Context
Follow-up from the extension-plane review-corrections work. Merged spec-only PR #557 froze the release-bounded v1 contract for dynamically declared planes and required production implementation plus merged-main certification before this issue could close.
Selected v1 contract
The completed v1 contract is:
- expose one stable
ErrUngeneratedPlane classification;
- reject ungenerated
Plane[T] contributions fail-closed;
- make generated canonical policy/storage authoritative so copied same-ID descriptors cannot redefine standard-plane semantics;
- remove arbitrary
map[string]any / reflection-backed plane contribution, freeze, validation and replay fallback;
- directly prove contribution freeze, request freeze/materialization,
FrozenPlaneSet/FeatureBundle validation, ordinary replay and candidate replay.
Completion evidence
The requested production behavior and its focused verification are complete:
That satisfies this issue's production-contract and merged-main/Linux-race acceptance boundary, so #554 is correctly closed.
Relationship to #571 / #398
#571 remains the top-level OSS Base pre-OSS work order because its canonical Kiro Task 8.4/archive/completion metadata still needs repository closeout. That remaining spec-closeout work does not reopen this already-proven #554 production contract.
Do not add #554 directly as a blocker of #398; keep the release gate transitive through #571.
Merged planning PR #559 / post-split #572 remains later milestone work and is not a dependency of this completed issue.
Context
Follow-up from the extension-plane review-corrections work. Merged spec-only PR #557 froze the release-bounded v1 contract for dynamically declared planes and required production implementation plus merged-main certification before this issue could close.
Selected v1 contract
The completed v1 contract is:
ErrUngeneratedPlaneclassification;Plane[T]contributions fail-closed;map[string]any/ reflection-backed plane contribution, freeze, validation and replay fallback;FrozenPlaneSet/FeatureBundlevalidation, ordinary replay and candidate replay.Completion evidence
The requested production behavior and its focused verification are complete:
mainatd784a8344888dd9de2141a13d4bf723125d4b08cand added fail-closed/global-mutation regression ratchets;33891386913executed against that merged SHA and completed successfully;That satisfies this issue's production-contract and merged-main/Linux-race acceptance boundary, so #554 is correctly closed.
Relationship to #571 / #398
#571 remains the top-level OSS Base pre-OSS work order because its canonical Kiro Task 8.4/archive/completion metadata still needs repository closeout. That remaining spec-closeout work does not reopen this already-proven #554 production contract.
Do not add #554 directly as a blocker of #398; keep the release gate transitive through #571.
Merged planning PR #559 / post-split #572 remains later milestone work and is not a dependency of this completed issue.