diff --git a/CHANGELOG.md b/CHANGELOG.md index 9717a337..447b8c47 100644 --- a/CHANGELOG.md +++ b/CHANGELOG.md @@ -16,6 +16,7 @@ Source admission, per-kind evidence, and qualified legal uncertainty. The protoc - Add source-controlled publication state with dated npm, MCP Registry, tag, and release snapshots, plus tests and evals that retain independent provider evidence through partial publication. - Add per-kind evidence inputs (`pub:evidence_inputs`, `admission_status`, `evidence_type`, `pub:source_review_state`) to every Obligation-First record, with regression coverage for the evidence boundary. A reviewed mapping input cannot promote a record whose native instrument or obligation definition remains legacy-unreviewed. - Retain D. Colo. ECF 24, the Utah HB 452 enrolled bill, and the Doctronic signed agreement, outcomes report, FAQ, and pilot page as admission sources, with source-specific regressions. +- Retain the Legion and ElizaChat signed agreements (with OCR review snapshots), the OAIP authorized-pilots register and pilot pages, the OAIP home page, and the Utah SB 149 bill-status page as admission sources. ### Changed @@ -23,6 +24,8 @@ Source admission, per-kind evidence, and qualified legal uncertainty. The protoc - Move EveryAILaw term and obligation anchors into the mapping index as source-owned fields with a related-not-equivalent relation, source URL, locator, and qualification, replacing the hardcoded special case in the Obligation-First export. The mapping parser now fails on malformed or duplicate entries. - README and current guides link to provider observations; `agents.json` and `/.well-known/mcp.json` render the independently evidenced install identity and any actual source candidate. - CI checks out full history so receipt retention is compared against the pull-request base or prior push head. +- Correct the nine overdue Utah records (issue #3) and six linked obligation files against retained sources, under agent source-consistency receipts: enacting-bill citations, sunset and term-ceiling history, vote and introduction rows, sponsors and titles, statutory versus proposed disclosure triggers, RMA cure periods, phase thresholds, reporting clocks, forbearance scope, and dead official URLs. Unconfirmed facts are qualified rather than asserted. After human review and approval by Sam Rogers, the nine records' `last_verified` is renewed to 2026-09-23 under human review receipts. +- Add an `obligation_qualification` field to two mapping entries; it appears in `api/v1/mappings.json`. ### Fixed diff --git a/MANIFEST.yaml b/MANIFEST.yaml index c1eea989..72e1067d 100644 --- a/MANIFEST.yaml +++ b/MANIFEST.yaml @@ -183,37 +183,37 @@ files: - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:372a62e39b49fc961482974100e5f04e22b1a922fadce391e66c68dc3d4993f2 + hash: sha256:6fb9a910496ef034a5b8b241d8859688cb39d2370fd3321b07649b32e3f49e2e note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:fe72c5b4cc375bf679bc8f03edd4ccd7b7cddafad47ece6439f8a5449fd967e7 + hash: sha256:c75fb508faa76236a1cd60e5ed221ff2df4bae4c426295098f1ac0cd9d7836fb note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:518882b00ebe9515a3f4697a2da41a607c506c8d844a31895dcf1851d0f5dd3a + hash: sha256:9cb602b984427da4e4f0bdc1ba9f56458de93a54911769c20584ce105b1c6cf0 note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:97e8084f429a9565d1b7e2d4eeb6ab7cb0d16c63762838c30c18afde1f436a83 + hash: sha256:6de7ddf6525087ffe3f1e32b40dac48954dc0cfe7eceabd5e5717f24307a9a36 note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.md - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:111b246cf8bb2b1118face419aa81634e3eba290346e98be8e47761d2a8345d5 + hash: sha256:01797df3b03a8a6d33869d8a1ed4a0575acea137ea8b84598087d3a0fca8008d note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:1c73dcfdf1dc9dc14040426990fdd43ea4db8615ca0523c2914d7fda1e40d740 + hash: sha256:639f19ea3a4b559894f32da3142be916fbd98e3b9fe5791edb9a05d80a6d61ad note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7 + hash: sha256:c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18 note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-001.md @@ -223,12 +223,12 @@ files: - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984 + hash: sha256:8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724 note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a + hash: sha256:3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788 note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md - path: ATTRIBUTION.md @@ -253,7 +253,7 @@ files: - path: data/examples/mapping/index.yml role: mapping - hash: sha256:3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592 + hash: sha256:b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f note: data/examples/mapping/index.yml - path: data/examples/obligations/admt-60-day-cure-period.md @@ -293,7 +293,7 @@ files: - path: data/examples/obligations/ai-defense-elimination.md role: obligation - hash: sha256:ecda85918d33c2ebe2345f5cdef1e78e25f533d645c3efa2d7402022cf2bba33 + hash: sha256:a55e45923f6c446174676808c25e74c677631fb8550f520ee92ba2786eb08151 note: data/examples/obligations/ai-defense-elimination.md - path: data/examples/obligations/cfpb-pay-to-pay-fee-prohibited.md @@ -313,7 +313,7 @@ files: - path: data/examples/obligations/chatbot-safety-policy-filing.md role: obligation - hash: sha256:64d1121bd3ffbe629f4ea714deee5bd9ac05371f8492487128fbe4a8de8f0b2e + hash: sha256:926ce7f92c39b4613ccaea98594d2a43f06982309402d41d5b1a4571842a3066 note: data/examples/obligations/chatbot-safety-policy-filing.md - path: data/examples/obligations/dentacor-58-69-5-enforcement-forborne.md @@ -338,7 +338,7 @@ files: - path: data/examples/obligations/disclose-genai-on-first-session.md role: obligation - hash: sha256:964a825c8ad92c8e5a59ceda27d05433bd145b2b381af9edb7f6309681a55b71 + hash: sha256:785f11886a59611ca6458facf971ef6bcf088085a4c12675492498d88380fc8d note: data/examples/obligations/disclose-genai-on-first-session.md - path: data/examples/obligations/disclose-genai-on-request.md @@ -353,7 +353,7 @@ files: - path: data/examples/obligations/elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle.md role: obligation - hash: sha256:44ccb58a19ec9ebb04c917de3e9b65ecb0cf3fdccad3464e3309f8818ff254b1 + hash: sha256:4caf489311fac12b33ead6ccea5e1765d489d4991aed57e4b2d174922b542d4e note: data/examples/obligations/elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle.md - path: data/examples/obligations/high-risk-ai-consumer-notice-correction-and-appeal.md @@ -383,12 +383,12 @@ files: - path: data/examples/obligations/learning-lab-agreement-participation.md role: obligation - hash: sha256:efeebe2f9d9c60fcfc09d9cdddc438f311e27a5064b2d999d490d1835f67b45b + hash: sha256:c7f07d610d5c3bb5aa942d5d80fb3dad563ed73529770ed89888a4fca1d537eb note: data/examples/obligations/learning-lab-agreement-participation.md - path: data/examples/obligations/named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.md role: obligation - hash: sha256:9bc50212ab23b5d835c423f3639e384f25ada45855f2c438e27f80bfef616083 + hash: sha256:a387cda4d9c8ae0c04a890f5cb8f665334ded7bf384cdab2048006bcd0818164 note: data/examples/obligations/named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.md - path: data/examples/obligations/rma-data-security-63a-19-102.md @@ -428,12 +428,12 @@ files: - path: data/examples/obligations/telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.md role: obligation - hash: sha256:7fc842d907a39f82bfca7bf5380ba6887404ff5693e1b473d807b424ffe49af0 + hash: sha256:ee6e7f615e88f8defb62bb6c58442887c9f13e51afd01a63249deff01c8e9bda note: data/examples/obligations/telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.md - path: CHANGELOG.md role: protocol - hash: sha256:850926cc973c09d2c295a9edf0134b2a3e2827272e974fee8e25477a0c152bcb + hash: sha256:0b46bc1d7717b1413fb3c8d23f183771a973e042c9c3ff7e9293c895976bc3a3 note: CHANGELOG.md - path: CONTRIBUTING.md @@ -1028,7 +1028,7 @@ files: - path: tests/maintenance.test.js role: code - hash: sha256:e79c6acf32b51c8203e8284f574c612b21984d8c5ebddabd42ba6f9e69495cda + hash: sha256:73a1456f27b4bacbd8aea385046f0ae29daef62df427091160766224ee462a40 note: T10 bounded maintenance pilot - path: tests/generated-record-schema.test.js @@ -1038,7 +1038,7 @@ files: - path: tests/source-admission.test.js role: code - hash: sha256:1b47af7b67056a838e3b19e9ed06f5f9a8bfc7cc11bdab8d5c096fde7fcc20bc + hash: sha256:d2ec25e0a18c9c83b9ec505fedecf776f2b5971b4f4de24102273681467f45b2 note: Source admission policy and producer-gate regressions - path: tests/publication-state.test.js @@ -1048,7 +1048,7 @@ files: - path: tests/doctronic-observation.test.js role: code - hash: sha256:9185ead5745b5a7de55c228ec30e6bd9b80746503516864786e949c7577fdb4d + hash: sha256:d9964bfaeb126d4111b4f7c7363b085567c3713ed68cbcff5e75d2b4003b5089 note: Dated outcomes versus issued-term boundary regression - path: tests/source-owned-mapping.test.js @@ -1058,7 +1058,7 @@ files: - path: tests/of-evidence-inputs.test.js role: code - hash: sha256:d9a179498a065b70f94d2bd81a951106da5a33cca12f72759774ce9b2d0e5423 + hash: sha256:1e604a0fb0f847f796d655245a431333e412da9f94e1f01e96c38818323b084c note: Per-kind native evidence input and review-boundary regressions - path: tests/colorado-order24.test.js diff --git a/data/admission/receipts.json b/data/admission/receipts.json index c9486750..05040906 100644 --- a/data/admission/receipts.json +++ b/data/admission/receipts.json @@ -2,26 +2,28 @@ "version": 1, "records": { "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md": { - "record_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "record_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "baseline_sha256": "bf5c7ce60c4fd1d9901613e1f258e5333755a67e84edc5c9a3a6f575f868eeb1", "whole_record": { "before_sha256": "bf5c7ce60c4fd1d9901613e1f258e5333755a67e84edc5c9a3a6f575f868eeb1", - "after_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc" + "after_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156" }, "review": { - "actor_type": "agent", - "actor": "Codex source-consistency review", - "reviewed_at": "2026-09-09T17:16:04Z", + "actor_type": "human", + "actor": "Sam Rogers", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:36:37Z", "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", - "scope": "Doctronic agreement permission wording, May 2026 operational outcomes, the September 2026 FAQ source conflict, official source links, and the record modified date only; no legal-status or currentness renewal.", - "packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299" + "human_approved": true, + "scope": "Human review and approval by Sam Rogers, attested in the Claude Code session on 2026-09-23, of source-consistency corrections prepared by an agent (Claude). Renews last_verified to 2026-09-23 on that basis. Agent preparation scope: Corrected open findings from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json for the Doctronic RMA: Schedule A 15.D.2 chapter citations reproduced as written, disclosure trigger, monthly versus separate adverse-outcome reporting, dated register observation on Phase 1 and the unlinked 2026 amendment, extension note, term-end and DRAFT-title locator notes, register terms absent from the agreement, stale legacy id, dead learning-lab and admin-rules links, and redirecting agreement-page link, plus the modified date. Carries forward the 2026-09-09 Codex unit reviews for Summary and official_url. Does not renew last_verified or legal currentness.", + "packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165" }, "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "evidence": { "agreement": { @@ -104,21 +106,438 @@ "identity_excerpts": [ "Office of AI Policy: Doctronic RMA - commerce.utah.gov" ] + }, + "home": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "8a86df5aec4d2c3cd1d7e1aec45577c61f12e04e0df11fec1cb6d1ef05e61062", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:40Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8" + }, + "document_id": "Utah OAIP AI home page", + "document_title": "AI Home", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy", + "document_type": "official agency home page", + "version": "server last-modified September 4, 2026; retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "Our Mission", + "excerpt": "The Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy is dedicated to regulating the bleeding edge of AI", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AI Home - commerce.utah.gov" + ] + }, + "agreement_cites": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5c3b3a54fd01a88472f6e28a1ae43d88e84f71534387e6c602f77169f8252044", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.pdf", + "sha256": "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", + "document_id": "Doctronic Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE POLICY, DOCTRONIC, LLC, AND THE DIVISION OF PROFESSIONAL LICENSING", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed October 23-24, 2025", + "locator": "Schedule A Section 15.D.2", + "excerpt": "58-61-502, 59-67-502, 58-68-502, 59-70a-503, and 58-71-502.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE" + ] + }, + "agreement_disclosure": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5c3b3a54fd01a88472f6e28a1ae43d88e84f71534387e6c602f77169f8252044", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.pdf", + "sha256": "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", + "document_id": "Doctronic Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE POLICY, DOCTRONIC, LLC, AND THE DIVISION OF PROFESSIONAL LICENSING", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed October 23-24, 2025", + "locator": "Section 6.G.1-2", + "excerpt": "When a user indicates they are requesting the renewal of a prescription as described in Part 2", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE" + ] + }, + "agreement_reporting": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5c3b3a54fd01a88472f6e28a1ae43d88e84f71534387e6c602f77169f8252044", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.pdf", + "sha256": "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", + "document_id": "Doctronic Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE POLICY, DOCTRONIC, LLC, AND THE DIVISION OF PROFESSIONAL LICENSING", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed October 23-24, 2025", + "locator": "Section 6.H.2(b)", + "excerpt": "Any user complaint reported to Participant or adverse health outcome resulting from a", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE" + ] + }, + "agreement_extension": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5c3b3a54fd01a88472f6e28a1ae43d88e84f71534387e6c602f77169f8252044", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.pdf", + "sha256": "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", + "document_id": "Doctronic Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE POLICY, DOCTRONIC, LLC, AND THE DIVISION OF PROFESSIONAL LICENSING", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed October 23-24, 2025", + "locator": "Section 13 Agreement Extension", + "excerpt": "Participant may request a single extension of up to 12 months for regulatory mitigation no later than 30", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE" + ] + }, + "agreement_title": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5c3b3a54fd01a88472f6e28a1ae43d88e84f71534387e6c602f77169f8252044", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.pdf", + "sha256": "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", + "document_id": "Doctronic Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE POLICY, DOCTRONIC, LLC, AND THE DIVISION OF PROFESSIONAL LICENSING", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed October 23-24, 2025", + "locator": "Page 1 title", + "excerpt": "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE" + ] + }, + "register_phase": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "b5a9c67706dcc149a860f46bbde7ccc3a53a9447fe9dbac50b686f90156a0780", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:39Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/", + "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8" + }, + "document_id": "Utah OAIP Authorized AI Pilots register", + "document_title": "Authorized AI Pilots", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy", + "document_type": "official agency pilot register page", + "version": "server last-modified September 3, 2026; retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "The Agreements: Doctronic entry, Where it stands", + "excerpt": "The pilot is still in Phase 1, which means a licensed medical practitioner authorizes every request.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AI Authorized Pilots - commerce.utah.gov", + "This page is the public record of those agreements." + ] + }, + "register_amendment": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "b5a9c67706dcc149a860f46bbde7ccc3a53a9447fe9dbac50b686f90156a0780", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:39Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/", + "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8" + }, + "document_id": "Utah OAIP Authorized AI Pilots register", + "document_title": "Authorized AI Pilots", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy", + "document_type": "official agency pilot register page", + "version": "server last-modified September 3, 2026; retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "The Agreements: Doctronic entry, Where it stands", + "excerpt": "The 2026 amendment tightened that threshold and removed two medications from the list.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AI Authorized Pilots - commerce.utah.gov", + "This page is the public record of those agreements." + ] + }, + "register_term": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "b5a9c67706dcc149a860f46bbde7ccc3a53a9447fe9dbac50b686f90156a0780", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:39Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/", + "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8" + }, + "document_id": "Utah OAIP Authorized AI Pilots register", + "document_title": "Authorized AI Pilots", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy", + "document_type": "official agency pilot register page", + "version": "server last-modified September 3, 2026; retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "The Agreements: Doctronic entry, Term", + "excerpt": "Term October 24, 2025 – October 24, 2026", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AI Authorized Pilots - commerce.utah.gov", + "This page is the public record of those agreements." + ] + }, + "register_adversarial": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "b5a9c67706dcc149a860f46bbde7ccc3a53a9447fe9dbac50b686f90156a0780", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:39Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/", + "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8" + }, + "document_id": "Utah OAIP Authorized AI Pilots register", + "document_title": "Authorized AI Pilots", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy", + "document_type": "official agency pilot register page", + "version": "server last-modified September 3, 2026; retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "The Agreements: Doctronic entry, What the company agreed to", + "excerpt": "Third party adversarial testing of the system.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AI Authorized Pilots - commerce.utah.gov", + "This page is the public record of those agreements." + ] + }, + "page_insurance": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/doctronic/", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Doctronic-Pilot-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "ac938ca56be8fdc84a4c411688e168d446eb93cc1de7f8129f3907b21d4ea4c8", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Doctronic-Pilot-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:40Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/doctronic/", + "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8" + }, + "document_id": "Utah OAIP Doctronic RMA pilot page", + "document_title": "Office of AI Policy: Doctronic RMA", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy", + "document_type": "official agency pilot page", + "version": "server last-modified June 17, 2026; retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "Prescription Renewals FAQs, liability answer", + "excerpt": "we expect companies in the regulatory mitigation program to maintain medical malpractice insurance that covers AI liabilities and risk", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of AI Policy: Doctronic RMA - commerce.utah.gov" + ] + }, + "agreement_telehealth": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5c3b3a54fd01a88472f6e28a1ae43d88e84f71534387e6c602f77169f8252044", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.pdf", + "sha256": "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", + "document_id": "Doctronic Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE POLICY, DOCTRONIC, LLC, AND THE DIVISION OF PROFESSIONAL LICENSING", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed October 23-24, 2025", + "locator": "Schedule A §16(A)(1), telehealth compliance clause", + "excerpt": "nor in violation of subsection (4) of such section", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE" + ] } }, "units": { + "metadata:issued_by": { + "before_sha256": "f589813d6705665132182b4c08e90f9dea0e85c4673afb508c63b60b119d3989", + "after_sha256": "e2623753f76da570a3196ac804ea809c75fe2b5d151deafae8be9365fd8c20f6", + "candidate_content": { + "@type": "https://w3id.org/semanticarts/ns/ontology/gist/SubCountryGovernment", + "name": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP)", + "ref": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/" + }, + "reason": "Replace the dead learning-lab link (HTTP 404) with the current official OAIP home page.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "issued_by.ref URL only.", + "exceptions": "The home page does not establish any term of this agreement.", + "time": "Home page retrieved 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "home" + ] + }, + "metadata:last_verified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Human reviewer renews verification after reviewing the corrected record against its retained sources.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Whole-record source-consistency review against the retained sources cited in this receipt.", + "exceptions": "Items listed as unresolved remain unverified; review does not certify legal currentness beyond the cited sources.", + "time": "Reviewed 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement" + ] + }, + "metadata:mitigations": { + "before_sha256": "da39c991478d4d2e62a0ad8772055325e39206b9dc1825dbd5b5f2a9a713e6e2", + "after_sha256": "c8bb73f12e51f840e3807ef9d2403c3584a79839382cc2d4372d513a6fb967e7", + "candidate_content": [ + "Three-phase comprehensive case-review process (pre-pharmacy review → retrospective review → ongoing sampling)", + "Identity and prescription verification protocols before AI engages with renewal request", + "AI may not issue new prescriptions, change doses, handle controlled substances, or modify treatment plans", + "Formulary limit: Schedule C of the Agreement", + "GenAI disclosure (§13-77-103) when a user indicates a renewal request and before the AI engages further on it; user acknowledgment before access to any function", + "Data-security posture per §63A-19-102 applied as if Participant were a governmental entity", + "Monthly reporting to ai@utah.gov including acceptance/denial counts, physician-review agreement rates, and user-complaint information; separate duty to report user complaints and adverse health outcomes of which Participant becomes aware (no deadline stated)" + ], + "reason": "Match the disclosure trigger in Section 6.G and separate monthly reporting from the Section 6.H.2(b) complaint and adverse-outcome duty.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Disclosure and reporting mitigations only.", + "exceptions": "No incident clock is stated in the agreement; other mitigations unchanged.", + "time": "Agreement signed October 23-24, 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_disclosure", + "agreement_reporting" + ] + }, "metadata:modified": { "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", - "after_sha256": "deab17f5c24dfc69254d7427a910923048244bb75e30f66a7d2bc6916b4ca270", - "candidate_content": "2026-09-09", - "reason": "Record the date of this bounded source-backed content correction without renewing legal currentness.", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Record the date of this bounded source-consistency correction.", "qualifications": { "scope": "This record edit only.", - "exceptions": "last_verified, status, effective date, and term dates remain unchanged.", - "time": "Edit date 2026-09-09; source observation dated May 19, 2026." + "exceptions": "last_verified, Verified rows, status, and dates are unchanged; this does not renew legal currentness.", + "time": "Edit date 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "register_term" + ] + }, + "metadata:official_url": { + "before_sha256": "8b14146b3d481e5b64e9a27d01797e200d9b12ce9642ca403637aa7d5852c797", + "after_sha256": "0178d3468419aa1c35ebfa5392b557c439025b892291344f72ccb7b2972df0bf", + "candidate_content": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/doctronic/", + "reason": "Replace the retired OAIP path with the current canonical official pilot page.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Official source landing-page URL only.", + "exceptions": "The landing page does not establish amendment effectiveness, Phase Two approval, compliance, extension, termination, or current status.", + "time": "Current OAIP page observed September 9, 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "pilot_page" + ] + }, + "metadata:rules_mitigated": { + "before_sha256": "fb124f53a5466e0840f5f6cb49c43d1136d8e2e988b62c30f686a3745baeba09", + "after_sha256": "f912580e642a9dae35af768496cd01fed1b0b5f0d98ebc95c3de58ea7274e971", + "candidate_content": [ + "Utah Code §58-1-501(1) and UAC R156-1-501(2)(b) — unlawful/unprofessional conduct for AI-authored Rx renewal", + "Utah Code §26B-4-704(6) and UAC R156-1-602 — telehealth provider requirements", + "Unprofessional-conduct provisions across prescriber chapters, as listed in Schedule A §15.D.2: §§58-31b-502, 58-60-110, 58-61-502, 59-67-502 [sic], 58-68-502, 59-70a-503 [sic], and 58-71-502 (the signed text cites 59-67-502 and 59-70a-503 as written)" + ], + "reason": "Reproduce the Schedule A 15.D.2 list as written (58-68-502) and mark the source's 59-67-502 and 59-70a-503 as [sic] without silently correcting them.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Chapter unprofessional-conduct list.", + "exceptions": "Other rules_mitigated entries unchanged.", + "time": "Agreement signed October 23-24, 2025." }, "evidence": [ - "outcomes" + "agreement_cites" + ] + }, + "metadata:statute_anchors": { + "before_sha256": "8d76cb819308e1bd92b009f2f5cfa54571ad44b06222e00fb1bb93c28e223ecb", + "after_sha256": "60a25b855acae65d6b31228ca810876a7ec676a58314eb4691524e46b83fed01", + "candidate_content": [ + { + "cite": "Utah Code §13-72-201", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72/13-72-S201.html" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah Code §13-72-301", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72/13-72-S301.html" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah Code §13-72-302", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72/13-72-S302.html" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah Code §13-77-103", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter77/13-77-S103.html" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah Code §58-17b (Pharmacy Practice Act)", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title58/Chapter17B/58-17b.html" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah Code §58-1-501 (Unlawful/unprofessional conduct)", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title58/Chapter1/58-1-S501.html" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah Code §26B-4-704 (Telehealth)", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title26B/Chapter4/26B-4-S704.html" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah Code §63A-19-102 (Data security)", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title63A/Chapter19/63A-19-S102.html" + }, + { + "cite": "UAC R156-1-501 / R156-1-602" + } + ], + "reason": "Remove the dead adminrules.utah.gov link (HTTP 404); keep the R156-1 citation text because no current URL is established by retained evidence.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "R156-1 anchor URL only.", + "exceptions": "Citation text unchanged.", + "time": "Link checked 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_cites" ] }, "section:Summary/text": { @@ -135,72 +554,128 @@ "agreement" ] }, + "section:Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §16)/text": { + "before_sha256": "58f3f6a20dce1c77c841317b88ffd0549cdc58e96cf23cb7f98f9fe4f8b80627", + "after_sha256": "c5098be9126bcec882b6a8bd498b84b68c907537042d4b0463656347a1a524c2", + "candidate_content": "- Proposal-conforming methodology and safety protocols; amendments only by signed written approval.\n- AI considered in compliance with §26B-4-704(2)(b)/(c), and not in violation of §26B-4-704(4), when Patient Journey and Clinical Workflow (Schedule B, Part 2B) is followed; with §26B-4-704(2)(e) when Escalation Protocols (Part 3B) are followed; §26B-4-704(5) does not apply.\n- §13-77-103 GenAI disclosure when a user indicates a renewal request and before the AI engages further on it; users must acknowledge before accessing any function (§6.G).\n- Data-security posture per §63A-19-102 treated as if Participant were a governmental entity; no sale or advertising use of user data even if deidentified.\n- Monthly reports to ai@utah.gov: acceptance/denial counts, AI-vs-physician agreement rates, trends, and user-complaint information (§6.H.1).\n- Separate reporting of user complaints and adverse health outcomes from AI renewals of which Participant becomes aware, with no stated deadline (§6.H.2(b)); the Agreement sets no incident-notification clock.\n- 30-day post-term written report on deployment, incidents, legal actions, complaints.", + "reason": "Match the Section 6.G disclosure trigger and split monthly reports from the Section 6.H.2(b) complaint and adverse-outcome duty, which has no stated deadline. Telehealth line now says the AI is not in violation of §26B-4-704(4), as the agreement states, rather than in compliance with it.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Disclosure and reporting lines.", + "exceptions": "The agreement sets no incident-notification clock; other lines unchanged.", + "time": "Agreement signed October 23-24, 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_disclosure", + "agreement_reporting", + "agreement_telehealth" + ] + }, + "section:PubLedge schema mapping/text": { + "before_sha256": "c51e959b407fbf569ad325bc76c3e772fb4bc98d84a3bd69e27fdf43dbdd5af4", + "after_sha256": "65e143abe0cbcb654c3c78d321e5f2bac5f9f262c47b6f4facc3652e1943b6fe", + "candidate_content": "| Source element | PubLedge field |\n|---|---|\n| \"Agreement between OAIP, Doctronic LLC, and DOPL\" | `title`, `name` |\n| Section 1 parties | `parties[]`, `participating_party`, `issuing_authority` |\n| Section 2 (12 months beginning on execution; no end date stated) and OAIP register term October 24, 2025 – October 24, 2026 | `term_start`, `term_end` |\n| Section 3 (Utah Code §13-72-201/301/302 authority) | `program`, `statute_anchors[]` |\n| Section 4 (Scope of Mitigation) + Schedule A §15 | `rules_mitigated[]`, `obligation_kind: permission` |\n| Section 6 (Participant Obligations) | `mitigations[]`, `obligation_kind: requirement/restriction` |\n| Latter signature date 2025-10-24 | `enacted`, `effective` |\n| Utah AI Learning Laboratory | `program` |", + "reason": "Note that Section 2 states 12 months from execution without an end date and that the OAIP register states October 24, 2026.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "term_start and term_end mapping note.", + "exceptions": "term_end value unchanged.", + "time": "Register retrieved 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement", + "register_term" + ] + }, + "section:Limitations/text": { + "before_sha256": "51a5f9a4f8f3fa1d985862e39d275c51bc65208adb9eeb8add4458dcba5f96cf", + "after_sha256": "6dd5e500828399e8eee9f125b7cfdecb67f5c37fe8a726e35f74eb91a7c04567", + "candidate_content": "- Does not waive federal laws (including controlled-substances statutes), HIPAA, or disclosure/privacy laws beyond what the four corners of the Agreement expressly address.\n- Does not endorse Participant's technology (§3D); advertising references to the Agreement require prior written approval.\n- Terminable at will by either party (§10A) under §13-72-302(7).\n- Assignment requires prior written OAIP consent (§11).\n- Section 13 allows a single extension request of up to 12 months no later than 30 days before the initial 12-month period ends. No retained source shows an extension request or decision; `term_end` records the initial term only.\n- OAIP's register lists third-party adversarial testing among Doctronic's commitments, and OAIP's FAQ says participants are expected to maintain malpractice insurance covering AI liabilities. Neither term appears in the retained signed agreement text; where those terms are set out is unverified.", + "reason": "State the Section 13 extension mechanism without asserting any request or decision, and flag register terms absent from the signed agreement.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Extension and completeness notes.", + "exceptions": "No extension, insurance, or adversarial-testing term is asserted as an agreement term.", + "time": "Register retrieved 2026-09-24; agreement signed October 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_extension", + "register_adversarial", + "page_insurance" + ] + }, "section:Sources/text": { "before_sha256": "0190b045b6bd1f233f41b04cc4209d180231f5b0a971f2430442d2ca25503944", - "after_sha256": "70cf8d68f6b3d3d73c146805b7050d048f405f173050c9017dc8ff0fd39959e2", - "candidate_content": "- [Agreement page — Utah OAIP](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/doctronic/)\n- [Signed PDF](https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf)\n- [OAIP outcomes report — May 19, 2026](https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/Doctronic-Outcomes-May-2026.pdf)\n- [OAIP AI FAQ — Phase 2 criteria and formulary changes observed September 9, 2026](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/ai-faq/)\n- [Utah AI Learning Laboratory](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/)\n- [Utah Code Title 13, Chapter 72](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72/13-72.html)", - "reason": "Link the official May 19, 2026 outcomes report and the official FAQ statement describing later criteria and formulary changes.", + "after_sha256": "b97d54e340c914f3227e4d49dfe60290cda0ec83201480eed026b0bc618456fa", + "candidate_content": "- [Pilot page — Utah OAIP](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/doctronic/)\n- [Authorized AI Pilots — Utah OAIP](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/)\n- [Signed PDF](https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf) (body title reads \"DRAFT AGREEMENT\"; signatures dated October 23-24, 2025)\n- [OAIP outcomes report — May 19, 2026](https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/Doctronic-Outcomes-May-2026.pdf)\n- [OAIP AI FAQ — Phase 2 criteria and formulary changes observed September 9, 2026](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/ai-faq/)\n- [Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/)\n- [Utah Code Title 13, Chapter 72](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72/13-72.html)", + "reason": "Use the final pilot-page URL, add the OAIP register, note the PDF's DRAFT title, and replace the dead learning-lab link with the OAIP home page.", "qualifications": { - "scope": "Adds official OAIP report and FAQ URLs.", - "exceptions": "The link is not evidence of a later phase or current legal status.", - "time": "Report dated May 19, 2026." + "scope": "Source links and a title note.", + "exceptions": "Links are not evidence of amendment, phase, or current status.", + "time": "Retrieved 2026-09-24; report May 19, 2026; FAQ observed September 9, 2026." }, "evidence": [ + "pilot_page", + "register_term", + "agreement_title", "outcomes", - "faq" + "faq", + "home" ] }, - "section:Operational observation (not an issued term)/text": { - "before_sha256": null, - "after_sha256": "c1b71c4caa492a406f101ed77632514dbed9573ba7640d5897b0af0ddb915cba", - "candidate_content": "OAIP's May 19, 2026 outcomes report describes January-April activity while the pilot was still in Phase One. It says the AI recommended renewal in 72% of cases, and each recommendation then went to human physician review. Within that 72% subset, the first reviewing physician agreed renewal was appropriate in 91% of cases. When the first physician requested more information, a second physician also reviewed the case; OAIP reports that either the first or second physician found renewal appropriate in 97% of that recommendation subset based on the information the AI gathered. In the remaining 28% of all cases, the AI escalated without recommending renewal; physicians agreed the escalation was appropriate in 69% of that escalation subset.\n\nThe report says the sample was limited, based on reports from Doctronic physicians, and subject to a separate OAIP review. It is an operational observation, not an amendment or issued term. It does not establish a later phase, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot's current phase or status after the reporting period.\n\nOAIP's AI FAQ, observed September 9, 2026, says the Phase 2 transition criteria were updated from 250 prescriptions total to 250 medications in each medication group, still subject to OAIP approval, and that Butalbital and Flecainide were removed from the formulary. The retained signed agreement instead describes the first 250 patients as Phase One and includes both medications in its formulary. OAIP's current Doctronic page links the signed agreement, outcomes report, medical-board correspondence, and a policy memorandum, but no signed amendment. The FAQ is therefore retained as an official dated observation and explicit source conflict; it does not establish the amendment mechanism or effective date, OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, or the pilot's current phase.", - "reason": "Preserve the official outcome observations with their actual denominators and distinguish them from issued legal terms.", + "section:Notes on this demonstration remap/text": { + "before_sha256": "b6107c1c4b1b18a2101a70f0abf0e1296dfa44cceb383c24d23fc7a33f514e6d", + "after_sha256": "bf9da20f8b9a7d8cc7f124944e16b3eee433982668d675f3da10a4b3398fc995", + "candidate_content": "Third RMA (`us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002`) by effective date. Exercises: (1) three-party contract (regulator + licensing division + participant), (2) multi-statute mitigation bundle including unprofessional-conduct provisions across seven prescriber chapters, (3) permission + requirement + restriction obligation mix in a single instrument, and (4) concurrent term with Utah's ongoing §13-72 → §13-72a statutory transition.", + "reason": "Replace the stale legacy id with the current record id.", "qualifications": { - "scope": "January-April 2026 activity reported by OAIP, including first-physician, first-or-second-physician, and escalation subsets.", - "exceptions": "Limited participant-reported outcome sample; independent OAIP review was initiated; the FAQ conflicts with the signed agreement and no signed amendment was linked; statistics and FAQ changes are not obligations or proof of compliance.", - "time": "Report dated May 19, 2026 and describes January-April activity while Phase One was ongoing." + "scope": "Record id reference only.", + "exceptions": "No substantive change.", + "time": "Current id us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002." }, "evidence": [ - "agreement", - "outcomes", - "faq" + "agreement" ] }, - "metadata:official_url": { - "reason": "Replace the retired OAIP path with the current canonical official pilot page.", + "section:Operational observation (not an issued term)/text": { + "before_sha256": null, + "after_sha256": "6d5dc2b305cdd909fa3fb755647f7371af676c8c4adbc367d8112e3420357927", + "candidate_content": "OAIP's May 19, 2026 outcomes report describes January-April activity while the pilot was still in Phase One. It says the AI recommended renewal in 72% of cases, and each recommendation then went to human physician review. Within that 72% subset, the first reviewing physician agreed renewal was appropriate in 91% of cases. When the first physician requested more information, a second physician also reviewed the case; OAIP reports that either the first or second physician found renewal appropriate in 97% of that recommendation subset based on the information the AI gathered. In the remaining 28% of all cases, the AI escalated without recommending renewal; physicians agreed the escalation was appropriate in 69% of that escalation subset.\n\nThe report says the sample was limited, based on reports from Doctronic physicians, and subject to a separate OAIP review. It is an operational observation, not an amendment or issued term. It does not establish a later phase, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot's current phase or status after the reporting period.\n\nOAIP's AI FAQ, observed September 9, 2026, says the Phase 2 transition criteria were updated from 250 prescriptions total to 250 medications in each medication group, still subject to OAIP approval, and that Butalbital and Flecainide were removed from the formulary. The retained signed agreement instead describes the first 250 patients as Phase One and includes both medications in its formulary. OAIP's current Doctronic page links the signed agreement, outcomes report, medical-board correspondence, and a policy memorandum, but no signed amendment. The FAQ is therefore retained as an official dated observation and explicit source conflict; it does not establish the amendment mechanism or effective date, OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, or the pilot's current phase.\n\nOAIP's Authorized AI Pilots page, retrieved 2026-09-24 (UTC), lists Doctronic as Active with term October 24, 2025 – October 24, 2026. It states that the pilot is still in Phase 1, that moving to Phase 2 requires OAIP approval by medication group, and that Phase 2 has not been approved. The same page refers to \"the 2026 amendment\" as tightening that threshold and removing two medications, but neither it nor the Doctronic pilot page links an amendment document. The amendment's date, signatories, and exact text remain unverified; the retained signed agreement is the only executed text reviewed.", + "reason": "Keep the May 2026 outcomes and FAQ conflict text, and add the dated register statement that the pilot is in Phase 1, Phase 2 is not approved, and a 2026 amendment is described but not linked.", "qualifications": { - "scope": "Official source landing-page URL only.", - "exceptions": "The landing page does not establish amendment effectiveness, Phase Two approval, compliance, extension, termination, or current status.", - "time": "Current OAIP page observed September 9, 2026." + "scope": "Dated agency observations about phase and an unlinked amendment.", + "exceptions": "Amendment date, signatories, and text unverified; the signed agreement remains the only executed text reviewed.", + "time": "Report May 19, 2026; FAQ observed September 9, 2026; register retrieved 2026-09-24." }, "evidence": [ - "pilot_page" - ], - "before_sha256": "8b14146b3d481e5b64e9a27d01797e200d9b12ce9642ca403637aa7d5852c797", - "after_sha256": "0178d3468419aa1c35ebfa5392b557c439025b892291344f72ccb7b2972df0bf", - "candidate_content": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/doctronic/" + "agreement", + "outcomes", + "faq", + "register_phase", + "register_amendment", + "register_term" + ] } } }, "data/examples/mapping/index.yml": { - "record_sha256": "bccad470cd138126ddc670288920d16837b0475c5588429205ad0e7d56a5c970", + "record_sha256": "3d367f840893643b2543ebe89b76a0669298b4003d0ed808ac253813c190385c", "baseline_sha256": "d072c09fd6fdb6d05da6ca7d1e784baac7b59c1e040e9f5b44b2fa7c7c5b3c62", "whole_record": { "before_sha256": "d072c09fd6fdb6d05da6ca7d1e784baac7b59c1e040e9f5b44b2fa7c7c5b3c62", - "after_sha256": "bccad470cd138126ddc670288920d16837b0475c5588429205ad0e7d56a5c970" + "after_sha256": "3d367f840893643b2543ebe89b76a0669298b4003d0ed808ac253813c190385c" }, "review": { "actor_type": "agent", - "actor": "Codex source-consistency review", - "reviewed_at": "2026-09-09T17:31:34Z", + "actor": "Claude source-consistency correction review", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:20:00Z", "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", - "scope": "Move the existing PubLedge draft-term and concrete-obligation EveryAILaw anchors from exporter code into one source-owned mapping entry, retaining exact targets and explicit non-equivalence.", - "packet_sha256": "476523ef2974b11f96c887c77c8135e1b4e835d70264833e80b5204eccc4d75f" + "scope": "Add obligation_qualification notes to the sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack entries: the learning-lab obligation reflects the post-HB 320 regime, and the first-session obligation is related to, not equivalent to, HB 452 13-72a-203. Earlier first-session JIA entry review carried forward unchanged. Agent source-consistency correction only; does not renew last_verified, Verified rows, legal status or legal currentness.", + "packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4" }, "unresolved": [ "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", - "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law." + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." ], "evidence": { "hb452": { @@ -222,28 +697,168 @@ "identity_excerpts": [ "H.B. 452 Enrolled Copy" ] - } - }, - "units": { - "entry:utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session": { - "before_sha256": "648b558040eb87d14bc739ecb64b90be1566ec84a69efe99c92f5f8bdb289cd3", - "after_sha256": "c307d8182e42993daa76516e2a364800ab0cccdea4fa8febf65c53f4371cb5d6", - "candidate_content": { - "id": "utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session", - "regulation": "us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001", - "authority": "utah-oaip", - "source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md", - "source_heading": "First-Session Disclosure (§13-72a-203)", - "term_anchors": [ - "https://everyailaw.com/term/utah-sb149-chatbot-disclosure.json" - ], - "obligation_anchors": [ - "https://everyailaw.com/obligation-category/transparency.json" - ], - "anchor_relation": "related-not-equivalent", - "anchor_source_url": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html", - "anchor_source_locator": "HB 452 §5, Utah Code §13-72a-203(1)-(2)", - "anchor_qualification": "The draft JIA's 30-minute re-display term is not the statutory seven-day interaction rule; the anchor records related disclosure subject matter, not equivalence or statutory force for the draft.", + }, + "sb149_rma_only": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2024/bills/enrolled/SB0149.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "0a85408fb06d18d8a6fd3ce2db74c19e86c17c84d9c375daecb5a0b3eece8d86", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 149 (2024)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2024 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 7, Utah Code 13-70-302(2), p16 lines 509-510", + "excerpt": "entering into a regulatory mitigation agreement with the office and relevant agencies.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AMENDMENTS" + ] + }, + "sb149_single_extension": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2024/bills/enrolled/SB0149.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "0a85408fb06d18d8a6fd3ce2db74c19e86c17c84d9c375daecb5a0b3eece8d86", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 149 (2024)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2024 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 10, Utah Code 13-70-305(2), p18 line 574", + "excerpt": "A participant may request a single 12-month extension for participation in the learning", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AMENDMENTS" + ] + }, + "hb320_two_extensions": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 6, Utah Code 13-72-403(4), p8 lines 244-245", + "excerpt": "The office may grant up to two extensions for any regulatory mitigation or joint", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_governmental_entity": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 1, Utah Code 13-72-101(10), p2 lines 54-57", + "excerpt": "(b) a state-funded institution of higher education or public education; or", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_disclosure_timing": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 5, Utah Code 13-72a-203(2), p6 lines 179-184", + "excerpt": "(2) The disclosure described in Subsection (1) shall be made:\n180 (a) before the Utah user may access the features of the mental health chatbot;", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_seven_days": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 5, Utah Code 13-72a-203(2)(b), p6 lines 181-182", + "excerpt": "accessed the mental health chatbot within the previous seven days; and", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "sb226_on_request": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 3, Utah Code 13-75-103(1)(b), p4 lines 103-105", + "excerpt": "(b) The individual's prompt or question under Subsection (1)(a) must be a clear and", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + } + }, + "units": { + "entry:utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session": { + "before_sha256": "648b558040eb87d14bc739ecb64b90be1566ec84a69efe99c92f5f8bdb289cd3", + "after_sha256": "c307d8182e42993daa76516e2a364800ab0cccdea4fa8febf65c53f4371cb5d6", + "candidate_content": { + "id": "utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session", + "regulation": "us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001", + "authority": "utah-oaip", + "source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md", + "source_heading": "First-Session Disclosure (§13-72a-203)", + "term_anchors": [ + "https://everyailaw.com/term/utah-sb149-chatbot-disclosure.json" + ], + "obligation_anchors": [ + "https://everyailaw.com/obligation-category/transparency.json" + ], + "anchor_relation": "related-not-equivalent", + "anchor_source_url": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html", + "anchor_source_locator": "HB 452 §5, Utah Code §13-72a-203(1)-(2)", + "anchor_qualification": "The draft JIA's 30-minute re-display term is not the statutory seven-day interaction rule; the anchor records related disclosure subject matter, not equivalence or statutory force for the draft.", "obligations": [ "disclose-genai-on-first-session" ] @@ -257,6 +872,62 @@ "evidence": [ "hb452" ] + }, + "entry:sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense": { + "before_sha256": "61f84dffd6d2394a4b68aa79f58c20c3ab31813efd1677bf8e94da2c8b88a21a", + "after_sha256": "56836cab160c49426e9224ae78e504cdbfa8c30d175cba082b10d0b98f1a2b21", + "candidate_content": { + "id": "sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense", + "regulation": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149", + "authority": "utah-legislature", + "source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md", + "source_heading": "Summary", + "obligation_qualification": "The learning-lab-agreement-participation text describes the regime as amended by HB 320 (2026), including joint interpretation agreements, a 36-month maximum, and governmental-entity counterparties; SB 149 as enacted provided regulatory mitigation agreements only, a 24-month maximum (12 months plus a single 12-month extension), and agency counterparties.", + "obligations": [ + "learning-lab-agreement-participation", + "ai-defense-elimination" + ] + }, + "reason": "Qualify that the mapped learning-lab obligation describes the HB 320 regime, not SB 149 as enacted (RMAs only, 24-month maximum, agency counterparties).", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Mapping qualification only; obligations list unchanged.", + "exceptions": "Mapping retained pending human decision.", + "time": "SB 149 effective 2024-05-01; HB 320 effective 2026-05-06." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb149_rma_only", + "sb149_single_extension", + "hb320_two_extensions", + "hb320_governmental_entity" + ] + }, + "entry:hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack": { + "before_sha256": "0efa1a9d629192ea94613364015b159f0297afd09676a5633788f81b626ed675", + "after_sha256": "66bc4b8a16d6100604ecc6c10e8fd489aed581208679ce6a3c847cb44b7b3d7c", + "candidate_content": { + "id": "hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack", + "regulation": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452", + "authority": "utah-legislature", + "source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md", + "source_heading": "Summary", + "obligation_qualification": "The disclose-genai-on-first-session mapping is related, not equivalent. HB 452 section 13-72a-203(2) requires disclosure before access, at the start of an interaction after seven days without access, and whenever the user asks or prompts; the obligation's per-session and 30-minute re-display terms are not statutory, and section 13-75-103(1) is the separate SB 226 on-request rule.", + "obligations": [ + "disclose-genai-on-first-session", + "chatbot-data-no-third-party-sharing", + "chatbot-safety-policy-filing" + ] + }, + "reason": "Qualify the first-session obligation mapping against HB 452 13-72a-203(2) timing and note 13-75-103(1) is the SB 226 on-request rule.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Mapping qualification only; obligations list unchanged.", + "exceptions": "Mapping retained as related-not-equivalent pending human decision.", + "time": "HB 452 effective 2025-05-07; SB 226 effective 2025-05-07." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452_disclosure_timing", + "hb452_seven_days", + "sb226_on_request" + ] } } }, @@ -407,23 +1078,26 @@ } }, "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md": { - "record_sha256": "53b0d1aff53dcae4e0bd8e34ee2021069340673c56b979bf6a639b1ca589c202", + "record_sha256": "c1aca07ba833a22c5029c1afa612bd5aff05a91c2a2e3d30309c12a4ba792235", "baseline_sha256": "0fe5646a650e116e792630ba398902c7d089dffd51cbea531b6d2370fbb02cef", "whole_record": { "before_sha256": "0fe5646a650e116e792630ba398902c7d089dffd51cbea531b6d2370fbb02cef", - "after_sha256": "53b0d1aff53dcae4e0bd8e34ee2021069340673c56b979bf6a639b1ca589c202" + "after_sha256": "c1aca07ba833a22c5029c1afa612bd5aff05a91c2a2e3d30309c12a4ba792235" }, "review": { - "actor_type": "agent", - "actor": "Codex source-consistency review", - "reviewed_at": "2026-09-12T20:15:00Z", + "actor_type": "human", + "actor": "Sam Rogers", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:36:37Z", "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", - "scope": "Utah SB 149 comparative-superlative removal and record modified date only; no legal-status or currentness renewal.", - "packet_sha256": "4f6f7ab0b94560d1e81548a417d56e0026eee2e21799079f7baa04f2b448aa7e" + "human_approved": true, + "scope": "Human review and approval by Sam Rogers, attested in the Claude Code session on 2026-09-23, of source-consistency corrections prepared by an agent (Claude). Renews last_verified to 2026-09-23 on that basis. Agent preparation scope: Correct SB 149 Timeline introduction and Senate vote rows from the retained bill status page; mark the Boyd appointment row unconfirmed; recast the HB 452 row and bullet as a related, non-amending chapter; fix the civil/criminal locators, add the Chapter 70/72 numbering note, correct the prior 24-month term ceiling and the 2025-05-01 sunset from-date; replace the dead OAIP Learning Lab link with the retrieved OAIP home page; set modified. Earlier Talking Point review carried forward unchanged. Agent source-consistency correction only; does not renew last_verified, Verified rows, legal status or legal currentness.", + "packet_sha256": "4638f21fae0dfa0223ba78a611e37ad1d1c900807b53ff46a89832c0ba759e74" }, "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy." ], "evidence": { "sb149": { @@ -525,147 +1199,4294 @@ "identity_excerpts": [ "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" ] - } - }, - "units": { - "metadata:modified": { - "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", - "after_sha256": "966e72cc301b962a096d19cfa5e46aef704e98ffc7a935616324a430eed63cd8", - "candidate_content": "2026-09-12", - "reason": "Record the date of this bounded source-backed wording correction without renewing legal currentness.", - "qualifications": { - "scope": "This record edit only.", - "exceptions": "No last_verified, legal status, effective date, relationship, obligation, or nationwide comparison is accepted by this review.", - "time": "Historical enactment source retained; wording correction reviewed September 12, 2026." + }, + "status_introduced": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-status-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "0a4bbd42f4970021907e36ba30bde7d7ba9a7b5000a611dde7d2f83b94b72e99", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-status-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "02db4dfb7fcc9c536f4aa7e006458da3ed0ba3567a7cc4478db9e3d5c3195514" }, - "evidence": [ - "sb149", - "sb226", - "hb452", - "sb332", - "hb320" + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:40Z", + "final_url": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", + "content_type": "text/html", + "redirects": 0, + "bytes": 48574, + "server_last_modified": "Tue, 01 Jul 2025 16:05:38 GMT" + }, + "document_id": "Utah SB 149 (2024) bill status page", + "document_title": "S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments (bill status)", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "official bill status page", + "version": "le.utah.gov static status page retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "Bill Status / Votes rows dated 1/25/2024 and 1/26/2024", + "excerpt": "1/26/2024\nSenate/ 1st reading (Introduced)\nSenate Rules Committee", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "2024 General Session" ] }, - "section:Summary/text": { - "before_sha256": "9cbacc9bc0c0aa57f1b51e35681438b656bf75866c47ead90be39bc781e0a0ac", - "after_sha256": "24cf22c778479422c92734659e37ef77abbfd672ca0ca60bb6fe946567654d72", - "candidate_content": "SB 149 established Utah's AI policy architecture: the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP), the Artificial Intelligence Learning Laboratory (regulatory mitigation program), a generative AI disclosure requirement for consumer transactions (§13-2-12), and statutory treatment of AI-assisted violations in civil and criminal contexts (§76-2-107).\n\nKey provisions have been substantially amended by subsequent legislation:\n- **SB 226 (2025)** repealed §13-2-12 and re-enacted the disclosure framework as Chapter 75 with a narrower \"clear and unambiguous request\" trigger and a safe-harbor for outset+throughout disclosure.\n- **HB 452 (2025)** added Chapter 72a for mental health chatbot suppliers, including disclosure and data-protection requirements.\n- **HB 320 (2026)** restructured Chapter 72, added the Joint Interpretation Agreement instrument, and extended the maximum agreement term from 12 to 36 months.\n- **SB 332** extended the Chapter 72 sunset from 2025-07-01 to 2027-07-01.\n\nFor the consolidated obligations matrix across the full Utah AI stack, see [everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149](https://everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149/).", - "reason": "Remove unsupported nationwide comparative language while retaining the source-supported Utah statutory description.", - "qualifications": { - "scope": "Utah SB 149 source-supported Utah provisions only.", - "exceptions": "No last_verified, legal status, effective date, relationship, obligation, or nationwide comparison is accepted by this review.", - "time": "Historical enactment source retained; wording correction reviewed September 12, 2026." + "status_numbered": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-status-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "0a4bbd42f4970021907e36ba30bde7d7ba9a7b5000a611dde7d2f83b94b72e99", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-status-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "02db4dfb7fcc9c536f4aa7e006458da3ed0ba3567a7cc4478db9e3d5c3195514" }, - "evidence": [ - "sb149", - "sb226", - "hb452", - "sb332", - "hb320" + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:40Z", + "final_url": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", + "content_type": "text/html", + "redirects": 0, + "bytes": 48574, + "server_last_modified": "Tue, 01 Jul 2025 16:05:38 GMT" + }, + "document_id": "Utah SB 149 (2024) bill status page", + "document_title": "S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments (bill status)", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "official bill status page", + "version": "le.utah.gov static status page retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "Bill Status / Votes row dated 1/25/2024", + "excerpt": "1/25/2024\nNumbered Bill Publicly Distributed", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "2024 General Session" ] }, - "section:Summary/subsection:Talking Point/text": { - "before_sha256": "73f6e739312aa2039325dbf78c9ad2a0cbca500f8e03d3570617fc1054caaebf", - "after_sha256": "e7ded560198e8883a990626e89efb7a18f50575f4549e58db5c2819aad1ce7fd", - "candidate_content": "> \"Utah SB 149 (2024) created OAIP and the Learning Lab. Later legislation moved the disclosure framework, added mental-health-chatbot rules and Joint Interpretation Agreements, and expanded potential agreement duration through extensions.\"", - "reason": "Remove unsupported nationwide comparative language while retaining the source-supported Utah statutory description.", - "qualifications": { - "scope": "Utah SB 149 source-supported Utah provisions only.", - "exceptions": "No last_verified, legal status, effective date, relationship, obligation, or nationwide comparison is accepted by this review.", - "time": "Historical enactment source retained; wording correction reviewed September 12, 2026." + "status_senate_2nd": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-status-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "0a4bbd42f4970021907e36ba30bde7d7ba9a7b5000a611dde7d2f83b94b72e99", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-status-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "02db4dfb7fcc9c536f4aa7e006458da3ed0ba3567a7cc4478db9e3d5c3195514" }, - "evidence": [ - "sb149", - "sb226", - "hb452", - "sb332", - "hb320" + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:40Z", + "final_url": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", + "content_type": "text/html", + "redirects": 0, + "bytes": 48574, + "server_last_modified": "Tue, 01 Jul 2025 16:05:38 GMT" + }, + "document_id": "Utah SB 149 (2024) bill status page", + "document_title": "S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments (bill status)", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "official bill status page", + "version": "le.utah.gov static status page retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "Bill Status / Votes row 2/12/2024 (2:37:26 PM)", + "excerpt": "2/12/2024 (2:37:26 PM)\nSenate/ passed 2nd reading\nSenate 3rd Reading Calendar\n22 0 7", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "2024 General Session" ] - } - } - }, - "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md": { - "record_sha256": "8deea5bfdfb67ecb23276907a46d7d76dbe492525a4b401dfcad8a1933fbbea5", - "baseline_sha256": "901c5fb7838b83ab095029aaa3095bf6011302523d4a727d6b0f753518f3e226", - "whole_record": { - "before_sha256": "901c5fb7838b83ab095029aaa3095bf6011302523d4a727d6b0f753518f3e226", - "after_sha256": "8deea5bfdfb67ecb23276907a46d7d76dbe492525a4b401dfcad8a1933fbbea5" - }, - "review": { - "actor_type": "agent", - "actor": "Codex source-consistency review", - "reviewed_at": "2026-09-12T20:15:00Z", - "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", - "scope": "Utah HB 452 comparative-superlative removal and record modified date only; no legal-status or currentness renewal.", - "packet_sha256": "38ad104b571b171500e69a42c94ef01bbc1f85d57335af6e7ec67f0c6bb43705" - }, - "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." - ], - "evidence": { - "enrolled": { - "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", - "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + }, + "status_senate_3rd": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-status-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "0a4bbd42f4970021907e36ba30bde7d7ba9a7b5000a611dde7d2f83b94b72e99", "original": { - "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", - "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-status-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "02db4dfb7fcc9c536f4aa7e006458da3ed0ba3567a7cc4478db9e3d5c3195514" }, - "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", - "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", - "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", - "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:40Z", + "final_url": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", + "content_type": "text/html", + "redirects": 0, + "bytes": 48574, + "server_last_modified": "Tue, 01 Jul 2025 16:05:38 GMT" + }, + "document_id": "Utah SB 149 (2024) bill status page", + "document_title": "S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments (bill status)", "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", - "document_type": "enacted legislation", - "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", - "locator": "Sections 13-72a-203 and 58-60-118", - "excerpt": "13-72a-203 . Disclosure requirements.", + "document_type": "official bill status page", + "version": "le.utah.gov static status page retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "Bill Status / Votes row 2/13/2024 (11:50:33 AM)", + "excerpt": "2/13/2024 (11:50:33 AM)\nSenate/ passed 3rd reading\nClerk of the House\n26 0 3", "identity_excerpts": [ - "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + "S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "2024 General Session" ] - } - }, - "units": { - "metadata:modified": { - "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", - "after_sha256": "966e72cc301b962a096d19cfa5e46aef704e98ffc7a935616324a430eed63cd8", - "candidate_content": "2026-09-12", - "reason": "Record the date of this bounded source-backed wording correction without renewing legal currentness.", - "qualifications": { + }, + "sb149_civil": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2024/bills/enrolled/SB0149.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "0a85408fb06d18d8a6fd3ce2db74c19e86c17c84d9c375daecb5a0b3eece8d86", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 149 (2024)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2024 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 1, Utah Code 13-2-12(2), p3 lines 65-66", + "excerpt": "(2) It is not a defense to the violation of any statute administered and enforced by the\n66 division, as described in Section 13-2-1, that generative artificial intelligence:", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AMENDMENTS" + ] + }, + "sb149_chapter70": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2024/bills/enrolled/SB0149.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "0a85408fb06d18d8a6fd3ce2db74c19e86c17c84d9c375daecb5a0b3eece8d86", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 149 (2024)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2024 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 11, Utah Code 63I-2-213(3), p18 line 583", + "excerpt": "(3) Title 13, Chapter 70, Artificial Intelligence Act, is repealed on May 1, 2025.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AMENDMENTS" + ] + }, + "sb149_single_extension": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2024/bills/enrolled/SB0149.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "0a85408fb06d18d8a6fd3ce2db74c19e86c17c84d9c375daecb5a0b3eece8d86", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 149 (2024)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2024 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 10, Utah Code 13-70-305(2), p18 line 574", + "excerpt": "A participant may request a single 12-month extension for participation in the learning", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AMENDMENTS" + ] + }, + "sb332_repeal": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0332.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb332/SB0332-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "2db8a28ce75c50fd5e19b4db5453a1d7b61e6c515243466ff4927e17c0d5cc0a", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb332/SB0332-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 332 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 332 Artificial Intelligence Revisions", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 1, Utah Code 63I-2-213(5), p2 lines 30-31", + "excerpt": "(5) Title 13, Chapter 72, Artificial Intelligence Policy Act, is repealed [May] July 1, [2025]", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Revisions" + ] + }, + "sb226_repeal": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 7, Utah Code 63I-2-213(5), p6 lines 181-182", + "excerpt": "(5) Title 13, Chapter 72, Artificial Intelligence Policy Act, is repealed [May 1, 2025] July 1,", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_codified": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Utah Code Sections Affected, p1 line 20", + "excerpt": "13-72-101, as enacted by Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_two_extensions": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 6, Utah Code 13-72-403(4), p8 lines 244-245", + "excerpt": "The office may grant up to two extensions for any regulatory mitigation or joint", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_sections_affected": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Utah Code Sections Affected, p1 lines 23-26", + "excerpt": "AMENDS:\n24 13-2-1, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 132\n25 ENACTS:\n26 13-72a-101, Utah Code Annotated 1953", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_crossref": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 2, Utah Code 13-72a-101(1), p3 line 89", + "excerpt": "\"Artificial intelligence\" means the same as that term is defined in Section 13-72-101.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "oaip_home": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "8a86df5aec4d2c3cd1d7e1aec45577c61f12e04e0df11fec1cb6d1ef05e61062", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:40Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", + "redirects": 0, + "bytes": 132890, + "server_last_modified": "Fri, 04 Sep 2026 07:18:27 GMT" + }, + "document_id": "Utah OAIP home page", + "document_title": "AI Home - commerce.utah.gov", + "issuing_body": "Utah Department of Commerce, Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy", + "document_type": "official agency web page", + "version": "commerce.utah.gov/ai/ retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "Page body, Our Mission paragraph", + "excerpt": "The Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy is dedicated to regulating the bleeding edge of AI.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AI Home - commerce.utah.gov" + ] + } + }, + "units": { + "metadata:last_verified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Human reviewer renews verification after reviewing the corrected record against its retained sources.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Whole-record source-consistency review against the retained sources cited in this receipt.", + "exceptions": "Items listed as unresolved remain unverified; review does not certify legal currentness beyond the cited sources.", + "time": "Reviewed 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb149" + ] + }, + "metadata:modified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Record the date of this bounded source-backed correction without renewing legal currentness.", + "qualifications": { "scope": "This record edit only.", - "exceptions": "No last_verified, legal status, effective date, relationship, obligation, or nationwide comparison is accepted by this review.", - "time": "Historical enactment source retained; wording correction reviewed September 12, 2026." + "exceptions": "No last_verified, legal status or currentness renewal is accepted by this review.", + "time": "Correction reviewed September 24, 2026 UTC against retained sources." }, "evidence": [ - "enrolled" + "sb149", + "status_senate_3rd" + ] + }, + "section:Timeline/text": { + "before_sha256": "ebf841fff57f44783d2c74badcf8f1381dcaa56d8dcdffb5efeaac9a012566eb", + "after_sha256": "3c8f3c9fc855d7497b6712f41e54a2994e2d1827fc25c9cd7b50295037a7fb93", + "candidate_content": "| Milestone | Date | Notes |\n|-----------|------|-------|\n| Introduced | 2024-01-26 | Senate 1st reading, to Senate Rules Committee (numbered and publicly distributed 2024-01-25) |\n| Senate passed | 2024-02-13 | 26-0-3 on 3rd reading (2nd reading 2024-02-12, 22-0-7) |\n| House passed | 2024-02-28 | 73-0-2 |\n| Governor Signed | 2024-03-13 | Gov. Cox |\n| Effective | 2024-05-01 | Office of AI Policy operational, §76-2-107 criminal mirror, §13-2-12 disclosure |\n| Boyd appointed | 2024-04-30 | First Director, Office of AI Policy (unconfirmed: not in the enrolled bill or bill status page) |\n| Amended by SB 226 | 2025-05-07 | §13-2-12 repealed; disclosure moved to Chapter 75 |\n| HB 452 effective | 2025-05-07 | Related Chapter 72a (mental health chatbots) enacted; HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted |\n| Amended by HB 320 | 2026-05-06 | Chapter 72 restructured; Learning Lab + JIA instrument added |\n| Chapter 72 sunset | 2027-07-01 | Office + Lab + agreements expire unless extended |\n\n---", + "reason": "Correct the Introduced and Senate passed rows to the status page (1st reading 2024-01-26; 3rd reading 2024-02-13, 26-0-3), mark the Boyd row unconfirmed, and recast HB 452 as a related chapter, since HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a only.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "SB 149 legislative history rows and the HB 452 relation row.", + "exceptions": "Boyd appointment remains unconfirmed; other dates (SB 226, HB 320, sunset) are unchanged and not re-reviewed beyond the cited bills.", + "time": "Status page retrieved 2026-09-24; enrolled copies 2024-2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "status_introduced", + "status_numbered", + "status_senate_2nd", + "status_senate_3rd", + "hb452_sections_affected" ] }, "section:Summary/text": { - "before_sha256": "b02fe39029476bcc76ec67e5278fccc7eb6ef14cdc816fa8117ca2caa8dcfca4", - "after_sha256": "1817161c5281e6d4f2036992eb649d255cd77b624a879cdb1b1383251c2dff33", - "candidate_content": "HB 452 established Chapter 72a of the Utah Code, a statutory framework governing AI-powered mental health chatbots. The bill imposes disclosure, data protection, and safety-policy requirements on suppliers of such services:\n\n- **Pre-access + post-gap + on-prompt disclosure** (§13-72a-203). Disclosure must appear before user access, again at the start of any interaction following a 7-day gap, and any time the user asks whether AI is involved. Scripted-only outputs (meditations, mindfulness) and referral-to-human-therapist bots are carved out (§13-72a-101(10)(b)).\n- **Data protection** (§13-72a-201). Suppliers may not sell or share identifiable health information or user input with third parties. Limited exceptions for user-consented or user-requested disclosure to health care providers; third-party functional sharing requires HIPAA Parts 160+164 Subparts A/E compliance as if the supplier were a covered entity.\n- **15-element safety policy** (§58-60-118). Suppliers who file a statutorily specified written policy with the Division of Consumer Protection (and comply with it at the time of alleged violation) gain an affirmative defense against §58-1-501(1)-(2) unauthorized-practice actions — a sector-specific safe harbor via documented policy.\n\nPenalties: $2,500 per violation (administrative or court), $5,000 per violation of a cease-and-desist order.", - "reason": "Remove unsupported nationwide comparative language while retaining the source-supported Utah statutory description.", + "before_sha256": "9cbacc9bc0c0aa57f1b51e35681438b656bf75866c47ead90be39bc781e0a0ac", + "after_sha256": "34d826187ad610d6bcf34888dd57f4e4529e9ec6dab60d0e5a9abeb64348e8f7", + "candidate_content": "SB 149 established Utah's AI policy architecture: the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP), the Artificial Intelligence Learning Laboratory (regulatory mitigation program), a generative AI disclosure requirement for consumer transactions (§13-2-12), and statutory treatment of AI-assisted violations in civil (§13-2-12(2)) and criminal (§76-2-107) contexts. The enrolled bill numbered the new chapter Title 13, Chapter 70; it is codified as Chapter 72, the chapter number later bills amend.\n\nKey provisions have been substantially amended or supplemented by subsequent legislation:\n- **SB 226 (2025)** repealed §13-2-12 and re-enacted the disclosure framework as Chapter 75 with a narrower \"clear and unambiguous request\" trigger and a safe-harbor for outset+throughout disclosure.\n- **HB 452 (2025)** added the related Chapter 72a for mental health chatbot suppliers, including disclosure and data-protection requirements. It cross-references Chapter 72 definitions but amends no section SB 149 enacted.\n- **HB 320 (2026)** restructured Chapter 72, added the Joint Interpretation Agreement instrument, and extended the maximum agreement term from 24 months (12 plus a single 12-month extension) to 36 months (12 plus up to two 12-month extensions).\n- **SB 332 (2025)** extended the Chapter 72 sunset from 2025-05-01 to 2027-07-01; SB 226 (2025) made the same §63I-2-213 amendment.\n\nFor the consolidated obligations matrix across the full Utah AI stack, see [everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149](https://everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149/).", + "reason": "Cite 13-2-12(2) for the civil rule, note the enrolled Chapter 70 numbering later cited as Chapter 72, qualify HB 452 as non-amending, correct the prior term ceiling to 24 months and the pre-SB 332 sunset to 2025-05-01, and note SB 226 made the same repeal-date amendment.", "qualifications": { - "scope": "Utah HB 452 source-supported Utah provisions only.", - "exceptions": "No last_verified, legal status, effective date, relationship, obligation, or nationwide comparison is accepted by this review.", - "time": "Historical enactment source retained; wording correction reviewed September 12, 2026." + "scope": "Utah SB 149 enrolled copy, its le.utah.gov bill status page, and the later Utah bills named in the record.", + "exceptions": "No nationwide comparison, legal status or relationship-field change is accepted; amended_by is unchanged.", + "time": "SB 149 effective 2024-05-01; later bills 2025-2026; reviewed September 24, 2026 UTC." }, "evidence": [ - "enrolled" + "sb149", + "sb149_civil", + "sb149_chapter70", + "sb149_single_extension", + "sb226", + "sb226_repeal", + "sb332", + "sb332_repeal", + "hb320", + "hb320_codified", + "hb320_two_extensions", + "hb452", + "hb452_crossref" ] }, "section:Summary/subsection:Talking Point/text": { - "before_sha256": "0019f536fba9489c28479b401deea81edcbd2eeae77a779b3664a491dde41c34", - "after_sha256": "5379d41802db7c0f0a75dd1b11ebf05ad5194f4f15a2f29ca3e8c2968b442b1c", - "candidate_content": "> \"Utah HB 452 (2025) requires mental health chatbots to disclose AI use before access, after a seven-day gap, and on prompt, and provides a policy-based affirmative defense to specified unauthorized-practice actions.\"", + "before_sha256": "73f6e739312aa2039325dbf78c9ad2a0cbca500f8e03d3570617fc1054caaebf", + "after_sha256": "e7ded560198e8883a990626e89efb7a18f50575f4549e58db5c2819aad1ce7fd", + "candidate_content": "> \"Utah SB 149 (2024) created OAIP and the Learning Lab. Later legislation moved the disclosure framework, added mental-health-chatbot rules and Joint Interpretation Agreements, and expanded potential agreement duration through extensions.\"", "reason": "Remove unsupported nationwide comparative language while retaining the source-supported Utah statutory description.", "qualifications": { - "scope": "Utah HB 452 source-supported Utah provisions only.", + "scope": "Utah SB 149 source-supported Utah provisions only.", "exceptions": "No last_verified, legal status, effective date, relationship, obligation, or nationwide comparison is accepted by this review.", "time": "Historical enactment source retained; wording correction reviewed September 12, 2026." }, "evidence": [ - "enrolled" + "sb149", + "sb226", + "hb452", + "sb332", + "hb320" + ] + }, + "section:Summary/subsection:Sources/text": { + "before_sha256": "cbfce15b614c2551f5e33c10a5477c554abd257340b91bb79960f2c923d402fa", + "after_sha256": "ba7c0b00626a5f9071161f9560744ef4f7cd3d734722d4d419dbf2d5f3c82554", + "candidate_content": "- [SB 149 Bill Text (le.utah.gov)](https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html)\n- [EveryAILaw — Utah AI Stack](https://everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149/)\n- [Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/)", + "reason": "Replace the dead OAIP Learning Lab link with the official OAIP home page that returned HTTP 200 and describes the office.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Sources link list only.", + "exceptions": "Does not assert a current Learning Lab page exists.", + "time": "OAIP home page retrieved 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "oaip_home" + ] + } + } + }, + "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md": { + "record_sha256": "823a6f04b847768379b4f8d5218794e3c88e31d2fcdd1032d881da4cc49eccde", + "baseline_sha256": "901c5fb7838b83ab095029aaa3095bf6011302523d4a727d6b0f753518f3e226", + "whole_record": { + "before_sha256": "901c5fb7838b83ab095029aaa3095bf6011302523d4a727d6b0f753518f3e226", + "after_sha256": "823a6f04b847768379b4f8d5218794e3c88e31d2fcdd1032d881da4cc49eccde" + }, + "review": { + "actor_type": "human", + "actor": "Sam Rogers", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:36:37Z", + "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", + "human_approved": true, + "scope": "Human review and approval by Sam Rogers, attested in the Claude Code session on 2026-09-23, of source-consistency corrections prepared by an agent (Claude). Renews last_verified to 2026-09-23 on that basis. Agent preparation scope: Add the enrolled short title and sponsors; qualify Timeline introduction and signing rows as unconfirmed; tighten the data-protection exceptions, add the (2)(b) documentation condition, the 13-72a-202 advertising bullet, the order-penalty wording and a non-amending note on SB 149; set modified. Earlier Talking Point review carried forward unchanged. Agent source-consistency correction only; does not renew last_verified, Verified rows, legal status or legal currentness.", + "packet_sha256": "be382469d216fa204a551bbd826747b34bbc49fc2e9581723266bd05df6a9690" + }, + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." + ], + "evidence": { + "enrolled": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Sections 13-72a-203 and 58-60-118", + "excerpt": "13-72a-203 . Disclosure requirements.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_title": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Enrolled copy p1 line 1 short title", + "excerpt": "1 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_sponsors": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Enrolled copy p1 header", + "excerpt": "Chief Sponsor: Jefferson Moss\n Senate Sponsor: Kirk A. Cullimore", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_sections_affected": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Utah Code Sections Affected, p1 lines 23-26", + "excerpt": "AMENDS:\n24 13-2-1, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 132\n25 ENACTS:\n26 13-72a-101, Utah Code Annotated 1953", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_crossref": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 2, Utah Code 13-72a-101(1), p3 line 89", + "excerpt": "\"Artificial intelligence\" means the same as that term is defined in Section 13-72-101.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_exceptions": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 3, Utah Code 13-72a-201(2), p5 lines 142-144", + "excerpt": "(a) requested by a health care provider with the consent of the Utah user;\n144 (b) provided to a health plan of a Utah user", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_advertising": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 4, Utah Code 13-72a-202, p5-6 lines 155-170", + "excerpt": "13-72a-202 . Restrictions on advertising.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_ad_input": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 4, Utah Code 13-72a-202(2)(a), p6 lines 165-167", + "excerpt": "user, unless the advertisement is for the mental health chatbot itself;", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_defense_docs": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 8, Utah Code 58-60-118(2)(b), p8 lines 234-240", + "excerpt": "(b) maintains documentation regarding the development and implementation of the", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_order_penalty": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 6, Utah Code 13-72a-204(6), p7 lines 211-212", + "excerpt": "(6) A court may impose a civil penalty of no more than $5,000 for each violation of an\n212 administrative or court order issued for a violation of this chapter.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_effective": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 9, Effective Date, p9 line 303", + "excerpt": "This bill takes effect on May 7, 2025.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + } + }, + "units": { + "metadata:last_verified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Human reviewer renews verification after reviewing the corrected record against its retained sources.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Whole-record source-consistency review against the retained sources cited in this receipt.", + "exceptions": "Items listed as unresolved remain unverified; review does not certify legal currentness beyond the cited sources.", + "time": "Reviewed 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452_title" + ] + }, + "metadata:modified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Record the date of this bounded source-backed correction without renewing legal currentness.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "This record edit only.", + "exceptions": "No last_verified, legal status or currentness renewal is accepted by this review.", + "time": "Correction reviewed September 24, 2026 UTC against retained sources." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452_title" + ] + }, + "metadata:title": { + "before_sha256": "4fd7b779befd7ee6e7cf19c24435b5180d33e1df84af68c63a6ec9d8c71c647f", + "after_sha256": "400da1228fa7e56b39cd8f3578c4d243032355bcd101830e6432fc32bc517663", + "candidate_content": "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots)", + "reason": "Lead the title with the enrolled short title \"Artificial Intelligence Amendments\" and keep the mental-health-chatbot subject as a parenthetical.