runtime truth; +- [ ] protocol/QMeta/P0/P1/P2/runtime/restart coverage gaps are explicitly classified; +- [ ] current contradictions, stale dependencies and supersessions are recorded with exact PR/path/head evidence; +- [ ] no green CI result is treated as capability proof; +- [ ] every material missing proof maps to the smallest falsifiable next discriminator and owning lane; +- [ ] E2E is `NOT_APPLICABLE` with reason because this is a no-runtime documentation/evidence audit; +- [ ] task-owned report receives a fresh documentation audit and exact-head repository/governance validation before Draft handoff. + +Research output is `DRAFT_NOT_PROMOTED`. Coordinator review is required before any global coverage/programme state change or merge. From 82e888d741d4480d0e30d05bc602cf5669e3ff9e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: blakinio <75369544+blakinio@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Sun, 16 Aug 2026 14:40:19 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 2/3] docs(track-a): persist coverage gap audit --- ...20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md | 334 ++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 334 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/agents/reports/OTCLIENT-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md diff --git a/docs/agents/reports/OTCLIENT-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md b/docs/agents/reports/OTCLIENT-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..cdef9c934e --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/agents/reports/OTCLIENT-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md @@ -0,0 +1,334 @@ +# OTCLIENT-TIBIA-RE coverage / contradiction / missing-proof audit — 2026-08-16 + +## Scope and result + +```yaml +task_id: OTC-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh +track: official-client-re +lane: COVERAGE-AUDIT +execution_class: github_hosted +runtime_access: none +physical_e2e: NOT_APPLICABLE_WITH_REASON +researcher_delivery: DRAFT_NOT_PROMOTED +snapshot_main: ddf7dd9408116fbeaca05bfeb69663f30f7cd34f +audit_result: FAIL_MATERIAL_GAPS_OPEN +programme_complete: false +material_findings_open: 9 +high_findings: 4 +medium_findings: 5 +owner_funded_ai_used: false +``` + +This audit attempts to falsify Track A campaign completeness from repository evidence only. It does not execute or observe the physical Tibia client, X11/VNC, login, process memory, network session or gameplay state. Current physical authority therefore remains: + +```yaml +display_98_current_canonical_status: UNKNOWN +rfb_6082_current_backend_mapping: UNKNOWN +current_exact_client_pid: NOT_REGISTERED +current_exact_client_session: NOT_REGISTERED +``` + +Exact researched client fence used by the accepted static evidence: + +```yaml +version: 15.32.df7b29 +size: 51965216 +sha256: e6c244bd39fe2e0632f6f000efd3147164696efa8e901718668e0442325ff7fe +platform: official_native_linux_only +``` + +## Point-in-time live repository snapshot + +Live Git state has priority over stale task/checkpoint prose. The following exact heads were observed during this audit; active workers may advance them after this snapshot. + +| Lane / concern | PR | Observed head | Snapshot disposition | +|---|---:|---|---| +| P0 direct player position | #302 | `d0b56ce562eb3ef6e59c1635687204917553dd32` | Draft; direct XYZ still not proven; new hosted exact-client retrieval hypothesis just landed | +| P1 bridge health/recovery | #357 | `fe37b80423d7cc8b269cd58edc19a2795e01e381` | Draft; semantic repair implementation validated, temporary validation workflow removed, integration/final-head gates remain | +| P2 downstream byte consumer | #310 | `a01281648c35dc04bf20437acc584b55b11ea727` | Draft; `BLOCKED_INPUT_STAGING` | +| canonical physical runtime | #358 | `d78e42b955c27ee07fba783f5496588f34d29461` | Draft; canonical registration absent; bootstrap required but not trusted/promoted | +| canonical bootstrap/rebind/Gate B implementation | #360 | `1d64fab66650b1fcd58388ff5cf6f9a77a392dc4` | Draft; four material coordinator findings remain open | +| hosted QLibrary source correlation | #356 | `f8e3733aa90bde0cd93c3bc6c3a364ac02b625dd` | Draft; load-bearing source validator failed | +| viewport continuation prompt | #363 | `b09e49cc950c091416c640dfd27f0fdfb7dd97fc` | open; continuation