diff --git a/docs/product/delivery/phase-06/reviews/P6.04-pr-review.triage.json b/docs/product/delivery/phase-06/reviews/P6.04-pr-review.triage.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..e790dd75 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/product/delivery/phase-06/reviews/P6.04-pr-review.triage.json @@ -0,0 +1,10 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "recordedAt": "2026-06-17T03:39:37.505Z", + "outcome": "skipped", + "note": "PR review disabled by policy", + "prBodyRefresh": { + "attemptedAt": "2026-06-17T03:39:40.760Z", + "status": "updated" + } +} diff --git a/docs/product/delivery/phase-06/reviews/P6.04-subagent-review.ledger.json b/docs/product/delivery/phase-06/reviews/P6.04-subagent-review.ledger.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c46352dc --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/product/delivery/phase-06/reviews/P6.04-subagent-review.ledger.json @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +{ + "ticket": "P6.04", + "invocations": [ + { + "runnerKind": "claude-cli", + "reviewedHeadSha": "dc35ac26f0932894469f3a05393460306f14e34e", + "outcome": "clean", + "completedAt": "2026-06-17T03:37:59.277Z", + "terminatedReason": "completed", + "rawOutput": "docs/product/delivery/phase-06/reviews/P6.04-subagent-review.report.md", + "filledPrompt": "docs/product/delivery/phase-06/reviews/P6.04-subagent-review.prompt.md", + "fallbackLevel": "preferred", + "schemaVersion": 1, + "primaryAgent": "claude", + "runnerSelfReport": "completed", + "fallbackFrom": null, + "findings": [], + "probedSurfaces": [], + "patches": [] + }, + { + "runnerKind": "operator-recorder", + "reviewedHeadSha": "dc35ac26f0932894469f3a05393460306f14e34e", + "outcome": "deferred", + "completedAt": "2026-06-17T03:38:42.472Z", + "terminatedReason": "completed", + "findings": [], + "probedSurfaces": [], + "patches": [], + "reason": "Condition B false positive: subagent used --- horizontal rules in report (violating template instructions), causing the section parser to misread the Actionable findings section. Actual findings: None. Advisory observations are non-blocking doc-vs-code drift notes (on:update T05 exception not in ticket Outcome) and DailyGauge selectedDate ordering note.", + "schemaVersion": 1, + "primaryAgent": "claude", + "runnerSelfReport": null, + "fallbackFrom": null + } + ] +} diff --git a/docs/product/delivery/phase-06/reviews/P6.04-subagent-review.prompt.md b/docs/product/delivery/phase-06/reviews/P6.04-subagent-review.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c709e207 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/product/delivery/phase-06/reviews/P6.04-subagent-review.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,135 @@ +You are conducting an adversarial review of a code change. +You may add extra attack surfaces when your independent repo read finds a plausible +ticket-relevant failure path. +Findings outside the three finding-discipline clauses belong in **Advisory Observations** — +anything off-scope but real is welcome there. +Your job is not a general code review — it is a targeted attack on the behavior this ticket is supposed to +protect. Start from the invariants and attack surfaces below, then independently inspect +the diff and directly related implementation code for missing ticket-relevant risks. You +are looking for paths where the ticket's intended behavior breaks, not for general +improvements. + +### Ticket scope + +**Outcome:** +- These 8 files use runes only: `LineChart/LineChart.svelte`, `PieChart/PieChart.svelte`, `ScatterPlot/ScatterPlot.svelte`, `Treemap/Treemap.svelte`, `TimelineChart/TimelineChart.svelte`, `GaugeChart/DailyGauge.svelte`, `AiTokenBarChart/AiTokenBarChart.svelte`, `AiLinesPieChart/AiLinesPieChart.svelte`. +- All apply the T01 ECharts recipe (`$derived option` + `$effect(setOption)`). +- Each file carries ``. +- `grep` for legacy idioms in these files returns zero (modulo T05-deferred `on:update` cross-boundary bridges in TimelineChart and DailyGauge). + +**Rationale:** +- Red first: n/a (`Red: skip`). +- Why this path: mechanical application of the proven T01 recipe across the remaining standalone charts. +- Alternative considered: per-chart tickets — rejected as ceremony for a solo operator on mechanical work. +- Deferred: chart control components (T05). `on:update` in TimelineChart and DailyGauge are T05-deferred cross-boundary bridges (same as ActivityChart in T03 — TypeScript rejects `onupdate` as unknown prop until T05 migrates the Svelte 4 child components). + +### Files touched + +Implementation: +src/lib/components/LineChart/LineChart.svelte +src/lib/components/PieChart/PieChart.svelte +src/lib/components/ScatterPlot/ScatterPlot.svelte +src/lib/components/Treemap/Treemap.svelte +src/lib/components/TimelineChart/TimelineChart.svelte +src/lib/components/GaugeChart/DailyGauge.svelte +src/lib/components/AiTokenBarChart/AiTokenBarChart.svelte +src/lib/components/AiLinesPieChart/AiLinesPieChart.svelte + +Tests: +None (Red: skip — behavior-preserving refactor; existing spec guards unchanged). + +### Invariants to hold + +1. Every file in scope has `` and zero remaining legacy idioms (`export let`, `$:`, `afterUpdate`), with the explicitly documented exception of `on:update` in TimelineChart and DailyGauge deferred to T05. +2. The T01 ECharts recipe is applied in each chart: `option` is `$derived`, `chart.setOption(option)` is called inside a `$effect`, and the `$effect` guards against an uninitialized chart ref. +3. `DailyGauge`'s local `selectedDate` state is properly managed: initialized to `$state('')`, updated by the side-effecting `$effect` when `defaultDate` changes, and updated by `onUpdate` when the user selects a date. + +### Attack surfaces to probe + +1. `DailyGauge.svelte` — `$effect` for `selectedDate` update: `$effect(() => { if (defaultDate && (!selectedDate || !availableDates.includes(selectedDate))) { selectedDate = defaultDate } })`. Probe whether this `$effect` creates an infinite loop: `selectedDate` is `$state`, reading `selectedDate` inside the `$effect` marks it as a dependency, writing `selectedDate = defaultDate` triggers a re-run. Since `availableDates.includes(selectedDate)` then returns true, the condition is false on the second run and no write occurs — but verify this reasoning holds. +2. `DailyGauge.svelte` — dual `$effect` for chart init: a `$effect` sets `selectedDate` (writing state), and a separate `$effect` re-renders the chart (reading `option` which reads `data` which reads `selectedDate`). Probe whether the ordering guarantee between these two effects is correct: does the chart re-render fire after `selectedDate` is settled, or can it fire with the stale empty string? +3. `TimelineChart.svelte` — `durations` local state: `let durations = $state(durationsProp)` captures the initial prop. Same pattern as ActivityChart in T03. Probe whether `hasData` and `option` are derived from the local `durations` (not `durationsProp`), and that the `onUpdate` handler writes to `durations` (not `durationsProp`). +4. `Treemap.svelte` — `$page` store in runes mode: `$page` is used inside two `$derived` expressions. In Svelte 5 runes mode, the `$store` auto-subscribe syntax is still valid. Probe whether TypeScript and the Svelte compiler accept `$page.params.projectName` inside `$derived(...)` in a runes-mode file, and whether the derived values re-run when the page params change. +5. `AiLinesPieChart.svelte` — nullable option propagation: `option` is `$derived(hasData ? buildAiLinesPieOption(slices!) : null)`. The `$effect` guards with `if (option) chart.setOption(option)`. Probe whether the non-null assertion `slices!` is safe at the point it's evaluated (i.e., `hasData` is true, meaning `slices !== null`). + +#### Diff-derived attack surfaces + +1. **Output stability across schema-version drift** — [N/A — purely in-memory component refactor; no persisted artifacts or schemas changed]. +2. **CLI flag/arg symmetry** — [N/A — no CLI flags modified]. +3. **Error-class breadth in `catch` blocks** — [N/A — no try/catch blocks in these files; same as T03]. +4. **Defensive layering at module boundaries** — Probe whether `createTimelineChartOption`, `createDisciplineGaugeData`, and `createDisciplineGaugeOption` handle their inputs defensively. `DailyGauge` passes `selectedDate` (which starts as empty string `''`) to `createDisciplineGaugeData`; verify the helper handles an empty string date without throwing before the `$effect` sets it to `defaultDate`. +5. **Cross-file atomicity windows** — [N/A — no multi-step file writes]. +6. **Test-contract strength** — Probe whether `PieChart.spec.ts`, `AiTokenBarChart.spec.ts`, and `AiLinesPieChart.spec.ts` are compatible with the runes migration — specifically, whether they pass props in a way that works with `$props()`. +7. **Doc-vs-code drift in the ticket Rationale** — Read the ticket Rationale and outcome against the diff. Verify: (a) T01 recipe applied to all 8 charts; (b) `on:update` bridges in TimelineChart and DailyGauge are correctly identified as T05-deferred; (c) the `DailyGauge` reactive state pattern is correctly described. + +### Diff context + +Eight files migrated from Svelte 4 to Svelte 5 runes. Patterns: + +- **Simple charts (LineChart, PieChart, ScatterPlot, Treemap, AiTokenBarChart, AiLinesPieChart):** `export let` → `$props()`, `$:` → `$derived`, `afterUpdate` → `$effect`. Template unchanged. +- **TimelineChart:** Same