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Record title only.", + "exceptions": "Slug and id unchanged.", + "time": "HB 452 enrolled 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452_title" + ] + }, + "section:Timeline/text": { + "before_sha256": "03a48db1a79add4566844abf367b0abc4c421791f9c8936877f8dd21e36cce13", + "after_sha256": "eeea31f59304544b87b11dec3dc2aa77a442c83f946d9ef513112e244ae1ff80", + "candidate_content": "| Milestone | Date | Notes |\n|-----------|------|-------|\n| Introduced | 2025-02 | 2025 General Session (month unconfirmed: not in the enrolled copy) |\n| Governor Signed | 2025-03-26 | Unconfirmed: not in the enrolled copy; bill status page not retained |\n| Effective | 2025-05-07 | Chapter 72a stands up |\n\n---", + "reason": "Mark the Introduced month and Governor Signed date unconfirmed because the enrolled copy does not show them and no status page is retained; the effective date matches the enrolled copy.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "HB 452 Timeline rows.", + "exceptions": "Signing and introduction dates stay unverified; enacted field unchanged.", + "time": "HB 452 effective May 7, 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452_effective" + ] + }, + "section:Summary/text": { + "before_sha256": "b02fe39029476bcc76ec67e5278fccc7eb6ef14cdc816fa8117ca2caa8dcfca4", + "after_sha256": "eed61efae4a1959ad7d3d3734da440894695b0d1711e519499f7e133a472e318", + "candidate_content": "HB 452 established Chapter 72a of the Utah Code, a statutory framework governing AI-powered mental health chatbots. The bill imposes disclosure, data protection, and advertising requirements on suppliers of such services and conditions a safety-policy affirmative defense. It amends §13-2-1 and enacts new sections; Chapter 72a cross-references the Chapter 72 definition of artificial intelligence (§13-72-101) but amends no section SB 149 enacted:\n\n- **Pre-access + post-gap + on-prompt disclosure** (§13-72a-203). Disclosure must appear before user access, again at the start of any interaction following a 7-day gap, and any time the user asks whether AI is involved. Scripted-only outputs (meditations, mindfulness) and referral-to-human-therapist bots are carved out (§13-72a-101(10)(b)).\n- **Data protection** (§13-72a-201). Suppliers may not sell or share identifiable health information or user input with third parties. Limited exceptions for information requested by a health care provider with the user's consent, or provided to the user's health plan at the user's request; third-party functional sharing requires HIPAA Parts 160+164 Subparts A/E compliance as if the supplier were a covered entity.\n- **Advertising restrictions** (§13-72a-202). In-conversation advertising must be clearly and conspicuously identified as advertising, with any sponsorship, business affiliation, or promotion agreement disclosed; user input may not be used to decide whether to show an advertisement (other than for the chatbot itself), to choose what to advertise, or to customize how an advertisement is presented.\n- **15-element safety policy** (§58-60-118). Suppliers who create, maintain, and implement a statutorily specified written policy, maintain documentation of foundation models, training data, privacy compliance, data practices, and accuracy and safety efforts (§58-60-118(2)(b)), file the policy with the Division of Consumer Protection, and comply with it at the time of alleged violation gain an affirmative defense against §58-1-501(1)-(2) unauthorized-practice actions — a sector-specific safe harbor via documented policy.\n\nPenalties: $2,500 per violation (administrative or court), $5,000 per violation of an administrative or court order issued for a violation of the chapter.", + "reason": "Align the data-protection exceptions, safety-policy defense conditions, order penalty and enacted sections to the enrolled text, add the advertising restrictions, and state the non-amending relation to SB 149.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Utah HB 452 enrolled copy provisions only.", + "exceptions": "No nationwide comparison or relationship-field change is accepted; the carve-out citation is not re-reviewed.", + "time": "HB 452 enrolled 2025; reviewed September 24, 2026 UTC." + }, + "evidence": [ + "enrolled", + "hb452_sections_affected", + "hb452_crossref", + "hb452_exceptions", + "hb452_advertising", + "hb452_ad_input", + "hb452_defense_docs", + "hb452_order_penalty" + ] + }, + "section:Summary/subsection:Talking Point/text": { + "before_sha256": "0019f536fba9489c28479b401deea81edcbd2eeae77a779b3664a491dde41c34", + "after_sha256": "5379d41802db7c0f0a75dd1b11ebf05ad5194f4f15a2f29ca3e8c2968b442b1c", + "candidate_content": "> \"Utah HB 452 (2025) requires mental health chatbots to disclose AI use before access, after a seven-day gap, and on prompt, and provides a policy-based affirmative defense to specified unauthorized-practice actions.\"", + "reason": "Remove unsupported nationwide comparative language while retaining the source-supported Utah statutory description.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Utah HB 452 source-supported Utah provisions only.", + "exceptions": "No last_verified, legal status, effective date, relationship, obligation, or nationwide comparison is accepted by this review.", + "time": "Historical enactment source retained; wording correction reviewed September 12, 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "enrolled" + ] + }, + "metadata:sponsors": { + "before_sha256": null, + "after_sha256": "8d76b96457e9950c5020d7a0f6c1fb421f380e1dd53720cedd3a385c36d6ae0e", + "candidate_content": [ + "Rep. Jefferson Moss (House sponsor)", + "Sen. Kirk A. Cullimore (Senate floor sponsor)" + ], + "reason": "Add sponsors printed on the enrolled copy: Chief Sponsor Jefferson Moss, Senate Sponsor Kirk A. Cullimore.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Sponsor names and chamber roles from the enrolled header.", + "exceptions": "Rep./Sen. honorifics follow the chamber roles shown on the enrolled copy.", + "time": "HB 452 enrolled 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452_sponsors" + ] + } + } + }, + "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md": { + "record_sha256": "b935a9e9d2a81ec511b4f507e2086e60394cba0f5ca191721dfd405edb4c17d6", + "baseline_sha256": "c2190dfc51ff2893e9e1a4d49c9457f0fca3791cd8cca5878fe55c1a7b014c19", + "whole_record": { + "before_sha256": "c2190dfc51ff2893e9e1a4d49c9457f0fca3791cd8cca5878fe55c1a7b014c19", + "after_sha256": "b935a9e9d2a81ec511b4f507e2086e60394cba0f5ca191721dfd405edb4c17d6" + }, + "review": { + "actor_type": "human", + "actor": "Sam Rogers", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:36:37Z", + "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", + "human_approved": true, + "scope": "Human review and approval by Sam Rogers, attested in the Claude Code session on 2026-09-23, of source-consistency corrections prepared by an agent (Claude). Renews last_verified to 2026-09-23 on that basis. Agent preparation scope: Corrects the JIA draft's enacting-bill citation, dead authority URL, statutory versus proposed disclosure triggers, provision date label and publication-state timeline against the retained HB 452 enrolled copy and the retained OAIP home page. Does not renew last_verified, promote the draft or assert issuance.", + "packet_sha256": "27b15547fb411ec37543f7deac2039683b39c228e9d71b8d5976e645c811d329" + }, + "unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ], + "evidence": { + "hb452-section": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 5 enacting 13-72a-203, line 175", + "excerpt": "13-72a-203 . Disclosure requirements.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "13-72a-203 . Disclosure requirements." + ] + }, + "hb452-before-access": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "13-72a-203(1)-(2)(a), lines 176-180", + "excerpt": "before the Utah user may access the features of the mental health chatbot", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "13-72a-203 . Disclosure requirements." + ] + }, + "hb452-seven-days": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "13-72a-203(2)(b), lines 181-182", + "excerpt": "accessed the mental health chatbot within the previous seven days", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "13-72a-203 . Disclosure requirements." + ] + }, + "hb452-on-request": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "13-72a-203(2)(c), lines 183-184", + "excerpt": "whether artificial intelligence is being used", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "13-72a-203 . Disclosure requirements." + ] + }, + "hb452-not-human": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "13-72a-203(1), lines 176-178", + "excerpt": "intelligence technology and not a human", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "13-72a-203 . Disclosure requirements." + ] + }, + "hb452-effective": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 8 effective date, line 303", + "excerpt": "This bill takes effect on May 7, 2025.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "13-72a-203 . Disclosure requirements." + ] + }, + "oaip-home": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "8a86df5aec4d2c3cd1d7e1aec45577c61f12e04e0df11fec1cb6d1ef05e61062", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:40Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8" + }, + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "document_id": "Utah OAIP home page", + "document_title": "AI Home - commerce.utah.gov", + "issuing_body": "Utah Department of Commerce, Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy", + "document_type": "official agency web page", + "version": "retrieved 2026-09-24T02:10:40Z; text snapshot of retained HTML", + "locator": "page body, final paragraph", + "excerpt": "The Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP) partners with companies building responsible AI.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AI Home - commerce.utah.gov" + ] + } + }, + "units": { + "metadata:issued_by": { + "before_sha256": "f589813d6705665132182b4c08e90f9dea0e85c4673afb508c63b60b119d3989", + "after_sha256": "e2623753f76da570a3196ac804ea809c75fe2b5d151deafae8be9365fd8c20f6", + "candidate_content": { + "@type": "https://w3id.org/semanticarts/ns/ontology/gist/SubCountryGovernment", + "name": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP)", + "ref": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/" + }, + "reason": "The Learning Lab URL returns 404 (2026-09-24). Point the interpreting authority reference at the current OAIP home page.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Authority reference URL only; the named interpreting authority is unchanged.", + "exceptions": "Does not assert that OAIP issued or endorsed this draft.", + "time": "Page state as retrieved 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "oaip-home" + ] + }, + "metadata:last_verified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Human reviewer renews verification after reviewing the corrected record against its retained sources.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Whole-record source-consistency review against the retained sources cited in this receipt.", + "exceptions": "Items listed as unresolved remain unverified; review does not certify legal currentness beyond the cited sources.", + "time": "Reviewed 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "oaip-home" + ] + }, + "metadata:modified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Record modified for the source-consistency corrections in this receipt.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Editorial modification date only.", + "exceptions": "Does not renew last_verified or verify legal currentness.", + "time": "2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452-section" + ] + }, + "metadata:official_url": { + "before_sha256": "23f550f8125157f63e898da96e98268bfc4b3353b4d6844676b574b64789d9de", + "after_sha256": "e18b02b5cf7676c96de58b9c1ba7b3c59ac21a922e9fb79398ff97f1adc991e2", + "candidate_content": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "reason": "Replace the dead Learning Lab URL with the current OAIP home page.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Official web location of the interpreting authority.", + "exceptions": "The OAIP page does not mention this draft JIA.", + "time": "Page state as retrieved 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "oaip-home" + ] + }, + "metadata:statute_anchors": { + "before_sha256": "3d75f9999e27bf056fa3d915f46c57269ccd18c9493d7168b786ad3c91761add", + "after_sha256": "829449d6dde85a03d98fa546e13ee4704bb20c8b5ade9accba61b2cc95dd264e", + "candidate_content": [ + { + "cite": "Utah Code §13-72a-203", + "url": "https://everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149/#mental-health-chatbot-disclosure" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah HB0452 (2025)", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html" + } + ], + "reason": "Section 13-72a-203 was enacted by HB 452 (2025), not SB 149 (2024), whose enrolled text contains no 13-72a section.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Enacting-bill citation for the anchored section.", + "exceptions": "The EveryAILaw anchor models the amended stack under its SB 149 page; unchanged.", + "time": "Enrolled 2025 General Session text; later amendments not reviewed." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452-section", + "hb452-effective" + ] + }, + "metadata:terms": { + "before_sha256": "e61175be3994b458006989cfbaba7af59941190e844350948235d4ffe4e6a9c3", + "after_sha256": "78e21f32d72de343fbe839426fa97c14f2ba4f19c7a7624c92ef6e4fddc6782c", + "candidate_content": [ + { + "@type": "https://w3id.org/semanticarts/ns/ontology/gist/ContractTerm", + "text": "Proposed interpretation: provider displays the standardized GenAI disclosure before first access and again on session resumption after 30 minutes of inactivity. The 30-minute re-display is a proposed term stricter than the statute's seven-day trigger, not a statutory requirement." + } + ], + "reason": "Separate the proposed 30-minute re-display term from the statutory triggers and align first display with the statute's before-access trigger.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Proposed term text of an unissued draft.", + "exceptions": "This record is a PubLedge original draft (source publedge-original-draft, status proposed). No official document records issuance of this JIA; the cited statute establishes only what the draft interprets.", + "time": "Statute effective May 7, 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452-before-access", + "hb452-seven-days" + ] + }, + "section:Timeline/text": { + "before_sha256": "c5f3029a61ca394e6a523a40e69a11303cc9a116a9f346b26c809868caf19c49", + "after_sha256": "b3abbea694ba7903d83d20ec1c72735b8f64fb021ddc99d841cccc22da96a17f", + "candidate_content": "| Milestone | Date | Notes |\n|-----------|------|-------|\n| Drafted | 2026-04-15 | Initial PubLedge draft, suggested prior art |\n| Reviewed | TBD | Lawyer review pending |\n| Published | TBD | Not issued; remains a PubLedge draft pending lawyer review and authority sign-off |\n\n---", + "reason": "'Awaiting v0.1 release' was stale. State the draft's actual publication state.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Publication state of this PubLedge draft.", + "exceptions": "This record is a PubLedge original draft (source publedge-original-draft, status proposed). No official document records issuance of this JIA; the cited statute establishes only what the draft interprets.", + "time": "As of 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452-section" + ] + }, + "section:First-Session Disclosure (§13-72a-203)/property:Effective": { + "before_sha256": "0ac613da8ca0604c124fc03dce4c022b0cf3e9f64d13299b7935387e23712e24", + "after_sha256": null, + "candidate_content": null, + "reason": "A draft has no effective date; 2026-04-15 was the drafting date. Removed in favor of a Drafted property.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Provision date label.", + "exceptions": "This record is a PubLedge original draft (source publedge-original-draft, status proposed). No official document records issuance of this JIA; the cited statute establishes only what the draft interprets.", + "time": "Statute itself effective May 7, 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452-effective" + ] + }, + "section:First-Session Disclosure (§13-72a-203)/property:Verified": { + "before_sha256": "6f237c58c76c7629ba051c47a5a59579fcbb7ccea17e8abccdde6d130ef37c34", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Human reviewer renews the provision's verification against the retained HB 452 enrolled text.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Whole-record source-consistency review against the retained sources cited in this receipt.", + "exceptions": "Items listed as unresolved remain unverified; review does not certify legal currentness beyond the cited sources.", + "time": "Reviewed 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452-section" + ] + }, + "section:First-Session Disclosure (§13-72a-203)/subsection:Requirements/text": { + "before_sha256": "12af40ab28f6fe0a488c1d5225687b0456fb0c8a83207f6b94d64d51ff83a918", + "after_sha256": "5910594437739540af01dda2ede59b90d7bd00e43a2b4136a272efe1e00b2553", + "candidate_content": "| Requirement | Details |\n|-------------|---------|\n| Display disclosure (statute) | Clearly and conspicuously disclose that the chatbot is AI and not a human, before the user may access its features |\n| Re-display after absence (statute) | Disclose again at the start of an interaction if the user hasn't accessed the chatbot within the previous seven days |\n| Disclose on request (statute) | Disclose whenever the user asks or prompts the chatbot about whether AI is being used |\n| Re-display on resumption (proposed JIA term) | After 30 minutes of inactivity, re-display the disclosure. Stricter than the statute; not a statutory requirement |", + "reason": "List the three statutory triggers (before access, seven-day absence, on request) and mark the 30-minute re-display as a proposed JIA term, not a statutory requirement.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Statutory disclosure triggers and one proposed term.", + "exceptions": "The proposed 30-minute term is not interchangeable with the statutory seven-day trigger.", + "time": "Statute effective May 7, 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452-not-human", + "hb452-before-access", + "hb452-seven-days", + "hb452-on-request" + ] + }, + "section:First-Session Disclosure (§13-72a-203)/subsection:Talking Point/text": { + "before_sha256": "8c683e552fecbb35e872e8b784df29a5a32084ff72198b1b1d6d84f2b5cfd0d0", + "after_sha256": "75531cbbb89e2b5fe9677694f2cd66ddb61ec9b69a6d37482a800a356b1729a4", + "candidate_content": "> \"A mental-health chatbot must tell the user it is an AI before first access, again after seven days away, and whenever asked. This draft proposes re-displaying it after 30 minutes of inactivity.\"", + "reason": "Talking point presented the proposed inactivity trigger as statutory. Restate the statutory triggers and label the proposal.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Plain-language summary.", + "exceptions": "Summary, not statutory text.", + "time": "Statute effective May 7, 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452-before-access", + "hb452-seven-days", + "hb452-on-request" + ] + }, + "section:First-Session Disclosure (§13-72a-203)/subsection:Sources/text": { + "before_sha256": "29efed8a53b184aa9cfead8be2eae47519b76b6a0b3a848c3e53f3650572d968", + "after_sha256": "aeba3b74f48167ef6e42966bd627bdfe094ded1312002bcc87d102e1d89df9e6", + "candidate_content": "- [EveryAILaw — Mental Health Chatbot Disclosure](https://everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149/#mental-health-chatbot-disclosure)\n- [Utah Code §13-72a-203](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72A/13-72a-S203.html), enacted by [Utah HB 452 (2025)](https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html)", + "reason": "The §13-72a-203 link pointed at the SB 149 bill page. Link the codified section and the enacting HB 452 page.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Source links.", + "exceptions": "Codified-section URL checked HTTP 200 on 2026-09-24; not retained as evidence.", + "time": "Enrolled 2025 text." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452-section" + ] + }, + "section:First-Session Disclosure (§13-72a-203)/property:Drafted": { + "before_sha256": null, + "after_sha256": "0ac613da8ca0604c124fc03dce4c022b0cf3e9f64d13299b7935387e23712e24", + "candidate_content": "2026-04-15", + "reason": "Relabels the 2026-04-15 date as the drafting date.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Provision date label.", + "exceptions": "This record is a PubLedge original draft (source publedge-original-draft, status proposed). No official document records issuance of this JIA; the cited statute establishes only what the draft interprets.", + "time": "Drafted 2026-04-15 per the record timeline." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452-effective" + ] + } + } + }, + "data/examples/obligations/disclose-genai-on-first-session.md": { + "record_sha256": "c87615a8fc2a979ae02b7d3c833c2b2cfcb476b6b61bdfae0d86d17343eb787d", + "baseline_sha256": "416ca3ea40e4681bf3f0ccb9a00cd890d94214d1e9c0ffd262fbb6a8a17da163", + "whole_record": { + "before_sha256": "416ca3ea40e4681bf3f0ccb9a00cd890d94214d1e9c0ffd262fbb6a8a17da163", + "after_sha256": "c87615a8fc2a979ae02b7d3c833c2b2cfcb476b6b61bdfae0d86d17343eb787d" + }, + "review": { + "actor_type": "agent", + "actor": "Claude source-consistency correction review", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:22:00Z", + "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", + "scope": "Corrects the first-session disclosure obligation's triggers against the retained SB 226 (§13-75-103) and HB 452 (§13-72a-203) enrolled copies. Does not renew last_verified or change the obligation's id, group or status.", + "packet_sha256": "8086134b9fedbd88d7dd4e183a80419860da6b3e77dd75151942f662cdfca44c" + }, + "unresolved": [ + "The obligation id and name still say 'first session'; renaming the id is a separate schema decision.", + "last_verified renewal requires a separate human review receipt." + ], + "evidence": { + "sb226-103": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 3 enacting 13-75-103, line 97", + "excerpt": "13-75-103 (Effective 05/07/25). Required disclosures.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + }, + "sb226-on-request": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "13-75-103(1)(a), lines 98-102", + "excerpt": "individual asks or otherwise prompts the supplier about whether artificial intelligence", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + }, + "sb226-clear-request": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "13-75-103(1)(b), lines 103-105", + "excerpt": "request to determine whether the interaction is with a human or with", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + }, + "sb226-regulated": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "13-75-103(2)(a), lines 106-110", + "excerpt": "prominently disclose when an individual receiving services is interacting with", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + }, + "sb226-verbal": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "13-75-103(3)(a), line 114", + "excerpt": "verbally at the start of a verbal interaction", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + }, + "sb226-written": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "13-75-103(3)(b), line 115", + "excerpt": "in writing before the start of a written interaction", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452-section": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 5 enacting 13-72a-203, line 175", + "excerpt": "13-72a-203 . Disclosure requirements.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "13-72a-203 . Disclosure requirements." + ] + }, + "hb452-before-access": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "13-72a-203(1)-(2)(a), lines 176-180", + "excerpt": "before the Utah user may access the features of the mental health chatbot", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "13-72a-203 . Disclosure requirements." + ] + }, + "hb452-seven-days": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "13-72a-203(2)(b), lines 181-182", + "excerpt": "accessed the mental health chatbot within the previous seven days", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "13-72a-203 . Disclosure requirements." + ] + }, + "hb452-on-request": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "13-72a-203(2)(c), lines 183-184", + "excerpt": "whether artificial intelligence is being used", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "13-72a-203 . Disclosure requirements." + ] + }, + "hb452-not-human": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "13-72a-203(1), lines 176-178", + "excerpt": "intelligence technology and not a human", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "13-72a-203 . Disclosure requirements." + ] + } + }, + "units": { + "section:Summary/text": { + "before_sha256": "b47fbd7120fb40392a96e66abb7d6eeac0363896dc17e42766b2a60457e1cae7", + "after_sha256": "8efa9f3f175a3b53267bafa0d5df10842c56da032e6c44b3ea59d68b9d84113a", + "candidate_content": "Disclose plainly that the person is interacting with generative AI and not a human. When the disclosure is due depends on the Utah provision: on a clear request in a consumer transaction (§13-75-103(1)); at the start of a high-risk interaction in a regulated occupation (§13-75-103(2)-(3)); and for a mental health chatbot, before access, again after seven days without access, and whenever asked (§13-72a-203(2)). No Utah provision anchored here requires re-display at every session or after a fixed inactivity period.", + "reason": "The summary required disclosure at the start of each session, which neither anchored provision requires. Restate the triggers of §13-75-103 and §13-72a-203.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Disclosure triggers under the two anchored Utah provisions.", + "exceptions": "Other states' rules and later Utah amendments are not reviewed.", + "time": "Both provisions effective May 7, 2025, per the enrolled copies." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb226-on-request", + "sb226-regulated", + "sb226-verbal", + "hb452-before-access", + "hb452-seven-days", + "hb452-on-request" + ] + }, + "section:What Counts/text": { + "before_sha256": "9f0f3002cad0b8d42c6d215aea52194e9a511d9c384af6dca4678217f8c6e0be", + "after_sha256": "df66facf40b76e079553744aad70bda93df9083b48bcc1469f3a1930a4c2d6ec", + "candidate_content": "- A disclosure that identifies the service as artificial intelligence and not a human\n- Consumer transactions: disclosing when the individual clearly and unambiguously asks whether they are interacting with a human or AI (§13-75-103(1))\n- Regulated occupations, high-risk interactions: a prominent disclosure given verbally at the start of a verbal interaction, or in writing before a written interaction (§13-75-103(2)-(3))\n- Mental health chatbots: a clear and conspicuous disclosure before the user may access the chatbot's features, again at the start of an interaction when the user hasn't accessed it within the previous seven days, and whenever the user asks (§13-72a-203)\n- Stricter terms, such as re-display after 30 minutes of inactivity in the draft JIA `us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001`, are proposals beyond the statute, not statutory requirements", + "reason": "Replace the per-session and 30-minute examples, which aren't statutory, with each provision's actual triggers; mark the 30-minute re-display as a draft proposal. Drop the unsupported preferred-language item.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Statutory triggers plus one labelled proposal.", + "exceptions": "The 30-minute term comes from the unissued PubLedge JIA draft, not from any statute.", + "time": "Enrolled 2025 text." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452-not-human", + "sb226-on-request", + "sb226-clear-request", + "sb226-regulated", + "sb226-verbal", + "sb226-written", + "hb452-before-access", + "hb452-seven-days", + "hb452-on-request" + ] + }, + "section:What Does Not Count/text": { + "before_sha256": "21b4a8c614606039da2817aa68ac0c1bf1e47e1abfee04ebfe17c0201f62bd5f", + "after_sha256": "86b91522c7beb727386b56a27200a9b3c560b220bb28b71bf8708a3934947020", + "candidate_content": "- For a mental health chatbot, a notice that isn't clear and conspicuous, such as one reachable only through a privacy policy or terms-of-service link\n- For a regulated occupation's high-risk interaction, a disclosure that isn't prominent or comes after the interaction starts\n- Phrasing that doesn't say the service is AI rather than a human (\"smart assistant,\" \"automated helper\")\n- For a mental health chatbot, skipping re-disclosure when the user returns after seven or more days without access", + "reason": "Replace 'one-time disclosure across sessions', which contradicts the seven-day rule, with the statutory failure modes; tie the privacy-policy item to the clear-and-conspicuous standard.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Failure modes under the anchored provisions.", + "exceptions": "Illustrative examples, not an exhaustive list.", + "time": "Enrolled 2025 text." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452-not-human", + "hb452-seven-days", + "sb226-regulated", + "sb226-verbal" + ] + }, + "section:Statute Anchors/text": { + "before_sha256": "bf4bbbe70ae4873d93465fd899ff7fdf9790c94e3611518059bdac15d2cce1ef", + "after_sha256": "068ad4c6619b0560ef75f744c29aa522c9c4d30877baed08b6c0ec05b2147dfd", + "candidate_content": "- Utah Code §13-75-103(1)-(3) — General GenAI disclosure (enacted by SB 226, 2025)\n- Utah Code §13-72a-203 — Mental-health chatbot disclosure (enacted by HB 452, 2025)", + "reason": "Name the enacting bill for each anchored section and include §13-75-103(2)-(3).", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Anchor citations.", + "exceptions": "Codified-section URLs not retained.", + "time": "Enrolled 2025 text." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb226-103", + "hb452-section" + ] + } + } + }, + "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md": { + "record_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "baseline_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", + "whole_record": { + "before_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", + "after_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf" + }, + "review": { + "actor_type": "human", + "actor": "Sam Rogers", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:36:37Z", + "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", + "human_approved": true, + "scope": "Human review and approval by Sam Rogers, attested in the Claude Code session on 2026-09-23, of source-consistency corrections prepared by an agent (Claude). Renews last_verified to 2026-09-23 on that basis. Agent preparation scope: Corrected open findings from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json for the ElizaChat RMA: high-risk sharing wording, stale legacy id, term-end locator note, extension and phase-history note, dead learning-lab link, and redirecting agreement-page URL, plus the modified date. Does not renew last_verified or legal currentness.", + "packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623" + }, + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "evidence": { + "home": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "8a86df5aec4d2c3cd1d7e1aec45577c61f12e04e0df11fec1cb6d1ef05e61062", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:40Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8" + }, + "document_id": "Utah OAIP AI home page", + "document_title": "AI Home", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy", + "document_type": "official agency home page", + "version": "server last-modified September 4, 2026; retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "Our Mission", + "excerpt": "The Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy is dedicated to regulating the bleeding edge of AI", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AI Home - commerce.utah.gov" + ] + }, + "pilot_page": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-ElizaChat-Pilot-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "03c4876823a2b18efa3f05f712b93434ef9dbdc9a5dab7750a52926869ae1e50", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-ElizaChat-Pilot-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:39Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", + "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8" + }, + "document_id": "Utah OAIP ElizaChat pilot page", + "document_title": "ElizaChat", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy", + "document_type": "official agency pilot page", + "version": "server last-modified May 15, 2026; retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "ElizaChat Agreement; How the Pilot Works", + "excerpt": "ElizaChat is authorized to conduct a phased rollout of its app in participating school districts", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AI Elizachat - commerce.utah.gov" + ] + }, + "register_term": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "b5a9c67706dcc149a860f46bbde7ccc3a53a9447fe9dbac50b686f90156a0780", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:39Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/", + "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8" + }, + "document_id": "Utah OAIP Authorized AI Pilots register", + "document_title": "Authorized AI Pilots", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy", + "document_type": "official agency pilot register page", + "version": "server last-modified September 3, 2026; retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "The Agreements: ElizaChat entry, Term", + "excerpt": "Term November 18, 2024 – November 18, 2025", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AI Authorized Pilots - commerce.utah.gov", + "This page is the public record of those agreements." + ] + }, + "agreement_high_risk": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/elizachat/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024-2026-09-24.ocr.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "72c8f0b1255dab74819cc133cc7dc1160c772ed39a2724439fd9b8c775dfc85b", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/elizachat/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024-2026-09-24.pdf", + "sha256": "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:39Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", + "content_type": "application/pdf" + }, + "document_id": "ElizaChat Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "Agreement between the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy, ElizaChat Inc., and the Division of Professional Licensing", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed November 14-18, 2024; OCR text of retrieved PDF", + "locator": "Schedule A Section XVI.A (PDF p.9)", + "excerpt": "Users who demonstrate high risk behavior, as determined by Participant, shall be promptly shared with", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE POLICY,", + "ELIZACHAT INC., AND THE DIVISION OF PROFESSIONAL LICENSING" + ] + }, + "agreement_term": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/elizachat/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024-2026-09-24.ocr.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "72c8f0b1255dab74819cc133cc7dc1160c772ed39a2724439fd9b8c775dfc85b", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/elizachat/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024-2026-09-24.pdf", + "sha256": "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:39Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", + "content_type": "application/pdf" + }, + "document_id": "ElizaChat Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "Agreement between the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy, ElizaChat Inc., and the Division of Professional Licensing", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed November 14-18, 2024; OCR text of retrieved PDF", + "locator": "Section II Effective Date and Demonstration Period (PDF p.1)", + "excerpt": "The demonstration period of this Agreement is for 12 months, beginning on the date this agreement is", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE POLICY,", + "ELIZACHAT INC., AND THE DIVISION OF PROFESSIONAL LICENSING" + ] + }, + "agreement_extension": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/elizachat/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024-2026-09-24.ocr.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "72c8f0b1255dab74819cc133cc7dc1160c772ed39a2724439fd9b8c775dfc85b", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/elizachat/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024-2026-09-24.pdf", + "sha256": "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:39Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", + "content_type": "application/pdf" + }, + "document_id": "ElizaChat Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "Agreement between the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy, ElizaChat Inc., and the Division of Professional Licensing", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed November 14-18, 2024; OCR text of retrieved PDF", + "locator": "Agreement Extension section (PDF p.6)", + "excerpt": "Participant may request a single extension of up to 12 months for regulatory mitigation no later than 30", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE POLICY,", + "ELIZACHAT INC., AND THE DIVISION OF PROFESSIONAL LICENSING" + ] + } + }, + "units": { + "metadata:issued_by": { + "before_sha256": "f589813d6705665132182b4c08e90f9dea0e85c4673afb508c63b60b119d3989", + "after_sha256": "e2623753f76da570a3196ac804ea809c75fe2b5d151deafae8be9365fd8c20f6", + "candidate_content": { + "@type": "https://w3id.org/semanticarts/ns/ontology/gist/SubCountryGovernment", + "name": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP)", + "ref": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/" + }, + "reason": "Replace the dead learning-lab link (HTTP 404) with the current official OAIP home page.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "issued_by.ref URL only.", + "exceptions": "The home page does not establish any term of this agreement.", + "time": "Home page retrieved 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "home" + ] + }, + "metadata:last_verified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Human reviewer renews verification after reviewing the corrected record against its retained sources.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Whole-record source-consistency review against the retained sources cited in this receipt.", + "exceptions": "Items listed as unresolved remain unverified; review does not certify legal currentness beyond the cited sources.", + "time": "Reviewed 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "home" + ] + }, + "metadata:modified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Record the date of this bounded source-consistency correction.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "This record edit only.", + "exceptions": "last_verified, Verified rows, status, and dates are unchanged; this does not renew legal currentness.", + "time": "Edit date 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_term" + ] + }, + "metadata:official_url": { + "before_sha256": "4416ab497b515d1fc36c0a0b292c6a7d5718129f8019c5cf4c4f2a49470b5532", + "after_sha256": "5dc6bd3499180b3bc97bb1b9b645acf349ec70f502967097079dff49043641f4", + "candidate_content": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", + "reason": "Use the final official pilot-page URL instead of the redirecting /ai/agreements/elizachat/ path.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Official landing-page URL only.", + "exceptions": "The page does not establish extension, termination, or current effect.", + "time": "Retrieved 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "pilot_page" + ] + }, + "section:Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)/text": { + "before_sha256": "7e22564bd1c59457398f8d1eb623d4b3d27acd1eb3b502b0408cbf60ea16a60e", + "after_sha256": "662e00c1b36c3f80be6ff99b6832b7d902cba9a52844a776d7cfbda4a124e05a", + "candidate_content": "- Approved testing plan designed to prevent the app from engaging in therapy or other licensed practice.\n- Immediate reporting to OAIP of any activity constituting a Schedule A incident, including the action, involved user(s), and any resulting harm.\n- 24-hour incident notification to OAIP for any harm to health, safety, or financial well-being.\n- High-risk users, as determined by the participant, promptly shared with ElizaChat's clinical team and emergency contacts; promptly connected to a licensed psychologist or therapist for real-time intervention (Schedule A §XVI.A).\n- School-district-specific limitations respected.\n- HIPAA-compliant anonymization and storage of user data.\n- Written parental consent before regular use by minors.\n- GenAI disclosure (§13-2-12(4)) with user acknowledgment.\n- Monthly reporting to ai@utah.gov: findings, complaints, impact analyses, technology assessments.", + "reason": "The agreement says high-risk users, as determined by Participant, are promptly shared; it has no automatic-sharing term.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "High-risk user sharing and connection duty in Section XVI.A.", + "exceptions": "Other obligation lines unchanged.", + "time": "Agreement signed November 2024." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_high_risk" + ] + }, + "section:PubLedge schema mapping/text": { + "before_sha256": "0ee2eb02561cbb478410744d13fc847582ff2030ae1926d1cc2a246e2339cc8e", + "after_sha256": "3a2c1f22e2599e03028e239e024f8d9934aa94284017a83dd1738fd314a8c6a4", + "candidate_content": "| Source element | PubLedge field |\n|---|---|\n| \"Agreement between OAIP, ElizaChat Inc., and DOPL\" | `title`, `name` |\n| Section I parties | `parties[]` |\n| Section II (12 months beginning on execution; no end date stated) and OAIP register term November 18, 2024 – November 18, 2025 | `term_start`, `term_end` |\n| Schedule A §XV incident-cure structure | `rules_mitigated[]` and `mitigations[]` (narrow cure window; immediate reporting; good-faith remediation and nonrecurrence efforts), `obligation_kind: permission` |\n| Section VI.H phased rollout | `mitigations[]` (Phase One commencement; written approval for subsequent phases), `obligation_kind: requirement` |\n| Section XVI.E parental consent | `mitigations[]`, `obligation_kind: requirement` |\n| Latter signature 2024-11-18 | `enacted`, `effective` |", + "reason": "Note that Section II states 12 months from execution without an end date, and that the OAIP register states the November 18, 2025 end.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "term_start and term_end mapping note only.", + "exceptions": "term_end value unchanged.", + "time": "Register retrieved 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_term", + "register_term" + ] + }, + "section:Limitations/text": { + "before_sha256": "d6e18def84ab6d38e127ce05962240ca7fd7dfc7cce73e850520e5c2f76b0fbf", + "after_sha256": "99c4c69791f88c8cd409e529acd6880a8fcb75b64adf13f84ce18366f8de1032", + "candidate_content": "- Pre-§13-77 instrument: references §13-2-12(4) for GenAI disclosure where later Utah RMAs reference §13-77-103.\n- Pre-§13-72a instrument: predates Utah's dedicated Mental Health Chatbot chapter; scope of the app vs. \"mental-health chatbot\" as later defined is not addressed here.\n- Pre-§13-72-401 renumbering: the Agreement cites only §13-72-302 (not the later §13-72-401 transitioning 2026-05-06).\n- Mitigation is event-triggered and time-bounded (30-day cure), not a blanket pre-authorization.\n- The Schedule A cure procedure's immediate incident report and Section VI.I.3's 24-hour harm report have different triggers and clocks.\n- Cure-period forbearance depends on good-faith efforts to follow the curing procedure; remediation and nonrecurrence are also good-faith-effort duties.\n- `status: expired` records the initial 12-month term end. OAIP's Authorized AI Pilots page, retrieved 2026-09-24 (UTC), lists ElizaChat as Expired with term November 18, 2024 – November 18, 2025. No retained source shows an extension request or decision under the Agreement Extension section, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.\n- Does not bar individual user, parent/guardian, or third-party claims.", + "reason": "State what the register shows and what no retained source shows about extension, termination, and phase approvals.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Expired-status limitation note.", + "exceptions": "No extension, termination, or phase history is asserted.", + "time": "Register retrieved 2026-09-24; agreement term November 18, 2024 to November 18, 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "register_term", + "agreement_extension" + ] + }, + "section:Sources/text": { + "before_sha256": "f343e06ce84406b2e4408e3edece3674c0bd6584ba5b65f83296040ffb0d4eca", + "after_sha256": "39eb3706bd5e5d919ceb978d2b5e80628d7dad0ecbc5029b3b444ebc5eaa7a18", + "candidate_content": "- [Pilot page — Utah OAIP](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/)\n- [Authorized AI Pilots — Utah OAIP](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/)\n- [Signed PDF](https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf)\n- [Source review receipt](https://github.com/snapsynapse/publedge/blob/main/ops/evidence/elizachat-source-review-2026-09-08.json)\n- [Utah Code Title 13, Chapter 72](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72/13-72.html)\n- [Utah Code §58-60 — Mental Health Professional Practice Act](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title58/Chapter60/58-60.html)", + "reason": "Replace the redirecting agreement-page link with the final pilot-page URL and add the OAIP register.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Source links only.", + "exceptions": "Links are not evidence of current legal effect.", + "time": "Retrieved 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "pilot_page", + "register_term" + ] + }, + "section:Notes on this demonstration remap/text": { + "before_sha256": "54c0b33635e4a1066282c6101104419c964efedb9d4056d153819f063e4d550f", + "after_sha256": "cbb8be8698f7a85404cfe53d00369e952ba20cf2149d136d165e8dc06884b115", + "candidate_content": "First RMA (`us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001`), earliest in the registry by `effective` date. Exercises schema features not covered by prior RMAs: (1) incident-triggered, time-bounded (30-day cure) mitigation rather than blanket pre-authorization; (2) phased-rollout structure as an explicit obligation; (3) reliance on the predecessor GenAI disclosure statute (§13-2-12(4)) rather than §13-77-103; (4) predates the §13-72a mental-health-chatbot chapter entirely — useful for demonstrating how earlier RMAs sit alongside later sector-specific rules in the same registry.", + "reason": "Replace the stale legacy id with the current record id.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Record id reference only.", + "exceptions": "No substantive change.", + "time": "Current id us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_term" + ] + } + } + }, + "data/examples/obligations/elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle.md": { + "record_sha256": "e449b7df832e2d80c45aac253c20e5502ba589defb7dbfafe479424158761207", + "baseline_sha256": "f64f5494465abe222b34894c969931ace7d9512886e328caac5e334f6faa4a4f", + "whole_record": { + "before_sha256": "f64f5494465abe222b34894c969931ace7d9512886e328caac5e334f6faa4a4f", + "after_sha256": "e449b7df832e2d80c45aac253c20e5502ba589defb7dbfafe479424158761207" + }, + "review": { + "actor_type": "agent", + "actor": "Claude source-consistency correction review", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:17:00Z", + "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", + "scope": "Removed the unverified claim that Utah Code 13-2-12(4) is now Chapter 75 post-SB 226, keeping the citation as the ElizaChat agreement states it, plus the modified date. Does not renew last_verified or legal currentness.", + "packet_sha256": "567d6db18f9afefffc5f88015f85ee6ba556464ad62d16cd0e0df759e8251814" + }, + "unresolved": [ + "The later statutory succession of Utah Code 13-2-12(4) was not verified in this review.", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ], + "evidence": { + "agreement_disclosure": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/elizachat/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024-2026-09-24.ocr.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "72c8f0b1255dab74819cc133cc7dc1160c772ed39a2724439fd9b8c775dfc85b", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/elizachat/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024-2026-09-24.pdf", + "sha256": "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:39Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", + "content_type": "application/pdf" + }, + "document_id": "ElizaChat Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "Agreement between the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy, ElizaChat Inc., and the Division of Professional Licensing", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed November 14-18, 2024; OCR text of retrieved PDF", + "locator": "Section VI.G.1.b (PDF p.4)", + "excerpt": "That the user is interacting with generative artificial intelligence pursuant to Utah Code §", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE POLICY,", + "ELIZACHAT INC., AND THE DIVISION OF PROFESSIONAL LICENSING" + ] + } + }, + "units": { + "section:What Counts/text": { + "before_sha256": "5cf01c4540c8001662154ca71486516166ed245c5bdc110c1d7d5a4da4e4bee3", + "after_sha256": "26be91fbc11ca2cb9bcacb07cc97f2cdcc82d11698785a1a593cbc6788ace17c", + "candidate_content": "- Participant name and contact information\n- Notice that the user is interacting with generative AI pursuant to Utah Code §13-2-12(4), as cited in the agreement\n- Notice that the app is in testing, may not function as intended, and may expose users to risks identified in the Testing Plan\n- Description of how user data and correspondence will be used and shared\n- OAIP complaint channel — phone number and/or website address provided by the Office\n- User acknowledgment obtained before any functional access", + "reason": "The agreement cites only Utah Code 13-2-12(4); the Chapter 75 succession claim is unverified.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "GenAI notice element citation.", + "exceptions": "No successor statute asserted.", + "time": "Agreement signed November 2024." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_disclosure" + ] + }, + "section:Statute Anchors/text": { + "before_sha256": "18a152543134f2d565aec73ba79f50513c24b3779f447a6bb2434daa3d009453", + "after_sha256": "94194ee1bbcffc63e1c6f25033aa07faf07f73395c9ac342591058f2d78e3878", + "candidate_content": "- Utah Code §13-2-12(4) (as cited in Section VI.G; later statutory succession not verified here)\n- Utah RMA 2024-001 Section VI.G — Disclosures to Users", + "reason": "Keep the citation as written in Section VI.G and flag succession as unverified.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Statute anchor note.", + "exceptions": "No successor statute asserted.", + "time": "Agreement signed November 2024." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_disclosure" + ] + }, + "metadata:modified": { + "before_sha256": null, + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Record the date of this bounded correction.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "This file edit only.", + "exceptions": "last_verified and lifecycle_status unchanged.", + "time": "Edit date 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_disclosure" + ] + } + } + }, + "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md": { + "record_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "baseline_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", + "whole_record": { + "before_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", + "after_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0" + }, + "review": { + "actor_type": "human", + "actor": "Sam Rogers", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:36:37Z", + "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", + "human_approved": true, + "scope": "Human review and approval by Sam Rogers, attested in the Claude Code session on 2026-09-23, of source-consistency corrections prepared by an agent (Claude). Renews last_verified to 2026-09-23 on that basis. Agent preparation scope: Corrected open findings from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json for the Legion Health RMA: cure-period wording, strict >98%/>99% phase gates, shortage-claim attribution, 16D versus 16E chapter lists, telehealth protocol locator, Proposal incident-notice target, dated register not-started observation, register insurance term absent from the agreement, stale legacy id, dead learning-lab and admin-rules links, and redirecting agreement-page URL, plus the modified date. Dates stay null and status stays enacted. Does not renew last_verified or legal currentness.", + "packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea" + }, + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "evidence": { + "home": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "8a86df5aec4d2c3cd1d7e1aec45577c61f12e04e0df11fec1cb6d1ef05e61062", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:40Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8" + }, + "document_id": "Utah OAIP AI home page", + "document_title": "AI Home", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy", + "document_type": "official agency home page", + "version": "server last-modified September 4, 2026; retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "Our Mission", + "excerpt": "The Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy is dedicated to regulating the bleeding edge of AI", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AI Home - commerce.utah.gov" + ] + }, + "pilot_page": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Legion-Pilot-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "49ac2253dcc9e2d989751a0b7a47a7fd2ca7ca4a85a71d8988af599f2fca4063", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Legion-Pilot-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:40Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", + "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8" + }, + "document_id": "Utah OAIP Legion Health pilot page", + "document_title": "Legion Health AI", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy", + "document_type": "official agency pilot page", + "version": "server last-modified May 15, 2026; retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "Legion Health AI Mitigation Agreement", + "excerpt": "Legion Health AI Mitigation Agreement", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AI Legion Health - commerce.utah.gov" + ] + }, + "register_not_started": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "b5a9c67706dcc149a860f46bbde7ccc3a53a9447fe9dbac50b686f90156a0780", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:39Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/", + "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8" + }, + "document_id": "Utah OAIP Authorized AI Pilots register", + "document_title": "Authorized AI Pilots", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy", + "document_type": "official agency pilot register page", + "version": "server last-modified September 3, 2026; retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "The Agreements: Legion Health entry, Term", + "excerpt": "Term The demonstration period has not started yet.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AI Authorized Pilots - commerce.utah.gov", + "This page is the public record of those agreements." + ] + }, + "register_insurance": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "b5a9c67706dcc149a860f46bbde7ccc3a53a9447fe9dbac50b686f90156a0780", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:39Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/", + "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8" + }, + "document_id": "Utah OAIP Authorized AI Pilots register", + "document_title": "Authorized AI Pilots", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy", + "document_type": "official agency pilot register page", + "version": "server last-modified September 3, 2026; retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "The Agreements: Legion Health entry, What the company agreed to", + "excerpt": "Malpractice insurance that covers AI related liability.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AI Authorized Pilots - commerce.utah.gov", + "This page is the public record of those agreements." + ] + }, + "agreement_commencement": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.ocr.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5b9403a371d62f6c0c2062d170d0f07f9b5932cd6b9f9634cb0c6e6efca38801", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.pdf", + "sha256": "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:38Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "content_type": "application/pdf" + }, + "document_id": "Legion Health Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "Agreement between the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy, Legion Health PA, Legion Health, Inc., and the Division of Professional Licensing", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed March 18-19, 2026; OCR text of retrieved PDF", + "locator": "Section 2.B (PDF p.1)", + "excerpt": "The Commencement Date shall be the date on which Participant delivers written notice to the", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "LEGION HEALTH PA, LEGION HEALTH, INC., AND THE DIVISION OF" + ] + }, + "agreement_cure": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.ocr.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5b9403a371d62f6c0c2062d170d0f07f9b5932cd6b9f9634cb0c6e6efca38801", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.pdf", + "sha256": "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:38Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "content_type": "application/pdf" + }, + "document_id": "Legion Health Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "Agreement between the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy, Legion Health PA, Legion Health, Inc., and the Division of Professional Licensing", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed March 18-19, 2026; OCR text of retrieved PDF", + "locator": "Section 6.J (PDF p.7)", + "excerpt": "Participant shall have at least thirty (30) business days, or a", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "LEGION HEALTH PA, LEGION HEALTH, INC., AND THE DIVISION OF" + ] + }, + "agreement_phase": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.ocr.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5b9403a371d62f6c0c2062d170d0f07f9b5932cd6b9f9634cb0c6e6efca38801", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.pdf", + "sha256": "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:38Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "content_type": "application/pdf" + }, + "document_id": "Legion Health Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "Agreement between the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy, Legion Health PA, Legion Health, Inc., and the Division of Professional Licensing", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed March 18-19, 2026; OCR text of retrieved PDF", + "locator": "Schedule B Proposal 4.3 (PDF p.18)", + "excerpt": "Proceed to Phase B if concordance >98%", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "LEGION HEALTH PA, LEGION HEALTH, INC., AND THE DIVISION OF" + ] + }, + "agreement_shortage": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.ocr.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5b9403a371d62f6c0c2062d170d0f07f9b5932cd6b9f9634cb0c6e6efca38801", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.pdf", + "sha256": "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:38Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "content_type": "application/pdf" + }, + "document_id": "Legion Health Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "Agreement between the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy, Legion Health PA, Legion Health, Inc., and the Division of Professional Licensing", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed March 18-19, 2026; OCR text of retrieved PDF", + "locator": "Schedule B Proposal 1.1 (PDF p.13)", + "excerpt": "All of Utah’s 29 counties have designated mental health shortages, and up to 500k", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "LEGION HEALTH PA, LEGION HEALTH, INC., AND THE DIVISION OF" + ] + }, + "agreement_16D": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.ocr.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5b9403a371d62f6c0c2062d170d0f07f9b5932cd6b9f9634cb0c6e6efca38801", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.pdf", + "sha256": "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:38Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "content_type": "application/pdf" + }, + "document_id": "Legion Health Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "Agreement between the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy, Legion Health PA, Legion Health, Inc., and the Division of Professional Licensing", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed March 18-19, 2026; OCR text of retrieved PDF", + "locator": "Schedule A Section 16.D.2 (PDF p.10; 58-31b confirmed on page image)", + "excerpt": "58-67-501-503, and 58-68-501-503, for unlawful or unprofessional", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "LEGION HEALTH PA, LEGION HEALTH, INC., AND THE DIVISION OF" + ] + }, + "agreement_16E": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.ocr.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5b9403a371d62f6c0c2062d170d0f07f9b5932cd6b9f9634cb0c6e6efca38801", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.pdf", + "sha256": "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:38Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "content_type": "application/pdf" + }, + "document_id": "Legion Health Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "Agreement between the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy, Legion Health PA, Legion Health, Inc., and the Division of Professional Licensing", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed March 18-19, 2026; OCR text of retrieved PDF", + "locator": "Schedule A Section 16.E.2 (PDF p.11)", + "excerpt": "58-31b-501-503, 58-60-109-111, 58-61-501-503, 58-67-501-503, 58-68-501-503, and", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "LEGION HEALTH PA, LEGION HEALTH, INC., AND THE DIVISION OF" + ] + }, + "agreement_telehealth": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.ocr.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5b9403a371d62f6c0c2062d170d0f07f9b5932cd6b9f9634cb0c6e6efca38801", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.pdf", + "sha256": "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:38Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "content_type": "application/pdf" + }, + "document_id": "Legion Health Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "Agreement between the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy, Legion Health PA, Legion Health, Inc., and the Division of Professional Licensing", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed March 18-19, 2026; OCR text of retrieved PDF", + "locator": "Schedule A Section 17.A.1-2 (PDF p.11)", + "excerpt": "subsection (2)(b) and (c) of such section, and not in violation of subsection (4) of such", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "LEGION HEALTH PA, LEGION HEALTH, INC., AND THE DIVISION OF" + ] + }, + "agreement_incident": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.ocr.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5b9403a371d62f6c0c2062d170d0f07f9b5932cd6b9f9634cb0c6e6efca38801", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.pdf", + "sha256": "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:38Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "content_type": "application/pdf" + }, + "document_id": "Legion Health Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "Agreement between the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy, Legion Health PA, Legion Health, Inc., and the Division of Professional Licensing", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed March 18-19, 2026; OCR text of retrieved PDF", + "locator": "Schedule B Proposal 5 (PDF p.19)", + "excerpt": "OAIP of defined pilot incidents within a bounded window after confirmation", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "LEGION HEALTH PA, LEGION HEALTH, INC., AND THE DIVISION OF" + ] + } + }, + "units": { + "metadata:issued_by": { + "before_sha256": "f589813d6705665132182b4c08e90f9dea0e85c4673afb508c63b60b119d3989", + "after_sha256": "e2623753f76da570a3196ac804ea809c75fe2b5d151deafae8be9365fd8c20f6", + "candidate_content": { + "@type": "https://w3id.org/semanticarts/ns/ontology/gist/SubCountryGovernment", + "name": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP)", + "ref": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/" + }, + "reason": "Replace the dead learning-lab link (HTTP 404) with the current official OAIP home page.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "issued_by.ref URL only.", + "exceptions": "The home page does not establish any term of this agreement.", + "time": "Home page retrieved 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "home" + ] + }, + "metadata:last_verified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Human reviewer renews verification after reviewing the corrected record against its retained sources.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Whole-record source-consistency review against the retained sources cited in this receipt.", + "exceptions": "Items listed as unresolved remain unverified; review does not certify legal currentness beyond the cited sources.", + "time": "Reviewed 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "home" + ] + }, + "metadata:mitigations": { + "before_sha256": "b617cbce227e48216eb8959cefeded4b0a1905cf07663402c3ed4ff1797a3da6", + "after_sha256": "872c0dcbad7ba23bbf3a9457207b6f33ca7ed5bbd0d1117728307bf413f0a6fe", + "candidate_content": [ + "Refills only for non-controlled, maintenance psychiatric medications on the Schedule B formulary (SSRIs, SNRIs, bupropion, trazodone ≤150mg, mirtazapine with metabolic monitoring, buspirone, hydroxyzine)", + "No new prescriptions, no dose changes, no switching or cross-taper", + "Excluded: controlled substances, benzodiazepines, antipsychotics, lithium/valproate, clozapine, anything requiring new labs/ECG", + "Stability gates: no recent dose changes; previously prescribed by a licensed provider; no psychiatric hospitalization or acute-safety events within 1 year", + "Max 10 automated refills between provider reviews, or 6 months, whichever is sooner", + "Identity verification via government ID + biometric/selfie matching", + "Escalation triggers: suicidality, severe adverse effects, mania indicators, pregnancy, human-review requests", + "Phased auditing: 250 pre-issuance reviews, advance if concordance >98%; 1,000 retrospective reviews, advance if concordance >99%; then ongoing periodic sampling (e.g., 5-10% monthly)", + "GenAI disclosure (§13-77-103 and §13-72a-203) + pharmacist disclosure that the renewal was AI-generated", + "Monthly reporting to ai@utah.gov with acceptance/denial counts, AI-vs-clinician agreement rates, complaints, adverse outcomes", + "At least 30 business days (longer if reasonably required) to propose and implement a cure for failure to meet a Section 6 obligation, before the Office may elect to terminate (Section 6J)" + ], + "reason": "Match the strict >98% and >99% concordance gates in Proposal 4.3 and the Section 6.J cure wording (at least 30 business days; Office may elect to terminate; no material-breach term).", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Phased-auditing and cure mitigations.", + "exceptions": "Other mitigations unchanged.", + "time": "Agreement signed March 18-19, 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_phase", + "agreement_cure" + ] + }, + "metadata:modified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Record the date of this bounded source-consistency correction.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "This record edit only.", + "exceptions": "last_verified, Verified rows, status, and dates are unchanged; this does not renew legal currentness.", + "time": "Edit date 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "register_not_started" + ] + }, + "metadata:official_url": { + "before_sha256": "bfb430360d025ffedccb5c9247a3108d4c0c4365ad1d0864d6e501ecb6c51c38", + "after_sha256": "4e11c70144f799f71cdb0709fc3fb0d8d7d0b0143c27070cdd2ff1c174d764c7", + "candidate_content": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", + "reason": "Use the final official pilot-page URL instead of the redirecting /ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/ path.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Official landing-page URL only.", + "exceptions": "The page does not establish commencement.", + "time": "Retrieved 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "pilot_page" + ] + }, + "metadata:rules_mitigated": { + "before_sha256": "9e9700f29aa78bd59c6e7cf83dc12c00047785fc29f60777edd4cf135a8caaa9", + "after_sha256": "c01a63bfc23a9edd8c9c6171df76ebac1292bb2b367cd6d15f01fd524831cb25", + "candidate_content": [ + "§58-1-501(1) and UAC R156-1-501(2)(b) — unlawful/unprofessional conduct for AI-authored psychiatric Rx renewal", + "§26B-4-704(6) and UAC R156-1-602 — telehealth-provider requirements", + "Unprofessional-conduct provisions across prescriber chapters: §16E (supporting services) covers §§58-31b-501-503, 58-60-109-111, 58-61-501-503, 58-67-501-503, 58-68-501-503, 58-70a-502-504; §16D (named prescribers) is limited to §§58-31b-501-503, 58-67-501-503, 58-68-501-503" + ], + "reason": "Qualify the chapter list: the full list is 16E (supporting services); 16D named prescribers get 58-31b, 58-67 and 58-68 only.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Chapter unprofessional-conduct entry.", + "exceptions": "Other rules_mitigated entries unchanged.", + "time": "Agreement signed March 18-19, 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_16D", + "agreement_16E" + ] + }, + "metadata:statute_anchors": { + "before_sha256": "7f6b776a65cd502c7154357fa6bd5f65b4c6f96dc3f392a634007730ae786196", + "after_sha256": "24062f8c4167cbaa4f24916d88ced879a375d2577a6d08fa75615c213feb0d4b", + "candidate_content": [ + { + "cite": "Utah Code §13-72-201", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72/13-72-S201.html" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah Code §13-72-302 (→ §13-72-401 effective 2026-05-06)", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72/13-72-S302.html" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah Code §13-72a (Mental Health Chatbot)", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72A/13-72a.html" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah Code §13-77-103 (GenAI disclosure)", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter77/13-77-S103.html" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah Code §58-17b (Pharmacy Practice Act)", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title58/Chapter17B/58-17b.html" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah Code §58-1-501", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title58/Chapter1/58-1-S501.html" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah Code §26B-4-704 (Telehealth)", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title26B/Chapter4/26B-4-S704.html" + }, + { + "cite": "UAC R156-1-501 / R156-1-602" + } + ], + "reason": "Remove the dead adminrules.utah.gov link (HTTP 404); keep the R156-1 citation text because no current URL is established by retained evidence.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "R156-1 anchor URL only.", + "exceptions": "Citation text unchanged.", + "time": "Link checked 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_16D" + ] + }, + "section:Background/text": { + "before_sha256": "9caff32df9b07f55cfc4e766022058ef7c646d93c3c166200f8fcef0ed593fcc", + "after_sha256": "0d32b68048b13608b11fbe06de809a5cee21cb3d991deada69ba68b3c5321c47", + "candidate_content": "Legion's proposal states that all 29 Utah counties have designated mental-health shortages and that up to 500,000 residents receive no behavioral health care. Legion Health, an AI-native psychiatry clinic, applied to the AI Learning Lab to automate refill authorization for maintenance psychiatric medications. Executed 2026-03-18 (OAIP Director Zachary Boyd) and 2026-03-19 (DOPL Director Mark Steinagel; Legion Health PA CEO Jonathan Kole M.D.; Legion Health, Inc. CEO Yash Patel). Effective date depends on Participant's written commencement notice (Section 2.B); term is 12 months from that commencement. The Agreement explicitly tracks the Utah Code §13-72-302 → §13-72-401 transition effective 2026-05-06.", + "reason": "Attribute the 29-county and 500,000-resident claim to Legion's proposal rather than to Utah.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Background shortage sentence.", + "exceptions": "The figures are a participant claim, not verified here.", + "time": "Proposal incorporated in the March 2026 agreement." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_shortage" + ] + }, + "section:Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)/text": { + "before_sha256": "48751cdaa4673547a6620941a11e83ffd876ed6703035decf15019f3a51635a3", + "after_sha256": "eaf492f0475331cd9db6b7ed0204fdf0814458f02687eac14dfd0a3c4681c272", + "candidate_content": "- Proposal-conforming methodology and protocols; amendments require signatures of all parties.\n- AI deemed compliant with §26B-4-704(2)(b)-(c) and (2)(e), and not in violation of (4), when it follows the protocols in Proposal section 4 (§17A.1-2); §26B-4-704(5) does not apply.\n- Portable electronic health records per §17B.\n- Compliance with Utah Code §13-72a (mental-health-chatbot requirements).\n- Disclosures per §13-77-103 and §13-72a-203 to users; additional disclosures to pharmacists that renewal was AI-generated.\n- Monthly reports with phased-audit benchmarks and adverse-event detail.\n- Proposal section 5 commits Legion to notify OAIP of defined pilot incidents within a bounded window after confirmation (target of 72 hours or less); the Agreement itself sets no incident-notification clock.\n- At least 30 business days (longer if reasonably required) to propose and implement a cure for failure to meet a Section 6 obligation, before the Office may elect to terminate (§6J).", + "reason": "Both 17.A.1 and 17.A.2 key compliance to Proposal section 4, and (4) is not-in-violation; add the Proposal 72-hour incident-notice target; restate the 6.J cure wording.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Telehealth, incident-notice, and cure lines.", + "exceptions": "The 72-hour figure is a Proposal target, not an agreement clock.", + "time": "Agreement signed March 18-19, 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_telehealth", + "agreement_incident", + "agreement_cure" + ] + }, + "section:Limitations/text": { + "before_sha256": "d28e4a3e7dc2e960f3f3d591a86b098d01382e2c1bc84eac287f95e5ef3a0121", + "after_sha256": "cec9597f42cb36fc75105f6aed65a794abf285596dafe390fa53064960c5dcf2", + "candidate_content": "- Effective date depends on Participant's commencement notice; `term_start`/`term_end` not computable from the signed document alone.\n- OAIP's Authorized AI Pilots page, retrieved 2026-09-24 (UTC), lists Legion Health as Approved and says \"The demonstration period has not started yet.\" No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the commencement notice, so `effective`, `term_start` and `term_end` remain null.\n- OAIP's register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability among Legion's commitments. No insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text; where that term is set out is unverified.\n- Does not cover new prescriptions, dose changes, switching, or cross-taper.\n- Does not cover controlled substances, benzodiazepines, antipsychotics, lithium/valproate, clozapine, or any medication requiring new labs or ECG for safe renewal.\n- Section 9 preserves IP; no transfer between parties.\n- Terminable at will (§11) under §13-72-302(7) / §13-72-401(8).", + "reason": "Add the dated register statement that the demonstration period has not started, and flag the register insurance term absent from the agreement.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Commencement and completeness notes.", + "exceptions": "Dates stay null; no Commencement Date or insurance term is asserted.", + "time": "Register retrieved 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "register_not_started", + "agreement_commencement", + "register_insurance" + ] + }, + "section:Sources/text": { + "before_sha256": "de074447d75e12c8ce280094f0933c092084bad4c0fd294e39397ac4c9613081", + "after_sha256": "875ae0cc302791c49a43a77ab2e06470f0208af03ea5c52633e22a7cdc10e9b7", + "candidate_content": "- [Pilot page — Utah OAIP](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/)\n- [Authorized AI Pilots — Utah OAIP](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/)\n- [Signed PDF](https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf)\n- [Utah Code Title 13, Chapter 72](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72/13-72.html)\n- [Utah Code Title 13, Chapter 72a — Mental Health Chatbot](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72A/13-72a.html)", + "reason": "Replace the redirecting agreement-page link with the final pilot-page URL and add the OAIP register.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Source links only.", + "exceptions": "Links are not evidence of commencement.", + "time": "Retrieved 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "pilot_page", + "register_not_started" + ] + }, + "section:Notes on this demonstration remap/text": { + "before_sha256": "fc6aaf55fc36bb3f824d051dd30e073ab46b3ffc085b88b734daa60d214b2c0b", + "after_sha256": "6091b67dd4871b99726142e99fcc61fadf68c5e6578d36b6dcad3eb1bfb84c22", + "candidate_content": "Fourth RMA (`us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001`). Exercises schema features not covered by earlier RMAs: (1) participant is a pair of affiliated legal entities; (2) effective date is a deferred Commencement Date not fixed at signature — the registry must represent `term_start: null`; (3) the agreement straddles a statute renumbering (§13-72-302 → §13-72-401 effective 2026-05-06) and carries both citations; (4) two-tier affiliated-provider forbearance (direct-prescriber vs. supporting-services) under one instrument.", + "reason": "Replace the stale legacy id with the current record id.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Record id reference only.", + "exceptions": "No substantive change.", + "time": "Current id us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001." + }, + "evidence": [ + "agreement_commencement" + ] + } + } + }, + "data/examples/obligations/telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.md": { + "record_sha256": "94a2bf8d07c1ef80630998be799cee2a47c2a9174e3daa33fb7299b79e149551", + "baseline_sha256": "9c48efe15d307aef5d471ed3f519cb58af70e2dcadfaa81b98f8ec49f3eb73a5", + "whole_record": { + "before_sha256": "9c48efe15d307aef5d471ed3f519cb58af70e2dcadfaa81b98f8ec49f3eb73a5", + "after_sha256": "94a2bf8d07c1ef80630998be799cee2a47c2a9174e3daa33fb7299b79e149551" + }, + "review": { + "actor_type": "agent", + "actor": "Claude source-consistency correction review", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:17:00Z", + "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", + "scope": "Corrected the telehealth protocol locators per agreement (Doctronic Parts 2B and 3B; Legion Proposal section 4 for both) and the subsection (4) not-in-violation wording, plus the modified date. Does not renew last_verified or legal currentness.", + "packet_sha256": "1310fbf27797da6fff4c35851151ae4515314be22eb50f876ae82212a3895657" + }, + "unresolved": [ + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ], + "evidence": { + "legion_telehealth": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.ocr.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5b9403a371d62f6c0c2062d170d0f07f9b5932cd6b9f9634cb0c6e6efca38801", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.pdf", + "sha256": "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:38Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "content_type": "application/pdf" + }, + "document_id": "Legion Health Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "Agreement between the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy, Legion Health PA, Legion Health, Inc., and the Division of Professional Licensing", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed March 18-19, 2026; OCR text of retrieved PDF", + "locator": "Schedule A Section 17.A.1-2 (PDF p.11)", + "excerpt": "subsection (2)(b) and (c) of such section, and not in violation of subsection (4) of such", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "LEGION HEALTH PA, LEGION HEALTH, INC., AND THE DIVISION OF" + ] + }, + "doctronic_telehealth": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5c3b3a54fd01a88472f6e28a1ae43d88e84f71534387e6c602f77169f8252044", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.pdf", + "sha256": "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", + "document_id": "Doctronic Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE POLICY, DOCTRONIC, LLC, AND THE DIVISION OF PROFESSIONAL LICENSING", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed October 23-24, 2025", + "locator": "Schedule A Section 16.A.1-2", + "excerpt": "nor in violation of subsection (4) of such section", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE" + ] + } + }, + "units": { + "section:Summary/text": { + "before_sha256": "7e1f3cd40b3c34aef683857b698b305a5d8d2214d49035274e48a5fd555a2f8c", + "after_sha256": "89d9efb32685c6d2f80cbf3a9190328b9e60dccfb96bedeec389ac9cdc08f3b6", + "candidate_content": "A participant operating AI-assisted prescription renewal must adhere to Utah's telehealth provider requirements in §26B-4-704, with specific subsections deemed satisfied by following protocols described in the participant's Proposal (Schedule B): Doctronic Parts 2B and 3B; Legion Proposal section 4. Certain subsections (e.g., the patient-records portability default) are inapplicable; others are substituted by Proposal-section conformance.", + "reason": "Name the Proposal protocols each agreement actually cites.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Protocol locators.", + "exceptions": "Other subsections unchanged.", + "time": "Doctronic signed October 2025; Legion signed March 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "legion_telehealth", + "doctronic_telehealth" + ] + }, + "section:What Counts/text": { + "before_sha256": "838c4803042d1ac0161891f253124115493bd382c29f36d7d19413aee3a9ad1c", + "after_sha256": "71d3daee268da9336a2338bb8a77e757b4958bfb6c4fbfc23eaef3336b09abb9", + "candidate_content": "- Adherence to §26B-4-704 as the baseline telehealth framework\n- Compliance with subsection (2)(b)-(c), and not being in violation of subsection (4), when the AI follows the Proposal protocols named in the agreement: Doctronic Part 2B (Patient Journey and Clinical Workflow); Legion Proposal section 4\n- Compliance with subsection (2)(e) when the AI follows the Proposal protocols named in the agreement: Doctronic Part 3B (Escalation Protocols); Legion Proposal section 4\n- Patient-records portability (where required by agreement, e.g., Legion §17(B)) through a portable format or user download/share option", + "reason": "Legion keys both 17.A.1 and 17.A.2 to Proposal section 4; Doctronic uses Parts 2B and 3B; subsection (4) is not-in-violation rather than compliance.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Telehealth substitution lines.", + "exceptions": "No other subsection is extended.", + "time": "Doctronic signed October 2025; Legion signed March 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "legion_telehealth", + "doctronic_telehealth" + ] + }, + "metadata:modified": { + "before_sha256": null, + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Record the date of this bounded correction.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "This file edit only.", + "exceptions": "last_verified and lifecycle_status unchanged.", + "time": "Edit date 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "legion_telehealth" + ] + } + } + }, + "data/examples/obligations/named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.md": { + "record_sha256": "7dc4b7ad687deab2b549477c9e6f9630e149d7276ad1b2a14e5792a23ad39a2e", + "baseline_sha256": "3efcdd6116bdcae121cc7aa3a01540886abcc8f1c02fd41381410d06eeae01b2", + "whole_record": { + "before_sha256": "3efcdd6116bdcae121cc7aa3a01540886abcc8f1c02fd41381410d06eeae01b2", + "after_sha256": "7dc4b7ad687deab2b549477c9e6f9630e149d7276ad1b2a14e5792a23ad39a2e" + }, + "review": { + "actor_type": "agent", + "actor": "Claude source-consistency correction review", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:17:00Z", + "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", + "scope": "Separated the Doctronic 15.D and Legion 16.D named-prescriber chapter lists and conditions instead of one merged list, plus the modified date. Does not renew last_verified or legal currentness.", + "packet_sha256": "a0c3843be94bb884536528046719eb207d6b40ff0e8ab6bb43e4c49a484dbf75" + }, + "unresolved": [ + "The Doctronic signed text cites 59-67-502 and 59-70a-503, which appear to be typographical errors for chapter 58 provisions; reproduced as written with [sic].", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ], + "evidence": { + "legion_16D": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.ocr.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5b9403a371d62f6c0c2062d170d0f07f9b5932cd6b9f9634cb0c6e6efca38801", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.pdf", + "sha256": "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:38Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "content_type": "application/pdf" + }, + "document_id": "Legion Health Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "Agreement between the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy, Legion Health PA, Legion Health, Inc., and the Division of Professional Licensing", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed March 18-19, 2026; OCR text of retrieved PDF", + "locator": "Schedule A Section 16.D.2 (PDF p.10; 58-31b confirmed on page image)", + "excerpt": "58-67-501-503, and 58-68-501-503, for unlawful or unprofessional", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "LEGION HEALTH PA, LEGION HEALTH, INC., AND THE DIVISION OF" + ] + }, + "legion_16D_condition": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.ocr.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5b9403a371d62f6c0c2062d170d0f07f9b5932cd6b9f9634cb0c6e6efca38801", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.pdf", + "sha256": "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:38Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "content_type": "application/pdf" + }, + "document_id": "Legion Health Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "Agreement between the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy, Legion Health PA, Legion Health, Inc., and the Division of Professional Licensing", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed March 18-19, 2026; OCR text of retrieved PDF", + "locator": "Schedule A Section 16.D (PDF p.10)", + "excerpt": "professional entity or provider employed or contracted by Participant who (1) abides by the", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "LEGION HEALTH PA, LEGION HEALTH, INC., AND THE DIVISION OF" + ] + }, + "legion_16E": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.ocr.