metadata still refers to superseded #325 lifecycle | +| this coverage audit | #369 | branch `research/OTC-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh` | Draft-only; coordinator promotion required | + +Historical bounded coverage source: + +```yaml +pr: 304 +final_head: 43a60bd96cc644b656b200c9edbfb75578b330b6 +state: CLOSED_UNMERGED +coordinator_disposition: ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS +exact_head_ci: 31882010038=SUCCESS +claim_boundary: bounded_inventory_baseline_not_global_semantic_coverage +``` + +The #304 registry was accepted as a bounded baseline and copied into superseded coordinator PR #300, but that coordinator branch was not merged. Current `main` evidence root does not contain an equivalent `capabilities.jsonl`, `protocol_messages.jsonl` or `runtime_types.jsonl` registry. The accepted historical blobs remain useful evidence, but they are not a current-main canonical registry. + +## Quantitative coverage ledger + +Every percentage below keeps its original denominator and evidence class. `UNKNOWN` is not rewritten as zero. + +| Metric | Current defensible value | Class | What it proves | What it does **not** prove | +|---|---:|---|---|---| +| generated protocol identifier inventory | `349/349` | FACT / inventory | exact known identifier set exists | semantic support or feature-family classification | +| protocol direction assignment | `349/349` | FACT / structural metadata | all 349 have direction; `189` inbound + `160` outbound | handler/field semantics | +| directly enumerated QMeta links in #304 registry | `27/349 = 7.736%` | FACT / bounded structural subset | 27 generated identifiers have accepted direct static links in that registry | global semantic protocol coverage | +| generated-message semantic support | `UNKNOWN/349` | UNKNOWN | denominator is known | no complete semantic numerator exists | +| protocol-handler QMeta inventory | `47/47` | FACT / bounded structural inventory | exact handler subset is represented | full Tibia-owned QMeta/runtime denominator or semantic coverage | +| raw direct Qt connection census | `2184/2184` | FACT / raw callsite inventory | known raw direct-connection callsites were inventoried | semantic classification of those 2184 edges | +| direct Qt semantic classification | `UNKNOWN/2184` | UNKNOWN | denominator is known | semantic numerator is absent | +| legacy QObject-connect selected subset | `40/41 = 97.561%` | FACT / selected subset | selected legacy edges were structurally resolved | all Qt/QMeta semantics | +| high-information GameAction sender metaobjects | `29/31 = 93.548%` | FACT / selected subset | selected high-information action sender set | global action-method coverage or action ABI proof | +| P0 top-level requirement registry | `16/16` | FACT / requirement registry | all 16 top-level P0 groups were represented in #304 | item-level P0 read/action coverage | +| P0 live-read coverage | `UNKNOWN/UNKNOWN` | UNKNOWN | no global percentage is defensible | terminal R1-R4 coverage | +| P1 bridge-v1 profile target inventory | `7/7` | FACT / implementation inventory | bounded bridge profile target set | overall P1 field/evidence coverage | +| P1 overall field/evidence coverage | `UNKNOWN/UNKNOWN` | UNKNOWN | item-level denominator was never normalized | global P1 completion | +| P2 chain closure | `UNKNOWN/5` | UNKNOWN | five closure questions were explicitly open in #304 | downstream framing/egress closure | +| restart/relogin stability | `UNKNOWN/1` | UNKNOWN | one required stability hypothesis is explicit | R3/R4/A4 restart stability | +| canonical physical runtime | registration `ABSENT`, lease generation `0` in #358 reconciliation | FACT / bounded physical reconciliation | current canonical registration was absent during run `31944216131` / job `95157691875` | current `IN_GAME`, display, VNC, PID, session, live bridge correlation | + +### P0 historical group-level state + +The accepted #304 `capabilities.jsonl` recorded the 16 top-level P0 groups as: + +```yaml +stage_distribution: + INVENTORIED: 7 + STRUCTURALLY_IDENTIFIED: 6 + SEMANTICALLY_SUPPORTED: 1 + UNKNOWN: 2 +read_state_summary: + R0_or_R1_groups: 10 + R1_groups: 1 + UNKNOWN_read_groups: 5 + NOT_APPLICABLE_read_groups: 1 +restart_proven: 0 +``` + +This is a group-level historical registry, not a