as ActivityChart in T03 — `durations` prop renamed to `durationsProp`, local `let durations = $state(durationsProp)` created, `on:update={onUpdate}` kept as T05 bridge. +- **DailyGauge:** Most complex. `selectedDate` stays as `$state('')`. `availableDates` and `defaultDate` become `$derived`. The reactive side-effect `$: if (defaultDate && ...) { selectedDate = defaultDate }` becomes `$effect(() => { if (defaultDate && ...) { selectedDate = defaultDate } })`. `on:update={onUpdate}` kept as T05 bridge. +- `Treemap` uses `$page` from `$app/stores` inside `$derived()` — valid in runes mode. + +--- + +### Your directives + +**Scope:** You conduct an adversarial review of the implementation diff and directly +related code paths named in the attack surfaces. Do not expand scope beyond what the +ticket outcome describes. + +**Advisory-only — no file writes:** You must not create, modify, or delete any file in +the repository. Your entire deliverable is findings prose in the required output format +below. The primary execution agent owns all patches. + +**Read boundary for delivery docs:** Do not write files under `docs/product/delivery/**` +(or anywhere else). You **must** still read the ticket Rationale and any referenced +contract docs as part of probing the "Doc-vs-code drift in the ticket Rationale" +diff-derived surface above. + +**Coverage mandate:** For each attack surface listed above, you must either probe it and +report what you found, or explain in one sentence why it does not apply. + +**Finding discipline:** Report a finding when one of the following holds: + +1. The code breaks a stated invariant. +2. The code introduces a correctness gap you can demonstrate. +3. **Spec-permits-real-bug:** the ticket's stated contract literally permits the + behavior, but that behavior is nevertheless unsafe in production. + +Do not report style, preference, or hypothetical future requirements as blocking findings. + +**No fabrication pressure:** If all invariants hold and all attack surfaces are sound, your +correct output is a clean report. Do not invent findings to justify the review step. + +--- + +### Required output format + +After completing your review, report in this exact structure (prose only — no file edits). + +- Use exactly these five top-level section headings, in this order: + `Invariant results`, `Surface results`, `Actionable findings`, + `Advisory Observations`, `Runner termination`. +- **Do not use `---` horizontal rules anywhere in the report.** +- **`Runner termination` must be the section heading**, not an inline key-value variant. +- Inside `Advisory Observations`, write **one observation per bullet or one observation per paragraph**. Do NOT use a bold span on a line by itself before the observation body. + +**Invariant results** +For each invariant: `[held | broken | untested]` — one line explaining what you tried. + +**Surface results** +For each attack surface (both ticket-spec-derived and the seven diff-derived classes): +`[probed | N/A — | blocked — missing-input]` +If probed: what you tried and what you found (one to three sentences). + +**Actionable findings** +If none: "None." + +**Advisory Observations** +If none: "None." + +**Runner termination** +runnerStatus: completed | rate_limit | sandbox_denied | runner_unavailable +terminatedReason: one short sentence explaining why this status was reported. diff --git a/docs/product/delivery/phase-06/reviews/P6.04-subagent-review.report.md b/docs/product/delivery/phase-06/reviews/P6.04-subagent-review.report.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..1c3abb4b --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/product/delivery/phase-06/reviews/P6.04-subagent-review.report.md @@ -0,0 +1,62 @@ +I have enough data. Compiling the report now. + +--- + +**Invariant results** + +1. `` present and zero legacy `export let` / `$:` / `afterUpdate` idioms — **held**. All 8 files confirmed on read. `on:update` is present in TimelineChart (line 57) and DailyGauge (line 65); these are the documented T05-deferred cross-boundary bridges and are not in the legacy-idiom ban list. + +2. T01 ECharts recipe (`$derived option` + `$effect(setOption)` + guard against uninitialized chart ref) — **held**. LineChart and ScatterPlot guard via `chart?.setOption(option)` (optional-chain null-guard); the remaining six files guard with explicit `if (!chartRef)` checks or `if (!chart)` re-init branches. All 8 have `option` as `$derived`. + +3. `DailyGauge` `selectedDate` state lifecycle — **held**. `selectedDate = $state('')`; updated by `$effect` when `defaultDate` changes; updated by `onUpdate` when user selects a date. + +--- + +**Surface results** + +**Surface 1 — DailyGauge `$effect` infinite loop probe:** probed. The `$effect` reads `defaultDate`, `selectedDate`, and `availableDates`. First run: `selectedDate = ''` → condition is true → writes `selectedDate = defaultDate`. Second run: `availableDates.includes(selectedDate)` returns true → condition is false → no write. Loop terminates after one write. No infinite loop. + +**Surface 2 — DailyGauge dual-effect ordering:** probed. Svelte 5 runs effects in registration order during the mount flush. Declaration order in the file: selectedDate `$effect` (line 29) → `onMount` (line 38) → chart update `$effect` (line 51). So the selectedDate effect fires first (settling `selectedDate = defaultDate`), `onMount` fires second (reading `option` derived from the now-settled `selectedDate`), then the chart update `$effect` fires third. On the initial mount this means `setOption` is called twice — once in `onMount` and once in the chart update `$effect`. ECharts handles repeated `setOption` calls idempotently; no visual artifact. This is the same accepted dual-call pattern as ActivityChart in T03. + +**Surface 3 — TimelineChart `durations` local state:** probed. `hasData` (line 27) and `option` (line 28) are both derived from local `durations` (`$state`), not `durationsProp`. `onUpdate` (line 49) writes to `durations`. The pattern is consistent with T03's ActivityChart. ✓ + +**Surface 4 — Treemap `$page` store in runes mode:** probed. `$page` is a Svelte store; the `$store` auto-subscribe shorthand is valid inside `$derived` in runes mode. The Svelte 5 compiler wraps the store read in the reactive context, so the derived values re-run when page params change. TypeScript accepts this. One pre-existing concern: `$page.params.projectName` is `string | undefined` at runtime (SvelteKit types `params` as `Record` but returns `undefined` for missing keys), and `createProjectFileToTimeDict` and `createTreemapOption` declare `projectName: string`. The split `entity.name.split('undefined/')` would silently produce wrong keys if `projectName` is undefined. This gap pre-dates the migration; the runes refactor does not introduce or worsen it. + +**Surface 5 — `AiLinesPieChart` `slices!` non-null assertion:** probed. `hasData = $derived(slices !== null)`. In the `option` derivation, `hasData ? buildAiLinesPieOption(slices!) : null` — when `hasData` is true, `slices !== null` is established by the same synchronous computation that evaluates `option`. No concurrency or async gap between `hasData` and `slices` evaluation. The non-null assertion is safe. ✓ + +**Diff-derived surface 1 — Output stability across schema-version drift:** N/A — purely in-memory component refactor; no persisted artifacts or schemas changed. + +**Diff-derived surface 2 — CLI flag/arg symmetry:** N/A — no CLI flags modified. + +**Diff-derived surface 3 — Error-class breadth in `catch` blocks:** N/A — no try/catch blocks in these files. + +**Diff-derived surface 4 — Defensive layering at module boundaries (`createDisciplineGaugeData` with empty string):** probed. `createDisciplineGaugeData(summaries, '')` evaluates `dateToRatioMap['']` which is `undefined` (no entry for the empty string key). This produces `[{ value: undefined, name: '...' }]`. ECharts accepts this without throwing — the gauge pointer renders at the zero position. Correctness hinges on the ordering proof from Surface 2: by the time `option` is first read (inside `onMount` and the chart update `$effect`), the selectedDate `$effect` has already fired and `selectedDate = defaultDate`. Given Svelte 5's declaration-order scheduling guarantee, `option` is never read with `selectedDate = ''` after mount. This is sound under the current file layout but carries an implicit ordering dependency (see Advisory Observations). + +**Diff-derived surface 5 — Cross-file atomicity windows:** N/A — no multi-step file writes. + +**Diff-derived surface 6 — Test-contract strength with `$props()`:** probed. All three spec files (`PieChart.spec.ts`, `AiTokenBarChart.spec.ts`, `AiLinesPieChart.spec.ts`) call `render(Component, propsObject)` using `@testing-library/svelte`. In Svelte 5, `render` passes the second argument directly to `mount()` as props, which maps correctly to `$props()` inside the component. The prop shapes are unchanged by this migration. No contract breakage. + +**Diff-derived surface 7 — Doc-vs-code drift in ticket Rationale:** probed. The ticket Outcome section (line 13, ticket doc) states "`grep` for legacy idioms in these files returns zero" without qualification. The `on:update` bridge directives are present in two files and are intentional T05-deferred exceptions, but the ticket doc does not record this exception in the Outcome statement. The Rationale section says only "Deferred: chart control components (T05)" without specifying that `on:update` is the deferred idiom or which files carry it. The adversarial review spec contains this qualification; the ticket doc does not. The outcome statement as written is literally false for `on:update` — a future developer grep would find these and have no ticket-level explanation. + +--- + +**Actionable findings** + +None. + +--- + +**Advisory Observations** + +The ticket outcome statement ("`grep` for legacy idioms in these files returns zero") is literally falsified by the `on:update` directives in TimelineChart and DailyGauge. The T05 deferral is a real and intentional decision, but it lives only in the adversarial review prompt and the `on:update` rationale doc — not in the ticket's Outcome section. A developer running the grep audit against the ticket outcome months from now would find two hits with no ticket-level explanation. Worth appending a one-liner to the Outcome noting the exception: e.g., "exception: `on:update` bridges in TimelineChart and DailyGauge are T05-deferred." + +`DailyGauge` correctness during initial mount depends on the Svelte 5 guarantee that `$effect` callbacks fire in declaration order during the mount flush (so the selectedDate effect settles `selectedDate = defaultDate` before `onMount` reads `option`). This guarantee holds under the current file layout. If a future refactor moves the `onMount` block above the selectedDate `$effect`, the gauge would initialize ECharts with `data[0].value = undefined` for one frame before correcting. The dependency on declaration order is not documented. A comment or a restructuring that initializes `selectedDate` synchronously (e.g., `let selectedDate = $state(availableDates.at(-1) ?? '')`) would eliminate the ordering dependency entirely — though that would require the `availableDates` derivation to be declared above `selectedDate`, which may conflict with how `$props()` and `$derived` interact on the initial computation. This is lower priority than the ticket-doc gap above; noting it for T05 or a future audit. + +`Treemap` passes `$page.params.projectName` (type: `string | undefined`) into `createProjectFileToTimeDict` and `createTreemapOption` which declare `projectName: string`. If the component ever renders outside a route that provides `projectName` (e.g., a test or a route refactor), the helpers will silently split on the string `"undefined"` and produce garbage tree keys rather than throwing. This is a pre-existing gap untouched by this migration; flagging for visibility since the runes migration is an opportunity to audit it. + +--- + +**Runner termination** + +runnerStatus: completed +terminatedReason: All invariants held, all attack surfaces probed, no actionable findings — report complete. diff --git a/docs/product/delivery/phase-06/ticket-04-standalone-charts.md b/docs/product/delivery/phase-06/ticket-04-standalone-charts.md index 3c79e58c..88995963 100644 --- a/docs/product/delivery/phase-06/ticket-04-standalone-charts.md +++ b/docs/product/delivery/phase-06/ticket-04-standalone-charts.md @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ Red: skip - These 8 files use runes only: `LineChart/LineChart.svelte`, `PieChart/PieChart.svelte`, `ScatterPlot/ScatterPlot.svelte`, `Treemap/Treemap.svelte`, `TimelineChart/TimelineChart.svelte`, `GaugeChart/DailyGauge.svelte`, `AiTokenBarChart/AiTokenBarChart.svelte`, `AiLinesPieChart/AiLinesPieChart.svelte`. - All apply the T01 ECharts recipe (`$derived option` + `$effect(setOption)`). - Each file carries ``. -- `grep` for legacy idioms in these files returns zero. +- `grep` for legacy idioms in these files returns zero; exception: `on:update` bridges in `TimelineChart.svelte` and `DailyGauge.svelte` are T05-deferred (TypeScript rejects `onupdate` as unknown prop until child controls are migrated to runes). ## Red diff --git a/src/lib/components/AiLinesPieChart/AiLinesPieChart.svelte b/src/lib/components/AiLinesPieChart/AiLinesPieChart.svelte index f0b80c50..4e3d2a51 100644 --- a/src/lib/components/AiLinesPieChart/AiLinesPieChart.svelte +++ b/src/lib/components/AiLinesPieChart/AiLinesPieChart.svelte @@ -1,5 +1,7 @@ + + diff --git a/src/lib/components/PieChart/PieChart.svelte b/src/lib/components/PieChart/PieChart.svelte index c6a0fe4d..2017ede2 100644 --- a/src/lib/components/PieChart/PieChart.svelte +++ b/src/lib/components/PieChart/PieChart.svelte @@ -1,5 +1,7 @@ + + diff --git a/src/lib/components/TimelineChart/TimelineChart.svelte b/src/lib/components/TimelineChart/TimelineChart.svelte index 7e970aed..6ac73acd 100644 --- a/src/lib/components/TimelineChart/TimelineChart.svelte +++ b/src/lib/components/TimelineChart/TimelineChart.svelte @@ -1,8 +1,9 @@ + +