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5b9403a371d62f6c0c2062d170d0f07f9b5932cd6b9f9634cb0c6e6efca38801", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.pdf", + "sha256": "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:38Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", + "content_type": "application/pdf" + }, + "document_id": "Legion Health Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "Agreement between the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy, Legion Health PA, Legion Health, Inc., and the Division of Professional Licensing", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed March 18-19, 2026; OCR text of retrieved PDF", + "locator": "Schedule A Section 16.E.2 (PDF p.11)", + "excerpt": "58-31b-501-503, 58-60-109-111, 58-61-501-503, 58-67-501-503, 58-68-501-503, and", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "LEGION HEALTH PA, LEGION HEALTH, INC., AND THE DIVISION OF" + ] + }, + "doctronic_15D": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5c3b3a54fd01a88472f6e28a1ae43d88e84f71534387e6c602f77169f8252044", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.pdf", + "sha256": "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", + "document_id": "Doctronic Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE POLICY, DOCTRONIC, LLC, AND THE DIVISION OF PROFESSIONAL LICENSING", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed October 23-24, 2025", + "locator": "Schedule A Section 15.D", + "excerpt": "contracted by Participant who (1) acts in reliance on Participant's artificial intelligence technology to", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE" + ] + }, + "doctronic_15D_cites": { + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5c3b3a54fd01a88472f6e28a1ae43d88e84f71534387e6c602f77169f8252044", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/doctronic/Doctronic-Final-Agreement-2026-09-09.pdf", + "sha256": "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", + "document_id": "Doctronic Regulatory Mitigation Agreement", + "document_title": "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE POLICY, DOCTRONIC, LLC, AND THE DIVISION OF PROFESSIONAL LICENSING", + "issuing_body": "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy and Utah Division of Professional Licensing", + "document_type": "signed agreement", + "version": "signed October 23-24, 2025", + "locator": "Schedule A Section 15.D.2", + "excerpt": "58-61-502, 59-67-502, 58-68-502, 59-70a-503, and 58-71-502.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "DRAFT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE" + ] + } + }, + "units": { + "section:Summary/text": { + "before_sha256": "1158ab4be7fa008745bdb665103eff87b2ea809159d2d406adaee56afd69030b", + "after_sha256": "d9580cdc4ba4ca6f14ee9b5fde1387bb10b22ea06b72ef90dcc08486086e7a78", + "candidate_content": "DOPL forgoes unlawful-conduct and unprofessional-conduct enforcement under §58-1-501(1)-(2) and related professional-licensing provisions against any provider who (1) acts solely as the named prescriber for AI-authorized renewals and (2) does not interact directly with a patient or other provider. Legion §16(D) adds a condition that the provider abides by the agreement and any agreement with the participant; Doctronic §15(D) states no such condition. The covered chapter provisions differ by agreement. Forbearance applies only to conduct authorized by the agreement.", + "reason": "Only Legion 16.D has the abides-by-terms condition; the chapter lists differ by agreement.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Named-prescriber conditions.", + "exceptions": "Supporting-services forbearance (Legion 16.E) is separate.", + "time": "Doctronic signed October 2025; Legion signed March 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "legion_16D_condition", + "doctronic_15D" + ] + }, + "section:What Counts/text": { + "before_sha256": "377afdbda2e5b8641b61b6d38852b7457dfa8f8edea372d69b2985277aa17cec", + "after_sha256": "34216b365e0f46c5bb630e19061412ff7b1aa85ff6087aaeac02ef285e4d2901", + "candidate_content": "- Provider's role is limited to being the named prescriber for AI-generated renewal\n- Provider does not interact directly with the patient or another provider in the renewal chain\n- Provider acts in reliance on the participant's AI technology\n- Provider abides by the terms of the RMA and any separate agreement with the participant (Legion §16(D) condition; not stated in Doctronic §15(D))\n- Doctronic §15(D)(2) chapter provisions, as written in the signed text: 58-31b-502, 58-60-110, 58-61-502, 59-67-502 [sic], 58-68-502, 59-70a-503 [sic], and 58-71-502\n- Legion §16(D)(2) chapter provisions: 58-31b-501-503, 58-67-501-503, and 58-68-501-503 (the broader list adding 58-60, 58-61 and 58-70a is in §16(E), which covers supporting-services providers, not named prescribers)", + "reason": "State each agreement's named-prescriber chapter list separately; 58-60, 58-61 and 58-70a are Legion 16.E only.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Chapter lists and conditions.", + "exceptions": "Doctronic cites reproduced as written with [sic].", + "time": "Doctronic signed October 2025; Legion signed March 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "legion_16D", + "legion_16E", + "legion_16D_condition", + "doctronic_15D_cites" + ] + }, + "section:Statute Anchors/text": { + "before_sha256": "1962e0966a5b67786e02a4573dcba0dc18094a3e1242088a3604c26fa1f3039c", + "after_sha256": "5391afa6c2a45a7c9a88c4a4061124f80ec2624921e63d1ce316ed31ebdd25a5", + "candidate_content": "- Utah Code §58-1-501(1) and (2) — Unlawful and unprofessional conduct baseline\n- UAC R156-1-501(2)(b) — Administrative rule\n- Utah RMAs 2025-002 (Doctronic) §15(D) and 2026-001 (Legion) §16(D) (supporting-services forbearance is separate, §16(E))", + "reason": "Anchor Legion to 16.D and note 16.E is separate supporting-services forbearance.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Anchor line.", + "exceptions": "No other anchors changed.", + "time": "Legion signed March 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "legion_16D", + "legion_16E" + ] + }, + "metadata:modified": { + "before_sha256": null, + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Record the date of this bounded correction.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "This file edit only.", + "exceptions": "last_verified and lifecycle_status unchanged.", + "time": "Edit date 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "legion_16D" + ] + } + } + }, + "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md": { + "record_sha256": "50b4e7a0685706064d5b50d211ba997047c14518a371a7ee1c859a4ccbe8e530", + "baseline_sha256": "7e4a5fbb8f032549b461c3d8840b09b6dfe91587e3b95cde0269b6a9bd69ac2c", + "whole_record": { + "before_sha256": "7e4a5fbb8f032549b461c3d8840b09b6dfe91587e3b95cde0269b6a9bd69ac2c", + "after_sha256": "50b4e7a0685706064d5b50d211ba997047c14518a371a7ee1c859a4ccbe8e530" + }, + "review": { + "actor_type": "human", + "actor": "Sam Rogers", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:36:37Z", + "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", + "human_approved": true, + "scope": "Human review and approval by Sam Rogers, attested in the Claude Code session on 2026-09-23, of source-consistency corrections prepared by an agent (Claude). Renews last_verified to 2026-09-23 on that basis. Agent preparation scope: Add SB 226 sponsors and its 63I-2-213 repeal-date amendment with the two-thirds effective-date alternative; narrow the safe-harbor scope to 13-75-103; replace the three 404 section anchor URLs with the chapter URL; relabel the report row as the SB 149 annual OAIP duty; drop the unsupported four-bill package note; mark introduction and signing rows unconfirmed; set modified. Agent source-consistency correction only; does not renew last_verified, Verified rows, legal status or legal currentness.", + "packet_sha256": "4ac77cfcca432ea01bcba7273922a36be25970b9c78729c8cd6241f6c3ee1733" + }, + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "evidence": { + "sb226_sponsors": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Enrolled copy p1 header", + "excerpt": "Chief Sponsor: Kirk A. Cullimore\n House Sponsor: Jefferson Moss", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + }, + "sb226_sections": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Utah Code Sections Affected, p1-2 lines 27-30", + "excerpt": "13-75-102 (Effective 05/07/25), Utah Code Annotated 1953\n29 13-75-103 (Effective 05/07/25), Utah Code Annotated 1953\n30 13-75-104 (Effective 05/07/25), Utah Code Annotated 1953", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + }, + "sb226_safe_harbor": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 4, Utah Code 13-75-104(1), p4 lines 118-119", + "excerpt": "(1) A person is not subject to an enforcement action for violating Section 13-75-103 if the", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + }, + "sb226_repeal": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 7, Utah Code 63I-2-213(5), p6 lines 181-182", + "excerpt": "(5) Title 13, Chapter 72, Artificial Intelligence Policy Act, is repealed [May 1, 2025] July 1,", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + }, + "sb226_effective": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 9, Effective Date, p6 lines 188-191", + "excerpt": "(a) except as provided in Subsection (2)(b), May 7, 2025; or\n191 (b) if approved by two-thirds of all members elected to each house:", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + }, + "sb226_civil": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 2, Utah Code 13-75-102, p3 lines 90-92", + "excerpt": "13-75-102 (Effective 05/07/25). Liability for violation of consumer protection law.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + }, + "sb149_report": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2024/bills/enrolled/SB0149.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "0a85408fb06d18d8a6fd3ce2db74c19e86c17c84d9c375daecb5a0b3eece8d86", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 149 (2024)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2024 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 5, Utah Code 13-70-201(3)(d), p14 line 465", + "excerpt": "(d) report annually, before November 30, to the Business and Labor Interim Committee", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AMENDMENTS" + ] + } + }, + "units": { + "metadata:last_verified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Human reviewer renews verification after reviewing the corrected record against its retained sources.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Whole-record source-consistency review against the retained sources cited in this receipt.", + "exceptions": "Items listed as unresolved remain unverified; review does not certify legal currentness beyond the cited sources.", + "time": "Reviewed 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb226_sponsors" + ] + }, + "metadata:modified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Record the date of this bounded source-backed correction without renewing legal currentness.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "This record edit only.", + "exceptions": "No last_verified, legal status or currentness renewal is accepted by this review.", + "time": "Correction reviewed September 24, 2026 UTC against retained sources." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb226_sponsors" + ] + }, + "metadata:statute_anchors": { + "before_sha256": "7d7ce0db7b4b15d9c30fb055cc2f0f49a11b3c2b8606c3e7ed26a13d16f4ab24", + "after_sha256": "8b9915dad1742faad90fee8eec2b1cbf86bec8454106ed23ddaec03b549bd5de", + "candidate_content": [ + { + "cite": "Utah Code Title 13, Chapter 75 (Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Act)", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter75/13-75.html" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah Code §13-75-102 (civil AI-assisted-violation liability)", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter75/13-75.html" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah Code §13-75-103 (disclosure requirements)", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter75/13-75.html" + }, + { + "cite": "Utah Code §13-75-104 (disclosure safe harbor)", + "url": "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter75/13-75.html" + } + ], + "reason": "Point the three section anchors at the Chapter 75 page because the section URLs returned 404; the cited sections are unchanged and appear in the enrolled bill.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Anchor URLs only; citations unchanged.", + "exceptions": "URL reachability is from the 2026-09-24 url_checks, not a retained snapshot.", + "time": "Checked 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb226_sections" + ] + }, + "section:Timeline/text": { + "before_sha256": "ea6e9ca331903aa90b963285665dbb6d83c213ab474e7bafa9387d490420dc2a", + "after_sha256": "29ccde23fabd81b5fc5a3fb6506de1a60c4d2d4d936ddc88e99dd122a66ceb24", + "candidate_content": "| Milestone | Date | Notes |\n|-----------|------|-------|\n| Introduced | 2025-02 | 2025 General Session (month unconfirmed: not in the enrolled copy) |\n| Governor Signed | 2025-03-25 | Unconfirmed: not in the enrolled copy; bill status page not retained |\n| Effective | 2025-05-07 | Chapter 75 and §13-2-12 repeal; the §63I-2-213 amendment took effect this date or on governor approval if passed by two-thirds of each house (vote not confirmed) |\n| Annual OAIP report due | 2025-11-30 | Before Nov 30, to Business & Labor Interim Committee; duty set by SB 149 (§13-70-201(3)(d)), not SB 226; filing history unverified |\n\n---", + "reason": "Replace the unsupported four-bill package note with the Chapter 75 effective date and the two-thirds alternative for the 63I-2-213 amendment; relabel the report row as the annual OAIP report due under SB 149; mark introduction and signing rows unconfirmed.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "SB 226 Timeline rows.", + "exceptions": "Signing, introduction, vote and report filing remain unverified.", + "time": "SB 226 effective May 7, 2025; SB 149 report duty from 2024." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb226_effective", + "sb149_report" + ] + }, + "section:Summary/text": { + "before_sha256": "ae7be6e41fc99ec5a55191378e9b874d2babd2e849ee081f3656cf2984da9915", + "after_sha256": "0e758e31d80f165f53b33e1db60de126783036dc96d69f8fcb3f76646e3f34be", + "candidate_content": "SB 226 relocated and narrowed Utah's generative AI disclosure framework. The original §13-2-12 disclosure requirement (enacted by SB 149 in 2024) was repealed and re-enacted as a new Chapter 75 with substantive changes:\n\n- **Narrower trigger.** The 2024 on-request standard was rewritten to require a consumer's \"clear and unambiguous\" request for AI disclosure (§13-75-103(1)).\n- **New safe harbor.** Providing a clear and conspicuous disclosure at the outset of consumer interactions, and throughout, eliminates enforcement exposure for violating §13-75-103 (§13-75-104).\n- **High-risk-occupation proactive tier.** For \"high-risk AI interactions\" (§13-75-101(5)) — sensitive data collection or personalized advice in finance, legal, medicine, or mental health — disclosure must be proactive: verbal at the start of oral exchanges, written before written exchanges (§13-75-103(2)-(3)).\n- **Civil AI-assisted-violation liability.** §13-75-102 codifies the civil mirror of §76-2-107: \"not a defense\" that GenAI made the violative statement or was used in furtherance of the violation.\n- **Chapter 72 repeal date.** SB 226 §7 also amended §63I-2-213(5) to move the Chapter 72 (Artificial Intelligence Policy Act) repeal date from May 1, 2025 to July 1, 2027, the same amendment SB 332 made. That amendment took effect May 7, 2025, or on governor approval if passed by two-thirds of each house; the vote is not confirmed here.", + "reason": "Narrow the safe harbor to 13-75-103 violations and add the 63I-2-213(5) repeal-date amendment with its special effective date.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Utah SB 226 enrolled provisions only.", + "exceptions": "Two-thirds vote not confirmed.", + "time": "SB 226 enrolled 2025; reviewed September 24, 2026 UTC." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb226_safe_harbor", + "sb226_repeal", + "sb226_effective", + "sb226_civil" + ] + }, + "metadata:sponsors": { + "before_sha256": null, + "after_sha256": "2532ac224784054772f614fa9a20df45da591a64dda335844da6985c798614cf", + "candidate_content": [ + "Sen. Kirk A. Cullimore (Senate sponsor)", + "Rep. Jefferson Moss (House floor sponsor)" + ], + "reason": "Add sponsors printed on the enrolled copy: Chief Sponsor Kirk A. Cullimore, House Sponsor Jefferson Moss.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Sponsor names and chamber roles from the enrolled header.", + "exceptions": "Format matches the SB 149 and SB 332 records.", + "time": "SB 226 enrolled 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb226_sponsors" + ] + } + } + }, + "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.md": { + "record_sha256": "bd4aa91c270b8033ecea8ff2cd6a4b7396df9b9e9ffdc9950d3bc69f10fe59b9", + "baseline_sha256": "9a1f758c218403901c5d9dcd442ebd4dff0118a7c713feeb24efdc0656e853d9", + "whole_record": { + "before_sha256": "9a1f758c218403901c5d9dcd442ebd4dff0118a7c713feeb24efdc0656e853d9", + "after_sha256": "bd4aa91c270b8033ecea8ff2cd6a4b7396df9b9e9ffdc9950d3bc69f10fe59b9" + }, + "review": { + "actor_type": "human", + "actor": "Sam Rogers", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:36:37Z", + "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", + "human_approved": true, + "scope": "Human review and approval by Sam Rogers, attested in the Claude Code session on 2026-09-23, of source-consistency corrections prepared by an agent (Claude). Renews last_verified to 2026-09-23 on that basis. Agent preparation scope: Replace the \"default\" effective-date note with the special effective-date clause and state that the two-thirds vote is not confirmed; mark legislative-history rows unconfirmed; qualify the exclusivity framing because SB 226 made the identical 63I-2-213(5) amendment; set modified. Agent source-consistency correction only; does not renew last_verified, Verified rows, legal status or legal currentness.", + "packet_sha256": "ad3c5755c52e64c6fba5d00117de2b57dba0291757f7084cc28f0b5641a1f09d" + }, + "unresolved": [ + "The effective field stays 2025-05-07. SB 332 took effect May 7, 2025, or on governor approval if passed by two-thirds of each house; the record votes (24-0-5, 74-0-1) would exceed two-thirds but are not confirmed against a retained status page.", + "enacted (2025-03-25) and all introduction, committee and floor-vote rows are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0332 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 332 amends 63I-2-213(5), the repeal date SB 149 set, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "evidence": { + "sb332_repeal": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0332.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb332/SB0332-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "2db8a28ce75c50fd5e19b4db5453a1d7b61e6c515243466ff4927e17c0d5cc0a", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb332/SB0332-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 332 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 332 Artificial Intelligence Revisions", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 1, Utah Code 63I-2-213(5), p2 lines 30-31", + "excerpt": "(5) Title 13, Chapter 72, Artificial Intelligence Policy Act, is repealed [May] July 1, [2025]", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Revisions" + ] + }, + "sb332_effective": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0332.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb332/SB0332-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "2db8a28ce75c50fd5e19b4db5453a1d7b61e6c515243466ff4927e17c0d5cc0a", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb332/SB0332-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 332 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 332 Artificial Intelligence Revisions", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 2, Effective Date, p2 lines 34-35", + "excerpt": "(1) except as provided in Subsection (2), May 7, 2025; or\n35 (2) if approved by two-thirds of all members elected to each house:", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Revisions" + ] + }, + "sb226_repeal": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 7, Utah Code 63I-2-213(5), p6 lines 181-182", + "excerpt": "(5) Title 13, Chapter 72, Artificial Intelligence Policy Act, is repealed [May 1, 2025] July 1,", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + } + }, + "units": { + "metadata:last_verified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Human reviewer renews verification after reviewing the corrected record against its retained sources.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Whole-record source-consistency review against the retained sources cited in this receipt.", + "exceptions": "Items listed as unresolved remain unverified; review does not certify legal currentness beyond the cited sources.", + "time": "Reviewed 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb332_repeal" + ] + }, + "metadata:modified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Record the date of this bounded source-backed correction without renewing legal currentness.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "This record edit only.", + "exceptions": "No last_verified, legal status or currentness renewal is accepted by this review.", + "time": "Correction reviewed September 24, 2026 UTC against retained sources." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb332_repeal" + ] + }, + "section:Timeline/text": { + "before_sha256": "c85bb9ce9f5c07403ed145d566b65b58d8f4eb264a19015ec136ea0885b2dc8a", + "after_sha256": "5a9b66be2d5dbeabf87ff709e7cd93e5583cdf42672c34f5480ced09f85a2cb0", + "candidate_content": "| Milestone | Date | Notes |\n|-----------|------|-------|\n| Introduced | 2025-02-24 | Senate Rules Committee (unconfirmed) |\n| Senate Business and Labor — favorable | 2025-02-26 | 7-0-1 (unconfirmed) |\n| Senate passed 3rd reading | 2025-03-03 | 24-0-5 (unconfirmed) |\n| House Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice — favorable | 2025-03-04 | 8-0-3 (unconfirmed) |\n| House passed | 2025-03-05 | 74-0-1 (unconfirmed) |\n| Governor Signed | 2025-03-25 | Gov. Cox (unconfirmed) |\n| Effective | 2025-05-07 | Special effective date (§2): May 7, 2025, or on governor approval if passed by two-thirds of each house; two-thirds vote not confirmed |\n| Chapter 72 sunset (post-amendment) | 2027-07-01 | Extended from 2025-05-01 (SB 226 §7 made the same amendment) |\n\n---", + "reason": "Replace the \"Default 2025 session effective date\" note with the bill's special effective-date clause, mark unconfirmed legislative-history rows, and note SB 226 made the same sunset amendment.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "SB 332 Timeline rows.", + "exceptions": "Vote counts, dates and the applicable effective date stay unconfirmed.", + "time": "SB 332 enrolled 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb332_effective", + "sb332_repeal", + "sb226_repeal" + ] + }, + "section:Summary/text": { + "before_sha256": "0eb6aab43c8d710b9f7a6208b8d3b5304bf541284c2364307b6f3b702f95d7c7", + "after_sha256": "43a6753dde85dc74d93cbe9f39e3484738da2404460cdd4de3cf12be8a93ac26", + "candidate_content": "SB 332 is a structural amendment to Utah Code §63I-2-213 (the state's legislative sunset registry). Its sole AI-relevant effect is to extend the repeal date of Title 13, Chapter 72 (the Artificial Intelligence Policy Act) from May 1, 2025 to July 1, 2027 — a 26-month extension of OAIP's statutory existence, the Artificial Intelligence Learning Laboratory, and the Regulatory Mitigation Agreement instrument as originally authorized by SB 149 (2024).\n\nThe bill introduced no new substantive obligations, no new disclosure duties, no new agency powers, and no new penalties. It is included in the PubLedge registry because it materially affects the reliance period of every Regulatory Mitigation Agreement, Joint Interpretation Agreement, and related authority artifact issued under Chapter 72. SB 226 (2025) §7 made the identical §63I-2-213(5) amendment in the same session, so SB 332 was one of two bills that moved the chapter's repeal date past 2025-05-01.\n\nThe bill took effect May 7, 2025, or, if approved by two-thirds of all members elected to each house, on governor approval (§2). The introduction, committee, floor-vote and signing entries in the Timeline are not shown in the enrolled copy and are not confirmed against a retained bill status page, so which effective date applied is not confirmed here.\n\nSubsequent amendments by HB 320 (2026) further restructured Chapter 72 (Learning Lab redesign, JIA instrument formalization, 36-month term ceiling) but did not further alter the sunset date set by SB 332 and SB 226.", + "reason": "Remove the \"without SB 332\" exclusivity claim because SB 226 made the identical amendment, and state the special effective-date alternative.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Utah SB 332 and SB 226 enrolled 63I-2-213 amendments.", + "exceptions": "Two-thirds vote not confirmed.", + "time": "Both enrolled 2025; reviewed September 24, 2026 UTC." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb332_repeal", + "sb332_effective", + "sb226_repeal" + ] + }, + "section:Summary/subsection:Talking Point/text": { + "before_sha256": "2514a67a7e6223f54c9e52841b0d1a30e5566634837ea950e568dc046b10d212", + "after_sha256": "009674c09e3884ecb654b96c4e0dcd4ec1f2d6f62adf70bb4e2ece999387e64f", + "candidate_content": "> \"Utah SB 332 (2025), together with the identical amendment in SB 226 (2025), moved the Artificial Intelligence Policy Act's repeal date from May 1, 2025 to July 1, 2027, a 26-month extension of the Office of AI Policy, the Learning Laboratory, and the Regulatory Mitigation Agreement framework.\"", + "reason": "Replace \"the statutory reason\" framing with a statement that SB 332 and SB 226 each moved the repeal date to July 1, 2027.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Talking Point only.", + "exceptions": "No claim about which bill was decisive.", + "time": "Both enrolled 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb332_repeal", + "sb226_repeal" + ] + } + } + }, + "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md": { + "record_sha256": "0602d5a250b66e24ed6f13779a1c055cc90a4f97b27249ef54d099a3e9eb9ad7", + "baseline_sha256": "8c4fba21742f0b6e177e6c4789075c6851acbcd3359335a24162d7f007393692", + "whole_record": { + "before_sha256": "8c4fba21742f0b6e177e6c4789075c6851acbcd3359335a24162d7f007393692", + "after_sha256": "0602d5a250b66e24ed6f13779a1c055cc90a4f97b27249ef54d099a3e9eb9ad7" + }, + "review": { + "actor_type": "human", + "actor": "Sam Rogers", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:36:37Z", + "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", + "human_approved": true, + "scope": "Human review and approval by Sam Rogers, attested in the Claude Code session on 2026-09-23, of source-consistency corrections prepared by an agent (Claude). Renews last_verified to 2026-09-23 on that basis. Agent preparation scope: Add the enrolled short title and sponsors; correct the prior term (12 months plus a single extension); reword the JIA bullet and Talking Point to the statutory \"clarifies the application\" definition without reliance language; add public education to counterparties; present eligibility prongs as carried over from SB 149 with source prong (c) wording; relabel the report row; mark introduction and signing rows unconfirmed; replace the dead OAIP Learning Lab link; set modified. Agent source-consistency correction only; does not renew last_verified, Verified rows, legal status or legal currentness.", + "packet_sha256": "b140f99a901d8f1e6f4bf389765fa85c72c5b7972a9ddf3f63132f56646e5da3" + }, + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "evidence": { + "hb320_title": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Enrolled copy p1 line 1 short title", + "excerpt": "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_sponsors": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Enrolled copy p1 header", + "excerpt": "Chief Sponsor: Paul A. Cutler\n Senate Sponsor: Kirk A. Cullimore", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_two_extensions": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 6, Utah Code 13-72-403(4), p8 lines 244-245", + "excerpt": "The office may grant up to two extensions for any regulatory mitigation or joint", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_single_struck": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 6, Utah Code 13-72-403(2), p8 line 238", + "excerpt": "(2) A participant may request a [single ]12-month [extension for participation in the", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "sb149_single_extension": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2024/bills/enrolled/SB0149.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "0a85408fb06d18d8a6fd3ce2db74c19e86c17c84d9c375daecb5a0b3eece8d86", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 149 (2024)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2024 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 10, Utah Code 13-70-305(2), p18 line 574", + "excerpt": "A participant may request a single 12-month extension for participation in the learning", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AMENDMENTS" + ] + }, + "hb320_jia_definition": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 1, Utah Code 13-72-101(12), p2-3 lines 60-62", + "excerpt": "(12) \"Joint interpretation agreement\" means an agreement between a participant, the office,", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_clarified": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 4, Utah Code 13-72-401(7), p6 lines 193-195", + "excerpt": "waived or modified by the terms of the regulatory mitigation agreement or clarified in a", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_mitigation_both": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 4, Utah Code 13-72-401(2), p6 lines 171-172", + "excerpt": "(2) The office may grant, on a temporary basis, regulatory mitigation to a participant by", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_governmental_entity": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 1, Utah Code 13-72-101(10), p2 lines 54-57", + "excerpt": "(b) a state-funded institution of higher education or public education; or", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_prong_c": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 5, Utah Code 13-72-402(1)(c), p7 lines 223-224", + "excerpt": "(c) the artificial intelligence technology provides potential substantial consumer benefits", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_renumbered_402": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Utah Code Sections Affected, p1 lines 26-27", + "excerpt": "13-72-402, (Renumbered from 13-72-303, as enacted by Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "sb149_prongs": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2024/bills/enrolled/SB0149.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "0a85408fb06d18d8a6fd3ce2db74c19e86c17c84d9c375daecb5a0b3eece8d86", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 149 (2024)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2024 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 8, Utah Code 13-70-303(1), p17 line 540", + "excerpt": "(1) To be eligible for regulatory mitigation, a participant shall demonstrate to the office that:", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AMENDMENTS" + ] + }, + "hb320_report": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 2, Utah Code 13-72-201(3)(d)(iii), p4 lines 115-116", + "excerpt": "(iii) any regulatory mitigation or joint interpretation agreements executed by the", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_effective": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 8, Effective Date, p8 line 250", + "excerpt": "This bill takes effect on May 6, 2026.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "oaip_home": { + "official_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "8a86df5aec4d2c3cd1d7e1aec45577c61f12e04e0df11fec1cb6d1ef05e61062", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.html", + "sha256": "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + }, + "acquisition": "primary_retrieval", + "retrieval": { + "http_status": 200, + "retrieved_at": "2026-09-24T02:10:40Z", + "final_url": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", + "redirects": 0, + "bytes": 132890, + "server_last_modified": "Fri, 04 Sep 2026 07:18:27 GMT" + }, + "document_id": "Utah OAIP home page", + "document_title": "AI Home - commerce.utah.gov", + "issuing_body": "Utah Department of Commerce, Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy", + "document_type": "official agency web page", + "version": "commerce.utah.gov/ai/ retrieved 2026-09-24", + "locator": "Page body, Our Mission paragraph", + "excerpt": "The Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy is dedicated to regulating the bleeding edge of AI.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "AI Home - commerce.utah.gov" + ] + } + }, + "units": { + "metadata:last_verified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Human reviewer renews verification after reviewing the corrected record against its retained sources.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Whole-record source-consistency review against the retained sources cited in this receipt.", + "exceptions": "Items listed as unresolved remain unverified; review does not certify legal currentness beyond the cited sources.", + "time": "Reviewed 2026-09-23." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb320_title" + ] + }, + "metadata:modified": { + "before_sha256": "e690a9db34a506022ddcf5d28c9159f07399430eedcb1db905f601ca73e1a743", + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Record the date of this bounded source-backed correction without renewing legal currentness.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "This record edit only.", + "exceptions": "No last_verified, legal status or currentness renewal is accepted by this review.", + "time": "Correction reviewed September 24, 2026 UTC against retained sources." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb320_title" + ] + }, + "metadata:title": { + "before_sha256": "3bcb2823b2b5e336859c2e82aba22563cd63648bd7df6765d91053708ab65124", + "after_sha256": "29a1eae32bc4a09a6ae946715a25fbc0c8064a77e42ce46f7c62b19877ddaf34", + "candidate_content": "Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements)", + "reason": "Lead the title with the enrolled short title and keep the descriptive subtitle in parentheses.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Record title only.", + "exceptions": "Slug and id unchanged.", + "time": "HB 320 enrolled 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb320_title" + ] + }, + "section:Timeline/text": { + "before_sha256": "ea5e522d5f83fea24f5ade17e63016af9b278456673caf5eb125cd6fe846c4dd", + "after_sha256": "07d2e108165f8be8ad51b84a472a912f28eeee9423777d9fe7b73bc87d329b14", + "candidate_content": "| Milestone | Date | Notes |\n|-----------|------|-------|\n| Introduced | 2026-01 | 2026 General Session (month unconfirmed: not in the enrolled copy) |\n| Governor Signed | 2026-03-19 | Unconfirmed: not in the enrolled copy; bill status page not retained |\n| Effective | 2026-05-06 | Chapter 72 restructured; JIA instrument live |\n| Annual OAIP report due | 2026-11-30 | Before Nov 30; first due date after HB 320 added executed RMAs and JIAs to the report (§13-72-201(3)(d)(iii)); filing history unverified |\n\n---", + "reason": "Relabel the report row as the annual OAIP report due before Nov 30, 2026, the first due date after HB 320 added executed agreements to the report, and mark introduction and signing rows unconfirmed.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "HB 320 Timeline rows.", + "exceptions": "Report filing history and signing and introduction dates remain unverified.", + "time": "HB 320 effective May 6, 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb320_report", + "hb320_effective" + ] + }, + "section:Summary/text": { + "before_sha256": "1ca5176cf107a722ef1e076b745b3e7800b7cfe5bc5bc0263f334ca34c79cbc3", + "after_sha256": "09e17cf4ac0ca98715c305e7d07b505c3b0554a87a0e6655edcf2bf5703b713a", + "candidate_content": "HB 320 substantially restructured Chapter 72 (the Utah AI Policy Act) and introduced a second instrument type — the Joint Interpretation Agreement (JIA) — alongside the existing Regulatory Mitigation Agreement (RMA). Key changes:\n\n- **Joint Interpretation Agreement (JIA) instrument.** A JIA is an agreement between a participant, OAIP, and a relevant agency or governmental entity that clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule to AI technology (§13-72-101(12)). Unlike an RMA, which may waive or modify requirements, a JIA leaves the clarified requirements in force (§13-72-401(7)). The statute presents both agreements as ways OAIP may grant temporary regulatory mitigation (§13-72-401(2)) and does not describe reliance on a JIA.\n- **Expanded counterparties.** Agreements may now involve the judiciary, state-funded higher or public education institutions, and political subdivisions — not only executive-branch agencies (§13-72-101(10), §13-72-401).\n- **Extended term.** The maximum agreement term was extended from 12 months plus a single 12-month extension (24 months) to 12 months plus up to two 12-month extensions — up to 36 months total (§13-72-403).\n- **Mandatory audits.** OAIP \"shall perform regular audits\" while an agreement is active (§13-72-401(6)).\n- **Eligibility prongs carried over and extended to JIAs.** The five prongs SB 149 enacted for regulatory mitigation now apply to both RMAs and JIAs: technical expertise and capability, financial resources to meet obligations during testing, potential substantial consumer benefits that may outweigh identified risks, a risk-monitoring plan, and appropriately limited testing (§13-72-402). HB 320 renumbered them and broadened prong (a) to cover implementing and using or supervising use.\n\nThe restructure formalizes Utah's two-instrument architecture — RMA (waiver) and JIA (interpretation) — that PubLedge uses as the prototypical pattern for fact-specific written interpretations between a regulator and a regulated party.", + "reason": "Correct the prior term ceiling, align the JIA description, counterparties and prong (c) wording to the enrolled text, and present the eligibility prongs as carried over from SB 149.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Utah HB 320 enrolled provisions compared with SB 149.", + "exceptions": "Closing PubLedge interpretation paragraph not changed; reliance characterization left to a human editor.", + "time": "HB 320 enrolled 2026; SB 149 2024; reviewed September 24, 2026 UTC." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb320_two_extensions", + "hb320_single_struck", + "sb149_single_extension", + "hb320_jia_definition", + "hb320_clarified", + "hb320_mitigation_both", + "hb320_governmental_entity", + "hb320_prong_c", + "hb320_renumbered_402", + "sb149_prongs" + ] + }, + "section:Summary/subsection:Talking Point/text": { + "before_sha256": "ade3c964b21c57e3018355d8318f9c3bb8d2e478a5217b3a3f95b975b1f9deb4", + "after_sha256": "1ddd093ec7bfa102a90b8ca4b2e28ffecf761d6798822cc229b34f5d627f15b7", + "candidate_content": "> \"Utah HB 320 (2026) gave Utah's Office of AI Policy a second instrument: the Joint Interpretation Agreement — an agreement that clarifies how existing state law or rule applies to AI technology, without the law being waived. That two-instrument architecture (waiver + interpretation) is the pattern PubLedge formalizes for the cross-jurisdictional registry.\"", + "reason": "Replace \"parties may rely on\" with the statutory clarification wording.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Talking Point only.", + "exceptions": "No reliance claim is made.", + "time": "HB 320 enrolled 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb320_jia_definition", + "hb320_clarified" + ] + }, + "section:Summary/subsection:Sources/text": { + "before_sha256": "97e93d0df62dfe2744a3f74b590d9691bd46d2b3f856689c130d9df61de61401", + "after_sha256": "c76a49a1fd5a98c9b04c787861c4294826c7b0970db9e5850149c00975a6f02f", + "candidate_content": "- [HB 320 Bill Text](https://le.utah.gov/~2026/bills/static/HB0320.html)\n- [EveryAILaw — RMA/JIA Learning Lab](https://everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149/#regulatory-mitigation-and-joint-interpretation-agreements)\n- [Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/)", + "reason": "Replace the dead OAIP Learning Lab link with the official OAIP home page that returned HTTP 200.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Sources link list only.", + "exceptions": "Does not assert a current Learning Lab page exists.", + "time": "OAIP home page retrieved 2026-09-24." + }, + "evidence": [ + "oaip_home" + ] + }, + "metadata:sponsors": { + "before_sha256": null, + "after_sha256": "469d1011ad37eeb9d59142694a87c6edfdc136c92fef8d984d981fcc130a626b", + "candidate_content": [ + "Rep. Paul A. Cutler (House sponsor)", + "Sen. Kirk A. Cullimore (Senate floor sponsor)" + ], + "reason": "Add sponsors printed on the enrolled copy: Chief Sponsor Paul A. Cutler, Senate Sponsor Kirk A. Cullimore.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Sponsor names and chamber roles from the enrolled header.", + "exceptions": "Rep./Sen. honorifics follow the chamber roles shown on the enrolled copy.", + "time": "HB 320 enrolled 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb320_sponsors" + ] + } + } + }, + "data/examples/obligations/chatbot-safety-policy-filing.md": { + "record_sha256": "ba1facfe4b4274c2be9551a415246ce1ce26893555011114157835277c98fcb9", + "baseline_sha256": "3e34be05b6bd18616f0fbfe450bcf9599ffd9d02386ba84fd27f5aa9172d2cee", + "whole_record": { + "before_sha256": "3e34be05b6bd18616f0fbfe450bcf9599ffd9d02386ba84fd27f5aa9172d2cee", + "after_sha256": "ba1facfe4b4274c2be9551a415246ce1ce26893555011114157835277c98fcb9" + }, + "review": { + "actor_type": "agent", + "actor": "Claude source-consistency correction review", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:20:00Z", + "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", + "scope": "Reframe the obligation as the conditions of the 58-60-118 affirmative defense rather than a mandatory filing, list the fifteen 3(c) procedure elements as enacted, separate the (2)(b) documentation condition, and correct the fee wording; set modified. Agent source-consistency correction only; does not renew last_verified, Verified rows, legal status or legal currentness.", + "packet_sha256": "16858b62701ee470ac7ee01bf9a0ff90f302fca04242dacd946f2ba09ee4ec18" + }, + "unresolved": [ + "The record name (\"File 15-Element Safety Policy\"), group (requirement) and @type Requirement still frame the item as a requirement; the statute makes the policy a condition of an affirmative defense. These schema-level fields were left for a human decision.", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ], + "evidence": { + "hb452_defense": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 8, Utah Code 58-60-118(2), p8 lines 230-231", + "excerpt": "(2) It is an affirmative defense to liability in an action brought under Subsection 58-1-501(1)", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_defense_docs": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 8, Utah Code 58-60-118(2)(b), p8 lines 234-240", + "excerpt": "(b) maintains documentation regarding the development and implementation of the", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_policy_elements": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 8, Utah Code 58-60-118(3)(c), p8 line 248", + "excerpt": "(c) describe the procedures by which the supplier:", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_element_xv": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 8, Utah Code 58-60-118(3)(c)(xv), p9 lines 275-278", + "excerpt": "(xv) ensures compliance with the security and privacy provisions of 45 C.F.R. Part", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb452_fee": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0452.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "1223a7bd0156baa3d35ce2f93e71df811de442c5e12e4535caceb332595db481", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb452/HB0452-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 452 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 452 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 8, Utah Code 58-60-118(4)(a)(iv) and (5)(b), p9 lines 285, 293", + "excerpt": "(b) may impose an annual filing fee set in accordance with Section 63J-1-504.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Amendments" + ] + } + }, + "units": { + "section:Summary/text": { + "before_sha256": "2cbb644f6ff6441a2b79fa630deb49f3f68084741a8b6ad9677cae361cc0bad0", + "after_sha256": "e220936fef9c88b8a2b3f6531d9fdbdf06d14ff1a1b99b1c72dcd3e033389794", + "candidate_content": "Filing is a condition of an affirmative defense, not a free-standing mandate. A mental health chatbot supplier has an affirmative defense against §58-1-501(1)-(2) unauthorized-practice actions if it shows that it created, maintained, and implemented a written policy meeting §58-60-118(3), including the fifteen procedure elements in (3)(c)(i)-(xv); maintains the development and implementation documentation required by (2)(b); filed the policy with Utah's Division of Consumer Protection; and complied with the filed policy at the time of the alleged violation.", + "reason": "State that filing and the other elements are conditions of the 58-60-118(2) affirmative defense, not a free-standing mandate.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Utah Code 58-60-118 as enacted by HB 452.", + "exceptions": "Name, group and type left unchanged.", + "time": "HB 452 effective May 7, 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452_defense", + "hb452_defense_docs", + "hb452_policy_elements" + ] + }, + "section:What Counts/text": { + "before_sha256": "c61fd689f4448586f8b6472d94b9b18b485bf1a2401a544154e64d75ecdb14e3", + "after_sha256": "83b0c6d053b43e52a8e8b29432189e85aa6ba21be20860b4c80dbc3faf989b2f", + "candidate_content": "- Written policy stating the chatbot's intended purposes, abilities, and limitations and describing all fifteen procedure elements in §58-60-118(3)(c) (therapist involvement, clinical best practices, pre-release and ongoing testing, foreseeable-harm identification, user reporting, risk-of-harm protocols, mitigation actions, real-time acute-risk protocols, regular safety reviews, safe-use instructions, AI-awareness, purpose and limitation awareness, safety over engagement or profit, non-discrimination, and HIPAA and consumer-protection compliance)\n- Separate documentation of foundation models, training data, federal health privacy compliance, user data practices, and accuracy, reliability, fairness, and safety efforts (§58-60-118(2)(b))\n- Policy filed with the Utah Division of Consumer Protection along with the required fee (the division may also impose an annual filing fee)\n- Operational conformance to the filed policy at the time of the challenged conduct", + "reason": "List the fifteen 3(c) procedure elements as enacted, separate the (2)(b) documentation condition, and correct the filing fee wording.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Utah Code 58-60-118(2)-(5).", + "exceptions": "Element labels are paraphrased summaries.", + "time": "HB 452 effective May 7, 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452_policy_elements", + "hb452_element_xv", + "hb452_defense_docs", + "hb452_fee" + ] + }, + "metadata:modified": { + "before_sha256": null, + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Record the date of this bounded source-backed correction without renewing legal currentness.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "This record edit only.", + "exceptions": "No last_verified, legal status or currentness renewal is accepted by this review.", + "time": "Correction reviewed September 24, 2026 UTC against retained sources." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb452_defense" + ] + } + } + }, + "data/examples/obligations/ai-defense-elimination.md": { + "record_sha256": "cfe3ca3e3ecabd66a2fae7c5efe481ad10b4a14f6ffb251c26b2e0ae99f45e26", + "baseline_sha256": "0950aebbe08e66dce2babf56a5ea6f3671fbb8595b6c91b82ef2d4ad66a97d19", + "whole_record": { + "before_sha256": "0950aebbe08e66dce2babf56a5ea6f3671fbb8595b6c91b82ef2d4ad66a97d19", + "after_sha256": "cfe3ca3e3ecabd66a2fae7c5efe481ad10b4a14f6ffb251c26b2e0ae99f45e26" + }, + "review": { + "actor_type": "agent", + "actor": "Claude source-consistency correction review", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:20:00Z", + "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", + "scope": "Note that the civil not-a-defense rule originated at 13-2-12(2) in SB 149 (effective 2024-05-01) and was re-sited at 13-75-102 by SB 226; set modified. Agent source-consistency correction only; does not renew last_verified, Verified rows, legal status or legal currentness.", + "packet_sha256": "d55ff8b00852b7a4a493871057a1dc3b033c434c83fef2eea19d1295f5a9cd8c" + }, + "unresolved": [ + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ], + "evidence": { + "sb149_civil": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2024/bills/enrolled/SB0149.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "0a85408fb06d18d8a6fd3ce2db74c19e86c17c84d9c375daecb5a0b3eece8d86", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 149 (2024)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2024 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 1, Utah Code 13-2-12(2), p3 lines 65-66", + "excerpt": "(2) It is not a defense to the violation of any statute administered and enforced by the\n66 division, as described in Section 13-2-1, that generative artificial intelligence:", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AMENDMENTS" + ] + }, + "sb149_effective": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2024/bills/enrolled/SB0149.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "0a85408fb06d18d8a6fd3ce2db74c19e86c17c84d9c375daecb5a0b3eece8d86", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 149 (2024)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2024 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 13, Effective date, p18 line 593", + "excerpt": "This bill takes effect on May 1, 2024.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AMENDMENTS" + ] + }, + "sb226_civil": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 2, Utah Code 13-75-102, p3 lines 90-92", + "excerpt": "13-75-102 (Effective 05/07/25). Liability for violation of consumer protection law.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + }, + "sb226_repealer": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0226.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "088cb7315787b8f1a2c999ab3cdf9527b10eae034d032c7912ad6530441f08d7", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-sb226/SB0226-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah SB 226 (2025)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy S.B. 226 Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2025 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 8, Repealer, p6 lines 183-186", + "excerpt": "Section 13-2-12, Generative artificial intelligence -- Impact on liability for violation of", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments" + ] + } + }, + "units": { + "section:Summary/text": { + "before_sha256": "a4da981146eaccac8a7b3b62e8d02d2d13e02a419ff83b59ce8a3614f20358c0", + "after_sha256": "13af5451800cf13bca0f44be568ed2b6193646244a8f49ed37958a391408cfb3", + "candidate_content": "Utah removed \"the AI did it\" as a defense in both civil and criminal contexts. A principal who uses, prompts, or acts through generative AI remains liable for the resulting statement or act. The criminal rule (§76-2-107, SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and the civil mirror together eliminate the doctrine across Utah consumer-protection and criminal law. The civil rule was first enacted at §13-2-12(2) (SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and re-sited at §13-75-102 (SB 226, effective 2025-05-07).", + "reason": "Add the civil rule's 2024 origin at 13-2-12(2) and its 2025 move to 13-75-102.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Utah SB 149 and SB 226 enrolled provisions.", + "exceptions": "Other Summary statements not re-reviewed.", + "time": "SB 149 effective 2024-05-01; SB 226 effective 2025-05-07." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb149_civil", + "sb149_effective", + "sb226_civil", + "sb226_repealer" + ] + }, + "section:Statute Anchors/text": { + "before_sha256": "6bc833b9e954caf769b4b7703397bb5b2f12f9b31285abada6481e54f8a88e14", + "after_sha256": "8bec2485e084d9df9509f75300789dcf9c31781625e61af31a9ba918e82174cd", + "candidate_content": "- Utah Code §13-75-102 — Civil AI-as-defense elimination (SB 226, 2025; formerly §13-2-12(2), SB 149, 2024)\n- Utah Code §76-2-107 — Criminal AI-as-defense / intentional prompting (SB 149, 2024)", + "reason": "Note the former 13-2-12(2) location on the 13-75-102 anchor.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Statute Anchors list only.", + "exceptions": "None.", + "time": "SB 149 2024; SB 226 2025." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb149_civil", + "sb226_civil" + ] + }, + "metadata:modified": { + "before_sha256": null, + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Record the date of this bounded source-backed correction without renewing legal currentness.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "This record edit only.", + "exceptions": "No last_verified, legal status or currentness renewal is accepted by this review.", + "time": "Correction reviewed September 24, 2026 UTC against retained sources." + }, + "evidence": [ + "sb226_civil" + ] + } + } + }, + "data/examples/obligations/learning-lab-agreement-participation.md": { + "record_sha256": "649cf9611b65c4fd518106a4ce461906db0953381bb5b342dc92b1bd149bfae3", + "baseline_sha256": "cedc5a7a4518542affc3c7518e31fc80696614382ab1ee3f976d1a8368ffd633", + "whole_record": { + "before_sha256": "cedc5a7a4518542affc3c7518e31fc80696614382ab1ee3f976d1a8368ffd633", + "after_sha256": "649cf9611b65c4fd518106a4ce461906db0953381bb5b342dc92b1bd149bfae3" + }, + "review": { + "actor_type": "agent", + "actor": "Claude source-consistency correction review", + "reviewed_at": "2026-09-24T02:20:00Z", + "decision": "source-consistency-reviewed", + "scope": "Align financial-resources, consumer-benefit, audit/reporting and removal items to HB 320 wording, move the Nov 30 report out of participant duties, add public education to counterparties, and correct the 13-72-301 anchor label; set modified. Agent source-consistency correction only; does not renew last_verified, Verified rows, legal status or legal currentness.", + "packet_sha256": "342fac2ddf576b7837c36901ef92ee9abfa96c0e6b3d6bd8459a87b57058c8b6" + }, + "unresolved": [ + "Prongs (a), (d) and (e) in What Counts remain paraphrases and were not re-worded; \"limited to the statute, use case, and deployment period\" is not statutory wording for prong (e) (scale, scope, and duration of testing limited based on risk assessments).", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ], + "evidence": { + "hb320_financial": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 5, Utah Code 13-72-402(1)(b), p7 line 222", + "excerpt": "(b) the participant has sufficient financial resources to meet obligations during testing;", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_prong_c": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 5, Utah Code 13-72-402(1)(c), p7 lines 223-224", + "excerpt": "(c) the artificial intelligence technology provides potential substantial consumer benefits", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_audits": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 4, Utah Code 13-72-401(6), p6 lines 190-192", + "excerpt": "(6) The office shall perform regular audits of a participant's application of artificial", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_audit_reporting": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 4, Utah Code 13-72-401(4)(e), p6 line 187", + "excerpt": "(e) reporting requirements to comply with audits from the office.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_office_report": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 2, Utah Code 13-72-201(3)(d), p4 line 111", + "excerpt": "(d) report annually, before November 30, to the Business and Labor Interim Committee", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_removal": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 4, Utah Code 13-72-401(8)(b), p6-7 lines 200-204", + "excerpt": "be immediately removed from further participation and subject to all applicable civil", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_learning_lab_301": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 3, Utah Code 13-72-301, p4 line 121", + "excerpt": "13-72-301 . Artificial Intelligence Learning Laboratory Program.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_jia_401": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 4, Utah Code 13-72-401 heading, p6 lines 165-166", + "excerpt": "[13-72-302] 13-72-401 . Regulatory mitigation agreements and joint\n166 interpretation agreements.", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + }, + "hb320_governmental_entity": { + "official_url": "https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0320.pdf", + "snapshot_path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.txt", + "snapshot_sha256": "5887b8a936ee0f8c13ceafc678cf0467464b7609841870c0cf3f613f0b5b8310", + "original": { + "path": "data/admission/sources/utah-hb320/HB0320-enrolled.pdf", + "sha256": "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + }, + "acquisition": "retained_snapshot", + "document_id": "Utah HB 320 (2026)", + "document_title": "Enrolled Copy H.B. 320 Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments", + "issuing_body": "Utah State Legislature", + "document_type": "enacted legislation", + "version": "2026 General Session enrolled copy", + "locator": "Section 1, Utah Code 13-72-101(10), p2 lines 54-57", + "excerpt": "(b) a state-funded institution of higher education or public education; or", + "identity_excerpts": [ + "Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments" + ] + } + }, + "units": { + "section:Summary/text": { + "before_sha256": "12cb1e7250f1ae3af956bc906b7c2debc96e46ea0a88710b4724a5099761853c", + "after_sha256": "0df10911552da62188a4753c77f35c1c6252457a8309a826dbce5dd41c026c68", + "candidate_content": "A person deploying AI in Utah may enter either a Regulatory Mitigation Agreement (RMA) — which waives specified law in exchange for safeguards, data sharing, and disclosures — or a Joint Interpretation Agreement (JIA) — which clarifies how existing statute applies to a specific AI use without waiver. Agreements run for an initial twelve months with up to two twelve-month extensions, counterparties include OAIP plus the relevant state agency (or the judiciary, a state-funded higher or public education institution, or a political subdivision under HB 320), and participants must satisfy five statutory eligibility prongs.", + "reason": "Add state-funded public education to the governmental-entity counterparties.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Utah Code 13-72-101(10) as amended by HB 320.", + "exceptions": "Other Summary statements not re-reviewed.", + "time": "HB 320 effective May 6, 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb320_governmental_entity" + ] + }, + "section:What Counts/text": { + "before_sha256": "a93ed35858beeeb2ca27c5a948e9564ec04f9b43df32c9b7fccf13ad6e3caada", + "after_sha256": "688e804e52ba1e0e581a7c28fadc0eabd12fd343cfa784315e9f18b10a133268", + "candidate_content": "- Demonstrated technical capability to operate the proposed AI use\n- Financial resources sufficient to meet obligations during testing\n- Potential substantial consumer benefits that may outweigh identified risks\n- Documented risk-monitoring plan covering the agreement scope\n- Scope appropriately limited to the statute, use case, and deployment period\n- Executed agreement stating scope limits, safeguards, mitigations granted, required consumer disclosures, and reporting requirements\n- Submission to OAIP regular audits while the agreement is in effect, with agreement reporting requirements to comply with those audits (the annual Nov 30 report is OAIP's duty to the Legislature, not a participant duty)", + "reason": "Use statutory wording for financial resources and prong (c), and limit reporting to audit-related agreement terms; the Nov 30 report is an office duty.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Utah Code 13-72-401 and 13-72-402 as amended by HB 320.", + "exceptions": "Prongs (a), (d), (e) not re-worded.", + "time": "HB 320 effective May 6, 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb320_financial", + "hb320_prong_c", + "hb320_audits", + "hb320_audit_reporting", + "hb320_office_report" + ] + }, + "section:What Does Not Count/text": { + "before_sha256": "f85efc03a2a0dd3e9594b9f6390521db88b40f008e7bf7b713da3a37f0d49ea1", + "after_sha256": "48dfa7f1f06387c7b969dd5596e941f61e6f82a2bf98ef5bcbf02f7ab95c9ca6", + "candidate_content": "- Broad regulatory waivers not tied to a specified statute or use case\n- Agreements without scope limits, safeguards, or consumer disclosures\n- Term exceeding thirty-six months in aggregate (§13-72-403)\n- Using or deploying AI technology that violates legal or regulatory requirements or the agreement terms (possible immediate removal and all applicable civil and criminal penalties)", + "reason": "Replace \"retroactive enforcement\" with the statutory removal and civil and criminal penalties consequence.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Utah Code 13-72-401(8)(b).", + "exceptions": "None.", + "time": "HB 320 effective May 6, 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb320_removal" + ] + }, + "section:Statute Anchors/text": { + "before_sha256": "d6049502470dfd88a48fbc71730b6308824725b4c8e91bfa056b09c1da9e8d7a", + "after_sha256": "4687eab435a890d06f70e7ad0ae4dec698b089391c5456537d5101549ab13275", + "candidate_content": "- Utah Code §13-72-201 — OAIP administration of the Learning Lab program\n- Utah Code §13-72-301 — Artificial Intelligence Learning Laboratory Program (JIAs are covered by §13-72-401)\n- Utah Code §13-72-401 — Agreement contents and counterparties\n- Utah Code §13-72-402 — Participant eligibility prongs\n- Utah Code §13-72-403 — Term limits and extensions", + "reason": "13-72-301 is the Learning Laboratory Program section; JIAs are in 13-72-401.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "Statute Anchors list only.", + "exceptions": "None.", + "time": "HB 320 effective May 6, 2026." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb320_learning_lab_301", + "hb320_jia_401" + ] + }, + "metadata:modified": { + "before_sha256": null, + "after_sha256": "203550de69fd32247aa59c67343c1ec7437181af7576b6b4a0750aca2b15d62b", + "candidate_content": "2026-09-23", + "reason": "Record the date of this bounded source-backed correction without renewing legal currentness.", + "qualifications": { + "scope": "This record edit only.", + "exceptions": "No last_verified, legal status or currentness renewal is accepted by this review.", + "time": "Correction reviewed September 24, 2026 UTC against retained sources." + }, + "evidence": [ + "hb320_financial" ] } } diff --git a/data/admission/sources/elizachat/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024-2026-09-24.ocr.txt b/data/admission/sources/elizachat/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024-2026-09-24.ocr.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..5bf2e5f6 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/admission/sources/elizachat/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024-2026-09-24.ocr.txt @@ -0,0 +1,457 @@ +=== page 01 +AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE POLICY, +ELIZACHAT INC., AND THE DIVISION OF PROFESSIONAL LICENSING + +1, Parties + +A. The Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy created in Utah Code § 13-72-201, an office within the +Utah Department of Commerce (hereinafter “the Office”). + +B. Elizachat Inc., a participant in the Learning Laboratory (hereinafter “Participant”). + +C. The Division of Professional Licensing, a division within the Utah Department of Commerce +(hereinafter “the Division”). + +Il. Effective Date and Demonstration Period + +The demonstration period of this Agreement is for 12 months, beginning on the date this agreement is +executed. + +TIE. Purpose and Authority + +A. The Office is a state agency with the authority to create and administer the artificial intelligence +Learning Laboratory program. (Utah Code. § 13-72-301) + +B, The Office may negotiate and grant limited regulatory mitigation agreements to further the purposes of +the artificial intelligence Learning Laboratory program. (Utah Code § {3-72-302) + +C, Participant has applied to the Office for this regulatory mitigation and the application is incorporated in +Schedule B of this agreement. + +D. The Office has determined that granting Participant limited regulatory mitigation will meaningfully +contribute to the objectives of the artificial intelligence Learning Laboratory program. + +E. This agreement is a grant of regulatory mitigation only and does not constitute an endorsement or +approval from the State of Utah or any of its political subdivisions of Participant’s use of artificial +intelligence technologies, + +IV. Scope of Mitigation + +A. The Office, in consultation with the Division, grants regulatory mitigation to Participant as outlined in +Schedule A. + +B. It is agreed and understood that the Agreement only grants mitigation as specified in Schedule A. +=== page 02 +C. The mitigation specified in Schedule A is not binding until this document has been signed and +executed by all parties. + +D. Participant is subject to all Federal, State and local laws not expressly waived or modified by the terms +of this Agreement, including any changes to existing law during the demonstration period (Utah Code § +13-72-302(6)). For the avoidance of doubt, this Agreement does not waive or modify any legal remedies +available to individual users, members of the public, or the State of Utah or its political subdivisions other +than the Division, If relevant laws change during the demonstration period and affect the enforceability of +any provision of this Agreement, the Office may require the parties to amend this agreement, If no new +agreement can be made, this Agreement will be terminated effective on the day the relevant law went into + +effect. + +V. Scope of Test + +A. Participant shall perform all relevant activities in accordance with the methodologies and safety +protocols set forth in Participant’s application and attached below as Schedule B (hereinafter referred to as +the “Testing Plan”. The Testing Plan can be amended by the Office’s Director (in consultation with the + +Division) as long as the amendment approval is in writing. + +B, Participant shall also abide by limitations on number and types of users, geographic limitations, and/or +other limitations prescribed by the Office. + +C. Participant may not use regulatory mitigation specified in this agreement to create goods, services, or +labor not specified in the Testing Plan. + +VI. Participant Obligations +Unless the Office determines otherwise in writing, Participant agrees as follows: +A. Capacity +Participant shall possess the technical expertise, financial resources, and capability to responsibly develop +and test the proposed artificial intelligence technology. Participant shall also have an effective plan to +monitor and minimize both identified and unknown risks from their projects specified in the Testing Plan. +B. Safeguards +1, Participant shall abide by safeguards and methodologies outlined in the Testing Plan to protect +users and stakeholders, as specified in Section XVI, from potential harm that may result from their + +activities. Participant shall abide by any other safeguards prescribed by the Office. + +2. Participant is fully responsible for the proper and efficient monitoring, operation and maintenance +of any projects stemming from the mitigation granted in this Agreement. +=== page 03 +3. In the event a user or third party is harmed as a result of using the ElizaChat app, nothing in this +agreement prevents the user, third party, the State of Utah or any of its subdivisions other than the +Division, from seeking any legally available remedy from Participant. + +C. Registration +Participant must be registered to do business in the State of Utah. +D. Permissions + +1 Participant shall not mention that it is a party to this agreement in any advertising or promotional +materials unless approved in writing by the Office. + +2. Participant is responsible for obtaining and maintaining all necessary permits, licenses, and +permissions required for the project from other federal, state or local government agencies having +jurisdiction over the project. Participant shall furnish any such permits and approvals to the Office +upon request. + +E. Data Security + +1, Participant shall implement data security measures in accordance with Utah Code § 63A-19-102. +Participant shall comply with all privacy and safe data usage requirements as stipulated by the +Office. Participant shall not use any information, technology, or advantage gained from regulatory +mitigation in a manner that is illegal, unethical, or contrary to public interest, including but not +limited to, selling user data or information or using user data or information for advertising or +other commercial purposes, regardless of whether the data or information is deidentified or +anonymized, + +2. For the avoidance of doubt, no data protection or privacy law or regulation, whether by statute or +common law, is waived or modified by the terms of this agreement. + +F, Cybersecurity + +Participant shall implement reasonable protections against data leaks to minimize the risk of breach of +confidential information in accordance with the State of Utah Enterprise Information Security Policy +5000-0002. These protections include, but are not limited to: + +1. Keeping data system testing environments separate from production environments; + +2. Maintaining reasonable server and storage capacity to enable continuous availability of data + +systems; +3. Formally managing technology assets through their lifecycle; and +4. Using integrity checking mechanisms to verify software, firmware, and information integrity. + +Participant shall ensure that its cyber security framework is regularly updated to address emerging threats +and vulnerabilities. For the avoidance of doubt, no cybersecurity law or regulation, whether by statute or +common law, is waived or modified by the terms of this agreement. +=== page 04 +G, Disclosures to Users + +1. Before granting users access to any functions of the ElizaChat app, Participant shall disclose the +following to the user: + +a, The name and contact information of Participant. + +b. That the user is interacting with generative artificial intelligence pursuant to Utah Code § +13-2-12(4); + +c. That the ElizaChat app is undergoing testing, may not function as intended, and may +expose users to certain risks identified in Participant’s Testing Plan. + +d, The precise manner, means, and extent in which all user data and information, including +all correspondence with the ElizaChat app, will be used and shared by Participant; and + +e. That a user may contact the Office and file a complaint regarding the use of the ElizaChat +app. Participant shall share with users a phone number and/or website address provided +by the Office where users may file a complaint. + +2. Disclosures shall be provided to users in a clear and conspicuous form and a user shall +acknowledge receipt of the disclosure before a user may access any functions of the ElizaChat +app. + +3. For the avoidance of doubt, no disclosure law or regulation, whether by statute or common law, is +waived or modified by the terms of this agreement. + +H. Phased roll-out + +Participant agrees to a three-phased rollout of the ElizaChat app. This agreement shall commence with +Phase One and each subsequent phase shal! occur only upon written approval from the Office. During +Phase One, Participant shall give the Office user access to the ElizaChat app as part of a “trusted tester” +study prior to releasing the ElizaChat app to any student users, During Phase Two, Participant shall select +a group of student users, the size and location of which shall be reviewed by the Office to further test the +ElizaChat app. During Phase Three, Participant may offer access to the ElizaChat app to all students in +Utah school districts. + +I. Reporting + +1. Participant shall submit a monthly report to the Office at ai@utah.gov. Monthly reports shall +detail information regarding the ElizaChat app users including research findings, impact analyses, +technology assessments, information about user complaints, and any other relevant information +requested by the Office. Reports shall also include: + +a. Relevant qualitative and quantitative data of users +b. Trends or observations made by Participant’s in-house clinicians +c. Excerpts from successful and unsuccessful applications of the ElizaChat app +=== page 05 +2, In response to any user complaint filed with the Office or any action reasonably likely to +constitute an incident as described in schedule A, the Office may request records, documents, and +data from Participant regarding its demonstrated use of the ElizaChat app under this Agreement +and Participant will make such records, documents and data available for inspection. + +3. Participant will notify the Office of any incidents that result in harm to the health, safety or +financial well-being of a user within 24 hours of such incident ocewring. + +4. No later than 30 days after the end date of this Agreement, Participant will submit a written report +to the Office describing an overview of Participant’s demonstration including any incidents of +harm to users, legal action filed against Participant as a result of the demonstration, and +complaints filed as a result of the demonstration. + +5. The Office is a governmental entity subject to the Government Records Access and Management +Act, Utah Code §§ 63G-2-101 to 63G-2-901 (“GRAMA”), Accordingly, certain records within +possession or control of the UORR, including without limitation this Agreement, may be subject +to public disclosure. The Office’s confidentiality obligations shall comply with GRAMA. The +Office will classify Participant’s application for regulatory mitigation as a protected record in +accordance with Utah Code § 63G-2-305. + +J. Failure to meet obligations. + +If Participant fails to meet any of the obligations set forth in this section, the Office may request more +comprehensive reports from Participant and a plan for resolving any issues related to such obligations. In +such an instance, Participant agrees to provide all requested information, If Participant cannot put a plan +forward to adequately resolve the issue, as determined by the Office, this Agreement shall be nullified and +thereafter the Division may pursue normal administrative remedies, + +VIL Notice + +All notices required to be given, by either Party to the other, shall be deemed fully given when delivered. +physically or by email. + +VIII. Indemnification + +Participant agrees to hold the Office and the Division, including their agents, officers, and employees +harniless from any claims, fiabilities, damages, losses, or expenses arising from Participant’s work that +stems from the mitigation granted in this Agreement. + +IX. Choice of Law, Venue, and Jurisdiction + +This Agreement shall be governed by and construed pursuant to the laws of the State of Utah. The Parties +will submit to the jurisdiction of the court of the State of Utah for any dispute arising out of this +agreement or the breach thereof. Venue shall be in the Salt Lake Department, Third Judicial District in + +and for Salt Lake County, State of Utah. + +X. Termination +=== page 06 +A. The Office or Participant may terminate this Agreement at any time, and for any reason, prior to the +completion of the 12-month mitigation period. Upon receipt of such notice, Participant shall no longer be +protected by the mitigation provisions of this Agreement, (Utah Code § 13-72-302(7)) + +XI. Assignment, Transfer, Collateral Use + +Participant may not assign or transfer regulatory mitigation granted in this Agreement without the prior +written consent of the Office. Approval of an assignment does not establish any legal relationship +between the Office and any other third party. The Office shall not be liable for any act or omission +committed pursuant to such an assignment. + +XII. Entire Agreement + +This Agreement, including all referenced documents and attachments, constitutes the entire agreement +between the Parties regarding the subject matter hereof, This Agreement supersedes any other written or +oral understanding of the Parties. This Agreement may not be modified except by a written instrument +executed by both Parties. This Agreement may be signed in counterparts, and may be signed +electronically. + +XII. Agreement Extension + +Participant may request a single extension of up to 12 months for regulatory mitigation no later than 30 +days before the end of the initial 12-month period. The Office shall grant or deny an extension request +before expiration of the initial demonstration period in accordance with Utah Code § 13-72-305. + +XIV. Signatures + +The individuals executing this Agreement represent and warrant that they have the legal capacity and +authority to do so on behalf of their respective legal entities. + +IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties have executed this Agreement as of the latter of the dates +written below. + +of 14, 2024 14:25 MST) 1 1/1 4/2024 + +ZACHARY BOYD Date +Office Director + +pty 11/15/2024 + +DAVE BARNEY Date +CEO ElizaChat Inc. + +=== page 07 +tikka W924: + +MARK STEINAGAL Date | | +Director, Division of Professional Licensing +=== page 08 +Schedule A + +XV. Mitigation Offered + +The Office, with approval from the Division, grants Participant the following regulatory mitigation +measures: + +A. During the Demonstration Period described in section Il, Participant may, with permission from +participating school districts, make the ElizaChat app available to students in accordance with the rollout +schedule described in Section VI(H). + +B. Participant shall abide by approved procedures in the Testing Plan to identify and prevent the +ElizaChat app from engaging in the practice of mental health therapy or any other licensed professional +practice. If the Office or the Division determines that the ElizaChat app has engaged in the practice of +mental health therapy with student users as defined in Utah Code §§ 58-60-102(17) and 58-61-102(8) or +other licensed professional practice, it shall constitute an incident pursuant to this agreement. + +C Ifan incident occurs, the Division will forgo any enforcement action for unlawful or unprofessional +conduct as defined in Utah Code § 58-1-501(1) and (2), respectively, and any administrative penalties for +engaging in the practice of mental health therapy as defined in Utah Code §§ 58-60-102(17) and +58-61-102(8) as it relates to the incident during a 30-day cure period outlined in Section XV(D-E). + +D. Participant shall have 30 days to cure any incidents that occur during the demonstration period, During +the cure period the Division will forgo any enforcement action for unlawful or unprofessional conduct as +defined in Utah Code § 58-1-501(1) and (2), respectively, and any administrative penalties for engaging in +the practice of mental health therapy, so long as Participant makes a good faith effort to follow the curing +procedure detailed in Section XV(E). + +E. The curing procedure for engaging in an incident as defined in Section XV(C) is as follows: +1. Participant shall immediately report any activity constituting an incident to the Office. Reports +shall include: +a. Notifying the Office of the action constituting an incident. +Notifying the Office of the user(s) involved in the incident. +Notifying the Office of any harm suffered by the user(s) as a result of the incident. +Notifying the user(s) involved in the incident of the action constituting an incident. +Making a good faith effort to remediate the incident and any harm resulting from the +incident. +f. Making a good faith effort to avoid repeat incidents. + +segs + +F, The scope of regulatory mitigation will be limited to incidents of the licensed practice of mental health +therapy as defined in Utah Code §§ 58-60-102(17) and 58-61-102(8). For the avoidance of doubt, this +mitigation does not extend to any claim brought by individual users or their parent/legal guardian, injured +=== page 09 +third parties, or any claim brought by the State of Utah or any of its political subdivisions other than the +Division of Professional Licensing. + +XVI. Additional Participant Obligations to Users + +Participant agrees to the following requirements to qualify for the mitigation measures outlined in +Sections IV and XV: + +A. Users who demonstrate high risk behavior, as determined by Participant, shall be promptly shared with +ElizaChat’s clinical team and emergency contacts for the users. Users who demonstrate high risk behavior +shall also promptly be connected with a licensed psychologist or therapist for a real-time intervention, as +stated in the Testing Plan. + +B. Participant shall also abide by any limitations agreed upon with any school district where Participant +makes the ElizaChat app available to student. + +C. Participant shall ensure that all user data will be anonymized and stored securely in accordance with +HIPAA regulations, as stated in the Testing Plan. + +D. Participant shall disclose to users and to the school district how user data will be used/stored by +Participant, This includes any encryption and anonymizing of data as well as procedures for how to +request deletion of user accounts and data + +E, Participant shall, in accordance with industry standards, obtain parental consent in writing prior to +engaging in regular activity with users under the age of 18 using the ElizaChat app. +=== page 10 +Schedule B + +Proposal for Elizachat Inc. Participation in Utah +Department of Commerce Al Lab + +Dave Barney, CEO ElizaChat Inc +June 2024 + +Introduction + +Elizachat Inc. is a pioneering startup dedicated to leveraging artificial intelligence (Al) to +enhance mental health therapy. Our flagship product, the Elizachat mental health app, aims to +provide accessible, effective, and timely mental health support, particularly for teenagers. +ElizaChat has been and will continue to be developed with our clinical advisory board, +composed of trained and licensed clinical psychologists and therapists. We are excited about +the opportunity to participate in the Utah Department of Commerce's new Al Lab. + +Challenge and Opportunity + +We see a significant opportunity for Al to play a role in treating the growing mental health +demands in our society. We believe the human therapist will never be replaced, but that Al can +extend the human therapist and fill needs currently unmet. Exactly what Al can do and cannot +do is still somewhat to be determined, but there are some clear advantages to an Al system, +including: +1. Availability of the system 24/7 to address acute needs when human therapists are +not available +2, Lower costs than human therapy +3. Accessibility. This includes both pricing and availability in regions and markets +where human therapy is limited + +The challenge is that current regulatory statutes around therapy designed to protect the public +also limit what companies can do to innovate potential meaningful solutions to compliment +human therapists. + +Project Overview + +We propose a pilot trial to evaluate the impact of our product on improving teen mental health in +Utah. The objective of this pilot trial is to measure the effectiveness of the Elizachat app asa +therapeutic tool for teenagers. The trial will focus on assessing improvements in mental health +outcomes, such as reductions in anxiety, depression, and stress levels, as well as overail +well-being. We propose to conduct the trial over a six-month period with a diverse group of +teenage participants in Utah. + +10 +=== page 11 +Methodology + +We will work with our clinical advisory board, researchers, and mental care industry leaders to +develop the appropriate methodology for a pilot trial, based on industry best practices. + +Safety Protocols + +Ensuring the safety and well-being of participants is our top priority. There is a rising concern in +the public about potential harms of Al. These harms are real in systems that are not designed +with rigorous safety protocols and guardrails. We have developed robust safety protocols to +address potential risks and ensure appropriate intervention when necessary. Please consider +the fotlowing: + +4. Eliza is a “steerable” ensemble of Al interactions: + +e Allinteractions with users are formed, reformed, scrutinized, and corrected +behind the scenes with guidelines and training data from our clinical advisory +board. + +¢ Input and output to Eliza are filtered by an NLU (Natural Language +Understanding) system that recognizes and screens intentions behind text +input and Eliza responses. + +| e There is ongoing reviewing and improving interactions with our clinica! +advisory board, similar to how clinicians in training are evaluated by +licensed clinicians. +2, Risk Assessment and Escalation: + +« The app includes an integrated risk assessment too! that identifies users +exhibiting signs of severe distress or suicidal ideation. + +e Incases of high-risk behavior, the app will immediately alert our clinical team +and adult emergency contacts for the participating teens, and, as appropriate, +emergency services + +3. Human Intervention: + +e Users identified as needing immediate attention will be connected with a +licensed psychologist or therapist for a real-time intervention. + +e@ We have established partnerships with local mental health professionals to + +| provide timely and effective support. +4. Data Privacy and Security: +e We are committed to maintaining the highest standards of data privacy and +- security. All participant data will be anonymized and stored securely in +| compliance with HIPAA regulations. + +Conclusion + +Elizachat Inc. is committed to advancing mental health care through innovative Al solutions. +We believe that our participation in the Utah Department of Commerce Al Lab will provide an +opportunity to develop solutions that are safe and effective by providing the regulatory +flexibility and oversight to safely develop clinically backed solutions to address the growing + +11 + +=== page 12 +need for mental health services among Utah teens. We look forward to the Opportunity to +collaborate with the Department to ensure the success of the project. + +12 diff --git a/data/admission/sources/elizachat/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024-2026-09-24.pdf b/data/admission/sources/elizachat/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024-2026-09-24.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c373c105 Binary files /dev/null and b/data/admission/sources/elizachat/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024-2026-09-24.pdf differ diff --git a/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.html b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.html new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ef995001 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.html @@ -0,0 +1,786 @@ + + + + + + + + + + AI Home - commerce.utah.gov + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
+ + + + + Schedule 1 on 1 Virtual Call Icon + + +
+ + +
+ + + +
+ + +
+ + +
+ + +

Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy logoAI Home
Strengthening trust in AI activities in Utah through data-driven policy, innovation-enabling regulatory relief, and timely regulatory adjustments.

Our Mission

+

The Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy is dedicated to regulating the bleeding edge of AI. We consult with businesses, academic institutions, and other stakeholders to facilitate dialogue on regulatory proposals, guided by three core objectives:

+ +
    +
  1. Observe and Learn
  2. +
  3. Protect the Public
  4. +
  5. Foster Innovation
  6. +

Through our AI regulatory sandbox (see Utah Code § 13-72-401) and our collaborative oversight process, Utah is setting a new standard for innovative governance and leading the nation in responsible AI policy.

What do you want to do today?

+

Explore our AI Sandbox

+

Information about the sandbox, application requirements, and a list of approved pilots.

Review our Policy Work

+

Resources for current and past topics on our learning agenda.

Engage with Us

+

Apply to our regulatory sandbox, participate in focus groups, or share feedback.

Pro-Human AI Initiative

+

Utah believes AI should bring people and ideas together. That's why we've partnered with community leaders to create the Pro-Human AI Initiative. With a pro-human approach, AI can amplify human potential while remaining clear, accountable, and responsive to human needs.

+

The Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP) partners with companies building responsible AI. We learn from real-world use and transform those insights into policies that support safe, effective innovation.

+ + +
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + + + + +
+ + +
+ + +
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Wednesday, July 24, in observance of the Pioneer Day holiday. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Sep 02, in observance of the Labor Day holiday. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Oct 14, in observance of the Columbus Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, Nov 28, in observance of the Thanksgiving Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Feb 17, in observance of the President's Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, May 26, in observance of Memorial Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Heber Wells Building will close at 4 p.m. today. All in-person services will resume at normal business hours on Friday, June 13, and all online services will remain available today.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, June 16, in observance of the Juneteenth holiday. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, July 24, in observance of Pioneer Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, September 1, in observance of Labor Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
Translate »
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
+ + \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.txt b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..8673d00c --- /dev/null +++ b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-AI-Home-2026-09-24.txt @@ -0,0 +1,69 @@ +AI Home - commerce.utah.gov +Strengthening trust in AI activities in Utah through data-driven policy, innovation-enabling regulatory relief, and timely regulatory adjustments. +Our Mission +The Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy is dedicated to regulating the bleeding edge of AI. We consult with businesses, academic institutions, and other stakeholders to facilitate dialogue on regulatory proposals, guided by three core objectives: +Observe and Learn +Protect the Public +Foster Innovation +Through our AI regulatory sandbox ( see Utah Code § 13-72-401 ) and our collaborative oversight process, Utah is setting a new standard for innovative governance and leading the nation in responsible AI policy. +What do you want to do today? +Explore our AI Sandbox +Information about the sandbox, application requirements, and a list of approved pilots. +Explore +Review our Policy Work +Resources for current and past topics on our learning agenda. +Review +Engage with Us +Apply to our regulatory sandbox, participate in focus groups, or share feedback. +Engage +Pro-Human AI Initiative +Utah believes AI should bring people and ideas together. That's why we've partnered with community leaders to create the Pro-Human AI Initiative . With a pro-human approach, AI can amplify human potential while remaining clear, accountable, and responsive to human needs. +The Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP) partners with companies building responsible AI. We learn from real-world use and transform those insights into policies that support safe, effective innovation. +Learn More +Follow us online +Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy +Mailing Address : P.O. Box 146741, Salt Lake City, UT 84114-6741 +Physical Address: Heber M. Wells Building 160 East 300 South Salt Lake City, Utah 84111 +Contact Info +Phone: (801) 530-6648 +Email : [email protected] +Hours : 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM +Monday - Friday +Closed for State and Federal Holidays +Services +Regulatory Relief +Learning Lab +Resources +GRAMA Record Request +Privacy Policy +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Wednesday, July 24, in observance of the Pioneer Day holiday. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Sep 02, in observance of the Labor Day holiday. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Oct 14, in observance of the Columbus Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, Nov 28, in observance of the Thanksgiving Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Feb 17, in observance of the President's Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, May 26, in observance of Memorial Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Heber Wells Building will close at 4 p.m. today. All in-person services will resume at normal business hours on Friday, June 13, and all online services will remain available today. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, June 16, in observance of the Juneteenth holiday. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, July 24, in observance of Pioneer Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, September 1, in observance of Labor Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +Translate » +< +< +< +< +< +< +< +< +< +< diff --git a/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.html b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.html new file mode 100644 index 00000000..0d8d6cec --- /dev/null +++ b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.html @@ -0,0 +1,1779 @@ + + + + + + + + + + AI Authorized Pilots - commerce.utah.gov + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
+ + + + + Schedule 1 on 1 Virtual Call Icon + + +
+ + +
+ + + +
+ + +
+ + +
+ + +
+ +
+ + + + +
+
+
+

Authorized AI Pilots

+
+
+
+ + + +
+
+
+

The following organizations have been authorized to test an artificial intelligence product in Utah under an agreement with this office and the agency that regulates them. This page is the public record of those agreements.

+

Each entry below lists the participating organizations, what their product does, which Utah regulations the state agreed to set aside while the test runs, what the company had to promise in exchange, when the agreement was signed, and whether it is still in force. The page for each pilot contains the full details and the signed agreement itself.

+

An agreement is not permission to do whatever the company likes. It is a narrow, time limited, written change to how one rule applies, and the company remains bound by everything else in Utah law.

+ +
+
+
+ + + + +
+
+

The Agreements

+ +
+ + +
+
+

Legion Health

+ Approved +

Psychiatry

+
+ +
+
Signed
March 19, 2026
+
Term
The demonstration period has not started yet.
+
Co-signed with
Division of Professional Licensing
+
+ +
+
+

What the pilot does

+

Legion Health runs an AI supported psychiatry practice. The pilot lets its system authorize a refill of a prescription a Utah patient is already taking, for stable patients on non controlled medication such as common anxiety and depression treatments. The system does not diagnose, does not start a new medication, and does not change a dose.

+

Relief granted

+

The Division of Professional Licensing agreed not to bring an enforcement action for unlicensed or unprofessional conduct, or under the state telehealth requirements, where the AI authorizes a renewal that a licensed prescriber would otherwise have had to authorize personally. The relief runs to the specific sections named in Schedule A of the agreement and to nothing else.

+
+
+

What the company agreed to

+
    +
  • A licensed clinician reviews the first 250 requests before any of them completes.
  • +
  • The next 1,000 requests go through intensive retrospective review, then monthly random sampling and audit continues for the rest of the term.
  • +
  • Any sign of suicidality, severe side effects, mania, or pregnancy stops the process and sends the case to a clinician. A patient can ask for a human at any point.
  • +
  • Patients are told AI is part of the process, and identity and prescription are verified before anything is issued.
  • +
  • Monthly reporting to this office, including agreement rates between the AI and the reviewing clinician.
  • +
  • Malpractice insurance that covers AI related liability.
  • +
+
+
+ + +
+ + + +
+
+

Doctronic

+ Active +

Prescription renewals

+
+ +
+
Signed
October 24, 2025
+
Term
October 24, 2025 – October 24, 2026
+
Co-signed with
Division of Professional Licensing
+
+ +
+
+

What the pilot does

+

Doctronic uses AI to process 30, 60, and 90 day renewals of medication a licensed provider has already prescribed. It does not write a new prescription, touch controlled or addictive substances, or change a treatment plan. The pilot covers a fixed list of medications set out in the agreement and no others.

+

Relief granted

+

The same narrow relief as the Legion Health pilot: the Division of Professional Licensing agreed not to enforce the unlicensed conduct and telehealth provisions named in Schedule A against a renewal the AI authorizes under the agreed protocol. The relief covers the renewal function only and expressly reaches nothing else Doctronic offers.

+

Where it stands

+

The pilot is still in Phase 1, which means a licensed medical practitioner authorizes every request. Moving to Phase 2 requires this office to approve it, group of medications by group of medications, and it has not been approved. The 2026 amendment tightened that threshold and removed two medications from the list.

+
+
+

What the company agreed to

+
    +
  • A three phase review, with this office deciding whether each phase advances.
  • +
  • Identity and prescription verification before any renewal is processed.
  • +
  • Telling the user, before the conversation starts, that they are interacting with generative AI, how their data will be used, and that they can file a complaint with this office.
  • +
  • Monthly reporting, including how often the AI and the reviewing physician agreed.
  • +
  • No selling user data and no advertising against it, deidentified or otherwise.
  • +
  • Third party adversarial testing of the system.
  • +
+
+
+ + +
+ + + +
+
+

Dentacor

+ Expired +

Mobile dental hygiene

+
+ +
+
Signed
May 31, 2025
+ +
Term
May 31, 2025 – May 31, 2026
+
Co-signed with
Division of Professional Licensing
+
+ +
+
+

What the pilot does

+

Dentacor brings dental hygiene care directly to shelters, recovery programs, and transitional housing, where a supervising dentist is rarely on site. The pilot lets a licensed dental hygienist use an AI radiograph tool to identify three specific conditions, and to perform two specific procedures that follow from them.

+

Relief granted

+

Utah normally requires a dentist to supervise a hygienist making those calls. Under the agreement, a hygienist finding and the AI tool reaching the same conclusion stands in place of that supervision, for periodontal disease, complete edentulism, and complete anodontia only, and for scaling and root planing and the fitting of full dentures only. Every other requirement on a dental hygienist still applies.

+
+
+

What the company agreed to

+
    +
  • The hygienist and the AI must reach the same conclusion. If they disagree, the case goes to a licensed dentist.
  • +
  • Patients consent in writing, and the consent says plainly that no dentist is supervising the procedure and what a hygienist is and is not trained to do.
  • +
  • No claims to patients about the AI tool beyond what it actually does.
  • +
  • A testing plan this office has accepted before any patient is seen.
  • +
  • Monthly reporting covering patients seen, results, incidents, and complaints.
  • +
  • HIPAA compliant systems, no sale of patient data, and no advertising against it.
  • +
+
+
+ + +
+ + + +
+
+

ElizaChat

+ Expired +

Student emotional support

+
+ +
+
Signed
November 18, 2024
+ +
Term
November 18, 2024 – November 18, 2025
+
Co-signed with
Division of Professional Licensing
+
+ +
+
+

What the pilot does

+

ElizaChat is a Utah company whose app holds guided conversations with students, encourages coping strategies, and is built to recognize when a person needs a human instead. It is not therapy and it does not replace a clinician. The pilot is a phased rollout in school districts that agree to take part.

+

Relief granted

+

The concern is that a conversation like this could cross into the practice of mental health therapy, which in Utah requires a license. The agreement does not permit that. What it grants is a 30 day period to fix the problem: if the app does cross the line, ElizaChat must report it, tell the affected users, and remedy it, and the Division holds off on enforcement during that window. The protection stops there. It does not cover a claim by a student, a parent, an injured third party, or any other part of the state.

+
+
+

What the company agreed to

+
    +
  • Written parental consent before any regular use by a student under 18.
  • +
  • Risk assessment built into the conversation, with high risk users passed to ElizaChat's clinical team and emergency contacts and connected to a licensed therapist in real time.
  • +
  • Clear disclosure to users that they are talking to AI and what it cannot do.
  • +
  • Any incident harming a user's health, safety, or finances reported to this office within 24 hours.
  • +
  • Anonymized storage on HIPAA compliant terms, with the district told how data is used, encrypted, and deleted.
  • +
  • Whatever additional limits a participating district sets.
  • +
+
+
+ + +
+ +
+
+
+ + + +
+
+
+

How We Scope Our Agreement

+

Three statutory limits apply to every agreement we sign with sandbox participants.

+
+ +
    +
  • +

    It does not last

    +

    A demonstration period runs no longer than 12 months. A participant may ask for a 12 month extension, no later than 30 days before the current period ends, and the office may grant at most two. There is no permanent version of this. The office may also end an agreement at any time and for any reason, and a participant has no property right or license to stay in the program.

    +
  • +
  • +

    It is not a blank check

    +

    An agreement changes how one identified requirement applies to one identified product. The participant remains subject to every other legal and regulatory requirement the agreement does not expressly waive or modify. A company that breaks the law, or breaks the terms of its own agreement, can be removed immediately and faces the full civil and criminal penalties it would otherwise have faced.

    +
  • +
  • +

    It is not an endorsement

    +

    Taking part in our AI sandbox does not mean the State of Utah has approved, endorsed, certified, or vouched for the product. It means the product is being tested under conditions the state can see and stop. Sandbox participants are also responsible for actions covered by their agreements.

    +
  • +
+ +
+

Where these limits come from. Term and extensions: Utah Code § 13-72-403. Scope, termination, endorsement, and state liability: § 13-72-401(7) through (10). What an applicant must prove before an agreement is possible: § 13-72-402. The program itself: § 13-72-301.

+
+
+
+ + + +
+
+
+

How Active Pilots Are Monitored

+

Signing an agreement is the start of the oversight, not the end of it. Every AI sandbox participant reports to us monthly for as long as its agreement is in force, and those reports carry numbers, not assurances: how many requests the system handled, how often a reviewing clinician agreed with it, and every adverse outcome. The office is required by statute to audit a participant's use of its AI while an agreement remains in effect.

+

We also report to the Legislature. Before November 30 each year the office reports to the Business and Labor Interim Committee on the learning agenda, on what the laboratory has found, on participation and outcomes, and on every agreement it has executed.

+

We publish what we can. Where a pilot generates a public outcomes report, it is published on that pilot's own page. Where a regulator or a professional board has raised an objection to a pilot, we publish the objection and our answer to it, side by side, so a reader can weigh both.

+

Audit duty: Utah Code § 13-72-401(6). Annual report: § 13-72-201(3)(d).

+
+
+
+ + + +
+
+
+

Tell Us What You Are Seeing

+

If you have used one of these products, or you work in a field one of them touches, what you know is valuable to our learning. You do not need to be a lawyer, a clinician, or a Utah resident to write to us, and you certainly do not need to wait for something to go wrong.

+
+ +
    +
  • +

    A concern about a pilot

    +

    Email [email protected] and name the pilot. We read everything that arrives and we take it into the next monthly review of that agreement.

    +
  • +
  • +

    A licensed professional's conduct

    +

    Complaints about a licensee, including one working with an AI system, go to the Division of Professional Licensing, which co-signed every agreement on this page.

    +
  • +
  • +

    A business practice

    +

    Misleading claims, unfair practices, and consumer harm go to the Division of Consumer Protection. An agreement with this office is no defense to a consumer protection violation.

    +
  • +
+
+
+ + + +
+
+
+
+

Thinking About Applying?

+
+
+

Before an agreement is possible you have to show us four things: that you can build and supervise the technology responsibly, that you can pay for your obligations through the test, that the benefit to Utah consumers plausibly outweighs the risk of setting a rule aside, and that your plan to find and limit that risk is real. The scale and length of what you propose has to match the risk you are asking us to accept.

+

If you are interested in applying, start with the process page, and read the evidence standards before reaching out to us. That is where most first drafts fall short.