valid item-level terminal-read percentage. In particular, the programme groups contain multiple independent fields/actions. The broad static capability census also contains more candidate surfaces than #304 normalized into these 16 rows, so the stage distribution must not be treated as exhaustive current static completeness. + +## Material findings + +### AUD-COV-001 — HIGH — accepted machine-readable coverage registry is not canonical on current `main` + +**Classification:** FACT. + +**Evidence:** closed Draft #304 at `43a60bd96cc644b656b200c9edbfb75578b330b6` contains the accepted task-scoped `capabilities.jsonl`, `protocol_messages.jsonl`, `runtime_types.jsonl`, validator and summary. Coordinator comment on #304 accepted it with provenance caveats and copied the blobs into coordinator PR #300. PR #300 was later superseded rather than merged. Current `docs/agents/evidence/` on `main@ddf7dd9408116fbeaca05bfeb69663f30f7cd34f` contains only the official-client RE, bootstrap-contract, lease-manager and viewport-feasibility evidence roots; repository search returns no current-main `capabilities.jsonl`, `protocol_messages.jsonl` or `runtime_types.jsonl`. + +**Impact:** later agents cannot query a single canonical current-main item-level registry and are forced to reconstruct coverage from closed Draft evidence plus reports. This is a durability/coordination gap, not loss of the historical evidence itself. + +**Smallest next discriminator/action:** coordinator reviews #304 accepted blobs against current programme schema and either promotes a provenance-preserving current-main copy or regenerates the same logical datasets from current accepted evidence. Promotion must preserve `UNKNOWN` and `DISPROVEN/SUPERSEDED`, and must not relabel inventory completeness as semantic completeness. + +### AUD-COV-002 — HIGH — required semantic denominators are still incomplete + +**Classification:** FACT for missing normalized denominators; UNKNOWN for resulting semantic coverage. + +The execution model requires at least: + +```text +protocol_message_classification_pct +qmeta_type_classification_pct +p0_capabilities_with_experiment_pct +p0_reads_terminal_pct +p0_actions_terminal_pct +unknown_inbound_count +unclassified_runtime_type_count +restart_validated_capability_count +``` + +Current defensible evidence does not provide all required numerators/denominators: + +- protocol identifier/direction inventory is complete, but accepted semantic support remains `UNKNOWN/349` and no current canonical per-message `feature_family | UNCLASSIFIED` registry exists; +- the 47 protocol handlers are a bounded subset, not the full Tibia-owned QMeta/controller/storage denominator required by E52; +- raw `2184/2184` direct Qt callsites have semantic classification `UNKNOWN/2184`; +- P0 and P1 lack an adopted item-level field/capability denominator, so group counts and bridge profile target counts cannot produce global read/action percentages; +- restart/relogin terminal coverage remains unproven. + +**Impact:** any claim such as “protocol X% complete”, “QMeta X% complete”, “P0 X% complete” or “Track A mostly complete” would be unsupported. + +**Smallest next discriminator/action:** build one current-main canonical registry with per-item provenance and deterministic validation. E51 must classify all 349 messages by feature family or explicit `UNCLASSIFIED`; E52 must define the complete recovered Tibia-owned runtime/QMeta set; P0/P1 must normalize individual read/action capabilities and attach experiment IDs or explicit `BLOCKED/UNSUPPORTED` rationale. + +### AUD-COV-003 — MEDIUM — action/QMeta denominator conflict (`612` vs historical `1004`) + +**Classification:** CONFLICT / unresolved metric-definition mismatch. + +`docs/agents/reports/OTCLIENT-20260814-official-client-capability-census.md` retains `HIGHLEVEL_ACTION_METHOD_COUNT=612` from the direct high-level action census while also preserving an older `1004` action summary. The report explicitly states that the two values must be treated as different definitions until the `1004` provenance/filter is reconstructed. + +**Impact:** no global action-method percentage may use either number as a silent denominator. The accepted `29/31` GameAction sender result remains only a selected high-information subset. + +**Smallest next discriminator/action:** reconstruct