+ +
+
+
+
+ + + +
+ + +
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + + + + +
+ + +
+ + +
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Wednesday, July 24, in observance of the Pioneer Day holiday. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Sep 02, in observance of the Labor Day holiday. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Oct 14, in observance of the Columbus Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, Nov 28, in observance of the Thanksgiving Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Feb 17, in observance of the President's Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, May 26, in observance of Memorial Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Heber Wells Building will close at 4 p.m. today. All in-person services will resume at normal business hours on Friday, June 13, and all online services will remain available today.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, June 16, in observance of the Juneteenth holiday. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, July 24, in observance of Pioneer Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, September 1, in observance of Labor Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
Translate »
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
+ + \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.txt b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..50a483e5 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Authorized-Pilots-2026-09-24.txt @@ -0,0 +1,281 @@ +AI Authorized Pilots - commerce.utah.gov +block, paste it +into .oaip-register in date order, newest first, and change nine things: +1. and the id on it company name, and a matching slug id +2. the badge word plus one of the classes above +3. Signed the execution date, in full +4. Term the date range, "Month D, YYYY - Month +D, YYYY", or a plain sentence where no +period has begun +5. Regulator the agency that co-signed +6. "What it does" two sentences, no marketing language +7. "Relief granted" the specific relief, then the sections +8. "What the company agreed to" three to five conditions, shortest first +9. the "Learn more" button href to that pilot's page, and the +aria-label, which must name the pilot so +the buttons stay distinguishable to a +screen reader listing links out of order +The intro deliberately carries no count ("The following organizations..."), +so adding a pilot needs no edit there. Nothing else on the page is per-pilot +and the register reflows on its own, so a fifth and sixth entry need no CSS +change. +Each entry carries ONE control, a "Learn more" button to that pilot's own +page, so the signed agreement and the outcome reports are reached one click +further in. That makes the pilot pages load-bearing: if a pilot page does not +link its own signed agreement, fix the pilot page rather than adding a second +link back into this card. +Open items before publish: the live index links all four pilots through +/ai/regulatory-mitigation/agreements/ /, which 301-redirects, while this +block links the canonical /ai/regulatory-relief/authorized-ai-pilots/ paths; +confirm those redirects stay in place for anyone holding an old link. A human +screen-reader pass and a keyboard-only pass are still owed. +--------------------------------------------------------------------------- +BAND ORDER +--------------------------------------------------------------------------- +1 hero, 2 intro, 3 the register, 4 limits, 5 oversight (one full-width +column; published documents live on the individual pilot pages), 6 raise a +concern, 7 apply. There is no contact band: the site footer already carries the +address, phone, and hours, and the RAISE A CONCERN band already carries +ai@utah.gov in context. If one is ever added, it goes after the apply band. +COPY STANDARD: this office uses the Oxford comma. Every list of three or +more items on this page carries a comma before the final "and" or "or". +Dates are written "Month D, YYYY" throughout, never "D Month YYYY". +--------------------------------------------------------------------------- +COLOUR - every value is an official Utah brand token +--------------------------------------------------------------------------- +--teal #165857 = --utah-brand-secondary-color-teal-04, the Department of +Commerce colour: headings, links, filled surfaces +--teal-dark #0D262E = --utah-brand-secondary-color-teal-05: link hover, +focus ring, hero fallback, card-button hover +--gold #FFB81D = --utah-brand-primary-color-gold-light +--gold-ink #633D11 = --utah-brand-secondary-color-orange-05 +--hover #A6C4CA = --utah-brand-secondary-color-teal-00, hover flash only +--panel #F1F1F1 = the design system's --gray-light-color +--ink #474747 = the design system default body colour +--green #007000 = the Active badge, and nothing else. NOT a Utah brand +token; the brand greens are lighter and would not hold +white label text. Confining it to one badge keeps it +reading as a status colour rather than a second brand +colour competing with the teal. +--navy #093692 = --utah-brand-primary-color-blue-medium, the Approved +badge and nothing else. It exists so Approved and Active +are distinguishable from each other at a glance. +The whole palette swaps from the token block; no rule below hard-codes a +colour. +Contrast, computed with the WCAG relative-luminance formula, not eyeballed. +Text: body ink 9.29:1 on white and 8.23:1 on band grey; teal 8.18:1 on white +and 7.24:1 on band grey; white on teal 8.18:1; the hero title over the teal +band at its worst case, a pure white photo pixel behind it, 5.92:1. +Badges, label and fill edge alike: Active white on #007000 6.33:1; Approved +white on teal 8.18:1; Expired #633D11 on gold 5.50:1 with a 9.52:1 outline; +Completed #474747 outline and label 9.29:1. +Buttons: gold label 5.50:1 at rest and 5.15:1 on the hover flash. On the teal +apply band the gold fill is 4.72:1 against the band. On a white pilot card the +gold fill is only 1.73:1, so that button's 1px #633D11 border carries the +control boundary at 9.52:1 against the card, in every state including hover. +Focus ring #0D262E: 15.74:1 on white, 13.94:1 on band grey; white on teal +8.18:1. All clear AA. Most clear AAA. +A gold fill on white is a 1.73:1 edge, under the 3:1 that WCAG 1.4.11 wants +for a control boundary. Every gold surface on white here therefore carries a +1px #633D11 outline that supplies the boundary instead: the "Learn more" +buttons on the pilot cards, and the gold Expired badge, which is not a control +but is outlined for the same reason. +A focus ring inside a filled card must be light: --teal-dark on a --teal fill +is 1.93:1 and effectively invisible. The apply band overrides it to white, +which is 8.18:1. Any new control placed on a teal fill needs the same +override. +TYPE +- The scale is declared in PX on purpose. The Commerce child theme sets +html{font-size:14px}, so a rem-based scale would silently ship 14px body +copy. These px values are the design system's own rem steps at a 16px root. +- h1, h2, h3 and the pilot names are UT Industry; body and UI are Source +Sans 3. Headings are semi-bold 600, never 700. +- Body copy is 16px everywhere, in one regular weight, including the citation +lines and the opening paragraph. An opening paragraph is distinguished by +position, never by size or weight. +- The only 14px text is non-prose UI chrome: the uppercase field labels +inside a pilot entry, the sector line, and the badges. The guide allows +uppercase for short labels, which is what those are. Nothing else on the +page is uppercase. +- Left-aligned throughout. Nothing is justified. Underline is links only. +SPACING paragraphs 24px below, headings 16px below, bands 72-80px. +SHAPE cards and panels 6px; buttons, badges, and pills 999px. +ELEVATION the UDS borderless set. A white card on #F1F1F1 is only 1.13:1 +against the band, so the small upward shadow is what defines its +edge. Borders return only in Windows High Contrast mode. +IMAGES The hero photograph is the one already in the Commerce media +library. It is a decorative CSS background and the teal band +supplies the message, so it takes no alt text. There are no other +images, deliberately: a register is read, not browsed. +NOTES FOR WHOEVER EDITS THIS LATER +- All CSS is scoped under .oaip-pilots so it cannot leak into other pages. +- font-family / font-size / font-weight carry !important because the Commerce +child theme sets h2, h3 and p site-wide with !important. +- Exactly one (the hero). Sections are h2, pilot names are h3, and the +labels inside an entry are not headings and must not become headings. +- Every external link and every PDF says so in its accessible name. A PDF +link also says PDF in its visible text, because a screen-reader-only note +does not help a sighted user on a metered connection. +- The hero band takes no side margin. It is width:100% inside .oaip-wrap, +which already supplies the page gutters; adding margins on top of that +pushes it past the viewport between roughly 900px and 1100px. +- No hairline rules, with one deliberate exception: a 1px #F1F1F1 line inside +a pilot card separating its navigation from its content. +============================================================================ +--> +Authorized AI Pilots +The following organizations have been authorized to test an artificial intelligence product in Utah under an agreement with this office and the agency that regulates them. This page is the public record of those agreements. +Each entry below lists the participating organizations, what their product does, which Utah regulations the state agreed to set aside while the test runs, what the company had to promise in exchange, when the agreement was signed, and whether it is still in force. The page for each pilot contains the full details and the signed agreement itself. +An agreement is not permission to do whatever the company likes. It is a narrow, time limited, written change to how one rule applies, and the company remains bound by everything else in Utah law. +block, paste +it in date order (newest first) and change the nine items listed in the +header comment. --> +The Agreements +Legion Health +Approved +Psychiatry +Signed March 19, 2026 +Term The demonstration period has not started yet. +Co-signed with Division of Professional Licensing +What the pilot does +Legion Health runs an AI supported psychiatry practice. The pilot lets its system authorize a refill of a prescription a Utah patient is already taking, for stable patients on non controlled medication such as common anxiety and depression treatments. The system does not diagnose, does not start a new medication, and does not change a dose. +Relief granted +The Division of Professional Licensing agreed not to bring an enforcement action for unlicensed or unprofessional conduct, or under the state telehealth requirements, where the AI authorizes a renewal that a licensed prescriber would otherwise have had to authorize personally. The relief runs to the specific sections named in Schedule A of the agreement and to nothing else. +What the company agreed to +A licensed clinician reviews the first 250 requests before any of them completes. +The next 1,000 requests go through intensive retrospective review, then monthly random sampling and audit continues for the rest of the term. +Any sign of suicidality, severe side effects, mania, or pregnancy stops the process and sends the case to a clinician. A patient can ask for a human at any point. +Patients are told AI is part of the process, and identity and prescription are verified before anything is issued. +Monthly reporting to this office, including agreement rates between the AI and the reviewing clinician. +Malpractice insurance that covers AI related liability. +Learn more +Doctronic +Active +Prescription renewals +Signed October 24, 2025 +Term October 24, 2025 – October 24, 2026 +Co-signed with Division of Professional Licensing +What the pilot does +Doctronic uses AI to process 30, 60, and 90 day renewals of medication a licensed provider has already prescribed. It does not write a new prescription, touch controlled or addictive substances, or change a treatment plan. The pilot covers a fixed list of medications set out in the agreement and no others. +Relief granted +The same narrow relief as the Legion Health pilot: the Division of Professional Licensing agreed not to enforce the unlicensed conduct and telehealth provisions named in Schedule A against a renewal the AI authorizes under the agreed protocol. The relief covers the renewal function only and expressly reaches nothing else Doctronic offers. +Where it stands +The pilot is still in Phase 1, which means a licensed medical practitioner authorizes every request. Moving to Phase 2 requires this office to approve it, group of medications by group of medications, and it has not been approved. The 2026 amendment tightened that threshold and removed two medications from the list. +What the company agreed to +A three phase review, with this office deciding whether each phase advances. +Identity and prescription verification before any renewal is processed. +Telling the user, before the conversation starts, that they are interacting with generative AI, how their data will be used, and that they can file a complaint with this office. +Monthly reporting, including how often the AI and the reviewing physician agreed. +No selling user data and no advertising against it, deidentified or otherwise. +Third party adversarial testing of the system. +Learn more +Dentacor +Expired +Mobile dental hygiene +Signed May 31, 2025 +Term May 31, 2025 – May 31, 2026 +Co-signed with Division of Professional Licensing +What the pilot does +Dentacor brings dental hygiene care directly to shelters, recovery programs, and transitional housing, where a supervising dentist is rarely on site. The pilot lets a licensed dental hygienist use an AI radiograph tool to identify three specific conditions, and to perform two specific procedures that follow from them. +Relief granted +Utah normally requires a dentist to supervise a hygienist making those calls. Under the agreement, a hygienist finding and the AI tool reaching the same conclusion stands in place of that supervision, for periodontal disease, complete edentulism, and complete anodontia only, and for scaling and root planing and the fitting of full dentures only. Every other requirement on a dental hygienist still applies. +What the company agreed to +The hygienist and the AI must reach the same conclusion. If they disagree, the case goes to a licensed dentist. +Patients consent in writing, and the consent says plainly that no dentist is supervising the procedure and what a hygienist is and is not trained to do. +No claims to patients about the AI tool beyond what it actually does. +A testing plan this office has accepted before any patient is seen. +Monthly reporting covering patients seen, results, incidents, and complaints. +HIPAA compliant systems, no sale of patient data, and no advertising against it. +Learn more +ElizaChat +Expired +Student emotional support +Signed November 18, 2024 +Term November 18, 2024 – November 18, 2025 +Co-signed with Division of Professional Licensing +What the pilot does +ElizaChat is a Utah company whose app holds guided conversations with students, encourages coping strategies, and is built to recognize when a person needs a human instead. It is not therapy and it does not replace a clinician. The pilot is a phased rollout in school districts that agree to take part. +Relief granted +The concern is that a conversation like this could cross into the practice of mental health therapy, which in Utah requires a license. The agreement does not permit that. What it grants is a 30 day period to fix the problem: if the app does cross the line, ElizaChat must report it, tell the affected users, and remedy it, and the Division holds off on enforcement during that window. The protection stops there. It does not cover a claim by a student, a parent, an injured third party, or any other part of the state. +What the company agreed to +Written parental consent before any regular use by a student under 18. +Risk assessment built into the conversation, with high risk users passed to ElizaChat's clinical team and emergency contacts and connected to a licensed therapist in real time. +Clear disclosure to users that they are talking to AI and what it cannot do. +Any incident harming a user's health, safety, or finances reported to this office within 24 hours. +Anonymized storage on HIPAA compliant terms, with the district told how data is used, encrypted, and deleted. +Whatever additional limits a participating district sets. +Learn more +How We Scope Our Agreement +Three statutory limits apply to every agreement we sign with sandbox participants. +It does not last +A demonstration period runs no longer than 12 months. A participant may ask for a 12 month extension, no later than 30 days before the current period ends, and the office may grant at most two. There is no permanent version of this. The office may also end an agreement at any time and for any reason, and a participant has no property right or license to stay in the program. +It is not a blank check +An agreement changes how one identified requirement applies to one identified product. The participant remains subject to every other legal and regulatory requirement the agreement does not expressly waive or modify. A company that breaks the law, or breaks the terms of its own agreement, can be removed immediately and faces the full civil and criminal penalties it would otherwise have faced. +It is not an endorsement +Taking part in our AI sandbox does not mean the State of Utah has approved, endorsed, certified, or vouched for the product. It means the product is being tested under conditions the state can see and stop. Sandbox participants are also responsible for actions covered by their agreements. +Where these limits come from. Term and extensions: Utah Code § 13-72-403 . Scope, termination, endorsement, and state liability: § 13-72-401(7) through (10). What an applicant must prove before an agreement is possible: § 13-72-402 . The program itself: § 13-72-301 . +How Active Pilots Are Monitored +Signing an agreement is the start of the oversight, not the end of it. Every AI sandbox participant reports to us monthly for as long as its agreement is in force, and those reports carry numbers, not assurances: how many requests the system handled, how often a reviewing clinician agreed with it, and every adverse outcome. The office is required by statute to audit a participant's use of its AI while an agreement remains in effect. +We also report to the Legislature. Before November 30 each year the office reports to the Business and Labor Interim Committee on the learning agenda, on what the laboratory has found, on participation and outcomes, and on every agreement it has executed. +We publish what we can. Where a pilot generates a public outcomes report, it is published on that pilot's own page. Where a regulator or a professional board has raised an objection to a pilot, we publish the objection and our answer to it, side by side, so a reader can weigh both. +Audit duty: Utah Code § 13-72-401(6) . Annual report: § 13-72-201(3)(d) . +Tell Us What You Are Seeing +If you have used one of these products, or you work in a field one of them touches, what you know is valuable to our learning. You do not need to be a lawyer, a clinician, or a Utah resident to write to us, and you certainly do not need to wait for something to go wrong. +A concern about a pilot +Email [email protected] and name the pilot. We read everything that arrives and we take it into the next monthly review of that agreement. +A licensed professional's conduct +Complaints about a licensee, including one working with an AI system, go to the Division of Professional Licensing , which co-signed every agreement on this page. +A business practice +Misleading claims, unfair practices, and consumer harm go to the Division of Consumer Protection . An agreement with this office is no defense to a consumer protection violation. +Thinking About Applying? +Before an agreement is possible you have to show us four things: that you can build and supervise the technology responsibly, that you can pay for your obligations through the test, that the benefit to Utah consumers plausibly outweighs the risk of setting a rule aside, and that your plan to find and limit that risk is real. The scale and length of what you propose has to match the risk you are asking us to accept. +If you are interested in applying, start with the process page, and read the evidence standards before reaching out to us. That is where most first drafts fall short. +How to apply +Read the evidence standards +Follow us online +Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy +Mailing Address : P.O. Box 146741, Salt Lake City, UT 84114-6741 +Physical Address: Heber M. Wells Building 160 East 300 South Salt Lake City, Utah 84111 +Contact Info +Phone: (801) 530-6648 +Email : [email protected] +Hours : 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM +Monday - Friday +Closed for State and Federal Holidays +Services +Regulatory Relief +Learning Lab +Resources +GRAMA Record Request +Privacy Policy +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Wednesday, July 24, in observance of the Pioneer Day holiday. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Sep 02, in observance of the Labor Day holiday. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Oct 14, in observance of the Columbus Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, Nov 28, in observance of the Thanksgiving Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Feb 17, in observance of the President's Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, May 26, in observance of Memorial Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Heber Wells Building will close at 4 p.m. today. All in-person services will resume at normal business hours on Friday, June 13, and all online services will remain available today. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, June 16, in observance of the Juneteenth holiday. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, July 24, in observance of Pioneer Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, September 1, in observance of Labor Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +Translate » +< +< +< +< +< +< +< +< +< +< diff --git a/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Doctronic-Pilot-2026-09-24.html b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Doctronic-Pilot-2026-09-24.html new file mode 100644 index 00000000..e1476e3e --- /dev/null +++ b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Doctronic-Pilot-2026-09-24.html @@ -0,0 +1,799 @@ + + + + + + + + + + Office of AI Policy: Doctronic RMA - commerce.utah.gov + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
+ + + + + Schedule 1 on 1 Virtual Call Icon + + +
+ + +
+ + + +
+ + +
+ + +
+ + +

Doctronic AI Regulatory Mitigation Agreement


Utah’s First AI Prescription Renewal Regulatory Mitigation Agreement
+Doctronic AI Mitigation Agreement
+


The Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP) has approved a new pilot program with Doctronic a health technology company using AI to simplify the prescription refill process.

+

Through this initiative, Doctronic’s AI will strive to automate routine, guideline-based prescription renewals—the kind of administrative work that often slows down clinics. By safely delegating these repetitive tasks to AI, the system could lighten clinician workload, improve refill continuity, and expand patient access—all while maintaining the same safety and quality standards patients expect.


How the Program Works

Under Utah’s new regulatory relief agreement, Doctronic’s AI will operate within strict parameters and with physician oversight. The system can process 30-, 60-, or 90-day renewals for medications that have already been prescribed by a licensed provider.


Safety and Guardrails

Doctronic will roll out their AI tool in a three-phased comprehensive review process. During each phase there will be extensive identity and prescription verification protocols to prevent misuse as well as patient privacy protocols to prevent incidental disclosures. Licensed professionals will oversee the implementation of AI tools. The AI will not issue new prescriptions, handle controlled or addictive substances, or make changes to treatment plans. Doctronic doctors will follow up with individual patients as needed.


Why It Matters

Prescription renewals make up a large portion of healthcare’s daily administrative load. By automating these safe, routine requests, Doctronic hopes to help doctors focus more on patient care, reduce delays, and make it easier for patients to stay on track with their medications.


Status of the Doctronic Pilot

The Doctronic prescription tool has been live in Utah for approximately three months. While the state does not endorse or promote any particular product, given the significant public attention on this pilot, the Office of AI Policy is providing the following update from a regulatory oversight and evaluation perspective.

+

Data received — To date, the Office has received two monthly reports from Doctronic, which are in substantial compliance with the contractual agreement. The scope of data collection has been adjusted by mutual agreement as the pilot has progressed -- initially prioritizing core safety metrics, with planned expansion to economic and public health outcomes, including effects across specific patient populations. This remains aligned with the intent of the original contract.

+

Safety — To date, no serious safety incidents have been reported to the Office by either Doctronic or the public. Doctronic has provided analyses of cases where its system and supervising clinicians disagreed, using a previously published medical risk rating framework; reported cases have been categorized as “no risk,” “minor risk,” or “minor-to-moderate risk.” A third-party red teaming report identified potential vulnerabilities under adversarial usage. The Office’s review indicates that the pilot’s guardrails substantially limit the likelihood of harm to typical users, and hard stops are in place to prevent unauthorized dispensing of controlled substances. The Office has also received non-safety-related customer support inquiries, which have been referred to Doctronic.

+

Pilot progress — The pilot remains in Phase 1, in which all prescription requests require authorization by a licensed medical practitioner. As the pilot is in its early stage, additional time is needed before drawing firm conclusions about overall performance.

+

Measurements of benefit — The Office does not yet have robust evidence on benefits, as most outcome measures are scheduled for later phases once safety is further established. The Office has received anecdotal feedback describing potential benefits, including multilingual support, 24/7 availability, immediate feedback on requests, and more thorough collection of medical history where applicable. Some pharmacists have noted operational convenience in cases where patients require prescription reauthorization.

+

The Office continues to monitor the pilot under its statutory authority and may require modifications if warranted by observed risks.


Feedback

We want to hear your thoughts on this pilot program. If you have opinions or experiences related to this pilot, please share them with us:


Prescription Renewals FAQs

+

Report Summaries

In this section, you will find important documents regarding the Doctronic's ongoing data reports to the Office.


Additional Information

In this section, you will find important documents regarding the Doctronic mitigation agreement and pilot program. This disclosure supports the Office of AI Policy’s commitment to transparency and accountability. We encourage you to review these documents for further insight into our actions and decisions.

+ + +
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + + + + +
+ + +
+ + +
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Wednesday, July 24, in observance of the Pioneer Day holiday. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Sep 02, in observance of the Labor Day holiday. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Oct 14, in observance of the Columbus Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, Nov 28, in observance of the Thanksgiving Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Feb 17, in observance of the President's Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, May 26, in observance of Memorial Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Heber Wells Building will close at 4 p.m. today. All in-person services will resume at normal business hours on Friday, June 13, and all online services will remain available today.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, June 16, in observance of the Juneteenth holiday. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, July 24, in observance of Pioneer Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, September 1, in observance of Labor Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
Translate »
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
+ + \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Doctronic-Pilot-2026-09-24.txt b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Doctronic-Pilot-2026-09-24.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..8b538b35 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Doctronic-Pilot-2026-09-24.txt @@ -0,0 +1,99 @@ +Office of AI Policy: Doctronic RMA - commerce.utah.gov +Doctronic AI Regulatory Mitigation Agreement +Utah’s First AI Prescription Renewal Regulatory Mitigation Agreement +Doctronic AI Mitigation Agreement +The Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP) has approved a new pilot program with Doctronic a health technology company using AI to simplify the prescription refill process. +Through this initiative, Doctronic’s AI will strive to automate routine, guideline-based prescription renewals—the kind of administrative work that often slows down clinics. By safely delegating these repetitive tasks to AI, the system could lighten clinician workload, improve refill continuity, and expand patient access—all while maintaining the same safety and quality standards patients expect. +How the Program Works +Under Utah’s new regulatory relief agreement, Doctronic’s AI will operate within strict parameters and with physician oversight. The system can process 30-, 60-, or 90-day renewals for medications that have already been prescribed by a licensed provider. +Safety and Guardrails +Doctronic will roll out their AI tool in a three-phased comprehensive review process. During each phase there will be extensive identity and prescription verification protocols to prevent misuse as well as patient privacy protocols to prevent incidental disclosures. Licensed professionals will oversee the implementation of AI tools. The AI will not issue new prescriptions, handle controlled or addictive substances, or make changes to treatment plans. Doctronic doctors will follow up with individual patients as needed. +Why It Matters +Prescription renewals make up a large portion of healthcare’s daily administrative load. By automating these safe, routine requests, Doctronic hopes to help doctors focus more on patient care, reduce delays, and make it easier for patients to stay on track with their medications. +Status of the Doctronic Pilot +The Doctronic prescription tool has been live in Utah for approximately three months. While the state does not endorse or promote any particular product, given the significant public attention on this pilot, the Office of AI Policy is providing the following update from a regulatory oversight and evaluation perspective. +Data received — To date, the Office has received two monthly reports from Doctronic, which are in substantial compliance with the contractual agreement. The scope of data collection has been adjusted by mutual agreement as the pilot has progressed -- initially prioritizing core safety metrics, with planned expansion to economic and public health outcomes, including effects across specific patient populations. This remains aligned with the intent of the original contract. +Safety — To date, no serious safety incidents have been reported to the Office by either Doctronic or the public. Doctronic has provided analyses of cases where its system and supervising clinicians disagreed, using a previously published medical risk rating framework; reported cases have been categorized as “no risk,” “minor risk,” or “minor-to-moderate risk.” A third-party red teaming report identified potential vulnerabilities under adversarial usage. The Office’s review indicates that the pilot’s guardrails substantially limit the likelihood of harm to typical users, and hard stops are in place to prevent unauthorized dispensing of controlled substances. The Office has also received non-safety-related customer support inquiries, which have been referred to Doctronic. +Pilot progress — The pilot remains in Phase 1, in which all prescription requests require authorization by a licensed medical practitioner. As the pilot is in its early stage, additional time is needed before drawing firm conclusions about overall performance. +Measurements of benefit — The Office does not yet have robust evidence on benefits, as most outcome measures are scheduled for later phases once safety is further established. The Office has received anecdotal feedback describing potential benefits, including multilingual support, 24/7 availability, immediate feedback on requests, and more thorough collection of medical history where applicable. Some pharmacists have noted operational convenience in cases where patients require prescription reauthorization. +The Office continues to monitor the pilot under its statutory authority and may require modifications if warranted by observed risks. +Feedback +We want to hear your thoughts on this pilot program. If you have opinions or experiences related to this pilot, please share them with us: +Share your Feedback +Prescription Renewals FAQs +What changes have been made to the Doctronic contract? The Phase 2 transition criteria in the contract has been updated. Previously, the pilot progressed after 250 total prescriptions were filled. Now, each medication group will be eligible to move on to Phase 2 as a group once Doctronic has filled 250 medications in that group. Moving from phase 1 to phase 2 is still subject to OAIP approval. +Additionally, Butalbital and Flecainide have been removed from Doctronic’s formulary. +How do AI prescriptions work in these pilots? For the entirety of these pilots, these AI tools are only permitted to renew existing prescriptions ordered by a licensed physician. New prescriptions or changes in dose or frequency must be ordered by a licensed physician. +During the first phase, a licensed physician must review the prescription renewal recommended by the AI tool before it is sent to a pharmacist. If companies meet agreed upon benchmarks and perform well in the first phase, they will move on to the second phase. +During the second phase, the AI tool may submit the prescription renewal directly to the pharmacist. Pharmacists will retain authority to escalate any AI-generated renewals to a licensed physician within the prescribing company and pharmacists will be provided a method to directly communicate escalations with each company. +Prescription renewal pilots authorized by our office are designed to minimize impacts on pharmacist workflow. +What medications can be prescribed? OAIP has worked with regulators, pharmacists, clinicians, and regulatory mitigation recipients to come up with a unique formulary for each company pilot, ranging from a list of about 20 to about 200 approved medications. These formularies are designed to address common medications used for chronic conditions and mental health management, and do not include any controlled substances. +Formularies for each pilot can be found within the signed agreement. +If it’s generated by AI, then whose name is on the prescription? All prescription refills are signed and approved by a licensed physician, either directly or vicariously through the AI system’s protocol. Thus, orders are still being issued by a licensed practitioner. +What if a pharmacist needs additional information, clinical clarification, or documentation? Our regulatory mitigation recipients are required to provide a direct line for pharmacists to communicate escalations with licensed professionals employed by the prescribing company. +During these pilots, an AI tool will never prescribe new medications. Patients must go through identity and prescription verification processes in order to qualify for AI-generated prescription renewals. Through that process, the AI-enabled prescription service will have information about the original prescribing physician and can relay necessary information to a pharmacist upon request. Additionally, there is always a physician’s name attached to a prescription authorization. +What mechanisms exist to ensure alignment between provider intent and the system-generated prescriptions? There are several relevant safeguards in place in these agreements. Controlled substances are specifically excluded from the renewal process, focusing on medications with established safety profiles for routine renewal. +Additionally, patients participating in the program will only be permitted a limited number refills per prescribed medication without a subsequent in person or telehealth visit with a clinician licensed to practice medicine in the State of Utah. +Finally, The AI system includes built-in escalation protocols that automatically refer cases to human physicians when clinical complexity exceeds predetermined safety thresholds, when conflicting information is detected, or when the patient's clinical status suggests potential medication-related complications. +What oversight can the public expect? OAIP receives monthly reports from regulatory mitigation recipients to monitor their work. The details of metrics to be shared in these reports are detailed in their contracts (agreements can be found on the OAIP website). OAIP carefully vets and confirms key metrics, the most important being safety. +If an AI tool approves a refill and an adverse event occurs, how is liability determined? Our office structures these pilots in a way that makes the risk of adverse events like this low, yet we recognize the possibility of such an event. Recipients of regulatory mitigation employ a licensed physician whose name appears on AI-generated prescription renewals. As a part of our agreement, we expect companies in the regulatory mitigation program to maintain medical malpractice insurance that covers AI liabilities and risk. +Is this program permanent? These pilots are a part of the Office of AI Policy’s statutory authority to authorize AI use cases requiring regulatory relief for a limited time. +For example, the Doctronic pilot will run for 1 year (Oct 2025 - Oct 2026) with the option for the office to review and renew the contract for another year. +Does this mean any AI can practice medicine in Utah? No. Agreements are temporary and conditional on adherence to the agreement. +What changes have been made to the contract? +The Phase 2 transition criteria in the contract has been updated. Previously, the pilot progressed after 250 total prescriptions were filled. Now, each medication group will be eligible to move on to Phase 2 as a group once Doctronic has filled 250 medications in that group. Moving from phase 1 to phase 2 is still subject to OAIP approval. Additionally, Butalbital and Flecainide have been removed from Doctronic’s formulary. +Report Summaries +In this section, you will find important documents regarding the Doctronic's ongoing data reports to the Office. +Doctronic Public Report 1 (May 19, 2026) +Additional Information +In this section, you will find important documents regarding the Doctronic mitigation agreement and pilot program. This disclosure supports the Office of AI Policy’s commitment to transparency and accountability. We encourage you to review these documents for further insight into our actions and decisions. +Utah Medical Licensing Board Doctronic Letter (April 20, 2026) +Commerce Doctronic Response Letter (April 21, 2026) +Policy Memorandum (2026) +Follow us online +Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy +Mailing Address : P.O. Box 146741, Salt Lake City, UT 84114-6741 +Physical Address: Heber M. Wells Building 160 East 300 South Salt Lake City, Utah 84111 +Contact Info +Phone: (801) 530-6648 +Email : [email protected] +Hours : 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM +Monday - Friday +Closed for State and Federal Holidays +Services +Regulatory Relief +Learning Lab +Resources +GRAMA Record Request +Privacy Policy +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Wednesday, July 24, in observance of the Pioneer Day holiday. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Sep 02, in observance of the Labor Day holiday. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Oct 14, in observance of the Columbus Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, Nov 28, in observance of the Thanksgiving Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Feb 17, in observance of the President's Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, May 26, in observance of Memorial Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Heber Wells Building will close at 4 p.m. today. All in-person services will resume at normal business hours on Friday, June 13, and all online services will remain available today. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, June 16, in observance of the Juneteenth holiday. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, July 24, in observance of Pioneer Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, September 1, in observance of Labor Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +Translate » +< +< +< +< +< +< +< +< +< +< diff --git a/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-ElizaChat-Pilot-2026-09-24.html b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-ElizaChat-Pilot-2026-09-24.html new file mode 100644 index 00000000..aaa009de --- /dev/null +++ b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-ElizaChat-Pilot-2026-09-24.html @@ -0,0 +1,799 @@ + + + + + + + + + + AI Elizachat - commerce.utah.gov + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
+ + + + + Schedule 1 on 1 Virtual Call Icon + + +
+ + +
+ + + +
+ + +
+ + +
+ + +

ElizaChat


Using AI to Expand Access to Mental Health Support
+ElizaChat Agreement
+


ElizaChat is a Utah-based company with an AI-supported mental health application designed to expand access to emotional support. The platform is built to engage users through guided conversations, encourage healthy coping strategies, and recognize when human intervention is appropriate.

+

Through a pilot with the Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP), ElizaChat is exploring how AI can responsibly support mental health systems—particularly for youth—by improving early engagement and helping direct users to appropriate resources.


How the Pilot Works

Under Utah’s regulatory mitigation agreement, ElizaChat is authorized to conduct a phased rollout of its app in participating school districts. The pilot evaluates how the AI interacts with users, how effectively it identifies potential mental health risks, and how reliably it escalates situations that require licensed professional involvement.

+

The AI does not provide therapy or replace clinicians. Instead, it operates within clearly defined boundaries and serves as a supportive tool alongside existing mental health services.

Why This Matters

Demand for mental health support continues to grow, while access to timely care remains limited—especially for young people. This pilot allows policymakers, educators, and clinicians to learn in real-world settings whether AI tools can help engage users earlier, surface concerns sooner, and support pathways to care—without compromising safety or trust.

+

By testing these tools under oversight, Utah is helping shape how emerging technologies may responsibly complement mental health services.

Safety, Oversight, and Guardrails

The ElizaChat pilot includes strong protections:

+ +
    +
  • +

    Built-in risk assessments to identify distress

    +
  • +
  • +

    Immediate escalation to trusted adults for high-risk situations
    +

    +
  • +
  • +

    Clear disclosures to users about AI use and limitations
    +

    +
  • +
  • +

    Robust data privacy, anonymization, and security standards
    +

    +
  • +
  • +

    Parental consent and topical guardrails

    +
  • +

OAIP and the Division of Professional Licensing provide ongoing oversight, and ElizaChat must submit regular reports on performance, safety, and outcomes.


Feedback

We want to hear your thoughts on this pilot program. If you have opinions or experiences related to this pilot, please share them with us:


+ + +
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + + + + +
+ + +
+ + +
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Wednesday, July 24, in observance of the Pioneer Day holiday. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Sep 02, in observance of the Labor Day holiday. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Oct 14, in observance of the Columbus Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, Nov 28, in observance of the Thanksgiving Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Feb 17, in observance of the President's Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, May 26, in observance of Memorial Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Heber Wells Building will close at 4 p.m. today. All in-person services will resume at normal business hours on Friday, June 13, and all online services will remain available today.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, June 16, in observance of the Juneteenth holiday. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, July 24, in observance of Pioneer Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, September 1, in observance of Labor Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
Translate »
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
+ + \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-ElizaChat-Pilot-2026-09-24.txt b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-ElizaChat-Pilot-2026-09-24.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..d0e48efa --- /dev/null +++ b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-ElizaChat-Pilot-2026-09-24.txt @@ -0,0 +1,70 @@ +AI Elizachat - commerce.utah.gov +ElizaChat +Using AI to Expand Access to Mental Health Support +ElizaChat Agreement +ElizaChat is a Utah-based company with an AI-supported mental health application designed to expand access to emotional support. The platform is built to engage users through guided conversations, encourage healthy coping strategies, and recognize when human intervention is appropriate. +Through a pilot with the Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP), ElizaChat is exploring how AI can responsibly support mental health systems—particularly for youth—by improving early engagement and helping direct users to appropriate resources. +How the Pilot Works +Under Utah’s regulatory mitigation agreement, ElizaChat is authorized to conduct a phased rollout of its app in participating school districts. The pilot evaluates how the AI interacts with users, how effectively it identifies potential mental health risks, and how reliably it escalates situations that require licensed professional involvement. +The AI does not provide therapy or replace clinicians. Instead, it operates within clearly defined boundaries and serves as a supportive tool alongside existing mental health services. +Why This Matters +Demand for mental health support continues to grow, while access to timely care remains limited—especially for young people. This pilot allows policymakers, educators, and clinicians to learn in real-world settings whether AI tools can help engage users earlier, surface concerns sooner, and support pathways to care—without compromising safety or trust. +By testing these tools under oversight, Utah is helping shape how emerging technologies may responsibly complement mental health services. +Safety, Oversight, and Guardrails +The ElizaChat pilot includes strong protections: +Built-in risk assessments to identify distress +Immediate escalation to trusted adults for high-risk situations +Clear disclosures to users about AI use and limitations +Robust data privacy, anonymization, and security standards +Parental consent and topical guardrails +OAIP and the Division of Professional Licensing provide ongoing oversight, and ElizaChat must submit regular reports on performance, safety, and outcomes. +Feedback +We want to hear your thoughts on this pilot program. If you have opinions or experiences related to this pilot, please share them with us: +Share your Feedback +Follow us online +Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy +Mailing Address : P.O. Box 146741, Salt Lake City, UT 84114-6741 +Physical Address: Heber M. Wells Building 160 East 300 South Salt Lake City, Utah 84111 +Contact Info +Phone: (801) 530-6648 +Email : [email protected] +Hours : 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM +Monday - Friday +Closed for State and Federal Holidays +Services +Regulatory Relief +Learning Lab +Resources +GRAMA Record Request +Privacy Policy +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Wednesday, July 24, in observance of the Pioneer Day holiday. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Sep 02, in observance of the Labor Day holiday. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Oct 14, in observance of the Columbus Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, Nov 28, in observance of the Thanksgiving Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Feb 17, in observance of the President's Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, May 26, in observance of Memorial Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Heber Wells Building will close at 4 p.m. today. All in-person services will resume at normal business hours on Friday, June 13, and all online services will remain available today. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, June 16, in observance of the Juneteenth holiday. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, July 24, in observance of Pioneer Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, September 1, in observance of Labor Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +Translate » +< +< +< +< +< +< +< +< +< +< diff --git a/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Legion-Pilot-2026-09-24.html b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Legion-Pilot-2026-09-24.html new file mode 100644 index 00000000..fd9a32f9 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Legion-Pilot-2026-09-24.html @@ -0,0 +1,809 @@ + + + + + + + + + + AI Legion Health - commerce.utah.gov + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
+ + + + + Schedule 1 on 1 Virtual Call Icon + + +
+ + +
+ + + +
+ + +
+ + +
+ + +

Smarter Psychiatry. Faster Refills. Safer Care.

Legion Health is an AI-enabled psychiatry clinic that combines licensed clinicians with advanced technology to improve access to care. Their focus is on safe AI routine prescription refills so that patients can get care faster and clinicians can focus on where they are needed most.

The Approach

Legion’s approach is intentionally narrow. The system only supports refills for stable patients on existing, non-controlled medications, like common treatments for anxiety and depression. It does not diagnose, prescribe new medications, or adjust doses.

What Patients Experience

Patients can request a refill in minutes. They are clearly informed that AI is part of the process, they verify their identity and prescription and answer a few targeted questions about how they are doing. If everything checks out, the refill is sent to their pharmacy. If not, they are quickly connected to a clinician.

Why It Matters

    +
  • +

    Access Gap: Many parts of Utah don’t have enough mental health providers, making it difficult for people to get care.

    +
  • +
  • +

    Reducing Bottlenecks: Prescription refills can be slow and time-consuming. Making this process faster helps patients get their medication without delays and stay on track.

    +
  • +
  • +

    Expanding Clinical Capacity: By handling routine tasks, AI gives providers more time to focus on patients who need more complex care.

    +
  • +

Why It Matters

Defined Scope and Accountability
This pilot runs for 12 months with special approval. While certain rules are relaxed for this project, all standard patient protections and legal responsibilities still apply.

+

Strict Boundaries
The AI is limited to renewing existing, non-controlled prescriptions. It cannot initiate new treatments, adjust dosages, or prescribe higher-risk medications.

+

Built-In Escalation
Conservative safety checks ensure that any risk—such as suicidality, severe side effects, signs of mania, or pregnancy—triggers immediate review by a licensed clinician. Patients may also request human review at any time.

+

Phased Validation
The system is introduced gradually to ensure safety at every step:

+
    +
  • +

    First 250 requests: reviewed by a licensed clinician before completion

    +
  • +
  • +

    Next 1,000 requests: undergo intensive retrospective review to confirm accuracy

    +
  • +
  • +

    Ongoing: monthly randomized sampling and auditing of cases

    +
  • +
  • +

    Detailed Monthly reporting to OAIP

    +
  • +

Feedback

We want to hear your thoughts on this pilot program. If you have opinions or experiences related to this pilot, please share them with us:


Prescription Renewals FAQs

+
+ + +
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + + + + +
+ + +
+ + +
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Wednesday, July 24, in observance of the Pioneer Day holiday. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Sep 02, in observance of the Labor Day holiday. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Oct 14, in observance of the Columbus Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, Nov 28, in observance of the Thanksgiving Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Feb 17, in observance of the President's Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, May 26, in observance of Memorial Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Heber Wells Building will close at 4 p.m. today. All in-person services will resume at normal business hours on Friday, June 13, and all online services will remain available today.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, June 16, in observance of the Juneteenth holiday. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, July 24, in observance of Pioneer Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+ +
+
+ +
+
+ The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, September 1, in observance of Labor Day. However, online services will remain available.
+
+ + + +
+ +
+ + + +
+ close-link
+ +
+ + +
+ + + + +
+
+
Translate »
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
+ + \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Legion-Pilot-2026-09-24.txt b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Legion-Pilot-2026-09-24.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..40ae9474 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/admission/sources/oaip-pilots/OAIP-Legion-Pilot-2026-09-24.txt @@ -0,0 +1,94 @@ +AI Legion Health - commerce.utah.gov +Legion Health AI +Legion Health AI Mitigation Agreement +Smarter Psychiatry. Faster Refills. Safer Care. +Legion Health is an AI-enabled psychiatry clinic that combines licensed clinicians with advanced technology to improve access to care. Their focus is on safe AI routine prescription refills so that patients can get care faster and clinicians can focus on where they are needed most. +The Approach +Legion’s approach is intentionally narrow. The system only supports refills for stable patients on existing, non-controlled medications, like common treatments for anxiety and depression. It does not diagnose, prescribe new medications, or adjust doses. +What Patients Experience +Patients can request a refill in minutes. They are clearly informed that AI is part of the process, they verify their identity and prescription and answer a few targeted questions about how they are doing. If everything checks out, the refill is sent to their pharmacy. If not, they are quickly connected to a clinician. +Why It Matters +Access Gap: Many parts of Utah don’t have enough mental health providers, making it difficult for people to get care. +Reducing Bottlenecks: Prescription refills can be slow and time-consuming. Making this process faster helps patients get their medication without delays and stay on track. +Expanding Clinical Capacity: By handling routine tasks, AI gives providers more time to focus on patients who need more complex care. +Why It Matters +Defined Scope and Accountability +This pilot runs for 12 months with special approval. While certain rules are relaxed for this project, all standard patient protections and legal responsibilities still apply. +Strict Boundaries +The AI is limited to renewing existing, non-controlled prescriptions. It cannot initiate new treatments, adjust dosages, or prescribe higher-risk medications. +Built-In Escalation +Conservative safety checks ensure that any risk—such as suicidality, severe side effects, signs of mania, or pregnancy—triggers immediate review by a licensed clinician. Patients may also request human review at any time. +Phased Validation +The system is introduced gradually to ensure safety at every step: +First 250 requests: reviewed by a licensed clinician before completion +Next 1,000 requests: undergo intensive retrospective review to confirm accuracy +Ongoing: monthly randomized sampling and auditing of cases +Detailed Monthly reporting to OAIP +Feedback +We want to hear your thoughts on this pilot program. If you have opinions or experiences related to this pilot, please share them with us: +Share your Feedback +Prescription Renewals FAQs +How do AI prescriptions work in these pilots? For the entirety of these pilots, these AI tools are only permitted to renew existing prescriptions ordered by a licensed physician. New prescriptions or changes in dose or frequency must be ordered by a licensed physician. +During the first phase, a licensed physician must review the prescription renewal recommended by the AI tool before it is sent to a pharmacist. If companies meet agreed upon benchmarks and perform well in the first phase, they will move on to the second phase. +During the second phase, the AI tool may submit the prescription renewal directly to the pharmacist. Pharmacists will retain authority to escalate any AI-generated renewals to a licensed physician within the prescribing company and pharmacists will be provided a method to directly communicate escalations with each company. +Prescription renewal pilots authorized by our office are designed to minimize impacts on pharmacist workflow. +What medications can be prescribed? OAIP has worked with regulators, pharmacists, clinicians, and regulatory mitigation recipients to come up with a unique formulary for each company pilot, ranging from a list of about 20 to about 200 approved medications. These formularies are designed to address common medications used for chronic conditions and mental health management, and do not include any controlled substances. +Formularies for each pilot can be found within the signed agreement. +If it’s generated by AI, then whose name is on the prescription? All prescription refills are signed and approved by a licensed physician, either directly or vicariously through the AI system’s protocol. Thus, orders are still being issued by a licensed practitioner. +What if a pharmacist needs additional information, clinical clarification, or documentation? Our regulatory mitigation recipients are required to provide a direct line for pharmacists to communicate escalations with licensed professionals employed by the prescribing company. +During these pilots, an AI tool will never prescribe new medications. Patients must go through identity and prescription verification processes in order to qualify for AI-generated prescription renewals. Through that process, the AI-enabled prescription service will have information about the original prescribing physician and can relay necessary information to a pharmacist upon request. Additionally, there is always a physician’s name attached to a prescription authorization. +What mechanisms exist to ensure alignment between provider intent and the system-generated prescriptions? There are several relevant safeguards in place in these agreements. Controlled substances are specifically excluded from the renewal process, focusing on medications with established safety profiles for routine renewal. +Additionally, patients participating in the program will only be permitted a limited number refills per prescribed medication without a subsequent in person or telehealth visit with a clinician licensed to practice medicine in the State of Utah. +Finally, The AI system includes built-in escalation protocols that automatically refer cases to human physicians when clinical complexity exceeds predetermined safety thresholds, when conflicting information is detected, or when the patient's clinical status suggests potential medication-related complications. +What oversight can the public expect? OAIP receives monthly reports from regulatory mitigation recipients to monitor their work. The details of metrics to be shared in these reports are detailed in their contracts (agreements can be found on the OAIP website). OAIP carefully vets and confirms key metrics, the most important being safety. +If an AI tool approves a refill and an adverse event occurs, how is liability determined? Our office structures these pilots in a way that makes the risk of adverse events like this low, yet we recognize the possibility of such an event. Recipients of regulatory mitigation employ a licensed physician whose name appears on AI-generated prescription renewals. As a part of our agreement, we expect companies in the regulatory mitigation program to maintain medical malpractice insurance that covers AI liabilities and risk. +Is this program permanent? These pilots are a part of the Office of AI Policy’s statutory authority to authorize AI use cases requiring regulatory relief for a limited time. +For example, the Doctronic pilot will run for 1 year (Oct 2025 - Oct 2026) with the option for the office to review and renew the contract for another year. +Does this mean any AI can practice medicine in Utah? No. Agreements are temporary and conditional on adherence to the agreement. +Follow us online +Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy +Mailing Address : P.O. Box 146741, Salt Lake City, UT 84114-6741 +Physical Address: Heber M. Wells Building 160 East 300 South Salt Lake City, Utah 84111 +Contact Info +Phone: (801) 530-6648 +Email : [email protected] +Hours : 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM +Monday - Friday +Closed for State and Federal Holidays +Services +Regulatory Relief +Learning Lab +Resources +GRAMA Record Request +Privacy Policy +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Wednesday, July 24, in observance of the Pioneer Day holiday. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Sep 02, in observance of the Labor Day holiday. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Oct 14, in observance of the Columbus Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, Nov 28, in observance of the Thanksgiving Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, Feb 17, in observance of the President's Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, May 26, in observance of Memorial Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Heber Wells Building will close at 4 p.m. today. All in-person services will resume at normal business hours on Friday, June 13, and all online services will remain available today. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, June 16, in observance of the Juneteenth holiday. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Thursday, July 24, in observance of Pioneer Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +The Utah Department of Commerce will be closed on Monday, September 1, in observance of Labor Day. However, online services will remain available. +Powered by Convert Plus +Translate » +< +< +< +< +< +< +< +< +< +< diff --git a/data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.ocr.txt b/data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.ocr.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..6425ba5d --- /dev/null +++ b/data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.ocr.txt @@ -0,0 +1,867 @@ +=== page 01 +AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE OFFICE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE POLICY, +LEGION HEALTH PA, LEGION HEALTH, INC., AND THE DIVISION OF +PROFESSIONAL LICENSING + +Section 1. Parties + +A. The Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy created in Utah Code § 13-72-201, an office +within the Utah Department of Commerce (hereinafter “Office”). + +B. Legion Health PA and Legion Health, Inc. (jointly hereinafter “Participant’’). + +C. The Division of Professional Licensing (hereinafter the “Division’). + +Section 2. Commencement Date and Participation Period + +A. The term of this Agreement shall be twelve (12) months from the Commencement Date. + +B. The Commencement Date shall be the date on which Participant delivers written notice to the +Office that the project is ready to proceed. + +Section 3. Purpose and Authority + +A. The Office is a state agency with the authority to create and administer the Artificial +Intelligence Learning Laboratory Program (Utah Code. § 13-72-301). + +B. The Office may negotiate and grant limited regulatory mitigation agreements to further the +purposes of the Artificial Intelligence Learning Laboratory program (Utah Code § 13-72-302, +transitioning to Utah Code § 13-72-401 effective May 6, 2026). + +C. Participant has applied to the Office for this regulatory mitigation and the applicant’s final +proposal and safety protocol is incorporated in Schedule B of this Agreement (hereinafter +referred to as the “Proposal”). + +D. This agreement is a grant of regulatory mitigation only and does not constitute an +endorsement or approval from the State of Utah or any of its political subdivisions of + +Participant’s use of artificial intelligence technologies. + +Section 4. Scope of Mitigation +=== page 02 +A. The Office, in consultation with the Division, grants regulatory mitigation to Participant as +outlined in Schedule A with respect to Participant’s provision of services during the term of this +Agreement using artificial intelligence technologies as detailed further in the Proposal. It is +agreed and understood that the Agreement only grants mitigation as specified in Schedule A. + +B. The mitigation specified in Schedule A is not binding until this document has been signed by +all parties and Participant has communicated the Commencement Date to the Office. + +C. Participant is subject to all Federal, State and local laws not expressly waived or modified by +the terms of this Agreement, including any changes to existing law during the demonstration +period (Utah Code § 13-72-302(6), transitioning to § 13-72-401(7) effective May 6, 2026). For +the avoidance of doubt, this Agreement does not waive or modify any legal remedies available to +any individual harmed by any action of Participant’s AI technology, other members of the public, +or the State of Utah or its political subdivisions other than the Division. If relevant laws change +during the demonstration period and affect the enforceability of any provision of this Agreement, +the Office may require the parties to amend this agreement. If no new agreement can be made, +this Agreement will be terminated effective on the day the relevant law went into effect. + +Section 5. Scope of Activities + +A. Participant shall perform all relevant activities in accordance with the methodologies and +safety protocols set forth in the Proposal. The Proposal may be amended by Participant or the +Office’s Director (in consultation with the Division) as long as the amendment approval is in + +writing and signed by all Parties. + +B. Participant may not use regulatory mitigation specified in this agreement to create or provide +goods, services, or labor not specified in the Proposal. + +Section 6. Participant Obligations + +Unless the Office determines otherwise in writing, Participant agrees as follows: + +A. Capacity + +Participant shall possess the technical expertise, financial resources, and capability to responsibly +deploy and use the proposed artificial intelligence technology. Participant shall also have an +effective plan and protocols to monitor and minimize both identified and unknown risks from the + +activities of the Participant’s AI technology. + +B. Safeguards +=== page 03 +1. Participant shall abide by safeguards, including safety measures, testing protocols, +quality assurance, and oversight methodologies outlined in the Proposal to protect users +of Participant’s AI technology from potential harm that may result from such activities. +Participant shall abide by any other safeguards prescribed by the Office set forth in this +Agreement. + +2. Participant is fully responsible for the proper and efficient monitoring, operation, and +maintenance of any activities stemming from the mitigation granted in this Agreement. + +3. In the event a user or third party is harmed as a result of using the Participant’s AI +technology, nothing in this Agreement prevents any user of the Participant’s AI +technology, any third party, the State of Utah or any of its subdivisions other than the +Division, from seeking any legally available remedy from Participant. + +C. Registration +Participant must be registered to do business in the State of Utah. +D. Permissions + +1. Participant may make public statements or engage in related publicity consistent with +scope and purpose of this Agreement, except that Participant shall not include any +statement in advertising, media or promotional materials that implies or could reasonably +be construed as the Office or State of Utah’s endorsement of Participant or Participant’s +technology, unless the Office provides prior written approval. + +2. Participant is responsible for obtaining and maintaining all necessary permits, licenses, +and permissions required for the activities in Participant’s Proposal from other federal, +state, or local government agencies having jurisdiction over the project. Participant shall +furnish any such permits and approvals to the Office upon request. + +E. Data Security + +1. Participant shall comply with all privacy and safe data usage requirements as set forth +in the Proposal and as stipulated by the Office. Participant shall not use any information, +technology, or advantage gained from this Agreement in a manner that is illegal, +unethical, or contrary to public interest, including, selling user data or information, or +using user data or information for advertising. +=== page 04 +2. For the avoidance of doubt, no data protection or privacy law or regulation, whether by +statute or common law, is waived or modified by the terms of this agreement. + +F. Cybersecurity + +Participant shall implement reasonable protections against data leaks to minimize the risk of +breach of confidential information in accordance with the data security and privacy protection +protocols described in Participant’s Proposal and with general cybersecurity best practices. These +protections include: + +1. Keeping data system testing environments separate from production environments; + +2. Maintaining reasonable server and storage capacity to enable continuous availability of +data systems; + +3. Formally managing technology assets through their lifecycle; and + +4. Using integrity checking mechanisms to verify software, firmware, and information +integrity. + +Participant shall ensure that its cyber security framework is regularly updated to address +emerging threats and vulnerabilities. For the avoidance of doubt, no cybersecurity law or +regulation, whether by statute or common law, is waived or modified by the terms of this + +agreement. +G. Disclosures to Users and Pharmacists + +1. When a Utah user indicates they are requesting the renewal of a prescription as +described in Participant’s Proposal, and before Participant's AI technology engages +further with the user regarding the prescription request, Participant shall disclose the +following to the user: + +a. The name and contact information of Participant. + +b. That the user is interacting with generative artificial intelligence pursuant to +Utah Code §§ 13-77-103 and 13-72a-203; + +c. The precise manner, means, and extent in which all user data and information, +including all correspondence with Participant’s AI technology, will be used or +shared by Participant; and +=== page 05 +d. That the user is engaging with a temporary offering of AI technology through +an agreement with Utah’s Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy. Participant shall +share with users a phone number and/or website address provided by the Office +where users may provide feedback regarding the use of Participant’s Al +technology. + +2. Disclosures to users shall be provided in a clear and conspicuous form and a user shall +acknowledge receipt of the disclosure before a user may access any functions of +Participant’s AI technology. + +3. Participant shall disclose the following to any pharmacist or pharmacy receiving +prescription renewals authorized by this agreement: + +a. That the prescription renewal was generated by artificial intelligence +technology; + +b. That such renewals are authorized by the Office of AI Policy and the Division +of Professional Licensing pursuant to this agreement; + +c. Contact information for Participant representatives that can answer any +questions from the pharmacist or pharmacy. + +d. A phone number and/or website address provided by the Office where the +pharmacist or pharmacy may ask questions/provide feedback regarding the +pharmacist’s or pharmacy’s experience with Participant’s AI technology. + +4. Participant shall disclose to the Office the manner in which they will communicate +such required disclosures to pharmacists or pharmacies. + +5. For the avoidance of doubt, no disclosure law or regulation, whether by statute or +common law, is waived or modified by the terms of this agreement. + +H. Reporting + +1. Participant shall submit a monthly report to the Office at ai@utah.gov. Monthly reports +shall detail information regarding the users of Participant’s AI technology, including +impact analyses, technology assessments, information about user complaints, and any +other relevant information requested by the Office. Reports shall also include: +=== page 06 +a. Relevant qualitative and quantitative data of users from the State of Utah, +including: + +i. the number of requests for prescription renewals accepted by +Participant’s AI technology; + +ii. the number of requests for prescription renewals denied by Participant’s +AI technology; and + +iii. the number of accepted requests and the number of denied requests that +were reviewed by a Utah-licensed prescribing clinician in accordance with +sections 4-5 of the Proposal and the respective agreement rates between +Participant’s AI technology and a Utah-licensed prescribing clinician on +acceptances and denials. + +b. Trends or observations made by Participant’s in-house or contracted licensed +physicians. + +c. Excerpts from a random sampling of successful and unsuccessful applications +of Participant’s artificial intelligence technology, with any personally identifiable +information of a user redacted. + +2. Participant shall report to the office: +a. The results of the performance benchmarking for sections 4-5 of the Proposal. + +b. Any user complaint reported to Participant or adverse health outcome resulting +from a renewal of a prescription by Participant’s AI technology of which +Participant becomes aware. + +3. Not later than 30 days after the end date of this Agreement, Participant will submit a +written report to the Office describing an overview of Participant’s deployment and user’s +use of Participant’s AI technology including any incidents of harm to users, legal action +filed against Participant as a result of the demonstration, and complaints filed as a result +of the such deployment and use. + +4. The Office is a governmental entity subject to the Government Records Access and +Management Act, Utah Code §§ 63G-2-103 to 63G-2-901 (“GRAMA”). Accordingly, +certain records within possession or control of the Office, including without limitation +this Agreement, may be subject to public disclosure. The Office’s confidentiality +=== page 07 +obligations shall comply with GRAMA. The Office will classify Participant’s application +for regulatory mitigation and any reports provided to the Office in accordance with + +Participant’s obligations in this Section as a protected record in accordance with Utah +Code §§ 63G-2-305 and 63G-2-309. + +J. Failure to meet obligations. + +If Participant fails to meet any of the obligations set forth in this section, the Office may request +more comprehensive reports from Participant and a mutually agreeable plan for resolving any +issues related to such obligations. In such an instance, Participant agrees to provide all +reasonably requested information. Participant shall have at least thirty (30) business days, or a +longer period if reasonably required given the nature of the issue, to propose and implement a +cure. The Office shall not unreasonably withhold or delay acceptance of Participant’s proposed +plan or cure. If, after good-faith collaboration and the expiration of the applicable cure period, or +if curing is not possible, Participant cannot put a plan forward to adequately resolve the issue, as +determined by the Office, the Office may elect to terminate this Agreement and thereafter the +Division may pursue normal administrative remedies. + +Section 7. Notice + +All notices required to be given, by either Party to the other, shall be deemed fully given when +delivered physically or by email. + +Section 8. Indemnification + +Participant agrees to hold the Office and the Division, including their agents, officers, and +employees harmless from any claims, liabilities, damages, losses, or expenses arising from the +services and technology provided by Participant under its Proposal and enabled by the mitigation +granted in this Agreement. + +Section 9. Intellectual Property + +For the avoidance of doubt, nothing in this Agreement shall be construed to transfer, assign, +license, or otherwise convey any intellectual property rights from one party to the other. Each +party retains all right, title, and interest in and to any intellectual property it owned, developed, or +otherwise controlled prior to entering into this Agreement, as well as any intellectual property it +develops independently of this Agreement. No rights are granted by implication, estoppel, or +otherwise except as expressly set forth in this Agreement. + +Section 10. Choice of Law, Venue, and Jurisdiction +=== page 08 +This Agreement shall be governed by and construed pursuant to the laws of the State of Utah. +The Parties will submit to the jurisdiction of the court of the State of Utah for any dispute arising +out of this Agreement or the breach thereof. Venue shall be in the Salt Lake Department, Third +Judicial District in and for Salt Lake County, State of Utah. + +Section 11. Termination + +The Office or Participant may terminate this Agreement at any time, and for any reason, prior to +the completion of the 12-month mitigation period by providing written notice to Participant. +Upon receipt of such notice, the mitigation provisions shall continue to protect Participant for +activities or services performed pursuant to the Proposal and are in compliance with the terms of +this Agreement up to the effective date of termination of this Agreement, but shall not apply +prospectively thereafter (Utah Code § 13-72-302(7), transitioning to Utah Code § 13-72-401(8) +effective May 6, 2026). + +Section 12. Assignment, Transfer, Collateral Use + +Participant may not assign or transfer regulatory mitigation granted in this Agreement without +the prior written consent of the Office. Approval of an assignment does not establish any legal +relationship between the Office and any other third party. The Office shall not be liable for any +act or omission committed pursuant to such an assignment. + +Section 13. Entire Agreement + +This Agreement, including all referenced documents and attachments, constitutes the entire +agreement between the Parties regarding the subject matter hereof. This Agreement supersedes +any other written or oral understanding of the Parties. This Agreement may not be modified +except by a written instrument executed by all Parties. This Agreement may be signed in +counterparts, and may be signed electronically. + +Section 14. Agreement Extension + +Participant may request an extension of up to 12 months for regulatory mitigation no later than +30 days before the end of an ongoing 12-month period. The Office shall grant or deny an +extension request before expiration of the initial demonstration period in accordance with Utah +Code § 13-72-305 (transitioning to Utah Code § 13-72-403 effective May 6, 2026). +=== page 09 +Section 15. Signatures + +The individuals executing this Agreement represent and warrant that they have the legal capacity +and authority to do so on behalf of their respective legal entities. + +IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties have executed this Agreement as of the latter of the dates +written below and the Agreement will be effective as of the Commencement Date described in +Section 2. + +Zach oa 18, 2026 15:33:55 MDT) 03/1 8/2026 + +ZACHARY BOYD, PhD Date +Director +Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy + +tithe 3/19/2026 + +MARK STEINAGEL Date +Director +Division of Professional Licensing + +Dem Kit 3/19/2026 + +Jor’Kole (Mar 19, 2026 08:11:38 EDT) + +JONATHAN KOLE, M.D. Date +President and CEO + +Legion Health, PA + +Yash M Fate 08:21:05 PDT) 03/1 9/2 026 + +YASH PATEL Date +CEO +Legion Health, Inc. + +=== page 10 +Schedule A + +Section 16. Mitigation Offered + +The Office, in agreement with the Division, grants Participant the following regulatory +mitigation measures: + +A. During the participation period described in Section 2 of this Agreement, Participant may, +using its artificial intelligence technology, authorize the renewal of a Utah resident’s verified +prescription and issue such prescriptions to a pharmacist licensed in the state under Utah Code § +58-17b. + +B. The Division will forgo any enforcement action for unlawful conduct, as defined in Utah +Code § 58-1-501(1) and administrative rule UAC R156-1-501(2)(b), in connection with the +services and/or technology provided by Participant hereunder during the period specified in +section 2 solely for the use of Participant’s artificial intelligence technology to authorize the +renewal of prescriptions as described in the Proposal, so long as Participant abides by the terms +of this Agreement. This only applies to enforcement related to actions authorized by this +Agreement and does not preclude enforcement actions for other unlawful or unprofessional +conduct. + +C. The Division will forgo any enforcement action against Participant under Utah Code § +26B-4-704(6) and administrative rule UAC R156-1-602 provided that Participant’s artificial +intelligence technology meets all obligations of telehealth providers in section 17(A) of this +Agreement. + +D. The Division will forgo enforcement of the following provisions against any affiliated +professional entity or provider employed or contracted by Participant who (1) abides by the +terms of this Agreement and of any agreement the entity or provider has with Participant; (2) acts +in reliance on Participant's artificial intelligence technology to facilitate the renewal of a +prescription solely by being the named prescriber for such renewals; and (3) does not interact +directly with a patient or other health care provider: + +1. Utah Code §§ 58-1-501(1)(a)(i),(d), and (f) and (2)(a)(i) and (a)(xiii) and +administrative rule UAC R156-1-501(2)(b), for unlawful or unprofessional conduct +relating to actions authorized by this Agreement; and + +2. Provisions relating to unlawful or unprofessional conduct in Utah Code §§ + +58-3 1b-501-503, 58-67-501-503, and 58-68-501-503, for unlawful or unprofessional +conduct relating to actions authorized by this Agreement. +=== page 11 +E. The Division will forgo enforcement of the following provisions against any affiliated +professional entity or provider employed or contracted by Participant who (1) abides by the +terms of this Agreement and of any agreement the entity or provider has with Participant; (2) acts +in reliance on Participant's artificial intelligence technology to render clinical guidance, +consultation, health education, care coordination, or other similar supportive services; and (3) +does not interact directly with a patient or other health care provider: + +1. Utah Code §§ 58-1-501(1)(a)(@),(d), and (f) and (2)(a)(i) and (a)(xiii) and +administrative rule UAC R156-1-501(2)(b), for unlawful or unprofessional conduct +relating to actions authorized by this Agreement; and + +2. Provisions relating to unlawful or unprofessional conduct in Utah Code §§ +58-31b-501-503, 58-60-109-111, 58-61-501-503, 58-67-501-503, 58-68-501-503, and +58-70a-502-504, for unlawful or unprofessional conduct relating to actions authorized by +this Agreement. + +F. Nothing in this agreement applies to any other services offered by Participant on the Legion +website or through any other manner other than the renewal of prescriptions as described in the +Proposal, nor does it provide any exemption to, stay of enforcement of, or other mitigation from, +any other provision of law related to such additional services. + +G. For the avoidance of doubt the mitigation described in Section 16 only applies to enforcement +related to actions authorized by this Agreement and does not preclude enforcement actions for +other unlawful or unprofessional conduct. + +Section 17. Obligations of Participant + +A. Participant’s artificial intelligence technology shall adhere to all requirements as a telehealth +provider as set forth in Utah Code § 26B-4-704, with the exception of the following: + +1. Participant’s artificial intelligence technology shall be considered in compliance with +subsection (2)(b) and (c) of such section, and not in violation of subsection (4) of such +section if Participant’s artificial intelligence technology follows the protocols outlined in +section 4 of the Proposal. + +2. Participant’s artificial intelligence technology shall be considered in compliance with +subsection 2(e) of such section if Participant’s artificial intelligence technology follows +the protocols outlined in section 4 of the Proposal. + +3. Subsection (5) of such section shall not apply to Participant’s artificial intelligence +technology. +=== page 12 +B. Participants shall maintain patient’s electronic health records in a portable format or allow +patients to promptly download or share their electronic health records upon request. + +C. Participant’s artificial intelligence technology shall adhere to all requirements as a mental +health chatbot as set forth in Utah Code § 13-72a. + +D. Participant shall abide by the procedures and safety protocols in the Proposal and ensure that: +1. Any health care provider, as defined in 45 CFR § 160.103, who interacts directly with +an individual residing in the State of Utah through a telehealth service, as defined in Utah + +Code § 26B-4-704(1)(h) is a provider, as defined in Utah Code § 26B-4-704(1)(f). + +2. Participant does not utilize its artificial intelligence technology to authorize renewals +of any medications not listed on the formulary in section 2 of the Proposal. +=== page 13 +Schedule B + +The Proposal + +0) Summary + +Legion Health proposes a pilot under OAIP’s Al Learning Lab / regulatory mitigation framework +to evaluate a narrowly-scoped, safety-first “Mental Health Refill Autopilot” for a constrained set +of non-controlled maintenance psychiatric medication renewals previously prescribed by a +licensed health care provider. + +Al determines eligibility and (when eligible) authorizes and transmits a renewal request to the +pharmacy under an OAIP-approved protocol, with conservative eligibility gates, explicit +disclosures/consent, phased review intensity, and clear escalation-to-clinician pathways for any +uncertainty or out-of-scope case. + +1) Who we are + +Legion Health is an Al-native, fully integrated psychiatry clinic. We deliver clinician-led care with +Al-powered automations (intake summarization, population risk screening, operational +automation, revenue cycle automation) and maintain documented safety protocols and +auditability for clinical operations. We have completed tens of thousands of visits in Texas with +exceptional clinical outcomes and patient satisfaction." + +1.1 Why Utah / why now + +e Prescription renewals are high-volume, high-friction, and directly tied to continuity of care +and avoidable deterioration. + +e All of Utah’s 29 counties have designated mental health shortages, and up to 500k +(almost 20%) residents are not receiving any behavioral health care. + +e This pilot would allow Utahns to get high-quality mental healthcare much more quickly +and much more affordably than ever before. + +2) Proposed pilot scope + +‘72 NPS (industry avg 35) and 5+ average visits completed per patient (industry avg 2.7). +=== page 14 +2.1 Population + +e Utah residents receiving services while physically located in Utah + +2.2 Medication scope + +Psychiatric Formulary + +Medication + +On-Label Psychiatry + +Acceptable Off-Label Uses + +Indications (Psychiatry) +Fluoxetine (Prozac) MDD; Panic disorder; OCD GAD +Sertraline (Zoloft) MDD; Panic disorder; PTSD; | GAD +OCD +Escitalopram (Lexapro) MDD; GAD - +Citalopram (Celexa) MDD GAD +Paroxetine (Paxil) MDD; Panic disorder; PTSD; | GAD +OCD +Venlafaxine XR (Effexor XR) | MDD; GAD; Panic disorder - +Desvenlafaxine (Pristiq) MDD GAD +Duloxetine (Cymbalta) MDD; GAD PTSD +Bupropion SR (Wellbutrin MDD ADHD adjunct; SSRI/SNRI +SR) sexual dysfunction +Bupropion XL (Wellbutrin XL) | MDD ADHD adjunct; SSRI/SNRI +sexual dysfunction +Trazodone (Desyrel) - Insomnia +Renew only if $150 mg +nightly +Mirtazapine (Remeron) MDD Insomnia; appetite +Renew only if baseline + +q6-month metabolic/CV +monitoring satisfied +Buspirone (BuSpar) GAD SSRI/SNRI augmentation for + +anxiety + +Hydroxyzine HCI (Atarax) + +Anxiety PRN; insomnia PRN +Renew only with quantity + +=== page 15 +limits + age cutoff + +Hydroxyzine pamoate - Anxiety PRN; insomnia PRN +(Vistaril) Renew only with quantity +limits + age cutoff + +Excluded from pilot: + +controlled substances + +benzodiazepines/hypnotics + +antipsychotics, lithium/valproate, clozapine + +any medication requiring new labs/ECG for safe renewal + +2.3 Clinical scope + +e Renewals only (no new starts, no dose changes, no switching/cross-taper) +e Stability definition: +© no recent dose changes +o only for prescriptions previously prescribed by a licensed health care +provider +© no recent psychiatric hospitalization or acute safety escalation signals within tyr +e Only standard refill durations (e.g., 30/60/90-day) +o during pilot, maximum of 10 automated refills between provider reviews, or 6 mo, +whichever is sooner + +3) Patient experience (what a Utah patient sees) +1. Patient initiates “Request refill’ (web/app). + +2. Disclosure + consent: patient is told Al is used in the workflow, what it can/can’t do, +how to request human review, how data is used/shared for this pilot, and how to contact +OAIP with concerns; patient must affirmatively acknowledge before proceeding. + +3. Identity Verification + +o Patients complete identity verification through an identity verification vendor using +government ID and biometric/selfie matching (or equivalent), to reduce +wrong-patient and misuse risk. + +4. Prescription Verification + +o Legion establishes prescription history including eligible refills: + +m Legion queries a pharmacy vendor for up-to-date prescription history. + +=== page 16 +m_ The patient may submit photographic evidence of the current medication +(prescription label or pill bottle) to establish a verified prescription. + +m_ If discrepancies are detected (no prior medication found, different +dose/schedule, etc), the case is automatically escalated to a +Utah-licensed clinician. + +5. Al-guided “micro-intake” collects only what’s needed for safe renewal: + +oo00 0 0 + +fe) + +medication verification (name, dose, frequency, route) +indication review (what the medication is for) + +efficacy assessment (is it helping / stable) + +safety monitoring (new side effects / adverse effects) + +allergy verification + +clinical status update (recent major changes/medical events) +symptom assessment (focused, indication-relevant) + +6. Psychiatry-specific safety screens (hard stops — escalation): + +oOo 0 + +fe) + +suicidality/self-harm risk signals + +mania/hypomania red flags + +pregnancy/planning pregnancy status changes +severe adverse reactions or contraindication signals + +7. Decision Pathways: + +Approval: if within scope and no risk/ambiguity, Al authorizes the renewal and +transmits it to the patient’s pharmacy of choice; pharmacists are clearly informed +the renewal originated from an Al system. + +Automated escalation: any out-of-scope, risk, or ambiguity — Utah-licensed +clinician review (and/or visit scheduling) before any renewal is sent. +Patient-initiated escalation: patient can request clinician review at any point. +Pharmacist-initiated escalation: pharmacist retains full authority to escalate to +a Utah-licensed clinician. + +Escalation SLA: Escalation to provider review queue for review or visit +scheduling within 24 business hours + +4) Safety plan (what prevents harm) + +Summary: when Al WILL vs WON’T renew + +Al WILL authorize and transmit a renewal only when all are true: +=== page 17 +Request is renewals-only (no new starts, no dose changes, no +switching/cross-tapering) and is within the pilot’s defined scope. + +Medication is on the Phase 1 formulary and is not excluded + +The prescription is verified against electronic prescription history + +Safety screening shows no escalation triggers (e.g., suicidality/self-harm risk +signals, mania/hypomania red flags, pregnancy status changes, new/worsening +symptoms or loss of efficacy, severe adverse effects, contraindication signals). +Patient is within required clinician-touch cadence (during the pilot: max 10 +automated refills between provider reviews, or 6 months—whichever is sooner). + +Al WON'T renew (it routes to a Utah-licensed clinician before anything is sent) if any are + +true: + +Medication is not on the formulary or is excluded (controlled substances; +benzodiazepines/hypnotics; antipsychotics and higher-risk mood stabilizers like +lithium/valproate/clozapine; or renewals requiring new labs/ECG to continue +safely). + +The request is not a straight renewal (new start, dose change, +switching/cross-tapering), or the case is otherwise out-of-scope. + +Identity or prescription can’t be verified with confidence + +Any risk/ambiguity is detected by the safety screens. + +Patient requests clinician review at any time, or pharmacy requests clinician +review (target: review or visit scheduling within 1 business day). + +4.1 Conservative eligibility gates + +Hard stops that force escalation (examples): + +positive suicidality screen or acute risk signals + +new/worsening symptoms or loss of efficacy +pregnancy/planning pregnancy status changes + +indications of mania/hypomania + +severe adverse effects or contraindication signals + +mismatch between patient request and medication ground truth + +Testing for hard stops: + +e@ Each hard stop is tested in two layers: + +oO deterministic rails unit tests (rule to expected decision/reason code) +© sandbox red-team scripts (synthetic cases that must fail closed) +=== page 18 +4.2 Escalation-to-human protocols (always available) + +e Any uncertainty — clinician review +e Any patient-requested escalation — clinician review +e Clinician SLAs and operational safety backstop for urgent cases +o Escalation to provider review queue results in review or visit scheduling within 24 +business hours +Provider can see chat log and patient medical records +Clinician can escalate to video call as needed +Patients outside clinical scope will be sent appropriate Utah referral resources +including links and phone numbers +o Urgent cases (defined as elevated patient risk) will be sent appropriate Utah +referral resources + +4.3 Auditability + sampling + +e Every Al decision produces a structured “refill packet” with: +o inputs, rule checks, safety flags, and a decision rationale +e Phased ramp stage-gated on concordance: +o Phase A (pre-issuance review): 250 renewal requests reviewed by a +Utah-licensed clinician before completion +m Proceed to Phase B if concordance >98% +o Phase B (intensive review): 1,000 with retrospective review +m Proceed to Phase C if concordance >99% +o Phase C (ongoing): ongoing periodic sampling (e.g., 5-10% monthly) + +incident-driven audits +e Measurement of concordance for each case is as follows: + +Al says Provider says Classification Affect on +concordance +measurement + +Refill Refill True positive Concordant + +Refill Escalate False positive Discordant (counts +against 98% goal) + +Escalate Escalate True negative Concordant + +Escalate Refill False negative Discordant but + +does not count +against 98% goal +(fine to have +risk-averse safety +slant in product) + +=== page 19 +4.4 Legion Health Clinic current general safety protocols (for visibility) + +e Legion uses clinician-led protocols, escalation pathways, and auditability safeguards +across our Al-supported workflows +°© Clinician-led protocols and auditability standards + += All Al-generated clinical co-pilot features are developed in collaboration +with our clinical lead, including prompt development, iterations of clinical +flows, etc + += AI patient caseload introspection tools and metrics dashboards used to +verify adherence to evidence based clinical protocols + +o How Legion avoids creating Cognitive Biases with Pre-Visit Al Summaries + +m= Alsummaries use detailed citations to explain source data and keep +analysis grounded in verified facts + += Alsummaries explicitly indicate potential differential diagnoses based on +available data, and clearly flag what additional questions could be asked +to form conclusions such that the provider can investigate during the visit +and come to a final conclusion based on their own expertise + +m= Al summaries explicitly call out gaps in data or missing diagnostic +pointers not present in the patient’s medical history + +m= Al summaries remind providers of Legion Health clinical protocols and +required empirical tests or labs in scenarios where multiple courses of +treatment are possible, or where observation alone is not sufficient + +5) Data posture + reporting (what Utah gets) +Data posture (security + HIPAA): + +e Operate under a HIPAA compliance posture as a provider clinic; treat all +patient-identifiable pilot data as PHI. + +e Use encryption in transit/at rest, role-based access control (least privilege), and +audit logging for access and critical actions. + +e Maintain production vs test separation; do not copy production PHI into test +environments. +Subprocessors: require BAAs for any vendor touching PHI +Incident response: maintain a documented incident response process and notify +OAIP of defined pilot incidents within a bounded window after confirmation +(target <= 72 hours). + +Model refinement safeguards: +=== page 20 +Do not use PHI to train foundation models. + +During the pilot, improvements are limited to deterministic rails updates and +prompt/template revisions informed by internal QA and an error taxonomy. PHI is +not used to train foundation models; any external sharing for reporting uses +de-identified/aggregated data and redacted excerpts. + +Any proposal to train/fine-tune on PHI is treated as a scope change requiring +explicit approval and OAIP discussion before execution. + +Retention and deletion (pilot vs post-pilot): + +Clinical record: retained per Legion's standard medical record retention policy. +Pilot-only audit artifacts: retained through the pilot and OAIP closeout, then +moved to reduced retention and purged. + +Deletion includes primary stores, backup rotation, and subprocessor deletions +per contractual terms; deletion actions are logged. + +No sale / sharing posture: + +No sale of identifiable patient data (PHI). +No use of PHI for advertising/marketing or ad retargeting for this pilot (unless we +obtain explicit patient authorization and update the pilot scope accordingly). +We may use de-identified/aggregated data for analytics, safety monitoring, and +public/policy reporting. +Sharing is limited to: +o care delivery operations and required subprocessors to run the pilot (BAA +where PHI is involved), +o OAIP reporting (de-identified/aggregated by default; redacted +minimum-necessary excerpts only when needed for audit), +o OAIP-approved third-party review if requested, under a data sharing +agreement. + +Monthly reporting (designed for OAIP safety + policy evaluation): + +Volume + disposition counts (approve / escalate / not eligible), with denominators +defined. + +Per-drug disposition matrix. + +Escalation breakdown by initiator (system/human/patient/pharmacist) and reason +codes; hard-stop trigger counts. + +Agreement/concordance on reviewed cases and an error taxonomy. + +Safety signals: incidents, complaints, urgent escalations within a defined +lookback window. +=== page 21 +e Redacted, de-identified excerpts sufficient to audit sampled cases and +disagreements (minimum necessary; not full chat logs). + +e Longitudinal signals: 30/60/90-day repeat renewal rates; time-of-day/day-of-week +distributions. + +6) What we are requesting from OAIP + +We request a regulatory mitigation agreement (Doctronic-template-compatible) that allows the +above renewal workflow in Utah within the defined scope, and OAIP coordination with the +appropriate Utah regulators (e.g., DOPL and any other relevant agencies) to mitigate the +specific state-level regulatory barriers implicated by Al-initiated renewal authorization. + +e allowing Al to authorize renewals only of verified prescriptions to a Utah-licensed +pharmacist +telehealth statute compliance posture for Al when following the agreed workflow +enforcement posture and “named prescriber” reliance posture (as applicable) solely +within the pilot scope, while preserving DOPL’s authority for out-of-scope conduct + +We acknowledge OAIP cannot change federal law and will structure the pilot accordingly diff --git a/data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.pdf b/data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c3cbabe0 Binary files /dev/null and b/data/admission/sources/utah-legion/Legion-Agreement-2026-09-24.pdf differ diff --git a/data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-status-2026-09-24.html b/data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-status-2026-09-24.html new file mode 100644 index 00000000..03c0bea0 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-status-2026-09-24.html @@ -0,0 +1,445 @@ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +SB0149 + + + + + + + +
+
+ + + + + + +
+ +
+
+ +