the exact query/filter/provenance that produced `1004`, normalize namespace/type/method inclusion rules against the retained `612` census, adopt one machine-verifiable denominator, and retain the other metric as historical/alternate scope if both are legitimate. + +### AUD-COV-004 — HIGH — live semantic promotion is blocked by the canonical runtime/bootstrap chain + +**Classification:** FACT. + +RUNTIME #358 performed a valid read-only Synology reconciliation (`31944216131` / `95157691875`) and proved: + +```yaml +canonical_lease_status: absent +canonical_lease_generation: 0 +canonical_registration: ABSENT +bootstrap: REQUIRED_UNIMPLEMENTED_on_trusted_main +target_uniqueness: UNKNOWN +mutation_authorized: false +``` + +Bootstrap/rebind implementation #360 is not promotion-safe. Coordinator audit `5307269111` retains four material blockers: + +1. `TACOORD-360-001` HIGH — failed post-write rebind probe may leave advanced registration authoritative; +2. `TACOORD-360-002` HIGH — transition/worker shell argv contract is incompatible; +3. `TACOORD-360-003` HIGH — login credentials are exposed in child argv through `xdotool`; +4. `TACOORD-360-004` material dependency — `wireproxy.pid` / SOCKS `25354` ownership is not proven current/non-#303/authorized. + +**Impact:** no current physical mutation/login/bootstrap is authorized. Consequently current `IN_GAME`, live bridge correlation, direct player XYZ, causal P0 reads/actions, R3/R4/A4 restart stability and physical E2E cannot be promoted. + +**Smallest next discriminator/action:** repair exactly the four #360 findings with deterministic hosted tests, independently re-audit, then deliberately promote the corrected primitive to trusted `main`. Only then may #358 execute Gate A -> bootstrap/rebind -> Gate B -> bounded login/relogin/E2E. The first high-information physical proof should be structural `IN_GAME` plus bridge/session correlation, followed by direct player XYZ and fresh-PID/relogin repeatability. + +### AUD-COV-005 — HIGH — compliant exact-client GitHub-hosted input is not yet proven reusable for static closure + +**Classification:** FACT at the last persisted P2/P0 evidence boundary; new #302 retrieval change is IN_PROGRESS/UNVALIDATED at this snapshot. + +P2 #310 has two accepted GitHub-hosted/no-runtime materialization attempts: + +```yaml +run_31944074222: download.tibia.com DNS failure +run_31944119641: static.tibia.com HTTP 403 +semantic_validator_executed: false +synology_static_fallback: forbidden +``` + +Therefore the current P2 first downstream consumer, framing/stage order, sequence/compression/encryption boundary and final binary egress remain `UNKNOWN`. + +P0 #302 shares the same exact-client fence. Its newly observed head `d0b56ce562eb3ef6e59c1635687204917553dd32` replaces historical Synology static execution with a GitHub-hosted exact-client retrieval hypothesis using the official static endpoint plus a same-URL Referer. At this snapshot the durable P0 task/evidence still classifies hosted input as blocked and no new exact-SHA semantic artifact/result has yet been persisted. The new workflow commit itself is not proof that input staging succeeded. + +**Impact:** both P2 exact-binary closure and the missing P0 instruction window around `0x8367c1` remain blocked until a hosted run proves exact size/SHA and produces sanitized evidence. + +**Smallest next discriminator/action:** consume the first terminal exact-SHA-fenced result from the new hosted P0 retrieval hypothesis. If it legally and technically materializes the exact official binary, coordinator should evaluate that same compliant staging mechanism for P2 rather than inventing a second source. If it fails, establish one coordinator-approved GitHub-hosted-readable staging source; do not fall back to Synology for deterministic static RE. + +### AUD-COV-006 — MEDIUM — P1 code findings are repaired, but P1 is not yet promotable and has no live semantic authority + +**Classification:** FACT. + +P1 #357 repaired the two earlier semantic code findings and validated the repaired implementation at `bf0fe057c5f320508dc7c9f0e5f2a55c2c3e1448` in run `31947365151=SUCCESS`. The current observed PR head `fe37b80423d7cc8b269cd58edc19a2795e01e381` removes the temporary validation workflow after that component validation. + +Open gates remain: + +- same-PR reusable integration records in `docs/agents/MODULE_CATALOG.md` and `docs/agents/CHANGELOG.md` are blocked on serialization because open PR #23 owns those shared paths; +- current-main refresh and final exact-head normal governance/repository CI remain to be completed after integration; +- coordinator promotion remains required; +- `session-status` remains `DERIVED_UNTIL_LIVE_CORRELATION` and does not prove current canonical runtime, `IN_GAME`, restart/relogin stability or player position. + +**Impact:** repaired hosted bridge code improves implementation coverage, but does not increase live semantic/R4 coverage yet. + +**Smallest next discriminator/action:** serialize shared index ownership, add integration docs on #357, refresh from current main, run exact final-head governance/CI, coordinator-review the final branch. Physical bridge/session correlation remains a separate bounded RUNTIME proof. + +### AUD-COV-007 — MEDIUM — durable coordinator checkpoint is stale relative to live Git state + +**Classification:** FACT. + +Current-main task `docs/agents/tasks/active/OTC-20260816-track-a-promotion-coordination.md` is a waiting snapshot whose embedded `current_main` is `0d7b2607912552599ae501891491aab439cfde7b`. Live `main` is `ddf7dd9408116fbeaca05bfeb69663f30f7cd34f`. + +The checkpoint also still lists #325 and #295 among relevant open PRs even though both are closed unmerged, and its P1 lane barrier records head `edcc3f85bbe084667cb89024b54cd3ab79185809` while live #357 has advanced through repaired heads to `fe37b80423d7cc8b269cd58edc19a2795e01e381`. + +**Impact:** the coordinator document is useful historical state but must not be treated as the current lane barrier. Repository policy already resolves the conflict correctly: live Git/PR state has higher authority. + +**Smallest next discriminator/action:** the next coordinator invocation should refresh its single owned checkpoint from exact live main/heads and current accepted evidence, removing closed PRs and incorporating the repaired P1 state. No other lane should mutate the coordinator checkpoint. + +### AUD-COV-008 — MEDIUM — QLibrary load-bearing hosted validator is still failed + +**Classification:** FACT. + +#356 exact head `f8e3733aa90bde0cd93c3bc6c3a364ac02b625dd` has green repository governance/CI but load-bearing Qt source validation `31943243252` / job `95155325324` failed. Coordinator findings remain: + +- `QLIB-COORD-001`: validator expects the wrong Qt 6.9.3 `.so` suffix source form; +- `QLIB-COORD-002`: generated candidate order must remain distinct from actual `dlopen` attempt order because an existing absolute-path candidate that fails to load can stop later retries. + +**Impact:** green generic CI cannot be used as evidence for QLibrary semantic resolution, and actual successful runtime mapping remains `UNKNOWN`. + +**Smallest next discriminator/action:** repair the structural source validator on #356 against exact official Qt 6.9.3 source, encode generated-vs-attempted ordering explicitly, rerun hosted validation, persist hashes/output, and retain successful runtime mapping as unknown absent RUNTIME evidence. + +### AUD-COV-009 — MEDIUM — viewport continuation metadata is stale against the promoted current-main feasibility checkpoint + +**Classification:** FACT for lifecycle staleness; governance consequence is RECOMMENDATION pending #363 owner refresh. + +#363 task `docs/agents/tasks/active/OTC-20260816-track-a-viewport-continuation-prompt.md` still treats PR #325 as a current dependency/read-only source. Live #325 is closed unmerged; its accepted report/evidence was replayed and promoted to `main` through #366, and the feasibility task is archived on `main@ddf7dd...