S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments

+ +
+
+
Bill Sponsor:

Sen. Cullimore, Kirk A.
Floor Sponsor:

Rep. Moss, Jefferson
  • Drafting Attorney: Scott Elder
  • Fiscal Analyst: Noah Matthew Hansen

+ +
+ +
+
  • Information
    • Last Action: 13 Mar 2024, Governor Signed
    • Last Location: Lieutenant Governor's office for filing

+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+Bill Status / Votes
+
• Senate Actions • House Actions • Fiscal Actions • Other Actions
DateActionLocationVote
1/25/2024 Bill Numbered but not DistributedLegislative Research and General Counsel
1/25/2024 Numbered Bill Publicly DistributedLegislative Research and General Counsel
1/25/2024 LFA/ bill sent to agencies for fiscal inputLegislative Research and General Counsel
1/26/2024 Senate/ received bill from Legislative ResearchWaiting for Introduction in the Senate
1/26/2024 Senate/ 1st reading (Introduced)Senate Rules Committee
1/29/2024 Senate/ to standing committeeSenate Business and Labor Committee
1/30/2024 LFA/ fiscal note sent to sponsorSenate Business and Labor Committee
1/30/2024 LFA/ fiscal note publicly availableSenate Business and Labor Committee
1/31/2024 Senate/ received fiscal note from Fiscal AnalystSenate Business and Labor Committee
2/8/2024 Senate Comm - Amendment Recommendation # 1Senate Business and Labor Committee4 0 4
2/8/2024 Senate Comm - Favorable RecommendationSenate Business and Labor Committee6 0 2
2/8/2024 (11:35:14 AM)Senate/ comm rpt/ amendedSenate Business and Labor Committee
2/8/2024 (11:35:15 AM)Senate/ placed on 2nd Reading CalendarSenate 2nd Reading Calendar
2/12/2024 (2:32:48 PM)Senate/ 2nd readingSenate 2nd Reading Calendar
2/12/2024 (2:37:26 PM)Senate/ passed 2nd readingSenate 3rd Reading Calendar22 0 7
2/13/2024 (11:28:18 AM)Senate/ 3rd readingSenate 3rd Reading Calendar
2/13/2024 (11:28:51 AM)Senate/ circledSenate 3rd Reading CalendarVoice vote
2/13/2024 (11:42:54 AM)Senate/ uncircledSenate 3rd Reading CalendarVoice vote
2/13/2024 (11:50:33 AM)Senate/ passed 3rd readingClerk of the House26 0 3
2/13/2024 (11:50:34 AM)Senate/ to HouseClerk of the House
2/13/2024 House/ received from SenateClerk of the House
2/13/2024 House/ 1st reading (Introduced)House Rules Committee
2/14/2024 House/ to standing committeeHouse Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee
2/20/2024 House Comm - Favorable RecommendationHouse Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee7 0 3
2/21/2024 House/ committee report favorableHouse Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee
2/21/2024 House/ return to Rules due to fiscal impactHouse Rules Committee
2/27/2024 House/ Rules to 3rd Reading CalendarHouse 3rd Reading Calendar for Senate bills
2/27/2024 (8:02:01 PM)House/ 2nd readingHouse 3rd Reading Calendar for Senate bills
2/28/2024 (10:07:58 AM)House/ 3rd readingHouse 3rd Reading Calendar for Senate bills
2/28/2024 (10:14:31 AM)House/ passed 3rd readingHouse Speaker73 0 2
2/28/2024 (10:14:32 AM)House/ signed by Speaker/ returned to SenateSenate President
2/28/2024 (10:14:33 AM)House/ to SenateSenate President
2/28/2024 Senate/ received from HouseSenate President
2/28/2024 Senate/ signed by President/ sent for enrollingLegislative Research and General Counsel / Enrolling
2/29/2024 Bill Received from Senate for EnrollingLegislative Research and General Counsel / Enrolling
2/29/2024 Draft of Enrolled Bill PreparedLegislative Research and General Counsel / Enrolling
3/8/2024 Enrolled Bill Returned to House or SenateSenate Secretary
3/8/2024 Senate/ enrolled bill to PrintingSenate Secretary
3/12/2024 Senate/ received enrolled bill from PrintingSenate Secretary
3/12/2024 Senate/ to GovernorExecutive Branch - Governor
3/13/2024 Governor SignedLieutenant Governor's office for filing
+
+ + +
+ + + + + + + + + + + + diff --git a/data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-status-2026-09-24.txt b/data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-status-2026-09-24.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ae59ac6a --- /dev/null +++ b/data/admission/sources/utah-sb149/SB0149-status-2026-09-24.txt @@ -0,0 +1,323 @@ +SB0149 +Accessibility +Use the Settings Button to view other accessibility Settings +Skip to Content +Search +Settings +Login +Search +Legislators +All Legislators +All Legislators +Find Legislators +By Session (1896-Current) +Alphabetical (Historical) +Find by Address/Map +Sessions +Reading Calendars +Journals +Session Dates +House +House +House Home +About the House +Leadership +Roster +Seating Chart +Conflict of Interest Forms +Past Floor Debates +Senate +Senate +Senate Home +About the Senate +Leadership +Roster +Seating Chart +Extraordinary Sessions +Past Floor Debates +Disclosure Forms +Bills +View Bills +2026 Bills +Browse by Session +Passed Bills +Keyword Search +Tracking Service +Working Bills (1896-1989) +Bill Data +Bill Drafting/Research Files (1990-Ongoing) +--> +Code +Utah Code +Code and Constitution +Keyword Search +Utah Constitution +Constitutional Convention +Laws of Utah 2014-ongoing +Historical Laws of Utah +Legislative Rules +Utah Administrative Rules +Advanced Law Search +Historical Code +Committees +All Committees +Appropriations +Commissions +Confirmation +Interim +Standing +Subcommittees +Task Forces +Bills in Committees +Interim Committee Histories (1990-Ongoing) +--> +Audits +New Audits +Audit Subcommittee +Government Excellence +Annual Reports +Office of the Legislative Auditor General +Budget +Budget.Utah.gov +State Budget (PDF) +COBI +Quick Facts (PDF) +Fiscal Health +Taxpayer Receipt +Data Visualizer +Budget Bills +Budget Committees +Budget Publications +Office of the Legislative Fiscal Analyst +Research and Legal +Office of Legislative Research and General Counsel +Publications +Bill Data +Legislative Information +Agency Reporting +Advanced Law Search +Additional Accessibility Settings +Default Settings +High Contrast +Text Only +Font Size: +A +A +A +The Playback of past Legislative meetings will be unavailable until 12:00pm today October 20th. We apologize for any inconvenience and appreciate your understanding. +--> +Home +2024 General Session +S.B. 149 +S.B. 149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments +Bill Text +Status +Hearings/Debate +Bill Sponsor: +Sen. Cullimore, Kirk A. +Floor Sponsor: +Rep. Moss, Jefferson +Drafting Attorney: Scott Elder +Fiscal Analyst: Noah Matthew Hansen +Bill Text Introduced +Amended Amended Pages Only +Enrolled +Related Documents Fiscal Note +House Transmittal Letter 1 +Senate Transmittal Letter 1 +Senate Committee Amendment 1(passed) +Program Evaluation Questions +Information Last Action: 13 Mar 2024, Governor Signed +Last Location: Lieutenant Governor's office for filing +Similar Bills Technology +Business +Commerce and Trade +Department of Commerce +Consumer Protection +Administrative Rulemaking +New Rulemaking Authority +Bill Status / Votes +• Senate Actions • House Actions • Fiscal Actions • Other Actions +Date +Action +Location +Vote +1/25/2024 +Bill Numbered but not Distributed +Legislative Research and General Counsel +1/25/2024 +Numbered Bill Publicly Distributed +Legislative Research and General Counsel +1/25/2024 +LFA/ bill sent to agencies for fiscal input +Legislative Research and General Counsel +1/26/2024 +Senate/ received bill from Legislative Research +Waiting for Introduction in the Senate +1/26/2024 +Senate/ 1st reading (Introduced) +Senate Rules Committee +1/29/2024 +Senate/ to standing committee +Senate Business and Labor Committee +1/30/2024 +LFA/ fiscal note sent to sponsor +Senate Business and Labor Committee +1/30/2024 +LFA/ fiscal note publicly available +Senate Business and Labor Committee +1/31/2024 +Senate/ received fiscal note from Fiscal Analyst +Senate Business and Labor Committee +2/8/2024 +Senate Comm - Amendment Recommendation # 1 +Senate Business and Labor Committee +4 0 4 +2/8/2024 +Senate Comm - Favorable Recommendation +Senate Business and Labor Committee +6 0 2 +2/8/2024 (11:35:14 AM) +Senate/ comm rpt/ amended +Senate Business and Labor Committee +2/8/2024 (11:35:15 AM) +Senate/ placed on 2nd Reading Calendar +Senate 2nd Reading Calendar +2/12/2024 (2:32:48 PM) +Senate/ 2nd reading +Senate 2nd Reading Calendar +2/12/2024 (2:37:26 PM) +Senate/ passed 2nd reading +Senate 3rd Reading Calendar +22 0 7 +2/13/2024 (11:28:18 AM) +Senate/ 3rd reading +Senate 3rd Reading Calendar +2/13/2024 (11:28:51 AM) +Senate/ circled +Senate 3rd Reading Calendar +Voice vote +2/13/2024 (11:42:54 AM) +Senate/ uncircled +Senate 3rd Reading Calendar +Voice vote +2/13/2024 (11:50:33 AM) +Senate/ passed 3rd reading +Clerk of the House +26 0 3 +2/13/2024 (11:50:34 AM) +Senate/ to House +Clerk of the House +2/13/2024 +House/ received from Senate +Clerk of the House +2/13/2024 +House/ 1st reading (Introduced) +House Rules Committee +2/14/2024 +House/ to standing committee +House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee +2/20/2024 +House Comm - Favorable Recommendation +House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee +7 0 3 +2/21/2024 +House/ committee report favorable +House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee +2/21/2024 +House/ return to Rules due to fiscal impact +House Rules Committee +2/27/2024 +House/ Rules to 3rd Reading Calendar +House 3rd Reading Calendar for Senate bills +2/27/2024 (8:02:01 PM) +House/ 2nd reading +House 3rd Reading Calendar for Senate bills +2/28/2024 (10:07:58 AM) +House/ 3rd reading +House 3rd Reading Calendar for Senate bills +2/28/2024 (10:14:31 AM) +House/ passed 3rd reading +House Speaker +73 0 2 +2/28/2024 (10:14:32 AM) +House/ signed by Speaker/ returned to Senate +Senate President +2/28/2024 (10:14:33 AM) +House/ to Senate +Senate President +2/28/2024 +Senate/ received from House +Senate President +2/28/2024 +Senate/ signed by President/ sent for enrolling +Legislative Research and General Counsel / Enrolling +2/29/2024 +Bill Received from Senate for Enrolling +Legislative Research and General Counsel / Enrolling +2/29/2024 +Draft of Enrolled Bill Prepared +Legislative Research and General Counsel / Enrolling +3/8/2024 +Enrolled Bill Returned to House or Senate +Senate Secretary +3/8/2024 +Senate/ enrolled bill to Printing +Senate Secretary +3/12/2024 +Senate/ received enrolled bill from Printing +Senate Secretary +3/12/2024 +Senate/ to Governor +Executive Branch - Governor +3/13/2024 +Governor Signed +Lieutenant Governor's office for filing +Committee Hearings/Floor Debate +Committee Hearings House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee Agenda +Minutes +Committee Report +Audio +Senate Business and Labor Committee Agenda +Minutes +Committee Report +Audio +Floor Debates Senate Floor Audio, Day 28 (2/12/2024) [SB149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments, Cullimore] +Senate Floor Audio, Day 29 (2/13/2024) [SB149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments, Cullimore] +Senate Floor Audio, Day 29 (2/13/2024) [SB149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments, Cullimore] +House Floor Audio, Day 43 (2/28/2024) [SB149 Artificial Intelligence Amendments, Moss] +Loading Twitter Feed... +--> +State +Senate +350 North State, Suite 320 +PO Box 145115 +Salt Lake City, Utah 84114 +Telephone: (801) 538-1408 +https://senate.utah.gov +Contact a Senator +House of +Representatives +350 North State, Suite 350 +PO Box 145030 +Salt Lake City, Utah 84114 +Telephone: (801) 538-1408 +https://house.utleg.gov +Contact a Representative +Staff Offices +Legislative Auditor General +Legislative Fiscal Analyst +Legislative Research and General Counsel +Legislative Services +Staff Awards +Public Information +Records Requests +Procurement +Contact the Webmaster +Job Opportunities +FAQ +--> +Site Map +Terms of Use +ADA +Utah.gov diff --git a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md index 24fc89d3..1bd73ae9 100644 --- a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md +++ b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md @@ -43,24 +43,24 @@ amended_by: - us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320 hash_chain_prev: null disclaimer: "" -last_verified: 2026-06-04 +last_verified: 2026-09-23 schema: https://publedge.org/schema/instrument.schema.json created: 2026-04-21 -modified: 2026-09-12 +modified: 2026-09-23 --- ## Timeline | Milestone | Date | Notes | |-----------|------|-------| -| Introduced | 2024-01-25 | Senate Rules Committee | -| Senate passed | 2024-02-12 | 22-0-7 | +| Introduced | 2024-01-26 | Senate 1st reading, to Senate Rules Committee (numbered and publicly distributed 2024-01-25) | +| Senate passed | 2024-02-13 | 26-0-3 on 3rd reading (2nd reading 2024-02-12, 22-0-7) | | House passed | 2024-02-28 | 73-0-2 | | Governor Signed | 2024-03-13 | Gov. Cox | | Effective | 2024-05-01 | Office of AI Policy operational, §76-2-107 criminal mirror, §13-2-12 disclosure | -| Boyd appointed | 2024-04-30 | First Director, Office of AI Policy | +| Boyd appointed | 2024-04-30 | First Director, Office of AI Policy (unconfirmed: not in the enrolled bill or bill status page) | | Amended by SB 226 | 2025-05-07 | §13-2-12 repealed; disclosure moved to Chapter 75 | -| Amended by HB 452 | 2025-05-07 | Mental health chatbot provisions added (Chapter 72a) | +| HB 452 effective | 2025-05-07 | Related Chapter 72a (mental health chatbots) enacted; HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted | | Amended by HB 320 | 2026-05-06 | Chapter 72 restructured; Learning Lab + JIA instrument added | | Chapter 72 sunset | 2027-07-01 | Office + Lab + agreements expire unless extended | @@ -68,13 +68,13 @@ modified: 2026-09-12 ## Summary -SB 149 established Utah's AI policy architecture: the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP), the Artificial Intelligence Learning Laboratory (regulatory mitigation program), a generative AI disclosure requirement for consumer transactions (§13-2-12), and statutory treatment of AI-assisted violations in civil and criminal contexts (§76-2-107). +SB 149 established Utah's AI policy architecture: the Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP), the Artificial Intelligence Learning Laboratory (regulatory mitigation program), a generative AI disclosure requirement for consumer transactions (§13-2-12), and statutory treatment of AI-assisted violations in civil (§13-2-12(2)) and criminal (§76-2-107) contexts. The enrolled bill numbered the new chapter Title 13, Chapter 70; it is codified as Chapter 72, the chapter number later bills amend. -Key provisions have been substantially amended by subsequent legislation: +Key provisions have been substantially amended or supplemented by subsequent legislation: - **SB 226 (2025)** repealed §13-2-12 and re-enacted the disclosure framework as Chapter 75 with a narrower "clear and unambiguous request" trigger and a safe-harbor for outset+throughout disclosure. -- **HB 452 (2025)** added Chapter 72a for mental health chatbot suppliers, including disclosure and data-protection requirements. -- **HB 320 (2026)** restructured Chapter 72, added the Joint Interpretation Agreement instrument, and extended the maximum agreement term from 12 to 36 months. -- **SB 332** extended the Chapter 72 sunset from 2025-07-01 to 2027-07-01. +- **HB 452 (2025)** added the related Chapter 72a for mental health chatbot suppliers, including disclosure and data-protection requirements. It cross-references Chapter 72 definitions but amends no section SB 149 enacted. +- **HB 320 (2026)** restructured Chapter 72, added the Joint Interpretation Agreement instrument, and extended the maximum agreement term from 24 months (12 plus a single 12-month extension) to 36 months (12 plus up to two 12-month extensions). +- **SB 332 (2025)** extended the Chapter 72 sunset from 2025-05-01 to 2027-07-01; SB 226 (2025) made the same §63I-2-213 amendment. For the consolidated obligations matrix across the full Utah AI stack, see [everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149](https://everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149/). @@ -86,4 +86,4 @@ For the consolidated obligations matrix across the full Utah AI stack, see [ever - [SB 149 Bill Text (le.utah.gov)](https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html) - [EveryAILaw — Utah AI Stack](https://everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149/) -- [Utah OAIP Learning Lab](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/) +- [Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/) diff --git a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md index afd96de0..3e386160 100644 --- a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md +++ b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md @@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ id: us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 instance: 2025-002 slug: utah-hb452-mental-health-chatbots -title: "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations" +title: "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots)" type: statute source: authoritative-reference jurisdiction: us-ut @@ -33,6 +33,9 @@ publication_citations: - cite: "Utah HB 452 (2025 General Session)" url: "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html" full_text_reference: "https://everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149/#mental-health-chatbot-disclosure" +sponsors: + - "Rep. Jefferson Moss (House sponsor)" + - "Sen. Kirk A. Cullimore (Senate floor sponsor)" status: enforcing editorial_status: published amends: us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 @@ -40,31 +43,32 @@ supersedes: null superseded_by: null hash_chain_prev: null disclaimer: "" -last_verified: 2026-06-04 +last_verified: 2026-09-23 schema: https://publedge.org/schema/instrument.schema.json created: 2026-04-21 -modified: 2026-09-12 +modified: 2026-09-23 --- ## Timeline | Milestone | Date | Notes | |-----------|------|-------| -| Introduced | 2025-02 | 2025 General Session | -| Governor Signed | 2025-03-26 | | +| Introduced | 2025-02 | 2025 General Session (month unconfirmed: not in the enrolled copy) | +| Governor Signed | 2025-03-26 | Unconfirmed: not in the enrolled copy; bill status page not retained | | Effective | 2025-05-07 | Chapter 72a stands up | --- ## Summary -HB 452 established Chapter 72a of the Utah Code, a statutory framework governing AI-powered mental health chatbots. The bill imposes disclosure, data protection, and safety-policy requirements on suppliers of such services: +HB 452 established Chapter 72a of the Utah Code, a statutory framework governing AI-powered mental health chatbots. The bill imposes disclosure, data protection, and advertising requirements on suppliers of such services and conditions a safety-policy affirmative defense. It amends §13-2-1 and enacts new sections; Chapter 72a cross-references the Chapter 72 definition of artificial intelligence (§13-72-101) but amends no section SB 149 enacted: - **Pre-access + post-gap + on-prompt disclosure** (§13-72a-203). Disclosure must appear before user access, again at the start of any interaction following a 7-day gap, and any time the user asks whether AI is involved. Scripted-only outputs (meditations, mindfulness) and referral-to-human-therapist bots are carved out (§13-72a-101(10)(b)). -- **Data protection** (§13-72a-201). Suppliers may not sell or share identifiable health information or user input with third parties. Limited exceptions for user-consented or user-requested disclosure to health care providers; third-party functional sharing requires HIPAA Parts 160+164 Subparts A/E compliance as if the supplier were a covered entity. -- **15-element safety policy** (§58-60-118). Suppliers who file a statutorily specified written policy with the Division of Consumer Protection (and comply with it at the time of alleged violation) gain an affirmative defense against §58-1-501(1)-(2) unauthorized-practice actions — a sector-specific safe harbor via documented policy. +- **Data protection** (§13-72a-201). Suppliers may not sell or share identifiable health information or user input with third parties. Limited exceptions for information requested by a health care provider with the user's consent, or provided to the user's health plan at the user's request; third-party functional sharing requires HIPAA Parts 160+164 Subparts A/E compliance as if the supplier were a covered entity. +- **Advertising restrictions** (§13-72a-202). In-conversation advertising must be clearly and conspicuously identified as advertising, with any sponsorship, business affiliation, or promotion agreement disclosed; user input may not be used to decide whether to show an advertisement (other than for the chatbot itself), to choose what to advertise, or to customize how an advertisement is presented. +- **15-element safety policy** (§58-60-118). Suppliers who create, maintain, and implement a statutorily specified written policy, maintain documentation of foundation models, training data, privacy compliance, data practices, and accuracy and safety efforts (§58-60-118(2)(b)), file the policy with the Division of Consumer Protection, and comply with it at the time of alleged violation gain an affirmative defense against §58-1-501(1)-(2) unauthorized-practice actions — a sector-specific safe harbor via documented policy. -Penalties: $2,500 per violation (administrative or court), $5,000 per violation of a cease-and-desist order. +Penalties: $2,500 per violation (administrative or court), $5,000 per violation of an administrative or court order issued for a violation of the chapter. ### Talking Point diff --git a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md index 4e91275c..1f731c66 100644 --- a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md +++ b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md @@ -22,15 +22,18 @@ statute_anchors: - cite: "Utah Code Title 13, Chapter 75 (Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Act)" url: "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter75/13-75.html" - cite: "Utah Code §13-75-102 (civil AI-assisted-violation liability)" - url: "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter75/13-75-S102.html" + url: "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter75/13-75.html" - cite: "Utah Code §13-75-103 (disclosure requirements)" - url: "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter75/13-75-S103.html" + url: "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter75/13-75.html" - cite: "Utah Code §13-75-104 (disclosure safe harbor)" - url: "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter75/13-75-S104.html" + url: "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter75/13-75.html" publication_citations: - cite: "Utah SB 226 (2025 General Session)" url: "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/SB0226.html" full_text_reference: "https://everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149/#general-genai-disclosure" +sponsors: + - "Sen. Kirk A. Cullimore (Senate sponsor)" + - "Rep. Jefferson Moss (House floor sponsor)" status: enforcing editorial_status: published amends: us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 @@ -38,20 +41,20 @@ supersedes: null superseded_by: null hash_chain_prev: null disclaimer: "" -last_verified: 2026-06-04 +last_verified: 2026-09-23 schema: https://publedge.org/schema/instrument.schema.json created: 2026-04-21 -modified: 2026-06-04 +modified: 2026-09-23 --- ## Timeline | Milestone | Date | Notes | |-----------|------|-------| -| Introduced | 2025-02 | 2025 General Session | -| Governor Signed | 2025-03-25 | | -| Effective | 2025-05-07 | Four-bill single-day AI package (with SB 271, SB 332, HB 452) | -| First annual report | 2025-11-30 | To Business & Labor Interim Committee | +| Introduced | 2025-02 | 2025 General Session (month unconfirmed: not in the enrolled copy) | +| Governor Signed | 2025-03-25 | Unconfirmed: not in the enrolled copy; bill status page not retained | +| Effective | 2025-05-07 | Chapter 75 and §13-2-12 repeal; the §63I-2-213 amendment took effect this date or on governor approval if passed by two-thirds of each house (vote not confirmed) | +| Annual OAIP report due | 2025-11-30 | Before Nov 30, to Business & Labor Interim Committee; duty set by SB 149 (§13-70-201(3)(d)), not SB 226; filing history unverified | --- @@ -60,9 +63,10 @@ modified: 2026-06-04 SB 226 relocated and narrowed Utah's generative AI disclosure framework. The original §13-2-12 disclosure requirement (enacted by SB 149 in 2024) was repealed and re-enacted as a new Chapter 75 with substantive changes: - **Narrower trigger.** The 2024 on-request standard was rewritten to require a consumer's "clear and unambiguous" request for AI disclosure (§13-75-103(1)). -- **New safe harbor.** Providing a clear and conspicuous disclosure at the outset of consumer interactions, and throughout, eliminates enforcement exposure under §13-75-104. +- **New safe harbor.** Providing a clear and conspicuous disclosure at the outset of consumer interactions, and throughout, eliminates enforcement exposure for violating §13-75-103 (§13-75-104). - **High-risk-occupation proactive tier.** For "high-risk AI interactions" (§13-75-101(5)) — sensitive data collection or personalized advice in finance, legal, medicine, or mental health — disclosure must be proactive: verbal at the start of oral exchanges, written before written exchanges (§13-75-103(2)-(3)). - **Civil AI-assisted-violation liability.** §13-75-102 codifies the civil mirror of §76-2-107: "not a defense" that GenAI made the violative statement or was used in furtherance of the violation. +- **Chapter 72 repeal date.** SB 226 §7 also amended §63I-2-213(5) to move the Chapter 72 (Artificial Intelligence Policy Act) repeal date from May 1, 2025 to July 1, 2027, the same amendment SB 332 made. That amendment took effect May 7, 2025, or on governor approval if passed by two-thirds of each house; the vote is not confirmed here. ### Talking Point diff --git a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.md b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.md index 14744af9..7c0aa655 100644 --- a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.md +++ b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.md @@ -39,24 +39,24 @@ supersedes: null superseded_by: null hash_chain_prev: null disclaimer: "" -last_verified: 2026-06-04 +last_verified: 2026-09-23 schema: https://publedge.org/schema/instrument.schema.json created: 2026-06-04 -modified: 2026-06-04 +modified: 2026-09-23 --- ## Timeline | Milestone | Date | Notes | |-----------|------|-------| -| Introduced | 2025-02-24 | Senate Rules Committee | -| Senate Business and Labor — favorable | 2025-02-26 | 7-0-1 | -| Senate passed 3rd reading | 2025-03-03 | 24-0-5 | -| House Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice — favorable | 2025-03-04 | 8-0-3 | -| House passed | 2025-03-05 | 74-0-1 | -| Governor Signed | 2025-03-25 | Gov. Cox | -| Effective | 2025-05-07 | Default 2025 session effective date | -| Chapter 72 sunset (post-amendment) | 2027-07-01 | Extended from 2025-05-01 | +| Introduced | 2025-02-24 | Senate Rules Committee (unconfirmed) | +| Senate Business and Labor — favorable | 2025-02-26 | 7-0-1 (unconfirmed) | +| Senate passed 3rd reading | 2025-03-03 | 24-0-5 (unconfirmed) | +| House Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice — favorable | 2025-03-04 | 8-0-3 (unconfirmed) | +| House passed | 2025-03-05 | 74-0-1 (unconfirmed) | +| Governor Signed | 2025-03-25 | Gov. Cox (unconfirmed) | +| Effective | 2025-05-07 | Special effective date (§2): May 7, 2025, or on governor approval if passed by two-thirds of each house; two-thirds vote not confirmed | +| Chapter 72 sunset (post-amendment) | 2027-07-01 | Extended from 2025-05-01 (SB 226 §7 made the same amendment) | --- @@ -64,13 +64,15 @@ modified: 2026-06-04 SB 332 is a structural amendment to Utah Code §63I-2-213 (the state's legislative sunset registry). Its sole AI-relevant effect is to extend the repeal date of Title 13, Chapter 72 (the Artificial Intelligence Policy Act) from May 1, 2025 to July 1, 2027 — a 26-month extension of OAIP's statutory existence, the Artificial Intelligence Learning Laboratory, and the Regulatory Mitigation Agreement instrument as originally authorized by SB 149 (2024). -The bill introduced no new substantive obligations, no new disclosure duties, no new agency powers, and no new penalties. It is included in the PubLedge registry because it materially affects the reliance period of every Regulatory Mitigation Agreement, Joint Interpretation Agreement, and related authority artifact issued under Chapter 72: without SB 332, the entire chapter — and every instrument issued under it — would have expired on 2025-05-01. +The bill introduced no new substantive obligations, no new disclosure duties, no new agency powers, and no new penalties. It is included in the PubLedge registry because it materially affects the reliance period of every Regulatory Mitigation Agreement, Joint Interpretation Agreement, and related authority artifact issued under Chapter 72. SB 226 (2025) §7 made the identical §63I-2-213(5) amendment in the same session, so SB 332 was one of two bills that moved the chapter's repeal date past 2025-05-01. -Subsequent amendments by HB 320 (2026) further restructured Chapter 72 (Learning Lab redesign, JIA instrument formalization, 36-month term ceiling) but did not further alter the sunset date set by SB 332. +The bill took effect May 7, 2025, or, if approved by two-thirds of all members elected to each house, on governor approval (§2). The introduction, committee, floor-vote and signing entries in the Timeline are not shown in the enrolled copy and are not confirmed against a retained bill status page, so which effective date applied is not confirmed here. + +Subsequent amendments by HB 320 (2026) further restructured Chapter 72 (Learning Lab redesign, JIA instrument formalization, 36-month term ceiling) but did not further alter the sunset date set by SB 332 and SB 226. ### Talking Point -> "Utah SB 332 (2025) is the statutory reason the Office of AI Policy, the Learning Laboratory, and every Regulatory Mitigation Agreement currently in force still exist. Without this 26-month extension, the entire AIPA framework would have sunset on May 1, 2025." +> "Utah SB 332 (2025), together with the identical amendment in SB 226 (2025), moved the Artificial Intelligence Policy Act's repeal date from May 1, 2025 to July 1, 2027, a 26-month extension of the Office of AI Policy, the Learning Laboratory, and the Regulatory Mitigation Agreement framework." ### Strict-line note (scaffolding-only stub) diff --git a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md index 9d4f82a9..9d2b1b3d 100644 --- a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md +++ b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md @@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ id: us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320 instance: 2026-001 slug: utah-hb320-learning-lab-restructure -title: "Utah HB 320 (2026) — AI Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements" +title: "Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements)" type: statute source: authoritative-reference jurisdiction: us-ut @@ -33,6 +33,9 @@ publication_citations: - cite: "Utah HB 320 (2026 General Session)" url: "https://le.utah.gov/~2026/bills/static/HB0320.html" full_text_reference: "https://everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149/#regulatory-mitigation-and-joint-interpretation-agreements" +sponsors: + - "Rep. Paul A. Cutler (House sponsor)" + - "Sen. Kirk A. Cullimore (Senate floor sponsor)" status: enforcing editorial_status: published amends: us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 @@ -40,20 +43,20 @@ supersedes: null superseded_by: null hash_chain_prev: null disclaimer: "" -last_verified: 2026-06-04 +last_verified: 2026-09-23 schema: https://publedge.org/schema/instrument.schema.json created: 2026-04-21 -modified: 2026-06-04 +modified: 2026-09-23 --- ## Timeline | Milestone | Date | Notes | |-----------|------|-------| -| Introduced | 2026-01 | 2026 General Session | -| Governor Signed | 2026-03-19 | | +| Introduced | 2026-01 | 2026 General Session (month unconfirmed: not in the enrolled copy) | +| Governor Signed | 2026-03-19 | Unconfirmed: not in the enrolled copy; bill status page not retained | | Effective | 2026-05-06 | Chapter 72 restructured; JIA instrument live | -| Second annual report | 2026-11-30 | First under restructured Chapter 72 | +| Annual OAIP report due | 2026-11-30 | Before Nov 30; first due date after HB 320 added executed RMAs and JIAs to the report (§13-72-201(3)(d)(iii)); filing history unverified | --- @@ -61,20 +64,20 @@ modified: 2026-06-04 HB 320 substantially restructured Chapter 72 (the Utah AI Policy Act) and introduced a second instrument type — the Joint Interpretation Agreement (JIA) — alongside the existing Regulatory Mitigation Agreement (RMA). Key changes: -- **Joint Interpretation Agreement (JIA) instrument.** OAIP may now enter agreements that interpret how existing law applies to AI without waiving the law (§13-72-401). Unlike an RMA, a JIA creates no waiver — it provides a written interpretive position that parties can rely upon while OAIP exercises regulatory discretion. -- **Expanded counterparties.** Agreements may now involve the judiciary, higher education institutions, and political subdivisions — not only executive-branch agencies (§13-72-401). -- **Extended term.** The maximum agreement term was extended from 12 months (with no renewal) to 12 months plus two 12-month extensions — up to 36 months total (§13-72-403). +- **Joint Interpretation Agreement (JIA) instrument.** A JIA is an agreement between a participant, OAIP, and a relevant agency or governmental entity that clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule to AI technology (§13-72-101(12)). Unlike an RMA, which may waive or modify requirements, a JIA leaves the clarified requirements in force (§13-72-401(7)). The statute presents both agreements as ways OAIP may grant temporary regulatory mitigation (§13-72-401(2)) and does not describe reliance on a JIA. +- **Expanded counterparties.** Agreements may now involve the judiciary, state-funded higher or public education institutions, and political subdivisions — not only executive-branch agencies (§13-72-101(10), §13-72-401). +- **Extended term.** The maximum agreement term was extended from 12 months plus a single 12-month extension (24 months) to 12 months plus up to two 12-month extensions — up to 36 months total (§13-72-403). - **Mandatory audits.** OAIP "shall perform regular audits" while an agreement is active (§13-72-401(6)). -- **Five-prong eligibility.** Learning Lab participants must demonstrate technical capability, financial resources, substantial consumer benefits outweighing risks, a risk-monitoring plan, and appropriately-limited scope (§13-72-402). +- **Eligibility prongs carried over and extended to JIAs.** The five prongs SB 149 enacted for regulatory mitigation now apply to both RMAs and JIAs: technical expertise and capability, financial resources to meet obligations during testing, potential substantial consumer benefits that may outweigh identified risks, a risk-monitoring plan, and appropriately limited testing (§13-72-402). HB 320 renumbered them and broadened prong (a) to cover implementing and using or supervising use. The restructure formalizes Utah's two-instrument architecture — RMA (waiver) and JIA (interpretation) — that PubLedge uses as the prototypical pattern for fact-specific written interpretations between a regulator and a regulated party. ### Talking Point -> "Utah HB 320 (2026) gave Utah's Office of AI Policy a second instrument: the Joint Interpretation Agreement — a written interpretation of existing law that parties may rely on without the law being waived. That two-instrument architecture (waiver + interpretation) is the pattern PubLedge formalizes for the cross-jurisdictional registry." +> "Utah HB 320 (2026) gave Utah's Office of AI Policy a second instrument: the Joint Interpretation Agreement — an agreement that clarifies how existing state law or rule applies to AI technology, without the law being waived. That two-instrument architecture (waiver + interpretation) is the pattern PubLedge formalizes for the cross-jurisdictional registry." ### Sources - [HB 320 Bill Text](https://le.utah.gov/~2026/bills/static/HB0320.html) - [EveryAILaw — RMA/JIA Learning Lab](https://everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149/#regulatory-mitigation-and-joint-interpretation-agreements) -- [Utah OAIP Learning Lab](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/) +- [Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/) diff --git a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md index f22464c6..33874831 100644 --- a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md +++ b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md @@ -11,8 +11,8 @@ authority: utah-oaip issued_by: "@type": "https://w3id.org/semanticarts/ns/ontology/gist/SubCountryGovernment" name: "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP)" - ref: "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/" -official_url: https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ + ref: "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/" +official_url: https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/ obligation_kind: [requirement, permission] reliance_scope: requesting-party-only requesting_party: "PubLedge (illustrative — suggested prior art, not party-specific)" @@ -25,12 +25,12 @@ parties: statute_anchors: - cite: "Utah Code §13-72a-203" url: "https://everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149/#mental-health-chatbot-disclosure" - - cite: "Utah SB0149 (2024)" - url: "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html" + - cite: "Utah HB0452 (2025)" + url: "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html" publication_citations: [] terms: - "@type": "https://w3id.org/semanticarts/ns/ontology/gist/ContractTerm" - text: "Provider must display the standardized GenAI disclosure on first session and on session resumption after 30 minutes of inactivity." + text: "Proposed interpretation: provider displays the standardized GenAI disclosure before first access and again on session resumption after 30 minutes of inactivity. The 30-minute re-display is a proposed term stricter than the statute's seven-day trigger, not a statutory requirement." status: proposed editorial_status: draft supersedes: null @@ -40,10 +40,10 @@ withdrawal_reason: null withdrawn_by_instrument: null hash_chain_prev: null disclaimer: "" -last_verified: 2026-06-04 +last_verified: 2026-09-23 schema: https://publedge.org/schema/instrument.schema.json created: 2026-04-15 -modified: 2026-06-04 +modified: 2026-09-23 --- ## Timeline @@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ modified: 2026-06-04 |-----------|------|-------| | Drafted | 2026-04-15 | Initial PubLedge draft, suggested prior art | | Reviewed | TBD | Lawyer review pending | -| Published | TBD | Awaiting v0.1 release | +| Published | TBD | Not issued; remains a PubLedge draft pending lawyer review and authority sign-off | --- @@ -63,22 +63,24 @@ modified: 2026-06-04 | Obligation | disclose-genai-on-first-session | | Sections | Utah Code §13-72a-203 | | Status | draft | -| Effective | 2026-04-15 | -| Verified | 2026-04-18 | -| Checked | 2026-04-18 | +| Drafted | 2026-04-15 | +| Verified | 2026-09-23 | +| Checked | 2026-09-23 | ### Requirements | Requirement | Details | |-------------|---------| -| Display disclosure | On first session, plainly identify the service as an AI chatbot | -| Re-display on resumption | After 30 minutes of inactivity, re-display the disclosure | +| Display disclosure (statute) | Clearly and conspicuously disclose that the chatbot is AI and not a human, before the user may access its features | +| Re-display after absence (statute) | Disclose again at the start of an interaction if the user hasn't accessed the chatbot within the previous seven days | +| Disclose on request (statute) | Disclose whenever the user asks or prompts the chatbot about whether AI is being used | +| Re-display on resumption (proposed JIA term) | After 30 minutes of inactivity, re-display the disclosure. Stricter than the statute; not a statutory requirement | ### Talking Point -> "A mental-health chatbot must tell the user it is an AI on first session and again after extended inactivity — not buried in a privacy policy." +> "A mental-health chatbot must tell the user it is an AI before first access, again after seven days away, and whenever asked. This draft proposes re-displaying it after 30 minutes of inactivity." ### Sources - [EveryAILaw — Mental Health Chatbot Disclosure](https://everyailaw.com/regulation/utah-sb149/#mental-health-chatbot-disclosure) -- [Utah Code §13-72a-203](https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html) +- [Utah Code §13-72a-203](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72A/13-72a-S203.html), enacted by [Utah HB 452 (2025)](https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html) diff --git a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md index 4dc9a072..c619201e 100644 --- a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md +++ b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md @@ -12,13 +12,13 @@ authority: utah-oaip issued_by: "@type": "https://w3id.org/semanticarts/ns/ontology/gist/SubCountryGovernment" name: "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP)" - ref: "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/" + ref: "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/" issuance_event: gist:Determination enacted: 2024-11-18 effective: 2024-11-18 term_start: 2024-11-18 term_end: 2025-11-18 -official_url: https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/ +official_url: https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/ publication_citations: - "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf" source_documents: @@ -71,10 +71,10 @@ withdrawal_reason: null withdrawn_by_instrument: null hash_chain_prev: null disclaimer: "" -last_verified: 2026-06-04 +last_verified: 2026-09-23 schema: https://publedge.org/schema/instrument.schema.json created: 2026-04-19 -modified: 2026-06-04 +modified: 2026-09-23 --- ## Summary @@ -102,7 +102,7 @@ May ElizaChat, Inc. offer its AI-supported mental-health app to Utah minors thro - Approved testing plan designed to prevent the app from engaging in therapy or other licensed practice. - Immediate reporting to OAIP of any activity constituting a Schedule A incident, including the action, involved user(s), and any resulting harm. - 24-hour incident notification to OAIP for any harm to health, safety, or financial well-being. -- High-risk users auto-shared with ElizaChat clinical team and emergency contacts; real-time connection to licensed psychologist/therapist. +- High-risk users, as determined by the participant, promptly shared with ElizaChat's clinical team and emergency contacts; promptly connected to a licensed psychologist or therapist for real-time intervention (Schedule A §XVI.A). - School-district-specific limitations respected. - HIPAA-compliant anonymization and storage of user data. - Written parental consent before regular use by minors. @@ -119,7 +119,7 @@ Requesting-party-only. Mitigation runs to ElizaChat, Inc. It expressly does not |---|---| | "Agreement between OAIP, ElizaChat Inc., and DOPL" | `title`, `name` | | Section I parties | `parties[]` | -| Section II (12-month from execution) | `term_start`, `term_end` | +| Section II (12 months beginning on execution; no end date stated) and OAIP register term November 18, 2024 – November 18, 2025 | `term_start`, `term_end` | | Schedule A §XV incident-cure structure | `rules_mitigated[]` and `mitigations[]` (narrow cure window; immediate reporting; good-faith remediation and nonrecurrence efforts), `obligation_kind: permission` | | Section VI.H phased rollout | `mitigations[]` (Phase One commencement; written approval for subsequent phases), `obligation_kind: requirement` | | Section XVI.E parental consent | `mitigations[]`, `obligation_kind: requirement` | @@ -133,12 +133,13 @@ Requesting-party-only. Mitigation runs to ElizaChat, Inc. It expressly does not - Mitigation is event-triggered and time-bounded (30-day cure), not a blanket pre-authorization. - The Schedule A cure procedure's immediate incident report and Section VI.I.3's 24-hour harm report have different triggers and clocks. - Cure-period forbearance depends on good-faith efforts to follow the curing procedure; remediation and nonrecurrence are also good-faith-effort duties. -- `status: expired` records the initial 12-month term end. The cited signed agreement and authority page do not establish a later extension, termination, replacement, or present legal effect. +- `status: expired` records the initial 12-month term end. OAIP's Authorized AI Pilots page, retrieved 2026-09-24 (UTC), lists ElizaChat as Expired with term November 18, 2024 – November 18, 2025. No retained source shows an extension request or decision under the Agreement Extension section, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved. - Does not bar individual user, parent/guardian, or third-party claims. ## Sources -- [Agreement page — Utah OAIP](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/) +- [Pilot page — Utah OAIP](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/) +- [Authorized AI Pilots — Utah OAIP](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/) - [Signed PDF](https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf) - [Source review receipt](https://github.com/snapsynapse/publedge/blob/main/ops/evidence/elizachat-source-review-2026-09-08.json) - [Utah Code Title 13, Chapter 72](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72/13-72.html) @@ -146,4 +147,4 @@ Requesting-party-only. Mitigation runs to ElizaChat, Inc. It expressly does not ## Notes on this demonstration remap -First RMA (`us-ut-oaip-rma-0001`), earliest in the registry by `effective` date. Exercises schema features not covered by prior RMAs: (1) incident-triggered, time-bounded (30-day cure) mitigation rather than blanket pre-authorization; (2) phased-rollout structure as an explicit obligation; (3) reliance on the predecessor GenAI disclosure statute (§13-2-12(4)) rather than §13-77-103; (4) predates the §13-72a mental-health-chatbot chapter entirely — useful for demonstrating how earlier RMAs sit alongside later sector-specific rules in the same registry. +First RMA (`us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001`), earliest in the registry by `effective` date. Exercises schema features not covered by prior RMAs: (1) incident-triggered, time-bounded (30-day cure) mitigation rather than blanket pre-authorization; (2) phased-rollout structure as an explicit obligation; (3) reliance on the predecessor GenAI disclosure statute (§13-2-12(4)) rather than §13-77-103; (4) predates the §13-72a mental-health-chatbot chapter entirely — useful for demonstrating how earlier RMAs sit alongside later sector-specific rules in the same registry. diff --git a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md index f8b96118..081e09fe 100644 --- a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md +++ b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md @@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ authority: utah-oaip issued_by: "@type": "https://w3id.org/semanticarts/ns/ontology/gist/SubCountryGovernment" name: "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP)" - ref: "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/" + ref: "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/" issuance_event: gist:Determination enacted: 2025-10-24 effective: 2025-10-24 @@ -54,19 +54,18 @@ statute_anchors: - cite: "Utah Code §63A-19-102 (Data security)" url: "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title63A/Chapter19/63A-19-S102.html" - cite: "UAC R156-1-501 / R156-1-602" - url: "https://adminrules.utah.gov/public/rule/R156-1/Current%20Rules" rules_mitigated: - "Utah Code §58-1-501(1) and UAC R156-1-501(2)(b) — unlawful/unprofessional conduct for AI-authored Rx renewal" - "Utah Code §26B-4-704(6) and UAC R156-1-602 — telehealth provider requirements" - - "Unprofessional-conduct provisions across prescriber chapters: §§58-31b-502, 58-60-110, 58-61-502, 59-67-502, 59-68-502, 59-70a-503, 58-71-502" + - "Unprofessional-conduct provisions across prescriber chapters, as listed in Schedule A §15.D.2: §§58-31b-502, 58-60-110, 58-61-502, 59-67-502 [sic], 58-68-502, 59-70a-503 [sic], and 58-71-502 (the signed text cites 59-67-502 and 59-70a-503 as written)" mitigations: - "Three-phase comprehensive case-review process (pre-pharmacy review → retrospective review → ongoing sampling)" - "Identity and prescription verification protocols before AI engages with renewal request" - "AI may not issue new prescriptions, change doses, handle controlled substances, or modify treatment plans" - "Formulary limit: Schedule C of the Agreement" - - "First-session GenAI disclosure (§13-77-103) with acknowledgment before access" + - "GenAI disclosure (§13-77-103) when a user indicates a renewal request and before the AI engages further on it; user acknowledgment before access to any function" - "Data-security posture per §63A-19-102 applied as if Participant were a governmental entity" - - "Monthly reporting to ai@utah.gov including acceptance/denial counts, physician-review agreement rates, complaints, adverse outcomes" + - "Monthly reporting to ai@utah.gov including acceptance/denial counts, physician-review agreement rates, and user-complaint information; separate duty to report user complaints and adverse health outcomes of which Participant becomes aware (no deadline stated)" status: enforcing editorial_status: published supersedes: null @@ -76,10 +75,10 @@ withdrawal_reason: null withdrawn_by_instrument: null hash_chain_prev: null disclaimer: "" -last_verified: 2026-06-04 +last_verified: 2026-09-23 schema: https://publedge.org/schema/instrument.schema.json created: 2026-04-19 -modified: 2026-09-09 +modified: 2026-09-23 --- ## Summary @@ -107,10 +106,11 @@ May a participant's artificial-intelligence technology authorize the renewal of ## Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §16) - Proposal-conforming methodology and safety protocols; amendments only by signed written approval. -- AI considered in compliance with §26B-4-704(2)(b)/(c) and (4) when Patient Journey and Clinical Workflow (Schedule B, Part 2B) is followed; with §26B-4-704(2)(e) when Escalation Protocols (Part 3B) are followed; §26B-4-704(5) does not apply. -- §13-77-103 GenAI disclosure on first session; users must acknowledge before use. +- AI considered in compliance with §26B-4-704(2)(b)/(c), and not in violation of §26B-4-704(4), when Patient Journey and Clinical Workflow (Schedule B, Part 2B) is followed; with §26B-4-704(2)(e) when Escalation Protocols (Part 3B) are followed; §26B-4-704(5) does not apply. +- §13-77-103 GenAI disclosure when a user indicates a renewal request and before the AI engages further on it; users must acknowledge before accessing any function (§6.G). - Data-security posture per §63A-19-102 treated as if Participant were a governmental entity; no sale or advertising use of user data even if deidentified. -- Monthly reports to ai@utah.gov: acceptance/denial counts, AI-vs-physician agreement rates, trends, adverse events, complaints. +- Monthly reports to ai@utah.gov: acceptance/denial counts, AI-vs-physician agreement rates, trends, and user-complaint information (§6.H.1). +- Separate reporting of user complaints and adverse health outcomes from AI renewals of which Participant becomes aware, with no stated deadline (§6.H.2(b)); the Agreement sets no incident-notification clock. - 30-day post-term written report on deployment, incidents, legal actions, complaints. ## Operational observation (not an issued term) @@ -121,6 +121,8 @@ The report says the sample was limited, based on reports from Doctronic physicia OAIP's AI FAQ, observed September 9, 2026, says the Phase 2 transition criteria were updated from 250 prescriptions total to 250 medications in each medication group, still subject to OAIP approval, and that Butalbital and Flecainide were removed from the formulary. The retained signed agreement instead describes the first 250 patients as Phase One and includes both medications in its formulary. OAIP's current Doctronic page links the signed agreement, outcomes report, medical-board correspondence, and a policy memorandum, but no signed amendment. The FAQ is therefore retained as an official dated observation and explicit source conflict; it does not establish the amendment mechanism or effective date, OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, or the pilot's current phase. +OAIP's Authorized AI Pilots page, retrieved 2026-09-24 (UTC), lists Doctronic as Active with term October 24, 2025 – October 24, 2026. It states that the pilot is still in Phase 1, that moving to Phase 2 requires OAIP approval by medication group, and that Phase 2 has not been approved. The same page refers to "the 2026 amendment" as tightening that threshold and removing two medications, but neither it nor the Doctronic pilot page links an amendment document. The amendment's date, signatories, and exact text remain unverified; the retained signed agreement is the only executed text reviewed. + ## Reliance scope Requesting-party-only. The Agreement grants mitigation to Doctronic, LLC and affiliated prescribers who act solely as named prescriber for AI-authored renewals without direct patient interaction. It is not prior art on which unrelated parties may rely; the Agreement expressly disclaims endorsement (Section 3D) and requires Participant registration (§6C). Harmed users and the State (other than DOPL) retain all legal remedies (§4D, §6B.3). @@ -131,7 +133,7 @@ Requesting-party-only. The Agreement grants mitigation to Doctronic, LLC and aff |---|---| | "Agreement between OAIP, Doctronic LLC, and DOPL" | `title`, `name` | | Section 1 parties | `parties[]`, `participating_party`, `issuing_authority` | -| Section 2 (12-month term, from execution) | `term_start`, `term_end` | +| Section 2 (12 months beginning on execution; no end date stated) and OAIP register term October 24, 2025 – October 24, 2026 | `term_start`, `term_end` | | Section 3 (Utah Code §13-72-201/301/302 authority) | `program`, `statute_anchors[]` | | Section 4 (Scope of Mitigation) + Schedule A §15 | `rules_mitigated[]`, `obligation_kind: permission` | | Section 6 (Participant Obligations) | `mitigations[]`, `obligation_kind: requirement/restriction` | @@ -144,16 +146,19 @@ Requesting-party-only. The Agreement grants mitigation to Doctronic, LLC and aff - Does not endorse Participant's technology (§3D); advertising references to the Agreement require prior written approval. - Terminable at will by either party (§10A) under §13-72-302(7). - Assignment requires prior written OAIP consent (§11). +- Section 13 allows a single extension request of up to 12 months no later than 30 days before the initial 12-month period ends. No retained source shows an extension request or decision; `term_end` records the initial term only. +- OAIP's register lists third-party adversarial testing among Doctronic's commitments, and OAIP's FAQ says participants are expected to maintain malpractice insurance covering AI liabilities. Neither term appears in the retained signed agreement text; where those terms are set out is unverified. ## Sources -- [Agreement page — Utah OAIP](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/doctronic/) -- [Signed PDF](https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf) +- [Pilot page — Utah OAIP](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/doctronic/) +- [Authorized AI Pilots — Utah OAIP](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/) +- [Signed PDF](https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf) (body title reads "DRAFT AGREEMENT"; signatures dated October 23-24, 2025) - [OAIP outcomes report — May 19, 2026](https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/Doctronic-Outcomes-May-2026.pdf) - [OAIP AI FAQ — Phase 2 criteria and formulary changes observed September 9, 2026](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/ai-faq/) -- [Utah AI Learning Laboratory](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/) +- [Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/) - [Utah Code Title 13, Chapter 72](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72/13-72.html) ## Notes on this demonstration remap -Third RMA (`us-ut-oaip-rma-0003`) by effective date. Exercises: (1) three-party contract (regulator + licensing division + participant), (2) multi-statute mitigation bundle including unprofessional-conduct provisions across seven prescriber chapters, (3) permission + requirement + restriction obligation mix in a single instrument, and (4) concurrent term with Utah's ongoing §13-72 → §13-72a statutory transition. +Third RMA (`us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002`) by effective date. Exercises: (1) three-party contract (regulator + licensing division + participant), (2) multi-statute mitigation bundle including unprofessional-conduct provisions across seven prescriber chapters, (3) permission + requirement + restriction obligation mix in a single instrument, and (4) concurrent term with Utah's ongoing §13-72 → §13-72a statutory transition. diff --git a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md index 24a37bb3..3f48a240 100644 --- a/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md +++ b/data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md @@ -12,14 +12,14 @@ authority: utah-oaip issued_by: "@type": "https://w3id.org/semanticarts/ns/ontology/gist/SubCountryGovernment" name: "Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy (OAIP)" - ref: "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/" + ref: "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/" issuance_event: gist:Determination enacted: 2026-03-19 effective: null commencement_date_trigger: "Participant's written notice to OAIP that project is ready to proceed (Section 2.B)" term_start: null term_end: null -official_url: https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/ +official_url: https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/ publication_citations: - "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf" source_documents: @@ -55,11 +55,10 @@ statute_anchors: - cite: "Utah Code §26B-4-704 (Telehealth)" url: "https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title26B/Chapter4/26B-4-S704.html" - cite: "UAC R156-1-501 / R156-1-602" - url: "https://adminrules.utah.gov/public/rule/R156-1/Current%20Rules" rules_mitigated: - "§58-1-501(1) and UAC R156-1-501(2)(b) — unlawful/unprofessional conduct for AI-authored psychiatric Rx renewal" - "§26B-4-704(6) and UAC R156-1-602 — telehealth-provider requirements" - - "Unprofessional-conduct provisions across prescriber chapters: §§58-31b-501-503, 58-60-109-111, 58-61-501-503, 58-67-501-503, 58-68-501-503, 58-70a-502-504" + - "Unprofessional-conduct provisions across prescriber chapters: §16E (supporting services) covers §§58-31b-501-503, 58-60-109-111, 58-61-501-503, 58-67-501-503, 58-68-501-503, 58-70a-502-504; §16D (named prescribers) is limited to §§58-31b-501-503, 58-67-501-503, 58-68-501-503" mitigations: - "Refills only for non-controlled, maintenance psychiatric medications on the Schedule B formulary (SSRIs, SNRIs, bupropion, trazodone ≤150mg, mirtazapine with metabolic monitoring, buspirone, hydroxyzine)" - "No new prescriptions, no dose changes, no switching or cross-taper" @@ -68,10 +67,10 @@ mitigations: - "Max 10 automated refills between provider reviews, or 6 months, whichever is sooner" - "Identity verification via government ID + biometric/selfie matching" - "Escalation triggers: suicidality, severe adverse effects, mania indicators, pregnancy, human-review requests" - - "Phased auditing: ≥98% agreement on 250 pre-pharmacy reviews; ≥99% on 1,000 retrospective reviews; ongoing monthly sampling" + - "Phased auditing: 250 pre-issuance reviews, advance if concordance >98%; 1,000 retrospective reviews, advance if concordance >99%; then ongoing periodic sampling (e.g., 5-10% monthly)" - "GenAI disclosure (§13-77-103 and §13-72a-203) + pharmacist disclosure that the renewal was AI-generated" - "Monthly reporting to ai@utah.gov with acceptance/denial counts, AI-vs-clinician agreement rates, complaints, adverse outcomes" - - "30-business-day cure period before termination for material breach (Section 6J)" + - "At least 30 business days (longer if reasonably required) to propose and implement a cure for failure to meet a Section 6 obligation, before the Office may elect to terminate (Section 6J)" status: enacted editorial_status: published supersedes: null @@ -81,10 +80,10 @@ withdrawal_reason: null withdrawn_by_instrument: null hash_chain_prev: null disclaimer: "" -last_verified: 2026-06-04 +last_verified: 2026-09-23 schema: https://publedge.org/schema/instrument.schema.json created: 2026-04-19 -modified: 2026-06-04 +modified: 2026-09-23 --- ## Summary @@ -93,7 +92,7 @@ A Regulatory Mitigation Agreement between the Utah Office of Artificial Intellig ## Background -Utah reports mental-health-provider shortages across all 29 counties, affecting up to 500,000 residents. Legion Health, an AI-native psychiatry clinic, applied to the AI Learning Lab to automate refill authorization for maintenance psychiatric medications. Executed 2026-03-18 (OAIP Director Zachary Boyd) and 2026-03-19 (DOPL Director Mark Steinagel; Legion Health PA CEO Jonathan Kole M.D.; Legion Health, Inc. CEO Yash Patel). Effective date depends on Participant's written commencement notice (Section 2.B); term is 12 months from that commencement. The Agreement explicitly tracks the Utah Code §13-72-302 → §13-72-401 transition effective 2026-05-06. +Legion's proposal states that all 29 Utah counties have designated mental-health shortages and that up to 500,000 residents receive no behavioral health care. Legion Health, an AI-native psychiatry clinic, applied to the AI Learning Lab to automate refill authorization for maintenance psychiatric medications. Executed 2026-03-18 (OAIP Director Zachary Boyd) and 2026-03-19 (DOPL Director Mark Steinagel; Legion Health PA CEO Jonathan Kole M.D.; Legion Health, Inc. CEO Yash Patel). Effective date depends on Participant's written commencement notice (Section 2.B); term is 12 months from that commencement. The Agreement explicitly tracks the Utah Code §13-72-302 → §13-72-401 transition effective 2026-05-06. ## Question presented @@ -113,12 +112,13 @@ May Legion Health's AI technology authorize refills of non-controlled maintenanc ## Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17) - Proposal-conforming methodology and protocols; amendments require signatures of all parties. -- AI deemed compliant with §26B-4-704(2)(b)-(c) and (4) when refill protocols followed; §26B-4-704(2)(e) when escalation protocols followed; §26B-4-704(5) does not apply. +- AI deemed compliant with §26B-4-704(2)(b)-(c) and (2)(e), and not in violation of (4), when it follows the protocols in Proposal section 4 (§17A.1-2); §26B-4-704(5) does not apply. - Portable electronic health records per §17B. - Compliance with Utah Code §13-72a (mental-health-chatbot requirements). - Disclosures per §13-77-103 and §13-72a-203 to users; additional disclosures to pharmacists that renewal was AI-generated. - Monthly reports with phased-audit benchmarks and adverse-event detail. -- 30-business-day cure period prior to termination for material breach. +- Proposal section 5 commits Legion to notify OAIP of defined pilot incidents within a bounded window after confirmation (target of 72 hours or less); the Agreement itself sets no incident-notification clock. +- At least 30 business days (longer if reasonably required) to propose and implement a cure for failure to meet a Section 6 obligation, before the Office may elect to terminate (§6J). ## Reliance scope @@ -140,6 +140,8 @@ Requesting-party-only. Mitigation runs to Legion Health PA, Legion Health, Inc., ## Limitations - Effective date depends on Participant's commencement notice; `term_start`/`term_end` not computable from the signed document alone. +- OAIP's Authorized AI Pilots page, retrieved 2026-09-24 (UTC), lists Legion Health as Approved and says "The demonstration period has not started yet." No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the commencement notice, so `effective`, `term_start` and `term_end` remain null. +- OAIP's register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability among Legion's commitments. No insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text; where that term is set out is unverified. - Does not cover new prescriptions, dose changes, switching, or cross-taper. - Does not cover controlled substances, benzodiazepines, antipsychotics, lithium/valproate, clozapine, or any medication requiring new labs or ECG for safe renewal. - Section 9 preserves IP; no transfer between parties. @@ -147,11 +149,12 @@ Requesting-party-only. Mitigation runs to Legion Health PA, Legion Health, Inc., ## Sources -- [Agreement page — Utah OAIP](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/) +- [Pilot page — Utah OAIP](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/) +- [Authorized AI Pilots — Utah OAIP](https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/) - [Signed PDF](https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf) - [Utah Code Title 13, Chapter 72](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72/13-72.html) - [Utah Code Title 13, Chapter 72a — Mental Health Chatbot](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter72A/13-72a.html) ## Notes on this demonstration remap -Fourth RMA (`us-ut-oaip-rma-0004`). Exercises schema features not covered by earlier RMAs: (1) participant is a pair of affiliated legal entities; (2) effective date is a deferred Commencement Date not fixed at signature — the registry must represent `term_start: null`; (3) the agreement straddles a statute renumbering (§13-72-302 → §13-72-401 effective 2026-05-06) and carries both citations; (4) two-tier affiliated-provider forbearance (direct-prescriber vs. supporting-services) under one instrument. +Fourth RMA (`us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001`). Exercises schema features not covered by earlier RMAs: (1) participant is a pair of affiliated legal entities; (2) effective date is a deferred Commencement Date not fixed at signature — the registry must represent `term_start: null`; (3) the agreement straddles a statute renumbering (§13-72-302 → §13-72-401 effective 2026-05-06) and carries both citations; (4) two-tier affiliated-provider forbearance (direct-prescriber vs. supporting-services) under one instrument. diff --git a/data/examples/mapping/index.yml b/data/examples/mapping/index.yml index d14666bf..5bf2a1cf 100644 --- a/data/examples/mapping/index.yml +++ b/data/examples/mapping/index.yml @@ -25,6 +25,7 @@ authority: utah-legislature source_file: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md source_heading: Summary + obligation_qualification: The learning-lab-agreement-participation text describes the regime as amended by HB 320 (2026), including joint interpretation agreements, a 36-month maximum, and governmental-entity counterparties; SB 149 as enacted provided regulatory mitigation agreements only, a 24-month maximum (12 months plus a single 12-month extension), and agency counterparties. obligations: - learning-lab-agreement-participation - ai-defense-elimination @@ -44,6 +45,7 @@ authority: utah-legislature source_file: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md source_heading: Summary + obligation_qualification: The disclose-genai-on-first-session mapping is related, not equivalent. HB 452 section 13-72a-203(2) requires disclosure before access, at the start of an interaction after seven days without access, and whenever the user asks or prompts; the obligation's per-session and 30-minute re-display terms are not statutory, and section 13-75-103(1) is the separate SB 226 on-request rule. obligations: - disclose-genai-on-first-session - chatbot-data-no-third-party-sharing diff --git a/data/examples/obligations/ai-defense-elimination.md b/data/examples/obligations/ai-defense-elimination.md index 3a81f22e..65b94254 100644 --- a/data/examples/obligations/ai-defense-elimination.md +++ b/data/examples/obligations/ai-defense-elimination.md @@ -6,6 +6,7 @@ group: restriction status: draft lifecycle_status: operative last_verified: 2026-04-21 +modified: 2026-09-23 search_terms: - ai defense - liability @@ -17,7 +18,7 @@ search_terms: ## Summary -Utah removed "the AI did it" as a defense in both civil and criminal contexts. A principal who uses, prompts, or acts through generative AI remains liable for the resulting statement or act. The criminal rule (§76-2-107, SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and the civil mirror (§13-75-102, SB 226, effective 2025-05-07) together eliminate the doctrine across Utah consumer-protection and criminal law. +Utah removed "the AI did it" as a defense in both civil and criminal contexts. A principal who uses, prompts, or acts through generative AI remains liable for the resulting statement or act. The criminal rule (§76-2-107, SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and the civil mirror together eliminate the doctrine across Utah consumer-protection and criminal law. The civil rule was first enacted at §13-2-12(2) (SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and re-sited at §13-75-102 (SB 226, effective 2025-05-07). ## What Counts @@ -33,5 +34,5 @@ Utah removed "the AI did it" as a defense in both civil and criminal contexts. A ## Statute Anchors -- Utah Code §13-75-102 — Civil AI-as-defense elimination (SB 226, 2025) +- Utah Code §13-75-102 — Civil AI-as-defense elimination (SB 226, 2025; formerly §13-2-12(2), SB 149, 2024) - Utah Code §76-2-107 — Criminal AI-as-defense / intentional prompting (SB 149, 2024) diff --git a/data/examples/obligations/chatbot-safety-policy-filing.md b/data/examples/obligations/chatbot-safety-policy-filing.md index ccf7e266..b297a62c 100644 --- a/data/examples/obligations/chatbot-safety-policy-filing.md +++ b/data/examples/obligations/chatbot-safety-policy-filing.md @@ -6,6 +6,7 @@ group: requirement status: draft lifecycle_status: operative last_verified: 2026-04-21 +modified: 2026-09-23 search_terms: - chatbot - mental health @@ -17,12 +18,13 @@ search_terms: ## Summary -A mental health chatbot supplier must draft, file with Utah's Division of Consumer Protection, and operationally comply with a fifteen-element written safety policy covering purposes, clinical practices, testing, risk protocols, user reporting, HIPAA posture, and more. Compliance with the filed policy at the time of an alleged violation provides an affirmative defense against §58-1-501(1)-(2) unauthorized-practice actions. +Filing is a condition of an affirmative defense, not a free-standing mandate. A mental health chatbot supplier has an affirmative defense against §58-1-501(1)-(2) unauthorized-practice actions if it shows that it created, maintained, and implemented a written policy meeting §58-60-118(3), including the fifteen procedure elements in (3)(c)(i)-(xv); maintains the development and implementation documentation required by (2)(b); filed the policy with Utah's Division of Consumer Protection; and complied with the filed policy at the time of the alleged violation. ## What Counts -- Written policy addressing all fifteen statutory elements (intended purposes, therapist involvement, clinical best practices, testing, risk identification, user reporting, acute-risk protocols, safety reviews, safe-use instructions, AI-awareness disclosure, engagement-over-safety prohibition, non-discrimination, HIPAA compliance, and foundation-model/training-data/accuracy documentation) -- Policy filed with the Utah Division of Consumer Protection along with the annual fee +- Written policy stating the chatbot's intended purposes, abilities, and limitations and describing all fifteen procedure elements in §58-60-118(3)(c) (therapist involvement, clinical best practices, pre-release and ongoing testing, foreseeable-harm identification, user reporting, risk-of-harm protocols, mitigation actions, real-time acute-risk protocols, regular safety reviews, safe-use instructions, AI-awareness, purpose and limitation awareness, safety over engagement or profit, non-discrimination, and HIPAA and consumer-protection compliance) +- Separate documentation of foundation models, training data, federal health privacy compliance, user data practices, and accuracy, reliability, fairness, and safety efforts (§58-60-118(2)(b)) +- Policy filed with the Utah Division of Consumer Protection along with the required fee (the division may also impose an annual filing fee) - Operational conformance to the filed policy at the time of the challenged conduct ## What Does Not Count diff --git a/data/examples/obligations/disclose-genai-on-first-session.md b/data/examples/obligations/disclose-genai-on-first-session.md index acca6d27..71f6879a 100644 --- a/data/examples/obligations/disclose-genai-on-first-session.md +++ b/data/examples/obligations/disclose-genai-on-first-session.md @@ -15,21 +15,24 @@ search_terms: ## Summary -A consumer-facing GenAI service must display a clear, prominent disclosure that the consumer is interacting with an AI system at the start of each session. +Disclose plainly that the person is interacting with generative AI and not a human. When the disclosure is due depends on the Utah provision: on a clear request in a consumer transaction (§13-75-103(1)); at the start of a high-risk interaction in a regulated occupation (§13-75-103(2)-(3)); and for a mental health chatbot, before access, again after seven days without access, and whenever asked (§13-72a-203(2)). No Utah provision anchored here requires re-display at every session or after a fixed inactivity period. ## What Counts -- Modal or banner shown on first session that names "AI" or "generative AI" plainly -- Re-display on session resumption after a defined inactivity threshold (e.g., 30 minutes) -- Disclosure is in the user's preferred language when supported by the product +- A disclosure that identifies the service as artificial intelligence and not a human +- Consumer transactions: disclosing when the individual clearly and unambiguously asks whether they are interacting with a human or AI (§13-75-103(1)) +- Regulated occupations, high-risk interactions: a prominent disclosure given verbally at the start of a verbal interaction, or in writing before a written interaction (§13-75-103(2)-(3)) +- Mental health chatbots: a clear and conspicuous disclosure before the user may access the chatbot's features, again at the start of an interaction when the user hasn't accessed it within the previous seven days, and whenever the user asks (§13-72a-203) +- Stricter terms, such as re-display after 30 minutes of inactivity in the draft JIA `us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001`, are proposals beyond the statute, not statutory requirements ## What Does Not Count -- Burying the notice in a privacy policy or terms-of-service link only -- Disclosure phrased ambiguously ("smart assistant," "automated helper") without the word "AI" -- One-time disclosure across multiple unrelated sessions +- For a mental health chatbot, a notice that isn't clear and conspicuous, such as one reachable only through a privacy policy or terms-of-service link +- For a regulated occupation's high-risk interaction, a disclosure that isn't prominent or comes after the interaction starts +- Phrasing that doesn't say the service is AI rather than a human ("smart assistant," "automated helper") +- For a mental health chatbot, skipping re-disclosure when the user returns after seven or more days without access ## Statute Anchors -- Utah Code §13-75-103(1) — General GenAI disclosure -- Utah Code §13-72a-203 — Mental-health chatbot disclosure (when applicable) +- Utah Code §13-75-103(1)-(3) — General GenAI disclosure (enacted by SB 226, 2025) +- Utah Code §13-72a-203 — Mental-health chatbot disclosure (enacted by HB 452, 2025) diff --git a/data/examples/obligations/elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle.md b/data/examples/obligations/elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle.md index 65759601..006f44bb 100644 --- a/data/examples/obligations/elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle.md +++ b/data/examples/obligations/elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle.md @@ -6,6 +6,7 @@ group: requirement status: draft lifecycle_status: expired last_verified: 2026-04-21 +modified: 2026-09-23 search_terms: - elizachat - disclosure @@ -20,7 +21,7 @@ Before granting any user access to ElizaChat app functionality, the participant ## What Counts - Participant name and contact information -- Notice that the user is interacting with generative AI pursuant to Utah Code §13-2-12(4) (now Chapter 75 post-SB 226) +- Notice that the user is interacting with generative AI pursuant to Utah Code §13-2-12(4), as cited in the agreement - Notice that the app is in testing, may not function as intended, and may expose users to risks identified in the Testing Plan - Description of how user data and correspondence will be used and shared - OAIP complaint channel — phone number and/or website address provided by the Office @@ -35,5 +36,5 @@ Before granting any user access to ElizaChat app functionality, the participant ## Statute Anchors -- Utah Code §13-2-12(4) (historical reference, superseded by Chapter 75 post-SB 226) +- Utah Code §13-2-12(4) (as cited in Section VI.G; later statutory succession not verified here) - Utah RMA 2024-001 Section VI.G — Disclosures to Users diff --git a/data/examples/obligations/learning-lab-agreement-participation.md b/data/examples/obligations/learning-lab-agreement-participation.md index 4a4981d8..eba2d41b 100644 --- a/data/examples/obligations/learning-lab-agreement-participation.md +++ b/data/examples/obligations/learning-lab-agreement-participation.md @@ -6,6 +6,7 @@ group: permission status: draft lifecycle_status: operative last_verified: 2026-04-21 +modified: 2026-09-23 search_terms: - learning lab - regulatory mitigation @@ -18,29 +19,29 @@ search_terms: ## Summary -A person deploying AI in Utah may enter either a Regulatory Mitigation Agreement (RMA) — which waives specified law in exchange for safeguards, data sharing, and disclosures — or a Joint Interpretation Agreement (JIA) — which clarifies how existing statute applies to a specific AI use without waiver. Agreements run for an initial twelve months with up to two twelve-month extensions, counterparties include OAIP plus the relevant state agency (or judiciary, higher-ed, or political subdivision under HB 320), and participants must satisfy five statutory eligibility prongs. +A person deploying AI in Utah may enter either a Regulatory Mitigation Agreement (RMA) — which waives specified law in exchange for safeguards, data sharing, and disclosures — or a Joint Interpretation Agreement (JIA) — which clarifies how existing statute applies to a specific AI use without waiver. Agreements run for an initial twelve months with up to two twelve-month extensions, counterparties include OAIP plus the relevant state agency (or the judiciary, a state-funded higher or public education institution, or a political subdivision under HB 320), and participants must satisfy five statutory eligibility prongs. ## What Counts - Demonstrated technical capability to operate the proposed AI use -- Financial resources sufficient for ongoing compliance and indemnification -- Consumer benefits that substantially outweigh identified risks +- Financial resources sufficient to meet obligations during testing +- Potential substantial consumer benefits that may outweigh identified risks - Documented risk-monitoring plan covering the agreement scope - Scope appropriately limited to the statute, use case, and deployment period - Executed agreement stating scope limits, safeguards, mitigations granted, required consumer disclosures, and reporting requirements -- Submission to OAIP regular audits and annual Nov 30 reporting +- Submission to OAIP regular audits while the agreement is in effect, with agreement reporting requirements to comply with those audits (the annual Nov 30 report is OAIP's duty to the Legislature, not a participant duty) ## What Does Not Count - Broad regulatory waivers not tied to a specified statute or use case - Agreements without scope limits, safeguards, or consumer disclosures - Term exceeding thirty-six months in aggregate (§13-72-403) -- Operating outside the agreement scope (immediate removal + retroactive enforcement) +- Using or deploying AI technology that violates legal or regulatory requirements or the agreement terms (possible immediate removal and all applicable civil and criminal penalties) ## Statute Anchors - Utah Code §13-72-201 — OAIP administration of the Learning Lab program -- Utah Code §13-72-301 — Joint Interpretation Agreements (added by HB 320, 2026) +- Utah Code §13-72-301 — Artificial Intelligence Learning Laboratory Program (JIAs are covered by §13-72-401) - Utah Code §13-72-401 — Agreement contents and counterparties - Utah Code §13-72-402 — Participant eligibility prongs - Utah Code §13-72-403 — Term limits and extensions diff --git a/data/examples/obligations/named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.md b/data/examples/obligations/named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.md index 4ecc59ca..c0c57b04 100644 --- a/data/examples/obligations/named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.md +++ b/data/examples/obligations/named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.md @@ -6,6 +6,7 @@ group: permission status: draft lifecycle_status: operative last_verified: 2026-04-21 +modified: 2026-09-23 search_terms: - named prescriber - enforcement forbearance @@ -17,15 +18,16 @@ search_terms: ## Summary -DOPL forgoes unlawful-conduct and unprofessional-conduct enforcement under §58-1-501(1)-(2) and related professional-licensing provisions against any provider who (1) acts solely as the named prescriber for AI-authorized renewals, (2) does not interact directly with a patient or other provider, and (3) complies with the RMA terms. Forbearance applies only to conduct authorized by the agreement. +DOPL forgoes unlawful-conduct and unprofessional-conduct enforcement under §58-1-501(1)-(2) and related professional-licensing provisions against any provider who (1) acts solely as the named prescriber for AI-authorized renewals and (2) does not interact directly with a patient or other provider. Legion §16(D) adds a condition that the provider abides by the agreement and any agreement with the participant; Doctronic §15(D) states no such condition. The covered chapter provisions differ by agreement. Forbearance applies only to conduct authorized by the agreement. ## What Counts - Provider's role is limited to being the named prescriber for AI-generated renewal - Provider does not interact directly with the patient or another provider in the renewal chain - Provider acts in reliance on the participant's AI technology -- Provider abides by the terms of the RMA and any separate agreement with the participant -- Forbearance also covers 58-31b / 58-60 / 58-61 / 58-67 / 58-68 / 58-70a professional-conduct provisions as specified in the agreement +- Provider abides by the terms of the RMA and any separate agreement with the participant (Legion §16(D) condition; not stated in Doctronic §15(D)) +- Doctronic §15(D)(2) chapter provisions, as written in the signed text: 58-31b-502, 58-60-110, 58-61-502, 59-67-502 [sic], 58-68-502, 59-70a-503 [sic], and 58-71-502 +- Legion §16(D)(2) chapter provisions: 58-31b-501-503, 58-67-501-503, and 58-68-501-503 (the broader list adding 58-60, 58-61 and 58-70a is in §16(E), which covers supporting-services providers, not named prescribers) ## What Does Not Count @@ -38,4 +40,4 @@ DOPL forgoes unlawful-conduct and unprofessional-conduct enforcement under §58- - Utah Code §58-1-501(1) and (2) — Unlawful and unprofessional conduct baseline - UAC R156-1-501(2)(b) — Administrative rule -- Utah RMAs 2025-002 (Doctronic) §15(D) and 2026-001 (Legion) §16(D)-(E) +- Utah RMAs 2025-002 (Doctronic) §15(D) and 2026-001 (Legion) §16(D) (supporting-services forbearance is separate, §16(E)) diff --git a/data/examples/obligations/telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.md b/data/examples/obligations/telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.md index 2281c737..62910bf9 100644 --- a/data/examples/obligations/telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.md +++ b/data/examples/obligations/telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.md @@ -6,6 +6,7 @@ group: requirement status: draft lifecycle_status: operative last_verified: 2026-04-21 +modified: 2026-09-23 search_terms: - telehealth - 26b-4-704 @@ -16,13 +17,13 @@ search_terms: ## Summary -A participant operating AI-assisted prescription renewal must adhere to Utah's telehealth provider requirements in §26B-4-704, with specific subsections deemed satisfied by following the patient-journey and escalation protocols described in the participant's Proposal (Schedule B). Certain subsections (e.g., the patient-records portability default) are inapplicable; others are substituted by Proposal-section conformance. +A participant operating AI-assisted prescription renewal must adhere to Utah's telehealth provider requirements in §26B-4-704, with specific subsections deemed satisfied by following protocols described in the participant's Proposal (Schedule B): Doctronic Parts 2B and 3B; Legion Proposal section 4. Certain subsections (e.g., the patient-records portability default) are inapplicable; others are substituted by Proposal-section conformance. ## What Counts - Adherence to §26B-4-704 as the baseline telehealth framework -- Compliance with subsection (2)(b)-(c) and subsection (4) is established through the participant's documented patient-journey and clinical-workflow protocols -- Compliance with subsection (2)(e) is established through the participant's documented escalation protocols +- Compliance with subsection (2)(b)-(c), and not being in violation of subsection (4), when the AI follows the Proposal protocols named in the agreement: Doctronic Part 2B (Patient Journey and Clinical Workflow); Legion Proposal section 4 +- Compliance with subsection (2)(e) when the AI follows the Proposal protocols named in the agreement: Doctronic Part 3B (Escalation Protocols); Legion Proposal section 4 - Patient-records portability (where required by agreement, e.g., Legion §17(B)) through a portable format or user download/share option ## What Does Not Count diff --git a/docs/MANIFEST.yaml b/docs/MANIFEST.yaml index c1eea989..72e1067d 100644 --- a/docs/MANIFEST.yaml +++ b/docs/MANIFEST.yaml @@ -183,37 +183,37 @@ files: - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:372a62e39b49fc961482974100e5f04e22b1a922fadce391e66c68dc3d4993f2 + hash: sha256:6fb9a910496ef034a5b8b241d8859688cb39d2370fd3321b07649b32e3f49e2e note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:fe72c5b4cc375bf679bc8f03edd4ccd7b7cddafad47ece6439f8a5449fd967e7 + hash: sha256:c75fb508faa76236a1cd60e5ed221ff2df4bae4c426295098f1ac0cd9d7836fb note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:518882b00ebe9515a3f4697a2da41a607c506c8d844a31895dcf1851d0f5dd3a + hash: sha256:9cb602b984427da4e4f0bdc1ba9f56458de93a54911769c20584ce105b1c6cf0 note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:97e8084f429a9565d1b7e2d4eeb6ab7cb0d16c63762838c30c18afde1f436a83 + hash: sha256:6de7ddf6525087ffe3f1e32b40dac48954dc0cfe7eceabd5e5717f24307a9a36 note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.md - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:111b246cf8bb2b1118face419aa81634e3eba290346e98be8e47761d2a8345d5 + hash: sha256:01797df3b03a8a6d33869d8a1ed4a0575acea137ea8b84598087d3a0fca8008d note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:1c73dcfdf1dc9dc14040426990fdd43ea4db8615ca0523c2914d7fda1e40d740 + hash: sha256:639f19ea3a4b559894f32da3142be916fbd98e3b9fe5791edb9a05d80a6d61ad note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7 + hash: sha256:c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18 note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-001.md @@ -223,12 +223,12 @@ files: - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984 + hash: sha256:8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724 note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md - path: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md role: instrument - hash: sha256:d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a + hash: sha256:3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788 note: data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md - path: ATTRIBUTION.md @@ -253,7 +253,7 @@ files: - path: data/examples/mapping/index.yml role: mapping - hash: sha256:3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592 + hash: sha256:b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f note: data/examples/mapping/index.yml - path: data/examples/obligations/admt-60-day-cure-period.md @@ -293,7 +293,7 @@ files: - path: data/examples/obligations/ai-defense-elimination.md role: obligation - hash: sha256:ecda85918d33c2ebe2345f5cdef1e78e25f533d645c3efa2d7402022cf2bba33 + hash: sha256:a55e45923f6c446174676808c25e74c677631fb8550f520ee92ba2786eb08151 note: data/examples/obligations/ai-defense-elimination.md - path: data/examples/obligations/cfpb-pay-to-pay-fee-prohibited.md @@ -313,7 +313,7 @@ files: - path: data/examples/obligations/chatbot-safety-policy-filing.md role: obligation - hash: sha256:64d1121bd3ffbe629f4ea714deee5bd9ac05371f8492487128fbe4a8de8f0b2e + hash: sha256:926ce7f92c39b4613ccaea98594d2a43f06982309402d41d5b1a4571842a3066 note: data/examples/obligations/chatbot-safety-policy-filing.md - path: data/examples/obligations/dentacor-58-69-5-enforcement-forborne.md @@ -338,7 +338,7 @@ files: - path: data/examples/obligations/disclose-genai-on-first-session.md role: obligation - hash: sha256:964a825c8ad92c8e5a59ceda27d05433bd145b2b381af9edb7f6309681a55b71 + hash: sha256:785f11886a59611ca6458facf971ef6bcf088085a4c12675492498d88380fc8d note: data/examples/obligations/disclose-genai-on-first-session.md - path: data/examples/obligations/disclose-genai-on-request.md @@ -353,7 +353,7 @@ files: - path: data/examples/obligations/elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle.md role: obligation - hash: sha256:44ccb58a19ec9ebb04c917de3e9b65ecb0cf3fdccad3464e3309f8818ff254b1 + hash: sha256:4caf489311fac12b33ead6ccea5e1765d489d4991aed57e4b2d174922b542d4e note: data/examples/obligations/elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle.md - path: data/examples/obligations/high-risk-ai-consumer-notice-correction-and-appeal.md @@ -383,12 +383,12 @@ files: - path: data/examples/obligations/learning-lab-agreement-participation.md role: obligation - hash: sha256:efeebe2f9d9c60fcfc09d9cdddc438f311e27a5064b2d999d490d1835f67b45b + hash: sha256:c7f07d610d5c3bb5aa942d5d80fb3dad563ed73529770ed89888a4fca1d537eb note: data/examples/obligations/learning-lab-agreement-participation.md - path: data/examples/obligations/named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.md role: obligation - hash: sha256:9bc50212ab23b5d835c423f3639e384f25ada45855f2c438e27f80bfef616083 + hash: sha256:a387cda4d9c8ae0c04a890f5cb8f665334ded7bf384cdab2048006bcd0818164 note: data/examples/obligations/named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.md - path: data/examples/obligations/rma-data-security-63a-19-102.md @@ -428,12 +428,12 @@ files: - path: data/examples/obligations/telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.md role: obligation - hash: sha256:7fc842d907a39f82bfca7bf5380ba6887404ff5693e1b473d807b424ffe49af0 + hash: sha256:ee6e7f615e88f8defb62bb6c58442887c9f13e51afd01a63249deff01c8e9bda note: data/examples/obligations/telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.md - path: CHANGELOG.md role: protocol - hash: sha256:850926cc973c09d2c295a9edf0134b2a3e2827272e974fee8e25477a0c152bcb + hash: sha256:0b46bc1d7717b1413fb3c8d23f183771a973e042c9c3ff7e9293c895976bc3a3 note: CHANGELOG.md - path: CONTRIBUTING.md @@ -1028,7 +1028,7 @@ files: - path: tests/maintenance.test.js role: code - hash: sha256:e79c6acf32b51c8203e8284f574c612b21984d8c5ebddabd42ba6f9e69495cda + hash: sha256:73a1456f27b4bacbd8aea385046f0ae29daef62df427091160766224ee462a40 note: T10 bounded maintenance pilot - path: tests/generated-record-schema.test.js @@ -1038,7 +1038,7 @@ files: - path: tests/source-admission.test.js role: code - hash: sha256:1b47af7b67056a838e3b19e9ed06f5f9a8bfc7cc11bdab8d5c096fde7fcc20bc + hash: sha256:d2ec25e0a18c9c83b9ec505fedecf776f2b5971b4f4de24102273681467f45b2 note: Source admission policy and producer-gate regressions - path: tests/publication-state.test.js @@ -1048,7 +1048,7 @@ files: - path: tests/doctronic-observation.test.js role: code - hash: sha256:9185ead5745b5a7de55c228ec30e6bd9b80746503516864786e949c7577fdb4d + hash: sha256:d9964bfaeb126d4111b4f7c7363b085567c3713ed68cbcff5e75d2b4003b5089 note: Dated outcomes versus issued-term boundary regression - path: tests/source-owned-mapping.test.js @@ -1058,7 +1058,7 @@ files: - path: tests/of-evidence-inputs.test.js role: code - hash: sha256:d9a179498a065b70f94d2bd81a951106da5a33cca12f72759774ce9b2d0e5423 + hash: sha256:1e604a0fb0f847f796d655245a431333e412da9f94e1f01e96c38818323b084c note: Per-kind native evidence input and review-boundary regressions - path: tests/colorado-order24.test.js diff --git a/docs/agents.json b/docs/agents.json index cf0fa5b9..acda95a7 100644 --- a/docs/agents.json +++ b/docs/agents.json @@ -174,7 +174,7 @@ }, { "id": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452", - "name": "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations", + "name": "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots)", "status": "enforcing", "url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-002/" }, @@ -192,7 +192,7 @@ }, { "id": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320", - "name": "Utah HB 320 (2026) — AI Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements", + "name": "Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements)", "status": "enforcing", "url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2026-001/" }, @@ -542,7 +542,7 @@ "protocol_authority_response": "https://publedge.org/about/#authority-response" }, "meta": { - "last_updated": "2026-09-12", + "last_updated": "2026-09-23", "built_with": "Knowledge as Code", "pattern_url": "https://knowledge-as-code.com", "template_url": "https://github.com/snapsynapse/knowledge-as-code-template" diff --git a/docs/api/v1/authorities.json b/docs/api/v1/authorities.json index 47da974c..f74f9fdf 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/authorities.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/authorities.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "meta": { - "generated": "2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z", + "generated": "2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z", "count": 8 }, "items": [ diff --git a/docs/api/v1/comparisons.json b/docs/api/v1/comparisons.json index 8486953b..cfeb253c 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/comparisons.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/comparisons.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "meta": { - "generated": "2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z" + "generated": "2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z" }, "comparisons": [ { diff --git a/docs/api/v1/containers.json b/docs/api/v1/containers.json index b3b2798c..a0de8c2e 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/containers.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/containers.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "meta": { - "generated": "2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z", + "generated": "2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z", "count": 18 }, "items": [ @@ -87,7 +87,7 @@ }, { "id": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452", - "name": "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations", + "name": "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots)", "source": "authoritative-reference", "status": "enforcing", "editorial_status": "published", @@ -114,7 +114,7 @@ }, { "id": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320", - "name": "Utah HB 320 (2026) — AI Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements", + "name": "Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements)", "source": "authoritative-reference", "status": "enforcing", "editorial_status": "published", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/index.json b/docs/api/v1/index.json index bebf8e32..53cc8fb7 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/index.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/index.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "meta": { - "generated": "2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z", + "generated": "2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z", "version": "1.0", "project": "publedge" }, diff --git a/docs/api/v1/mappings.json b/docs/api/v1/mappings.json index ad61bdc6..cc631ab3 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/mappings.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/mappings.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "meta": { - "generated": "2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z", + "generated": "2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z", "count": 16 }, "items": [ @@ -26,11 +26,11 @@ "_evidence_input": { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session", "canonical_sha256": "c307d8182e42993daa76516e2a364800ab0cccdea4fa8febf65c53f4371cb5d6", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "476523ef2974b11f96c887c77c8135e1b4e835d70264833e80b5204eccc4d75f", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], @@ -38,7 +38,9 @@ "unresolved": [ "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", - "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law." + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." ] } }, @@ -48,6 +50,7 @@ "authority": "utah-legislature", "source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md", "source_heading": "Summary", + "obligation_qualification": "The learning-lab-agreement-participation text describes the regime as amended by HB 320 (2026), including joint interpretation agreements, a 36-month maximum, and governmental-entity counterparties; SB 149 as enacted provided regulatory mitigation agreements only, a 24-month maximum (12 months plus a single 12-month extension), and agency counterparties.", "obligations": [ "learning-lab-agreement-participation", "ai-defense-elimination" @@ -55,14 +58,23 @@ "_evidence_input": { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense", - "canonical_sha256": "61f84dffd6d2394a4b68aa79f58c20c3ab31813efd1677bf8e94da2c8b88a21a", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "56836cab160c49426e9224ae78e504cdbfa8c30d175cba082b10d0b98f1a2b21", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." + ] } }, { @@ -79,7 +91,7 @@ "_evidence_input": { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense", "canonical_sha256": "4a99aeb263d40980aeb761d4572a047a19b10322e712878efd9d8c5f3bdda649", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -95,6 +107,7 @@ "authority": "utah-legislature", "source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md", "source_heading": "Summary", + "obligation_qualification": "The disclose-genai-on-first-session mapping is related, not equivalent. HB 452 section 13-72a-203(2) requires disclosure before access, at the start of an interaction after seven days without access, and whenever the user asks or prompts; the obligation's per-session and 30-minute re-display terms are not statutory, and section 13-75-103(1) is the separate SB 226 on-request rule.", "obligations": [ "disclose-genai-on-first-session", "chatbot-data-no-third-party-sharing", @@ -103,14 +116,23 @@ "_evidence_input": { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack", - "canonical_sha256": "0efa1a9d629192ea94613364015b159f0297afd09676a5633788f81b626ed675", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "66bc4b8a16d6100604ecc6c10e8fd489aed581208679ce6a3c847cb44b7b3d7c", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." + ] } }, { @@ -125,7 +147,7 @@ "_evidence_input": { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements", "canonical_sha256": "b85f1f2ef1628ab2a223640d36314be87543371986c0cb7fdd43099d48765c2e", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -154,7 +176,7 @@ "_evidence_input": { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -183,7 +205,7 @@ "_evidence_input": { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -212,7 +234,7 @@ "_evidence_input": { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -241,7 +263,7 @@ "_evidence_input": { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -263,7 +285,7 @@ "_evidence_input": { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:cfpb-ao-2022-001-pay-to-pay", "canonical_sha256": "e20e0bcb6fa5c62776f77e650f41e715b8d0ce8458a1f56e75a3a91709f998e5", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -285,7 +307,7 @@ "_evidence_input": { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:cftc-il-17-65-cta-unbundled-fee", "canonical_sha256": "cb56b0ebd2521dd3f2e355886a0b19d77ceda42cd5ad315aa03459673efec377", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -307,7 +329,7 @@ "_evidence_input": { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:irs-plr-202506001-incentive-fee", "canonical_sha256": "c2145852b85e818957983272334c5f4d57d23b7aecb92fa4ab317cb205d88489", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -329,7 +351,7 @@ "_evidence_input": { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:irs-tege-2026-001-501c3-adverse", "canonical_sha256": "baba5d8ce4007aca04c51194d650f7639c767679b1e300d0f35b9ce0f8cb88bc", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -351,7 +373,7 @@ "_evidence_input": { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001-rule-506c", "canonical_sha256": "9c7546b5135751e232852b0e9fcdf18e02973c38dd7c819d999b897a259e32e4", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -375,7 +397,7 @@ "_evidence_input": { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb24-205-never-operative-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "4849304cb37f40f5cb292b4ab29c1230e89a3dbce9c3f16ba17c1d63f50f8e1b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -402,7 +424,7 @@ "_evidence_input": { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb26-189-admt-act-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8208176ce48fdbdfcd77357ea089231259a600b6827dd8a0fcd6ed41047afd4d", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/matrix.json b/docs/api/v1/matrix.json index edd891d5..8c6b5afb 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/matrix.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/matrix.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "meta": { - "generated": "2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z" + "generated": "2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z" }, "matrix": { "admt-60-day-cure-period": { diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/authorities.json b/docs/api/v1/of/authorities.json index 27686dbf..5bc5c058 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/authorities.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/authorities.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "@context": "https://obligationfirst.org/v1/context.jsonld", - "generated": "2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z", + "generated": "2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z", "authorities": [ { "@context": [ diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/determinations.json b/docs/api/v1/of/determinations.json index 0c0f112c..63631bab 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/determinations.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/determinations.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "@context": "https://obligationfirst.org/v1/context.jsonld", - "generated": "2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z", + "generated": "2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z", "determinations": [ { "@context": [ @@ -451,36 +451,42 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", "source_citation": "Utah SB 149 (2024 General Session), Governor Signed March 13, 2024", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md", - "native_file_sha256": "372a62e39b49fc961482974100e5f04e22b1a922fadce391e66c68dc3d4993f2", + "native_file_sha256": "6fb9a910496ef034a5b8b241d8859688cb39d2370fd3321b07649b32e3f49e2e", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "53b0d1aff53dcae4e0bd8e34ee2021069340673c56b979bf6a639b1ca589c202", + "canonical_sha256": "c1aca07ba833a22c5029c1afa612bd5aff05a91c2a2e3d30309c12a4ba792235", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "4f6f7ab0b94560d1e81548a417d56e0026eee2e21799079f7baa04f2b448aa7e", + "review_packet_sha256": "4638f21fae0dfa0223ba78a611e37ad1d1c900807b53ff46a89832c0ba759e74", "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "02db4dfb7fcc9c536f4aa7e006458da3ed0ba3567a7cc4478db9e3d5c3195514", "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884", "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy." ] } ] @@ -510,36 +516,38 @@ "resulting_instrument": [ "https://publedge.org/instrument/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.json" ], - "notes": "Issuance record for Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations.", + "notes": "Issuance record for Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots).", "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html", "source_citation": "Utah HB 452 (2025 General Session)", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md", - "native_file_sha256": "fe72c5b4cc375bf679bc8f03edd4ccd7b7cddafad47ece6439f8a5449fd967e7", + "native_file_sha256": "c75fb508faa76236a1cd60e5ed221ff2df4bae4c426295098f1ac0cd9d7836fb", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8deea5bfdfb67ecb23276907a46d7d76dbe492525a4b401dfcad8a1933fbbea5", + "canonical_sha256": "823a6f04b847768379b4f8d5218794e3c88e31d2fcdd1032d881da4cc49eccde", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "38ad104b571b171500e69a42c94ef01bbc1f85d57335af6e7ec67f0c6bb43705", + "review_packet_sha256": "be382469d216fa204a551bbd826747b34bbc49fc2e9581723266bd05df6a9690", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." ] } ] @@ -572,26 +580,41 @@ "notes": "Issuance record for Utah SB 226 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments.", "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/SB0226.html", "source_citation": "Utah SB 226 (2025 General Session)", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md", - "native_file_sha256": "518882b00ebe9515a3f4697a2da41a607c506c8d844a31895dcf1851d0f5dd3a", + "native_file_sha256": "9cb602b984427da4e4f0bdc1ba9f56458de93a54911769c20584ce105b1c6cf0", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "7e4a5fbb8f032549b461c3d8840b09b6dfe91587e3b95cde0269b6a9bd69ac2c", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "50b4e7a0685706064d5b50d211ba997047c14518a371a7ee1c859a4ccbe8e530", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "4ac77cfcca432ea01bcba7273922a36be25970b9c78729c8cd6241f6c3ee1733", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] } ] }, @@ -623,26 +646,37 @@ "notes": "Issuance record for Utah SB 332 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Revisions (AIPA Sunset Extension).", "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/SB0332.html", "source_citation": "Utah SB 332 (2025 General Session), Governor Signed March 25, 2025", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "The effective field stays 2025-05-07. SB 332 took effect May 7, 2025, or on governor approval if passed by two-thirds of each house; the record votes (24-0-5, 74-0-1) would exceed two-thirds but are not confirmed against a retained status page.", + "enacted (2025-03-25) and all introduction, committee and floor-vote rows are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0332 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 332 amends 63I-2-213(5), the repeal date SB 149 set, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.md", - "native_file_sha256": "97e8084f429a9565d1b7e2d4eeb6ab7cb0d16c63762838c30c18afde1f436a83", + "native_file_sha256": "6de7ddf6525087ffe3f1e32b40dac48954dc0cfe7eceabd5e5717f24307a9a36", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "9a1f758c218403901c5d9dcd442ebd4dff0118a7c713feeb24efdc0656e853d9", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "bd4aa91c270b8033ecea8ff2cd6a4b7396df9b9e9ffdc9950d3bc69f10fe59b9", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "ad3c5755c52e64c6fba5d00117de2b57dba0291757f7084cc28f0b5641a1f09d", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The effective field stays 2025-05-07. SB 332 took effect May 7, 2025, or on governor approval if passed by two-thirds of each house; the record votes (24-0-5, 74-0-1) would exceed two-thirds but are not confirmed against a retained status page.", + "enacted (2025-03-25) and all introduction, committee and floor-vote rows are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0332 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 332 amends 63I-2-213(5), the repeal date SB 149 set, so the source does not contradict it." + ] } ] }, @@ -671,29 +705,45 @@ "resulting_instrument": [ "https://publedge.org/instrument/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.json" ], - "notes": "Issuance record for Utah HB 320 (2026) — AI Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements.", + "notes": "Issuance record for Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements).", "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2026/bills/static/HB0320.html", "source_citation": "Utah HB 320 (2026 General Session)", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md", - "native_file_sha256": "111b246cf8bb2b1118face419aa81634e3eba290346e98be8e47761d2a8345d5", + "native_file_sha256": "01797df3b03a8a6d33869d8a1ed4a0575acea137ea8b84598087d3a0fca8008d", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8c4fba21742f0b6e177e6c4789075c6851acbcd3359335a24162d7f007393692", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "0602d5a250b66e24ed6f13779a1c055cc90a4f97b27249ef54d099a3e9eb9ad7", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "b140f99a901d8f1e6f4bf389765fa85c72c5b7972a9ddf3f63132f56646e5da3", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] } ] }, @@ -723,28 +773,39 @@ "https://publedge.org/instrument/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.json" ], "notes": "Issuance record for Utah OAIP × ElizaChat — Teen Mental-Health App RMA (2024).", - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] } ] }, @@ -828,7 +889,7 @@ "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/doctronic/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", @@ -836,33 +897,38 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] } ] @@ -893,28 +959,41 @@ "https://publedge.org/instrument/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.json" ], "notes": "Issuance record for Utah OAIP × Legion Health — AI Maintenance Psychiatric Refill RMA (2026).", - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/index.json b/docs/api/v1/of/index.json index 1e5864aa..8bcc519f 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/index.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/index.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "@context": "https://obligationfirst.org/v1/context.jsonld", - "generated": "2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z", + "generated": "2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z", "files": { "authorities": "authorities.json", "parties": "parties.json", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/instruments.json b/docs/api/v1/of/instruments.json index 6dfbb517..a6aeded7 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/instruments.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/instruments.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "@context": "https://obligationfirst.org/v1/context.jsonld", - "generated": "2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z", + "generated": "2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z", "instruments": [ { "@context": [ @@ -591,7 +591,7 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", "source_citation": "Utah SB 149 (2024 General Session), Governor Signed March 13, 2024", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "enforcing", "pub:editorial_status": "published", @@ -600,30 +600,36 @@ "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md", - "native_file_sha256": "372a62e39b49fc961482974100e5f04e22b1a922fadce391e66c68dc3d4993f2", + "native_file_sha256": "6fb9a910496ef034a5b8b241d8859688cb39d2370fd3321b07649b32e3f49e2e", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "53b0d1aff53dcae4e0bd8e34ee2021069340673c56b979bf6a639b1ca589c202", + "canonical_sha256": "c1aca07ba833a22c5029c1afa612bd5aff05a91c2a2e3d30309c12a4ba792235", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "4f6f7ab0b94560d1e81548a417d56e0026eee2e21799079f7baa04f2b448aa7e", + "review_packet_sha256": "4638f21fae0dfa0223ba78a611e37ad1d1c900807b53ff46a89832c0ba759e74", "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "02db4dfb7fcc9c536f4aa7e006458da3ed0ba3567a7cc4478db9e3d5c3195514", "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884", "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy." ] } ] @@ -638,8 +644,8 @@ "@type": "of:Instrument", "@id": "https://publedge.org/instrument/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.json", "pub:id": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452", - "title": "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations", - "short_title": "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations", + "title": "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots)", + "short_title": "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots)", "issuedBy": [ "https://publedge.org/authority/utah-legislature.json" ], @@ -669,7 +675,7 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html", "source_citation": "Utah HB 452 (2025 General Session)", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "enforcing", "pub:editorial_status": "published", @@ -678,26 +684,28 @@ "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md", - "native_file_sha256": "fe72c5b4cc375bf679bc8f03edd4ccd7b7cddafad47ece6439f8a5449fd967e7", + "native_file_sha256": "c75fb508faa76236a1cd60e5ed221ff2df4bae4c426295098f1ac0cd9d7836fb", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8deea5bfdfb67ecb23276907a46d7d76dbe492525a4b401dfcad8a1933fbbea5", + "canonical_sha256": "823a6f04b847768379b4f8d5218794e3c88e31d2fcdd1032d881da4cc49eccde", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "38ad104b571b171500e69a42c94ef01bbc1f85d57335af6e7ec67f0c6bb43705", + "review_packet_sha256": "be382469d216fa204a551bbd826747b34bbc49fc2e9581723266bd05df6a9690", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." ] } ] @@ -742,29 +750,44 @@ "citation": "Utah SB 226 (2025 General Session)", "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/SB0226.html", "source_citation": "Utah SB 226 (2025 General Session)", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "enforcing", "pub:editorial_status": "published", "pub:canonical_url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-001/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md", - "native_file_sha256": "518882b00ebe9515a3f4697a2da41a607c506c8d844a31895dcf1851d0f5dd3a", + "native_file_sha256": "9cb602b984427da4e4f0bdc1ba9f56458de93a54911769c20584ce105b1c6cf0", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "7e4a5fbb8f032549b461c3d8840b09b6dfe91587e3b95cde0269b6a9bd69ac2c", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "50b4e7a0685706064d5b50d211ba997047c14518a371a7ee1c859a4ccbe8e530", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "4ac77cfcca432ea01bcba7273922a36be25970b9c78729c8cd6241f6c3ee1733", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] } ] }, @@ -806,29 +829,40 @@ "citation": "Utah SB 332 (2025 General Session), Governor Signed March 25, 2025", "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/SB0332.html", "source_citation": "Utah SB 332 (2025 General Session), Governor Signed March 25, 2025", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "enforcing", "pub:editorial_status": "published", "pub:canonical_url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-003/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "The effective field stays 2025-05-07. SB 332 took effect May 7, 2025, or on governor approval if passed by two-thirds of each house; the record votes (24-0-5, 74-0-1) would exceed two-thirds but are not confirmed against a retained status page.", + "enacted (2025-03-25) and all introduction, committee and floor-vote rows are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0332 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 332 amends 63I-2-213(5), the repeal date SB 149 set, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.md", - "native_file_sha256": "97e8084f429a9565d1b7e2d4eeb6ab7cb0d16c63762838c30c18afde1f436a83", + "native_file_sha256": "6de7ddf6525087ffe3f1e32b40dac48954dc0cfe7eceabd5e5717f24307a9a36", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "9a1f758c218403901c5d9dcd442ebd4dff0118a7c713feeb24efdc0656e853d9", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "bd4aa91c270b8033ecea8ff2cd6a4b7396df9b9e9ffdc9950d3bc69f10fe59b9", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "ad3c5755c52e64c6fba5d00117de2b57dba0291757f7084cc28f0b5641a1f09d", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The effective field stays 2025-05-07. SB 332 took effect May 7, 2025, or on governor approval if passed by two-thirds of each house; the record votes (24-0-5, 74-0-1) would exceed two-thirds but are not confirmed against a retained status page.", + "enacted (2025-03-25) and all introduction, committee and floor-vote rows are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0332 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 332 amends 63I-2-213(5), the repeal date SB 149 set, so the source does not contradict it." + ] } ] }, @@ -842,8 +876,8 @@ "@type": "of:Instrument", "@id": "https://publedge.org/instrument/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.json", "pub:id": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320", - "title": "Utah HB 320 (2026) — AI Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements", - "short_title": "Utah HB 320 (2026) — AI Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements", + "title": "Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements)", + "short_title": "Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements)", "issuedBy": [ "https://publedge.org/authority/utah-legislature.json" ], @@ -872,29 +906,45 @@ "citation": "Utah HB 320 (2026 General Session)", "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2026/bills/static/HB0320.html", "source_citation": "Utah HB 320 (2026 General Session)", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "enforcing", "pub:editorial_status": "published", "pub:canonical_url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2026-001/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md", - "native_file_sha256": "111b246cf8bb2b1118face419aa81634e3eba290346e98be8e47761d2a8345d5", + "native_file_sha256": "01797df3b03a8a6d33869d8a1ed4a0575acea137ea8b84598087d3a0fca8008d", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8c4fba21742f0b6e177e6c4789075c6851acbcd3359335a24162d7f007393692", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "0602d5a250b66e24ed6f13779a1c055cc90a4f97b27249ef54d099a3e9eb9ad7", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "b140f99a901d8f1e6f4bf389765fa85c72c5b7972a9ddf3f63132f56646e5da3", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] } ] }, @@ -944,30 +994,39 @@ "territorial_scope": [ "us-ut" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "proposed", "pub:editorial_status": "draft", "pub:canonical_url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/jia/2026-001/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "1c73dcfdf1dc9dc14040426990fdd43ea4db8615ca0523c2914d7fda1e40d740", + "native_file_sha256": "639f19ea3a4b559894f32da3142be916fbd98e3b9fe5791edb9a05d80a6d61ad", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "c2190dfc51ff2893e9e1a4d49c9457f0fca3791cd8cca5878fe55c1a7b014c19", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "b935a9e9d2a81ec511b4f507e2086e60394cba0f5ca191721dfd405edb4c17d6", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "27b15547fb411ec37543f7deac2039683b39c228e9d71b8d5976e645c811d329", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ] } ] }, @@ -1028,31 +1087,42 @@ "us-ut" ], "citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "expired", "pub:editorial_status": "published", "pub:canonical_url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2024-001/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] } ] }, @@ -1201,7 +1271,7 @@ "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/doctronic/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "enforcing", "pub:editorial_status": "published", @@ -1212,33 +1282,38 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] } ] @@ -1304,31 +1379,44 @@ "us-ut" ], "citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "enacted", "pub:editorial_status": "published", "pub:canonical_url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2026-001/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/obligations.json b/docs/api/v1/of/obligations.json index 36cb7607..af6a200c 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/obligations.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/obligations.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "@context": "https://obligationfirst.org/v1/context.jsonld", - "generated": "2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z", + "generated": "2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z", "obligations": [ { "@context": [ @@ -13,7 +13,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session-disclose-genai-on-first-session.json", "pub:id": "utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session-disclose-genai-on-first-session", "title": "Disclose GenAI on First Session", - "content": "A consumer-facing GenAI service must display a clear, prominent disclosure that the consumer is interacting with an AI system at the start of each session.", + "content": "Disclose plainly that the person is interacting with generative AI and not a human. When the disclosure is due depends on the Utah provision: on a clear request in a consumer transaction (§13-75-103(1)); at the start of a high-risk interaction in a regulated occupation (§13-75-103(2)-(3)); and for a mental health chatbot, before access, again after seven days without access, and whenever asked (§13-72a-203(2)). No Utah provision anchored here requires re-display at every session or after a fixed inactivity period.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session.json" ], @@ -29,9 +29,9 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", "source_locator": "Utah Code §13-72a-203", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", "verified": "2026-04-18", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:primary_id": "disclose-genai-on-first-session", @@ -45,35 +45,47 @@ "chatbot" ], "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field.", "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", - "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law." + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt.", + "The obligation id and name still say 'first session'; renaming the id is a separate schema decision.", + "last_verified renewal requires a separate human review receipt." ], - "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "1c73dcfdf1dc9dc14040426990fdd43ea4db8615ca0523c2914d7fda1e40d740", + "native_file_sha256": "639f19ea3a4b559894f32da3142be916fbd98e3b9fe5791edb9a05d80a6d61ad", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "c2190dfc51ff2893e9e1a4d49c9457f0fca3791cd8cca5878fe55c1a7b014c19", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "b935a9e9d2a81ec511b4f507e2086e60394cba0f5ca191721dfd405edb4c17d6", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "27b15547fb411ec37543f7deac2039683b39c228e9d71b8d5976e645c811d329", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session", "canonical_sha256": "c307d8182e42993daa76516e2a364800ab0cccdea4fa8febf65c53f4371cb5d6", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "476523ef2974b11f96c887c77c8135e1b4e835d70264833e80b5204eccc4d75f", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], @@ -81,20 +93,28 @@ "unresolved": [ "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", - "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law." + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." ] }, { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/disclose-genai-on-first-session.md", - "native_file_sha256": "964a825c8ad92c8e5a59ceda27d05433bd145b2b381af9edb7f6309681a55b71", + "native_file_sha256": "785f11886a59611ca6458facf971ef6bcf088085a4c12675492498d88380fc8d", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "416ca3ea40e4681bf3f0ccb9a00cd890d94214d1e9c0ffd262fbb6a8a17da163", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "c87615a8fc2a979ae02b7d3c833c2b2cfcb476b6b61bdfae0d86d17343eb787d", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "8086134b9fedbd88d7dd4e183a80419860da6b3e77dd75151942f662cdfca44c", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The obligation id and name still say 'first session'; renaming the id is a separate schema decision.", + "last_verified renewal requires a separate human review receipt." + ] } ] }, @@ -109,7 +129,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense-learning-lab-agreement-participation.json", "pub:id": "sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense-learning-lab-agreement-participation", "title": "Learning Lab Agreement — Eligibility and Participation", - "content": "A person deploying AI in Utah may enter either a Regulatory Mitigation Agreement (RMA) — which waives specified law in exchange for safeguards, data sharing, and disclosures — or a Joint Interpretation Agreement (JIA) — which clarifies how existing statute applies to a specific AI use without waiver. Agreements run for an initial twelve months with up to two twelve-month extensions, counterparties include OAIP plus the relevant state agency (or judiciary, higher-ed, or political subdivision under HB 320), and participants must satisfy five statutory eligibility prongs.", + "content": "A person deploying AI in Utah may enter either a Regulatory Mitigation Agreement (RMA) — which waives specified law in exchange for safeguards, data sharing, and disclosures — or a Joint Interpretation Agreement (JIA) — which clarifies how existing statute applies to a specific AI use without waiver. Agreements run for an initial twelve months with up to two twelve-month extensions, counterparties include OAIP plus the relevant state agency (or the judiciary, a state-funded higher or public education institution, or a political subdivision under HB 320), and participants must satisfy five statutory eligibility prongs.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense.json" ], @@ -125,7 +145,7 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", "source_locator": "Summary", "source_citation": "Utah SB 149 (2024 General Session), Governor Signed March 13, 2024", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", "verified": "2026-04-21", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:primary_id": "learning-lab-agreement-participation", @@ -142,58 +162,85 @@ "hb320" ], "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy.", + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt.", + "Prongs (a), (d) and (e) in What Counts remain paraphrases and were not re-worded; \"limited to the statute, use case, and deployment period\" is not statutory wording for prong (e) (scale, scope, and duration of testing limited based on risk assessments).", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." ], - "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md", - "native_file_sha256": "372a62e39b49fc961482974100e5f04e22b1a922fadce391e66c68dc3d4993f2", + "native_file_sha256": "6fb9a910496ef034a5b8b241d8859688cb39d2370fd3321b07649b32e3f49e2e", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "53b0d1aff53dcae4e0bd8e34ee2021069340673c56b979bf6a639b1ca589c202", + "canonical_sha256": "c1aca07ba833a22c5029c1afa612bd5aff05a91c2a2e3d30309c12a4ba792235", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "4f6f7ab0b94560d1e81548a417d56e0026eee2e21799079f7baa04f2b448aa7e", + "review_packet_sha256": "4638f21fae0dfa0223ba78a611e37ad1d1c900807b53ff46a89832c0ba759e74", "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "02db4dfb7fcc9c536f4aa7e006458da3ed0ba3567a7cc4478db9e3d5c3195514", "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884", "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense", - "canonical_sha256": "61f84dffd6d2394a4b68aa79f58c20c3ab31813efd1677bf8e94da2c8b88a21a", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "56836cab160c49426e9224ae78e504cdbfa8c30d175cba082b10d0b98f1a2b21", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." + ] }, { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/learning-lab-agreement-participation.md", - "native_file_sha256": "efeebe2f9d9c60fcfc09d9cdddc438f311e27a5064b2d999d490d1835f67b45b", + "native_file_sha256": "c7f07d610d5c3bb5aa942d5d80fb3dad563ed73529770ed89888a4fca1d537eb", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "cedc5a7a4518542affc3c7518e31fc80696614382ab1ee3f976d1a8368ffd633", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "649cf9611b65c4fd518106a4ce461906db0953381bb5b342dc92b1bd149bfae3", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "342fac2ddf576b7837c36901ef92ee9abfa96c0e6b3d6bd8459a87b57058c8b6", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "Prongs (a), (d) and (e) in What Counts remain paraphrases and were not re-worded; \"limited to the statute, use case, and deployment period\" is not statutory wording for prong (e) (scale, scope, and duration of testing limited based on risk assessments).", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ] } ] }, @@ -208,7 +255,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense-ai-defense-elimination.json", "pub:id": "sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense-ai-defense-elimination", "title": "GenAI Is Not A Defense — Civil And Criminal", - "content": "Utah removed \"the AI did it\" as a defense in both civil and criminal contexts. A principal who uses, prompts, or acts through generative AI remains liable for the resulting statement or act. The criminal rule (§76-2-107, SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and the civil mirror (§13-75-102, SB 226, effective 2025-05-07) together eliminate the doctrine across Utah consumer-protection and criminal law.", + "content": "Utah removed \"the AI did it\" as a defense in both civil and criminal contexts. A principal who uses, prompts, or acts through generative AI remains liable for the resulting statement or act. The criminal rule (§76-2-107, SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and the civil mirror together eliminate the doctrine across Utah consumer-protection and criminal law. The civil rule was first enacted at §13-2-12(2) (SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and re-sited at §13-75-102 (SB 226, effective 2025-05-07).", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense.json" ], @@ -224,7 +271,7 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", "source_locator": "Summary", "source_citation": "Utah SB 149 (2024 General Session), Governor Signed March 13, 2024", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", "verified": "2026-04-21", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:primary_id": "ai-defense-elimination", @@ -240,58 +287,84 @@ "sb226" ], "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy.", + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt.", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." ], - "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md", - "native_file_sha256": "372a62e39b49fc961482974100e5f04e22b1a922fadce391e66c68dc3d4993f2", + "native_file_sha256": "6fb9a910496ef034a5b8b241d8859688cb39d2370fd3321b07649b32e3f49e2e", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "53b0d1aff53dcae4e0bd8e34ee2021069340673c56b979bf6a639b1ca589c202", + "canonical_sha256": "c1aca07ba833a22c5029c1afa612bd5aff05a91c2a2e3d30309c12a4ba792235", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "4f6f7ab0b94560d1e81548a417d56e0026eee2e21799079f7baa04f2b448aa7e", + "review_packet_sha256": "4638f21fae0dfa0223ba78a611e37ad1d1c900807b53ff46a89832c0ba759e74", "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "02db4dfb7fcc9c536f4aa7e006458da3ed0ba3567a7cc4478db9e3d5c3195514", "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884", "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense", - "canonical_sha256": "61f84dffd6d2394a4b68aa79f58c20c3ab31813efd1677bf8e94da2c8b88a21a", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "56836cab160c49426e9224ae78e504cdbfa8c30d175cba082b10d0b98f1a2b21", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." + ] }, { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/ai-defense-elimination.md", - "native_file_sha256": "ecda85918d33c2ebe2345f5cdef1e78e25f533d645c3efa2d7402022cf2bba33", + "native_file_sha256": "a55e45923f6c446174676808c25e74c677631fb8550f520ee92ba2786eb08151", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "0950aebbe08e66dce2babf56a5ea6f3671fbb8595b6c91b82ef2d4ad66a97d19", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "cfe3ca3e3ecabd66a2fae7c5efe481ad10b4a14f6ffb251c26b2e0ae99f45e26", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "d55ff8b00852b7a4a493871057a1dc3b033c434c83fef2eea19d1295f5a9cd8c", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ] } ] }, @@ -339,25 +412,40 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md", - "native_file_sha256": "518882b00ebe9515a3f4697a2da41a607c506c8d844a31895dcf1851d0f5dd3a", + "native_file_sha256": "9cb602b984427da4e4f0bdc1ba9f56458de93a54911769c20584ce105b1c6cf0", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "7e4a5fbb8f032549b461c3d8840b09b6dfe91587e3b95cde0269b6a9bd69ac2c", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "50b4e7a0685706064d5b50d211ba997047c14518a371a7ee1c859a4ccbe8e530", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "4ac77cfcca432ea01bcba7273922a36be25970b9c78729c8cd6241f6c3ee1733", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense", "canonical_sha256": "4a99aeb263d40980aeb761d4572a047a19b10322e712878efd9d8c5f3bdda649", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -424,25 +512,40 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md", - "native_file_sha256": "518882b00ebe9515a3f4697a2da41a607c506c8d844a31895dcf1851d0f5dd3a", + "native_file_sha256": "9cb602b984427da4e4f0bdc1ba9f56458de93a54911769c20584ce105b1c6cf0", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "7e4a5fbb8f032549b461c3d8840b09b6dfe91587e3b95cde0269b6a9bd69ac2c", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "50b4e7a0685706064d5b50d211ba997047c14518a371a7ee1c859a4ccbe8e530", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "4ac77cfcca432ea01bcba7273922a36be25970b9c78729c8cd6241f6c3ee1733", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense", "canonical_sha256": "4a99aeb263d40980aeb761d4572a047a19b10322e712878efd9d8c5f3bdda649", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -476,7 +579,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense-ai-defense-elimination.json", "pub:id": "sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense-ai-defense-elimination", "title": "GenAI Is Not A Defense — Civil And Criminal", - "content": "Utah removed \"the AI did it\" as a defense in both civil and criminal contexts. A principal who uses, prompts, or acts through generative AI remains liable for the resulting statement or act. The criminal rule (§76-2-107, SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and the civil mirror (§13-75-102, SB 226, effective 2025-05-07) together eliminate the doctrine across Utah consumer-protection and criminal law.", + "content": "Utah removed \"the AI did it\" as a defense in both civil and criminal contexts. A principal who uses, prompts, or acts through generative AI remains liable for the resulting statement or act. The criminal rule (§76-2-107, SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and the civil mirror together eliminate the doctrine across Utah consumer-protection and criminal law. The civil rule was first enacted at §13-2-12(2) (SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and re-sited at §13-75-102 (SB 226, effective 2025-05-07).", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense.json" ], @@ -510,25 +613,41 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it.", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md", - "native_file_sha256": "518882b00ebe9515a3f4697a2da41a607c506c8d844a31895dcf1851d0f5dd3a", + "native_file_sha256": "9cb602b984427da4e4f0bdc1ba9f56458de93a54911769c20584ce105b1c6cf0", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "7e4a5fbb8f032549b461c3d8840b09b6dfe91587e3b95cde0269b6a9bd69ac2c", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "50b4e7a0685706064d5b50d211ba997047c14518a371a7ee1c859a4ccbe8e530", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "4ac77cfcca432ea01bcba7273922a36be25970b9c78729c8cd6241f6c3ee1733", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense", "canonical_sha256": "4a99aeb263d40980aeb761d4572a047a19b10322e712878efd9d8c5f3bdda649", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -540,14 +659,19 @@ { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/ai-defense-elimination.md", - "native_file_sha256": "ecda85918d33c2ebe2345f5cdef1e78e25f533d645c3efa2d7402022cf2bba33", + "native_file_sha256": "a55e45923f6c446174676808c25e74c677631fb8550f520ee92ba2786eb08151", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "0950aebbe08e66dce2babf56a5ea6f3671fbb8595b6c91b82ef2d4ad66a97d19", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "cfe3ca3e3ecabd66a2fae7c5efe481ad10b4a14f6ffb251c26b2e0ae99f45e26", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "d55ff8b00852b7a4a493871057a1dc3b033c434c83fef2eea19d1295f5a9cd8c", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ] } ] }, @@ -562,7 +686,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-disclose-genai-on-first-session.json", "pub:id": "hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-disclose-genai-on-first-session", "title": "Disclose GenAI on First Session", - "content": "A consumer-facing GenAI service must display a clear, prominent disclosure that the consumer is interacting with an AI system at the start of each session.", + "content": "Disclose plainly that the person is interacting with generative AI and not a human. When the disclosure is due depends on the Utah provision: on a clear request in a consumer transaction (§13-75-103(1)); at the start of a high-risk interaction in a regulated occupation (§13-75-103(2)-(3)); and for a mental health chatbot, before access, again after seven days without access, and whenever asked (§13-72a-203(2)). No Utah provision anchored here requires re-display at every session or after a fixed inactivity period.