`. + +The #363 task also predates the full post-#331 hybrid-routing front-matter shape used by current Track A tasks: it records `runtime_access: none` admission fields, but does not record `routing_contract`, `execution_class`, `persistent_session_role` and `physical_e2e_required` in the active task checkpoint. + +The prompt's strict GUI rule itself remains safe: it says to reuse an existing logged-in session only when current ownership/admission permits and otherwise stop `WAITING/BLOCKED`. Because current canonical PID/session are `NOT_REGISTERED`, the prompt must not infer that such a reusable session exists. + +**Impact:** a new viewport worker could start from stale lifecycle metadata even though the research conclusions themselves were preserved on current `main`. + +**Smallest next discriminator/action:** #363 owner should replace #325 lifecycle dependency with the current-main feasibility report/evidence/archive, add the current hybrid-routing fields for a GitHub-hosted/no-runtime task, preserve the `NOT_REGISTERED` runtime nonclaim, then run exact-head governance/CI. No runtime bootstrap is justified by this documentation repair. + +## Supersessions and negative evidence that must remain explicit + +The audit retains the following non-positive evidence rather than allowing later workers to rediscover/re-promote it accidentally: + +| Evidence / model | Required classification | +|---|---| +| historical `0xb5b880` P2 endpoint model | `DISPROVEN/SUPERSEDED` | +| `0xb46bd0` binary gameplay sink claim | `DISPROVEN/SUPERSEDED` | +| `0xc33259` network-sink claim | `DISPROVEN/SUPERSEDED` | +| stale `TProtocolWriter` RTTI `0x3080700` | `DISPROVEN/SUPERSEDED`; later exact evidence used corrected `0x3080728` | +| PR #303 physical runtime surfaces | `CLOSED_SUPERSEDED`, historical evidence only, never current runtime authority | +| PR #325 viewport task branch | `CLOSED_SUPERSEDED`; accepted report/evidence now on current `main` via #366 | +| PR #304 coverage branch | `CLOSED_UNMERGED`; accepted bounded evidence only, not current canonical registry | +| socket existence/byte deltas alone | insufficient for `IN_GAME` or server-accepted movement | +| green generic CI alone | execution evidence only, never semantic/capability proof | + +## Missing-proof queue, ordered by information gain + +| Priority | Missing proof | Owning lane / executor | Smallest falsifiable next step | +|---:|---|---|---| +| 1 | current canonical machine-readable coverage registries | COVERAGE-AUDIT + coordinator, GitHub-hosted | promote/regenerate provenance-preserving `capabilities`, `protocol_messages`, `runtime_types` and validator on current main | +| 2 | full 349-message semantic/family classification | protocol/COVERAGE-AUDIT, GitHub-hosted | E51: every identifier gets family or explicit `UNCLASSIFIED`, fields/handler provenance where known | +| 3 | full Tibia-owned QMeta/runtime denominator | QMeta/COVERAGE-AUDIT, GitHub-hosted | E52: enumerate types/controllers/storages, classify every entry or ignored-with-reason | +| 4 | exact-client hosted staging | coordinator + P0/P2, GitHub-hosted | prove one official exact-SHA staging mechanism and reuse it across static lanes | +| 5 | promotion-safe canonical bootstrap/rebind | RUNTIME-INFRA #360, GitHub-hosted tests first | repair TACOORD-360-001..004 and pass independent re-audit | +| 6 | structural current `IN_GAME` + bridge correlation | RUNTIME #358, Synology physical only after trusted gates | Gate A/bootstrap/Gate B then one bounded structural session proof; no historical display/PID reuse | +| 7 | direct authoritative player XYZ | P0 static + RUNTIME physical evidence | recover member/accessor candidate; two passive live observations + structural world comparison + camera/viewport negative controls | +| 8 | restart/relogin stability | RUNTIME with P0/P1 consumer | fresh PID/PIE/session, rediscover and reproduce same semantic read/bridge correlation | +| 9 | P2 downstream transform/framing/egress | P2 GitHub-hosted | once exact input exists, prove first consumer then one stage at a time; keep compression/encryption/sequence/final egress unknown until exact evidence | +| 10 | action/QMeta normalized denominator | COVERAGE-AUDIT/QMeta, GitHub-hosted | reconcile `612` vs `1004`, then classify selected action surfaces against one explicit denominator | +| 11 | viewport patch/dependency graph | viewport static RE, GitHub-hosted | consume current-main feasibility report and recover extent/storage/protocol/render/camera/picker field/reader/writer graph before mutation | + +## Campaign completeness verdict + +```yaml +protocol_identifier_inventory_complete: true +protocol_semantic_coverage_complete: false +qmeta_handler_subset_inventory_complete: true +full_qmeta_runtime_denominator_complete: false +p0_group_requirement_inventory_complete: true +p0_item_level_read_action_denominator_complete: false +p1_implementation_profile_inventory_complete: true +p1_global_semantic_coverage_complete: false +p2_chain_complete: false +canonical_physical_runtime_ready: false +restart_relogin_stability_proven: false +stable_live_bridge_semantics_proven: false +programme_complete: false +``` + +No evidence in this audit supports a Track A completion claim. The largest quantitative progress is inventory/structural coverage. The highest-information remaining work is to restore a canonical queryable registry, clear exact-client hosted staging, make the canonical bootstrap path promotion-safe, and then use RUNTIME only for the narrow physical discriminators that static GitHub-hosted work cannot prove. + +## Audit and E2E classification + +```yaml +audit: + result: FAIL_MATERIAL_GAPS_OPEN + findings: + high: 4 + medium: 5 + false_completion_claim_found: false + inventory_vs_semantic_boundary_preserved: true + historical_runtime_promoted_to_current: false + negative_evidence_preserved: true +e2e: + result: NOT_APPLICABLE_WITH_REASON + reason: documentation/evidence-only COVERAGE-AUDIT with runtime_access none; physical E2E belongs exclusively to the admitted RUNTIME lane +``` + +The next gate for this Draft is exact-head repository/governance validation and coordinator review. This researcher does not merge or promote global coverage state. From 17df0fdf5385aa7ab9f337afc012884cde716905 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: blakinio <75369544+blakinio@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Sun, 16 Aug 2026 14:40:57 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 3/3] docs(track-a): checkpoint coverage audit findings --- ...20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md | 67 +++++++++++++------ 1 file changed, 47 insertions(+), 20 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/agents/tasks/active/OTC-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md b/docs/agents/tasks/active/OTC-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md index b23fbca2bc..6c915bf22f 100644 --- a/docs/agents/tasks/active/OTC-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md +++ b/docs/agents/tasks/active/OTC-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ --- task_id: OTC-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh -status: investigating +status: validating agent: ChatGPT session_id: chatgpt-coverage-audit-20260816-1427 session_role: researcher_auditor @@ -8,13 +8,14 @@ project_lane: otclient lane: COVERAGE-AUDIT track_id: official-client-re task_kind: audit -phase: investigate +phase: validate branch: research/OTC-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh base_branch: main base_main: ddf7dd9408116fbeaca05bfeb69663f30f7cd34f current_main: ddf7dd9408116fbeaca05bfeb69663f30f7cd34f +pull_request: 369 created: 2026-08-16T14:27:00+02:00 -updated: 2026-08-16T14:35:00+02:00 +updated: 2026-08-16T14:41:00+02:00 risk: low researcher_delivery: draft_only implementation_authorized: false @@ -76,23 +77,43 @@ feature_scope: e2e_required: false completion_claim: internal_only invocation_started_at: 2026-08-16T14:27:00+02:00 -last_progress_at: 2026-08-16T14:35:00+02:00 +last_progress_at: 2026-08-16T14:41:00+02:00 ci_checks_for_current_head: 0 -ci_check_generation: draft-audit -terminal_ci_wait_started_at: null +ci_check_generation: final-audit-head +terminal_ci_wait_started_at: 2026-08-16T14:41:00+02:00 terminal_ci_checks_for_current_generation: 0 unchanged_state_checks: 0 identical_failure_retries: 0 repair_cycles_for_current_gate: 0 context_reconstruction_attempts: 0 stall_warnings: 0 +snapshot_heads: + P0_PR302: d0b56ce562eb3ef6e59c1635687204917553dd32 + P1_PR357: fe37b80423d7cc8b269cd58edc19a2795e01e381 + P2_PR310: a01281648c35dc04bf20437acc584b55b11ea727 + RUNTIME_PR358: d78e42b955c27ee07fba783f5496588f34d29461 + RUNTIME_INFRA_PR360: 1d64fab66650b1fcd58388ff5cf6f9a77a392dc4 + QLIBRARY_PR356: f8e3733aa90bde0cd93c3bc6c3a364ac02b625dd + VIEWPORT_PROMPT_PR363: b09e49cc950c091416c640dfd27f0fdfb7dd97fc +historical_coverage_baseline: + pr: 304 + final_head: 43a60bd96cc644b656b200c9edbfb75578b330b6 + disposition: ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS_BOUNDED_INVENTORY_ONLY + merged: false +audit_result: FAIL_MATERIAL_GAPS_OPEN +material_findings_open: 9 +high_findings: 4 +medium_findings: 5 +programme_complete: false runtime_nonclaims: display_98_current_canonical_status: UNKNOWN rfb_6082_current_backend_mapping: UNKNOWN current_exact_client_pid: NOT_REGISTERED current_exact_client_session: NOT_REGISTERED -last_completed_step: resolved live main, current Track A Draft ownership, historical accepted coverage baseline and current no-runtime routing boundary -next_action: audit exact current Draft heads plus canonical programme denominators, persist contradictions/missing-proof inventory, and validate the task-owned report before Draft handoff +last_checkpoint: + - docs/agents/reports/OTCLIENT-20260816-track-a-coverage-audit-refresh.md +last_completed_step: persisted a denominator-preserving current-state coverage ledger, nine stable material findings, supersession/negative-evidence table and information-gain-ordered missing-proof queue +next_action: validate this exact Draft head with Track A governance and repository CI, then publish a no-head-change handoff to coordinator; do not merge or promote global coverage state --- # Track A coverage / contradiction / missing-proof audit refresh @@ -103,19 +124,25 @@ Falsify campaign completeness from current repository evidence. Reconcile quanti ## Scope boundary -This task is GitHub-hosted and `runtime_access: none`. It may consume durable runtime evidence and current Draft branches read-only, but it must not use Synology, inspect a live client/display/VNC surface, log in, mutate gameplay/session state, touch PR #303-owned runtime surfaces, or use owner-funded Codex/OpenAI API/paid AI quota. +This task is GitHub-hosted and `runtime_access: none`. It consumed durable runtime evidence and exact live Draft heads read-only. It did not use Synology, inspect a live client/display/VNC surface, log in, mutate gameplay/session state, touch PR #303-owned runtime surfaces, or use owner-funded Codex/OpenAI API/paid AI quota. ## Acceptance -- [ ] exact current `main` and relevant Track A Draft heads are recorded; -- [ ] every percentage has an explicit denominator and evidence class; -- [ ] inventory completeness is separated from semantic/read/action completion; -- [ ] accepted #304 bounded baseline is reconciled without promoting its closed Draft as canonical runtime truth; -- [ ] protocol/QMeta/P0/P1/P2/runtime/restart coverage gaps are explicitly classified; -- [ ] current contradictions, stale dependencies and supersessions are recorded with exact PR/path/head evidence; -- [ ] no green CI result is treated as capability proof; -- [ ] every material missing proof maps to the smallest falsifiable next discriminator and owning lane; -- [ ] E2E is `NOT_APPLICABLE` with reason because this is a no-runtime documentation/evidence audit; -- [ ] task-owned report receives a fresh documentation audit and exact-head repository/governance validation before Draft handoff. +- [x] exact current `main` and relevant Track A Draft heads are recorded; +- [x] every percentage has an explicit denominator and evidence class; +- [x] inventory completeness is separated from semantic/read/action completion; +- [x] accepted #304 bounded baseline is reconciled without promoting its closed Draft as canonical runtime truth; +- [x] protocol/QMeta/P0/P1/P2/runtime/restart coverage gaps are explicitly classified; +- [x] current contradictions, stale dependencies and supersessions are recorded with exact PR/path/head evidence; +- [x] no green CI result is treated as capability proof; +- [x] every material missing proof maps to the smallest falsifiable next discriminator and owning lane; +- [x] E2E is `NOT_APPLICABLE_WITH_REASON` because this is a no-runtime documentation/evidence audit; +- [ ] exact final-head Track A governance and repository CI complete successfully before Draft handoff. + +## Result + +`FAIL_MATERIAL_GAPS_OPEN` / `DRAFT_NOT_PROMOTED`. + +The report records nine open material findings: four HIGH and five MEDIUM. No evidence supports a Track A completion claim. The dominant remaining gaps are canonical machine-readable coverage durability, semantic denominators, promotion-safe canonical runtime bootstrap, and reusable compliant GitHub-hosted exact-client staging. -Research output is `DRAFT_NOT_PROMOTED`. Coordinator review is required before any global coverage/programme state change or merge. +Coordinator review is required before any global coverage/programme state change or merge.