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack.json" ], @@ -578,7 +702,7 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html", "source_locator": "Summary", "source_citation": "Utah HB 452 (2025 General Session)", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", "verified": "2026-04-18", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:primary_id": "disclose-genai-on-first-session", @@ -592,54 +716,78 @@ "chatbot" ], "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed.", + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt.", + "The obligation id and name still say 'first session'; renaming the id is a separate schema decision.", + "last_verified renewal requires a separate human review receipt." ], - "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md", - "native_file_sha256": "fe72c5b4cc375bf679bc8f03edd4ccd7b7cddafad47ece6439f8a5449fd967e7", + "native_file_sha256": "c75fb508faa76236a1cd60e5ed221ff2df4bae4c426295098f1ac0cd9d7836fb", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8deea5bfdfb67ecb23276907a46d7d76dbe492525a4b401dfcad8a1933fbbea5", + "canonical_sha256": "823a6f04b847768379b4f8d5218794e3c88e31d2fcdd1032d881da4cc49eccde", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "38ad104b571b171500e69a42c94ef01bbc1f85d57335af6e7ec67f0c6bb43705", + "review_packet_sha256": "be382469d216fa204a551bbd826747b34bbc49fc2e9581723266bd05df6a9690", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack", - "canonical_sha256": "0efa1a9d629192ea94613364015b159f0297afd09676a5633788f81b626ed675", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "66bc4b8a16d6100604ecc6c10e8fd489aed581208679ce6a3c847cb44b7b3d7c", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." + ] }, { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/disclose-genai-on-first-session.md", - "native_file_sha256": "964a825c8ad92c8e5a59ceda27d05433bd145b2b381af9edb7f6309681a55b71", + "native_file_sha256": "785f11886a59611ca6458facf971ef6bcf088085a4c12675492498d88380fc8d", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "416ca3ea40e4681bf3f0ccb9a00cd890d94214d1e9c0ffd262fbb6a8a17da163", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "c87615a8fc2a979ae02b7d3c833c2b2cfcb476b6b61bdfae0d86d17343eb787d", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "8086134b9fedbd88d7dd4e183a80419860da6b3e77dd75151942f662cdfca44c", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The obligation id and name still say 'first session'; renaming the id is a separate schema decision.", + "last_verified renewal requires a separate human review receipt." + ] } ] }, @@ -688,39 +836,55 @@ "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed.", + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md", - "native_file_sha256": "fe72c5b4cc375bf679bc8f03edd4ccd7b7cddafad47ece6439f8a5449fd967e7", + "native_file_sha256": "c75fb508faa76236a1cd60e5ed221ff2df4bae4c426295098f1ac0cd9d7836fb", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8deea5bfdfb67ecb23276907a46d7d76dbe492525a4b401dfcad8a1933fbbea5", + "canonical_sha256": "823a6f04b847768379b4f8d5218794e3c88e31d2fcdd1032d881da4cc49eccde", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "38ad104b571b171500e69a42c94ef01bbc1f85d57335af6e7ec67f0c6bb43705", + "review_packet_sha256": "be382469d216fa204a551bbd826747b34bbc49fc2e9581723266bd05df6a9690", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack", - "canonical_sha256": "0efa1a9d629192ea94613364015b159f0297afd09676a5633788f81b626ed675", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "66bc4b8a16d6100604ecc6c10e8fd489aed581208679ce6a3c847cb44b7b3d7c", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." + ] }, { "kind": "obligation-definition", @@ -747,7 +911,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-chatbot-safety-policy-filing.json", "pub:id": "hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-chatbot-safety-policy-filing", "title": "Mental Health Chatbot — File 15-Element Safety Policy", - "content": "A mental health chatbot supplier must draft, file with Utah's Division of Consumer Protection, and operationally comply with a fifteen-element written safety policy covering purposes, clinical practices, testing, risk protocols, user reporting, HIPAA posture, and more. Compliance with the filed policy at the time of an alleged violation provides an affirmative defense against §58-1-501(1)-(2) unauthorized-practice actions.", + "content": "Filing is a condition of an affirmative defense, not a free-standing mandate. A mental health chatbot supplier has an affirmative defense against §58-1-501(1)-(2) unauthorized-practice actions if it shows that it created, maintained, and implemented a written policy meeting §58-60-118(3), including the fifteen procedure elements in (3)(c)(i)-(xv); maintains the development and implementation documentation required by (2)(b); filed the policy with Utah's Division of Consumer Protection; and complied with the filed policy at the time of the alleged violation.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack.json" ], @@ -763,7 +927,7 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html", "source_locator": "Summary", "source_citation": "Utah HB 452 (2025 General Session)", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", "verified": "2026-04-21", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:primary_id": "chatbot-safety-policy-filing", @@ -779,54 +943,77 @@ "hb452" ], "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed.", + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt.", + "The record name (\"File 15-Element Safety Policy\"), group (requirement) and @type Requirement still frame the item as a requirement; the statute makes the policy a condition of an affirmative defense. These schema-level fields were left for a human decision.", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." ], - "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md", - "native_file_sha256": "fe72c5b4cc375bf679bc8f03edd4ccd7b7cddafad47ece6439f8a5449fd967e7", + "native_file_sha256": "c75fb508faa76236a1cd60e5ed221ff2df4bae4c426295098f1ac0cd9d7836fb", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8deea5bfdfb67ecb23276907a46d7d76dbe492525a4b401dfcad8a1933fbbea5", + "canonical_sha256": "823a6f04b847768379b4f8d5218794e3c88e31d2fcdd1032d881da4cc49eccde", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "38ad104b571b171500e69a42c94ef01bbc1f85d57335af6e7ec67f0c6bb43705", + "review_packet_sha256": "be382469d216fa204a551bbd826747b34bbc49fc2e9581723266bd05df6a9690", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack", - "canonical_sha256": "0efa1a9d629192ea94613364015b159f0297afd09676a5633788f81b626ed675", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "66bc4b8a16d6100604ecc6c10e8fd489aed581208679ce6a3c847cb44b7b3d7c", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." + ] }, { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/chatbot-safety-policy-filing.md", - "native_file_sha256": "64d1121bd3ffbe629f4ea714deee5bd9ac05371f8492487128fbe4a8de8f0b2e", + "native_file_sha256": "926ce7f92c39b4613ccaea98594d2a43f06982309402d41d5b1a4571842a3066", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "3e34be05b6bd18616f0fbfe450bcf9599ffd9d02386ba84fd27f5aa9172d2cee", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "ba1facfe4b4274c2be9551a415246ce1ce26893555011114157835277c98fcb9", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "16858b62701ee470ac7ee01bf9a0ff90f302fca04242dacd946f2ba09ee4ec18", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The record name (\"File 15-Element Safety Policy\"), group (requirement) and @type Requirement still frame the item as a requirement; the statute makes the policy a condition of an affirmative defense. These schema-level fields were left for a human decision.", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ] } ] }, @@ -841,7 +1028,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements-learning-lab-agreement-participation.json", "pub:id": "hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements-learning-lab-agreement-participation", "title": "Learning Lab Agreement — Eligibility and Participation", - "content": "A person deploying AI in Utah may enter either a Regulatory Mitigation Agreement (RMA) — which waives specified law in exchange for safeguards, data sharing, and disclosures — or a Joint Interpretation Agreement (JIA) — which clarifies how existing statute applies to a specific AI use without waiver. Agreements run for an initial twelve months with up to two twelve-month extensions, counterparties include OAIP plus the relevant state agency (or judiciary, higher-ed, or political subdivision under HB 320), and participants must satisfy five statutory eligibility prongs.", + "content": "A person deploying AI in Utah may enter either a Regulatory Mitigation Agreement (RMA) — which waives specified law in exchange for safeguards, data sharing, and disclosures — or a Joint Interpretation Agreement (JIA) — which clarifies how existing statute applies to a specific AI use without waiver. Agreements run for an initial twelve months with up to two twelve-month extensions, counterparties include OAIP plus the relevant state agency (or the judiciary, a state-funded higher or public education institution, or a political subdivision under HB 320), and participants must satisfy five statutory eligibility prongs.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements.json" ], @@ -876,25 +1063,43 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it.", + "Prongs (a), (d) and (e) in What Counts remain paraphrases and were not re-worded; \"limited to the statute, use case, and deployment period\" is not statutory wording for prong (e) (scale, scope, and duration of testing limited based on risk assessments).", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md", - "native_file_sha256": "111b246cf8bb2b1118face419aa81634e3eba290346e98be8e47761d2a8345d5", + "native_file_sha256": "01797df3b03a8a6d33869d8a1ed4a0575acea137ea8b84598087d3a0fca8008d", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8c4fba21742f0b6e177e6c4789075c6851acbcd3359335a24162d7f007393692", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "0602d5a250b66e24ed6f13779a1c055cc90a4f97b27249ef54d099a3e9eb9ad7", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "b140f99a901d8f1e6f4bf389765fa85c72c5b7972a9ddf3f63132f56646e5da3", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements", "canonical_sha256": "b85f1f2ef1628ab2a223640d36314be87543371986c0cb7fdd43099d48765c2e", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -906,14 +1111,19 @@ { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/learning-lab-agreement-participation.md", - "native_file_sha256": "efeebe2f9d9c60fcfc09d9cdddc438f311e27a5064b2d999d490d1835f67b45b", + "native_file_sha256": "c7f07d610d5c3bb5aa942d5d80fb3dad563ed73529770ed89888a4fca1d537eb", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "cedc5a7a4518542affc3c7518e31fc80696614382ab1ee3f976d1a8368ffd633", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "649cf9611b65c4fd518106a4ce461906db0953381bb5b342dc92b1bd149bfae3", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "342fac2ddf576b7837c36901ef92ee9abfa96c0e6b3d6bd8459a87b57058c8b6", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "Prongs (a), (d) and (e) in What Counts remain paraphrases and were not re-worded; \"limited to the statute, use case, and deployment period\" is not statutory wording for prong (e) (scale, scope, and duration of testing limited based on risk assessments).", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ] } ] }, @@ -941,7 +1151,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -961,25 +1171,36 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -1026,7 +1247,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -1045,25 +1266,36 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -1110,7 +1342,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -1129,25 +1361,36 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -1194,7 +1437,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -1212,25 +1455,36 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -1277,7 +1531,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -1296,25 +1550,36 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -1361,7 +1626,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -1381,25 +1646,36 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -1446,7 +1722,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -1465,25 +1741,38 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed.", + "The later statutory succession of Utah Code 13-2-12(4) was not verified in this review.", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -1495,14 +1784,19 @@ { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle.md", - "native_file_sha256": "44ccb58a19ec9ebb04c917de3e9b65ecb0cf3fdccad3464e3309f8818ff254b1", + "native_file_sha256": "4caf489311fac12b33ead6ccea5e1765d489d4991aed57e4b2d174922b542d4e", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "f64f5494465abe222b34894c969931ace7d9512886e328caac5e334f6faa4a4f", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "e449b7df832e2d80c45aac253c20e5502ba589defb7dbfafe479424158761207", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "567d6db18f9afefffc5f88015f85ee6ba556464ad62d16cd0e0df759e8251814", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The later statutory succession of Utah Code 13-2-12(4) was not verified in this review.", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ] } ] }, @@ -1530,7 +1824,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -1549,25 +1843,36 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -1652,7 +1957,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -1736,7 +2041,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -1820,7 +2125,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -1903,7 +2208,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -1987,7 +2292,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -2072,7 +2377,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -2157,7 +2462,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -2241,7 +2546,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -2311,39 +2616,44 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -2412,39 +2722,44 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -2513,39 +2828,44 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -2613,39 +2933,44 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -2714,39 +3039,44 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -2817,39 +3147,44 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -2883,7 +3218,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/doctronic-rma-obligations-named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.json", "pub:id": "doctronic-rma-obligations-named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne", "title": "Named-Prescriber Enforcement Forborne", - "content": "DOPL forgoes unlawful-conduct and unprofessional-conduct enforcement under §58-1-501(1)-(2) and related professional-licensing provisions against any provider who (1) acts solely as the named prescriber for AI-authorized renewals, (2) does not interact directly with a patient or other provider, and (3) complies with the RMA terms. Forbearance applies only to conduct authorized by the agreement.", + "content": "DOPL forgoes unlawful-conduct and unprofessional-conduct enforcement under §58-1-501(1)-(2) and related professional-licensing provisions against any provider who (1) acts solely as the named prescriber for AI-authorized renewals and (2) does not interact directly with a patient or other provider. Legion §16(D) adds a condition that the provider abides by the agreement and any agreement with the participant; Doctronic §15(D) states no such condition. The covered chapter provisions differ by agreement. Forbearance applies only to conduct authorized by the agreement.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/doctronic-rma-obligations.json" ], @@ -2920,8 +3255,11 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained.", + "The Doctronic signed text cites 59-67-502 and 59-70a-503, which appear to be typographical errors for chapter 58 provisions; reproduced as written with [sic].", "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", @@ -2929,30 +3267,34 @@ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -2964,14 +3306,20 @@ { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.md", - "native_file_sha256": "9bc50212ab23b5d835c423f3639e384f25ada45855f2c438e27f80bfef616083", + "native_file_sha256": "a387cda4d9c8ae0c04a890f5cb8f665334ded7bf384cdab2048006bcd0818164", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "3efcdd6116bdcae121cc7aa3a01540886abcc8f1c02fd41381410d06eeae01b2", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7dc4b7ad687deab2b549477c9e6f9630e149d7276ad1b2a14e5792a23ad39a2e", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "a0c3843be94bb884536528046719eb207d6b40ff0e8ab6bb43e4c49a484dbf75", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The Doctronic signed text cites 59-67-502 and 59-70a-503, which appear to be typographical errors for chapter 58 provisions; reproduced as written with [sic].", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ] } ] }, @@ -2986,7 +3334,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/doctronic-rma-obligations-telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.json", "pub:id": "doctronic-rma-obligations-telehealth-compliance-per-proposal", "title": "Telehealth Compliance Anchored To Participant Proposal", - "content": "A participant operating AI-assisted prescription renewal must adhere to Utah's telehealth provider requirements in §26B-4-704, with specific subsections deemed satisfied by following the patient-journey and escalation protocols described in the participant's Proposal (Schedule B). Certain subsections (e.g., the patient-records portability default) are inapplicable; others are substituted by Proposal-section conformance.", + "content": "A participant operating AI-assisted prescription renewal must adhere to Utah's telehealth provider requirements in §26B-4-704, with specific subsections deemed satisfied by following protocols described in the participant's Proposal (Schedule B): Doctronic Parts 2B and 3B; Legion Proposal section 4. Certain subsections (e.g., the patient-records portability default) are inapplicable; others are substituted by Proposal-section conformance.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/doctronic-rma-obligations.json" ], @@ -3022,8 +3370,10 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained.", "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", @@ -3031,30 +3381,34 @@ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -3066,14 +3420,19 @@ { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.md", - "native_file_sha256": "7fc842d907a39f82bfca7bf5380ba6887404ff5693e1b473d807b424ffe49af0", + "native_file_sha256": "ee6e7f615e88f8defb62bb6c58442887c9f13e51afd01a63249deff01c8e9bda", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "9c48efe15d307aef5d471ed3f519cb58af70e2dcadfaa81b98f8ec49f3eb73a5", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "94a2bf8d07c1ef80630998be799cee2a47c2a9174e3daa33fb7299b79e149551", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "1310fbf27797da6fff4c35851151ae4515314be22eb50f876ae82212a3895657", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ] } ] }, @@ -3101,7 +3460,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -3121,25 +3480,38 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -3186,7 +3558,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -3205,25 +3577,38 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -3270,7 +3655,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -3289,25 +3674,38 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -3354,7 +3752,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -3372,25 +3770,38 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -3437,7 +3848,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -3456,25 +3867,38 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -3521,7 +3945,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -3542,25 +3966,38 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -3594,7 +4031,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/legion-rma-obligations-named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.json", "pub:id": "legion-rma-obligations-named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne", "title": "Named-Prescriber Enforcement Forborne", - "content": "DOPL forgoes unlawful-conduct and unprofessional-conduct enforcement under §58-1-501(1)-(2) and related professional-licensing provisions against any provider who (1) acts solely as the named prescriber for AI-authorized renewals, (2) does not interact directly with a patient or other provider, and (3) complies with the RMA terms. Forbearance applies only to conduct authorized by the agreement.", + "content": "DOPL forgoes unlawful-conduct and unprofessional-conduct enforcement under §58-1-501(1)-(2) and related professional-licensing provisions against any provider who (1) acts solely as the named prescriber for AI-authorized renewals and (2) does not interact directly with a patient or other provider. Legion §16(D) adds a condition that the provider abides by the agreement and any agreement with the participant; Doctronic §15(D) states no such condition. The covered chapter provisions differ by agreement. Forbearance applies only to conduct authorized by the agreement.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/legion-rma-obligations.json" ], @@ -3607,7 +4044,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -3628,25 +4065,40 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained.", + "The Doctronic signed text cites 59-67-502 and 59-70a-503, which appear to be typographical errors for chapter 58 provisions; reproduced as written with [sic].", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -3658,14 +4110,20 @@ { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.md", - "native_file_sha256": "9bc50212ab23b5d835c423f3639e384f25ada45855f2c438e27f80bfef616083", + "native_file_sha256": "a387cda4d9c8ae0c04a890f5cb8f665334ded7bf384cdab2048006bcd0818164", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "3efcdd6116bdcae121cc7aa3a01540886abcc8f1c02fd41381410d06eeae01b2", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7dc4b7ad687deab2b549477c9e6f9630e149d7276ad1b2a14e5792a23ad39a2e", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "a0c3843be94bb884536528046719eb207d6b40ff0e8ab6bb43e4c49a484dbf75", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The Doctronic signed text cites 59-67-502 and 59-70a-503, which appear to be typographical errors for chapter 58 provisions; reproduced as written with [sic].", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ] } ] }, @@ -3680,7 +4138,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/legion-rma-obligations-telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.json", "pub:id": "legion-rma-obligations-telehealth-compliance-per-proposal", "title": "Telehealth Compliance Anchored To Participant Proposal", - "content": "A participant operating AI-assisted prescription renewal must adhere to Utah's telehealth provider requirements in §26B-4-704, with specific subsections deemed satisfied by following the patient-journey and escalation protocols described in the participant's Proposal (Schedule B). Certain subsections (e.g., the patient-records portability default) are inapplicable; others are substituted by Proposal-section conformance.", + "content": "A participant operating AI-assisted prescription renewal must adhere to Utah's telehealth provider requirements in §26B-4-704, with specific subsections deemed satisfied by following protocols described in the participant's Proposal (Schedule B): Doctronic Parts 2B and 3B; Legion Proposal section 4. Certain subsections (e.g., the patient-records portability default) are inapplicable; others are substituted by Proposal-section conformance.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/legion-rma-obligations.json" ], @@ -3693,7 +4151,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -3713,25 +4171,39 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained.", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -3743,14 +4215,19 @@ { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.md", - "native_file_sha256": "7fc842d907a39f82bfca7bf5380ba6887404ff5693e1b473d807b424ffe49af0", + "native_file_sha256": "ee6e7f615e88f8defb62bb6c58442887c9f13e51afd01a63249deff01c8e9bda", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "9c48efe15d307aef5d471ed3f519cb58af70e2dcadfaa81b98f8ec49f3eb73a5", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "94a2bf8d07c1ef80630998be799cee2a47c2a9174e3daa33fb7299b79e149551", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "1310fbf27797da6fff4c35851151ae4515314be22eb50f876ae82212a3895657", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ] } ] }, @@ -3816,7 +4293,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:cfpb-ao-2022-001-pay-to-pay", "canonical_sha256": "e20e0bcb6fa5c62776f77e650f41e715b8d0ce8458a1f56e75a3a91709f998e5", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -3902,7 +4379,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:cftc-il-17-65-cta-unbundled-fee", "canonical_sha256": "cb56b0ebd2521dd3f2e355886a0b19d77ceda42cd5ad315aa03459673efec377", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -3987,7 +4464,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:irs-plr-202506001-incentive-fee", "canonical_sha256": "c2145852b85e818957983272334c5f4d57d23b7aecb92fa4ab317cb205d88489", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -4073,7 +4550,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:irs-tege-2026-001-501c3-adverse", "canonical_sha256": "baba5d8ce4007aca04c51194d650f7639c767679b1e300d0f35b9ce0f8cb88bc", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -4158,7 +4635,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001-rule-506c", "canonical_sha256": "9c7546b5135751e232852b0e9fcdf18e02973c38dd7c819d999b897a259e32e4", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -4257,7 +4734,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb24-205-never-operative-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "4849304cb37f40f5cb292b4ab29c1230e89a3dbce9c3f16ba17c1d63f50f8e1b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -4356,7 +4833,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb24-205-never-operative-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "4849304cb37f40f5cb292b4ab29c1230e89a3dbce9c3f16ba17c1d63f50f8e1b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -4456,7 +4933,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb24-205-never-operative-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "4849304cb37f40f5cb292b4ab29c1230e89a3dbce9c3f16ba17c1d63f50f8e1b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -4542,7 +5019,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb26-189-admt-act-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8208176ce48fdbdfcd77357ea089231259a600b6827dd8a0fcd6ed41047afd4d", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -4628,7 +5105,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb26-189-admt-act-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8208176ce48fdbdfcd77357ea089231259a600b6827dd8a0fcd6ed41047afd4d", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -4714,7 +5191,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb26-189-admt-act-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8208176ce48fdbdfcd77357ea089231259a600b6827dd8a0fcd6ed41047afd4d", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -4800,7 +5277,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb26-189-admt-act-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8208176ce48fdbdfcd77357ea089231259a600b6827dd8a0fcd6ed41047afd4d", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -4886,7 +5363,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb26-189-admt-act-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8208176ce48fdbdfcd77357ea089231259a600b6827dd8a0fcd6ed41047afd4d", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -4972,7 +5449,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb26-189-admt-act-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8208176ce48fdbdfcd77357ea089231259a600b6827dd8a0fcd6ed41047afd4d", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/parties.json b/docs/api/v1/of/parties.json index 68dd26a1..8675d051 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/parties.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/parties.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "@context": "https://obligationfirst.org/v1/context.jsonld", - "generated": "2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z", + "generated": "2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z", "parties": [ { "@context": [ @@ -21,27 +21,36 @@ "roles": [ "requesting_party" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "1c73dcfdf1dc9dc14040426990fdd43ea4db8615ca0523c2914d7fda1e40d740", + "native_file_sha256": "639f19ea3a4b559894f32da3142be916fbd98e3b9fe5791edb9a05d80a6d61ad", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "c2190dfc51ff2893e9e1a4d49c9457f0fca3791cd8cca5878fe55c1a7b014c19", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "b935a9e9d2a81ec511b4f507e2086e60394cba0f5ca191721dfd405edb4c17d6", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "27b15547fb411ec37543f7deac2039683b39c228e9d71b8d5976e645c811d329", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ] } ] }, @@ -64,27 +73,36 @@ "roles": [ "interpreting_authority" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "1c73dcfdf1dc9dc14040426990fdd43ea4db8615ca0523c2914d7fda1e40d740", + "native_file_sha256": "639f19ea3a4b559894f32da3142be916fbd98e3b9fe5791edb9a05d80a6d61ad", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "c2190dfc51ff2893e9e1a4d49c9457f0fca3791cd8cca5878fe55c1a7b014c19", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "b935a9e9d2a81ec511b4f507e2086e60394cba0f5ca191721dfd405edb4c17d6", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "27b15547fb411ec37543f7deac2039683b39c228e9d71b8d5976e645c811d329", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ] } ] }, @@ -107,28 +125,39 @@ "roles": [ "issuing_authority" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] } ] }, @@ -151,28 +180,39 @@ "roles": [ "co_signatory_authority" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] } ] }, @@ -195,28 +235,39 @@ "roles": [ "participant" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] } ] }, @@ -374,7 +425,7 @@ "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/doctronic/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", @@ -382,33 +433,38 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] } ] @@ -435,7 +491,7 @@ "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/doctronic/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", @@ -443,33 +499,38 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] } ] @@ -496,7 +557,7 @@ "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/doctronic/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", @@ -504,33 +565,38 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] } ] @@ -554,28 +620,41 @@ "roles": [ "issuing_authority" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] } ] }, @@ -598,28 +677,41 @@ "roles": [ "co_signatory_authority" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] } ] }, @@ -642,28 +734,41 @@ "roles": [ "participant" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] } ] }, @@ -686,28 +791,41 @@ "roles": [ "participant" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/cfpb-ao-2022-001-pay-to-pay-cfpb-pay-to-pay-fee-prohibited.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/cfpb-ao-2022-001-pay-to-pay-cfpb-pay-to-pay-fee-prohibited.json index 6bbd69f2..65bc7c5f 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/cfpb-ao-2022-001-pay-to-pay-cfpb-pay-to-pay-fee-prohibited.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/cfpb-ao-2022-001-pay-to-pay-cfpb-pay-to-pay-fee-prohibited.json @@ -60,7 +60,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:cfpb-ao-2022-001-pay-to-pay", "canonical_sha256": "e20e0bcb6fa5c62776f77e650f41e715b8d0ce8458a1f56e75a3a91709f998e5", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/cfpb-ao-2022-001-pay-to-pay.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/cfpb-ao-2022-001-pay-to-pay.json index c1e0eb91..2ada3c7f 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/cfpb-ao-2022-001-pay-to-pay.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/cfpb-ao-2022-001-pay-to-pay.json @@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:cfpb-ao-2022-001-pay-to-pay", "canonical_sha256": "e20e0bcb6fa5c62776f77e650f41e715b8d0ce8458a1f56e75a3a91709f998e5", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/cftc-il-17-65-cta-unbundled-fee-cftc-unbundled-fee-not-cta-trigger.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/cftc-il-17-65-cta-unbundled-fee-cftc-unbundled-fee-not-cta-trigger.json index 41af05a6..91fe7f68 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/cftc-il-17-65-cta-unbundled-fee-cftc-unbundled-fee-not-cta-trigger.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/cftc-il-17-65-cta-unbundled-fee-cftc-unbundled-fee-not-cta-trigger.json @@ -61,7 +61,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:cftc-il-17-65-cta-unbundled-fee", "canonical_sha256": "cb56b0ebd2521dd3f2e355886a0b19d77ceda42cd5ad315aa03459673efec377", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/cftc-il-17-65-cta-unbundled-fee.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/cftc-il-17-65-cta-unbundled-fee.json index 47988d12..89eed69c 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/cftc-il-17-65-cta-unbundled-fee.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/cftc-il-17-65-cta-unbundled-fee.json @@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:cftc-il-17-65-cta-unbundled-fee", "canonical_sha256": "cb56b0ebd2521dd3f2e355886a0b19d77ceda42cd5ad315aa03459673efec377", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-dentacor-58-69-5-enforcement-forborne.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-dentacor-58-69-5-enforcement-forborne.json index 50017cf7..9a6c4688 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-dentacor-58-69-5-enforcement-forborne.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-dentacor-58-69-5-enforcement-forborne.json @@ -60,7 +60,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-dentacor-hygienist-ai-concurrence-diagnosis.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-dentacor-hygienist-ai-concurrence-diagnosis.json index 0a418310..0d38cb3e 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-dentacor-hygienist-ai-concurrence-diagnosis.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-dentacor-hygienist-ai-concurrence-diagnosis.json @@ -60,7 +60,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-dentacor-informed-consent-no-dentist.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-dentacor-informed-consent-no-dentist.json index 5a84ab3c..2e347e0e 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-dentacor-informed-consent-no-dentist.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-dentacor-informed-consent-no-dentist.json @@ -59,7 +59,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-data-security-63a-19-102.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-data-security-63a-19-102.json index 72398c28..787e9760 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-data-security-63a-19-102.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-data-security-63a-19-102.json @@ -59,7 +59,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-end-of-term-report.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-end-of-term-report.json index 7e202a00..fee4a9d1 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-end-of-term-report.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-end-of-term-report.json @@ -59,7 +59,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-hold-harmless-state.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-hold-harmless-state.json index 1c020103..d6f37276 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-hold-harmless-state.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-hold-harmless-state.json @@ -58,7 +58,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-monthly-report-to-oaip.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-monthly-report-to-oaip.json index 6607d564..e5050b57 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-monthly-report-to-oaip.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-monthly-report-to-oaip.json @@ -60,7 +60,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-no-advertising-reference.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-no-advertising-reference.json index 72076bc3..f28df953 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-no-advertising-reference.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations-rma-no-advertising-reference.json @@ -59,7 +59,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations.json index 586a0527..4b30023c 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/dentacor-rma-obligations.json @@ -62,7 +62,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-ai-authorized-rx-renewal.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-ai-authorized-rx-renewal.json index 8e41a4ee..7f48266d 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-ai-authorized-rx-renewal.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-ai-authorized-rx-renewal.json @@ -46,39 +46,44 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.json index 40aa5cdc..81f65b47 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.json @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/doctronic-rma-obligations-named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.json", "pub:id": "doctronic-rma-obligations-named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne", "title": "Named-Prescriber Enforcement Forborne", - "content": "DOPL forgoes unlawful-conduct and unprofessional-conduct enforcement under §58-1-501(1)-(2) and related professional-licensing provisions against any provider who (1) acts solely as the named prescriber for AI-authorized renewals, (2) does not interact directly with a patient or other provider, and (3) complies with the RMA terms. Forbearance applies only to conduct authorized by the agreement.", + "content": "DOPL forgoes unlawful-conduct and unprofessional-conduct enforcement under §58-1-501(1)-(2) and related professional-licensing provisions against any provider who (1) acts solely as the named prescriber for AI-authorized renewals and (2) does not interact directly with a patient or other provider. Legion §16(D) adds a condition that the provider abides by the agreement and any agreement with the participant; Doctronic §15(D) states no such condition. The covered chapter provisions differ by agreement. Forbearance applies only to conduct authorized by the agreement.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/doctronic-rma-obligations.json" ], @@ -46,8 +46,11 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained.", + "The Doctronic signed text cites 59-67-502 and 59-70a-503, which appear to be typographical errors for chapter 58 provisions; reproduced as written with [sic].", "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", @@ -55,30 +58,34 @@ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -90,14 +97,20 @@ { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.md", - "native_file_sha256": "9bc50212ab23b5d835c423f3639e384f25ada45855f2c438e27f80bfef616083", + "native_file_sha256": "a387cda4d9c8ae0c04a890f5cb8f665334ded7bf384cdab2048006bcd0818164", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "3efcdd6116bdcae121cc7aa3a01540886abcc8f1c02fd41381410d06eeae01b2", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7dc4b7ad687deab2b549477c9e6f9630e149d7276ad1b2a14e5792a23ad39a2e", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "a0c3843be94bb884536528046719eb207d6b40ff0e8ab6bb43e4c49a484dbf75", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The Doctronic signed text cites 59-67-502 and 59-70a-503, which appear to be typographical errors for chapter 58 provisions; reproduced as written with [sic].", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-data-security-63a-19-102.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-data-security-63a-19-102.json index e3d83203..55d403d4 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-data-security-63a-19-102.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-data-security-63a-19-102.json @@ -44,39 +44,44 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-end-of-term-report.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-end-of-term-report.json index bc38e23b..e02f611a 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-end-of-term-report.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-end-of-term-report.json @@ -44,39 +44,44 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-hold-harmless-state.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-hold-harmless-state.json index 8062fa91..200c64d0 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-hold-harmless-state.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-hold-harmless-state.json @@ -43,39 +43,44 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-monthly-report-to-oaip.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-monthly-report-to-oaip.json index f156f589..e815231e 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-monthly-report-to-oaip.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-monthly-report-to-oaip.json @@ -45,39 +45,44 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-no-advertising-reference.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-no-advertising-reference.json index c62f6275..0549963f 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-no-advertising-reference.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-rma-no-advertising-reference.json @@ -44,39 +44,44 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.json index b26a2fcc..4a04ce2e 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations-telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.json @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/doctronic-rma-obligations-telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.json", "pub:id": "doctronic-rma-obligations-telehealth-compliance-per-proposal", "title": "Telehealth Compliance Anchored To Participant Proposal", - "content": "A participant operating AI-assisted prescription renewal must adhere to Utah's telehealth provider requirements in §26B-4-704, with specific subsections deemed satisfied by following the patient-journey and escalation protocols described in the participant's Proposal (Schedule B). Certain subsections (e.g., the patient-records portability default) are inapplicable; others are substituted by Proposal-section conformance.", + "content": "A participant operating AI-assisted prescription renewal must adhere to Utah's telehealth provider requirements in §26B-4-704, with specific subsections deemed satisfied by following protocols described in the participant's Proposal (Schedule B): Doctronic Parts 2B and 3B; Legion Proposal section 4. Certain subsections (e.g., the patient-records portability default) are inapplicable; others are substituted by Proposal-section conformance.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/doctronic-rma-obligations.json" ], @@ -45,8 +45,10 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained.", "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", @@ -54,30 +56,34 @@ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -89,14 +95,19 @@ { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.md", - "native_file_sha256": "7fc842d907a39f82bfca7bf5380ba6887404ff5693e1b473d807b424ffe49af0", + "native_file_sha256": "ee6e7f615e88f8defb62bb6c58442887c9f13e51afd01a63249deff01c8e9bda", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "9c48efe15d307aef5d471ed3f519cb58af70e2dcadfaa81b98f8ec49f3eb73a5", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "94a2bf8d07c1ef80630998be799cee2a47c2a9174e3daa33fb7299b79e149551", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "1310fbf27797da6fff4c35851151ae4515314be22eb50f876ae82212a3895657", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations.json index 631d301a..d8677255 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/doctronic-rma-obligations.json @@ -37,7 +37,7 @@ "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §16)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:source_heading": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §16)", "pub:source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", @@ -47,39 +47,44 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-elizachat-phased-rollout.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-elizachat-phased-rollout.json index ef86e0d7..eef2e4bf 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-elizachat-phased-rollout.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-elizachat-phased-rollout.json @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -41,25 +41,36 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle.json index c880dbcc..43a9f936 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle.json @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -41,25 +41,38 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed.", + "The later statutory succession of Utah Code 13-2-12(4) was not verified in this review.", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -71,14 +84,19 @@ { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle.md", - "native_file_sha256": "44ccb58a19ec9ebb04c917de3e9b65ecb0cf3fdccad3464e3309f8818ff254b1", + "native_file_sha256": "4caf489311fac12b33ead6ccea5e1765d489d4991aed57e4b2d174922b542d4e", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "f64f5494465abe222b34894c969931ace7d9512886e328caac5e334f6faa4a4f", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "e449b7df832e2d80c45aac253c20e5502ba589defb7dbfafe479424158761207", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "567d6db18f9afefffc5f88015f85ee6ba556464ad62d16cd0e0df759e8251814", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The later statutory succession of Utah Code 13-2-12(4) was not verified in this review.", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-data-security-63a-19-102.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-data-security-63a-19-102.json index 448f1f9b..a195ba93 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-data-security-63a-19-102.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-data-security-63a-19-102.json @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -41,25 +41,36 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-end-of-term-report.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-end-of-term-report.json index 36aefdc9..56ff2637 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-end-of-term-report.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-end-of-term-report.json @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -41,25 +41,36 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-hold-harmless-state.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-hold-harmless-state.json index 6cbe0540..563c1c6e 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-hold-harmless-state.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-hold-harmless-state.json @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -40,25 +40,36 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-incident-notification-24hr.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-incident-notification-24hr.json index 0a2e3c43..2ea1e3ff 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-incident-notification-24hr.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-incident-notification-24hr.json @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -42,25 +42,36 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-monthly-report-to-oaip.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-monthly-report-to-oaip.json index ba882dc5..2aeec00f 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-monthly-report-to-oaip.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-monthly-report-to-oaip.json @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -42,25 +42,36 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-no-advertising-reference.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-no-advertising-reference.json index b9cfd4e1..afe7e238 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-no-advertising-reference.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations-rma-no-advertising-reference.json @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -41,25 +41,36 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations.json index 42deb8ca..863e3449 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/elizachat-rma-obligations.json @@ -33,36 +33,47 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:source_heading": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "pub:source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements-learning-lab-agreement-participation.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements-learning-lab-agreement-participation.json index ae9dfeec..a97fe5f7 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements-learning-lab-agreement-participation.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements-learning-lab-agreement-participation.json @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements-learning-lab-agreement-participation.json", "pub:id": "hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements-learning-lab-agreement-participation", "title": "Learning Lab Agreement — Eligibility and Participation", - "content": "A person deploying AI in Utah may enter either a Regulatory Mitigation Agreement (RMA) — which waives specified law in exchange for safeguards, data sharing, and disclosures — or a Joint Interpretation Agreement (JIA) — which clarifies how existing statute applies to a specific AI use without waiver. Agreements run for an initial twelve months with up to two twelve-month extensions, counterparties include OAIP plus the relevant state agency (or judiciary, higher-ed, or political subdivision under HB 320), and participants must satisfy five statutory eligibility prongs.", + "content": "A person deploying AI in Utah may enter either a Regulatory Mitigation Agreement (RMA) — which waives specified law in exchange for safeguards, data sharing, and disclosures — or a Joint Interpretation Agreement (JIA) — which clarifies how existing statute applies to a specific AI use without waiver. Agreements run for an initial twelve months with up to two twelve-month extensions, counterparties include OAIP plus the relevant state agency (or the judiciary, a state-funded higher or public education institution, or a political subdivision under HB 320), and participants must satisfy five statutory eligibility prongs.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements.json" ], @@ -44,25 +44,43 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it.", + "Prongs (a), (d) and (e) in What Counts remain paraphrases and were not re-worded; \"limited to the statute, use case, and deployment period\" is not statutory wording for prong (e) (scale, scope, and duration of testing limited based on risk assessments).", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md", - "native_file_sha256": "111b246cf8bb2b1118face419aa81634e3eba290346e98be8e47761d2a8345d5", + "native_file_sha256": "01797df3b03a8a6d33869d8a1ed4a0575acea137ea8b84598087d3a0fca8008d", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8c4fba21742f0b6e177e6c4789075c6851acbcd3359335a24162d7f007393692", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "0602d5a250b66e24ed6f13779a1c055cc90a4f97b27249ef54d099a3e9eb9ad7", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "b140f99a901d8f1e6f4bf389765fa85c72c5b7972a9ddf3f63132f56646e5da3", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements", "canonical_sha256": "b85f1f2ef1628ab2a223640d36314be87543371986c0cb7fdd43099d48765c2e", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -74,14 +92,19 @@ { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/learning-lab-agreement-participation.md", - "native_file_sha256": "efeebe2f9d9c60fcfc09d9cdddc438f311e27a5064b2d999d490d1835f67b45b", + "native_file_sha256": "c7f07d610d5c3bb5aa942d5d80fb3dad563ed73529770ed89888a4fca1d537eb", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "cedc5a7a4518542affc3c7518e31fc80696614382ab1ee3f976d1a8368ffd633", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "649cf9611b65c4fd518106a4ce461906db0953381bb5b342dc92b1bd149bfae3", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "342fac2ddf576b7837c36901ef92ee9abfa96c0e6b3d6bd8459a87b57058c8b6", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "Prongs (a), (d) and (e) in What Counts remain paraphrases and were not re-worded; \"limited to the statute, use case, and deployment period\" is not statutory wording for prong (e) (scale, scope, and duration of testing limited based on risk assessments).", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements.json index b48d6d82..ea01604e 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements.json @@ -27,32 +27,48 @@ "source_locator": "Summary", "source_citation": "Utah HB 320 (2026 General Session)", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:source_heading": "Summary", "pub:source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md", - "native_file_sha256": "111b246cf8bb2b1118face419aa81634e3eba290346e98be8e47761d2a8345d5", + "native_file_sha256": "01797df3b03a8a6d33869d8a1ed4a0575acea137ea8b84598087d3a0fca8008d", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8c4fba21742f0b6e177e6c4789075c6851acbcd3359335a24162d7f007393692", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "0602d5a250b66e24ed6f13779a1c055cc90a4f97b27249ef54d099a3e9eb9ad7", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "b140f99a901d8f1e6f4bf389765fa85c72c5b7972a9ddf3f63132f56646e5da3", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements", "canonical_sha256": "b85f1f2ef1628ab2a223640d36314be87543371986c0cb7fdd43099d48765c2e", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-chatbot-data-no-third-party-sharing.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-chatbot-data-no-third-party-sharing.json index fc0a9959..373ad53b 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-chatbot-data-no-third-party-sharing.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-chatbot-data-no-third-party-sharing.json @@ -43,39 +43,55 @@ "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed.", + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md", - "native_file_sha256": "fe72c5b4cc375bf679bc8f03edd4ccd7b7cddafad47ece6439f8a5449fd967e7", + "native_file_sha256": "c75fb508faa76236a1cd60e5ed221ff2df4bae4c426295098f1ac0cd9d7836fb", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8deea5bfdfb67ecb23276907a46d7d76dbe492525a4b401dfcad8a1933fbbea5", + "canonical_sha256": "823a6f04b847768379b4f8d5218794e3c88e31d2fcdd1032d881da4cc49eccde", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "38ad104b571b171500e69a42c94ef01bbc1f85d57335af6e7ec67f0c6bb43705", + "review_packet_sha256": "be382469d216fa204a551bbd826747b34bbc49fc2e9581723266bd05df6a9690", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack", - "canonical_sha256": "0efa1a9d629192ea94613364015b159f0297afd09676a5633788f81b626ed675", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "66bc4b8a16d6100604ecc6c10e8fd489aed581208679ce6a3c847cb44b7b3d7c", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." + ] }, { "kind": "obligation-definition", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-chatbot-safety-policy-filing.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-chatbot-safety-policy-filing.json index 90188d2c..b837db68 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-chatbot-safety-policy-filing.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-chatbot-safety-policy-filing.json @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-chatbot-safety-policy-filing.json", "pub:id": "hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-chatbot-safety-policy-filing", "title": "Mental Health Chatbot — File 15-Element Safety Policy", - "content": "A mental health chatbot supplier must draft, file with Utah's Division of Consumer Protection, and operationally comply with a fifteen-element written safety policy covering purposes, clinical practices, testing, risk protocols, user reporting, HIPAA posture, and more. Compliance with the filed policy at the time of an alleged violation provides an affirmative defense against §58-1-501(1)-(2) unauthorized-practice actions.", + "content": "Filing is a condition of an affirmative defense, not a free-standing mandate. A mental health chatbot supplier has an affirmative defense against §58-1-501(1)-(2) unauthorized-practice actions if it shows that it created, maintained, and implemented a written policy meeting §58-60-118(3), including the fifteen procedure elements in (3)(c)(i)-(xv); maintains the development and implementation documentation required by (2)(b); filed the policy with Utah's Division of Consumer Protection; and complied with the filed policy at the time of the alleged violation.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack.json" ], @@ -25,7 +25,7 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html", "source_locator": "Summary", "source_citation": "Utah HB 452 (2025 General Session)", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", "verified": "2026-04-21", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:primary_id": "chatbot-safety-policy-filing", @@ -41,54 +41,77 @@ "hb452" ], "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed.", + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt.", + "The record name (\"File 15-Element Safety Policy\"), group (requirement) and @type Requirement still frame the item as a requirement; the statute makes the policy a condition of an affirmative defense. These schema-level fields were left for a human decision.", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." ], - "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md", - "native_file_sha256": "fe72c5b4cc375bf679bc8f03edd4ccd7b7cddafad47ece6439f8a5449fd967e7", + "native_file_sha256": "c75fb508faa76236a1cd60e5ed221ff2df4bae4c426295098f1ac0cd9d7836fb", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8deea5bfdfb67ecb23276907a46d7d76dbe492525a4b401dfcad8a1933fbbea5", + "canonical_sha256": "823a6f04b847768379b4f8d5218794e3c88e31d2fcdd1032d881da4cc49eccde", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "38ad104b571b171500e69a42c94ef01bbc1f85d57335af6e7ec67f0c6bb43705", + "review_packet_sha256": "be382469d216fa204a551bbd826747b34bbc49fc2e9581723266bd05df6a9690", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack", - "canonical_sha256": "0efa1a9d629192ea94613364015b159f0297afd09676a5633788f81b626ed675", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "66bc4b8a16d6100604ecc6c10e8fd489aed581208679ce6a3c847cb44b7b3d7c", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." + ] }, { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/chatbot-safety-policy-filing.md", - "native_file_sha256": "64d1121bd3ffbe629f4ea714deee5bd9ac05371f8492487128fbe4a8de8f0b2e", + "native_file_sha256": "926ce7f92c39b4613ccaea98594d2a43f06982309402d41d5b1a4571842a3066", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "3e34be05b6bd18616f0fbfe450bcf9599ffd9d02386ba84fd27f5aa9172d2cee", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "ba1facfe4b4274c2be9551a415246ce1ce26893555011114157835277c98fcb9", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "16858b62701ee470ac7ee01bf9a0ff90f302fca04242dacd946f2ba09ee4ec18", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The record name (\"File 15-Element Safety Policy\"), group (requirement) and @type Requirement still frame the item as a requirement; the statute makes the policy a condition of an affirmative defense. These schema-level fields were left for a human decision.", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-disclose-genai-on-first-session.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-disclose-genai-on-first-session.json index 977b72f4..8767b48f 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-disclose-genai-on-first-session.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-disclose-genai-on-first-session.json @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-disclose-genai-on-first-session.json", "pub:id": "hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack-disclose-genai-on-first-session", "title": "Disclose GenAI on First Session", - "content": "A consumer-facing GenAI service must display a clear, prominent disclosure that the consumer is interacting with an AI system at the start of each session.", + "content": "Disclose plainly that the person is interacting with generative AI and not a human. When the disclosure is due depends on the Utah provision: on a clear request in a consumer transaction (§13-75-103(1)); at the start of a high-risk interaction in a regulated occupation (§13-75-103(2)-(3)); and for a mental health chatbot, before access, again after seven days without access, and whenever asked (§13-72a-203(2)). No Utah provision anchored here requires re-display at every session or after a fixed inactivity period.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack.json" ], @@ -25,7 +25,7 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html", "source_locator": "Summary", "source_citation": "Utah HB 452 (2025 General Session)", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", "verified": "2026-04-18", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:primary_id": "disclose-genai-on-first-session", @@ -39,54 +39,78 @@ "chatbot" ], "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed.", + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt.", + "The obligation id and name still say 'first session'; renaming the id is a separate schema decision.", + "last_verified renewal requires a separate human review receipt." ], - "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md", - "native_file_sha256": "fe72c5b4cc375bf679bc8f03edd4ccd7b7cddafad47ece6439f8a5449fd967e7", + "native_file_sha256": "c75fb508faa76236a1cd60e5ed221ff2df4bae4c426295098f1ac0cd9d7836fb", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8deea5bfdfb67ecb23276907a46d7d76dbe492525a4b401dfcad8a1933fbbea5", + "canonical_sha256": "823a6f04b847768379b4f8d5218794e3c88e31d2fcdd1032d881da4cc49eccde", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "38ad104b571b171500e69a42c94ef01bbc1f85d57335af6e7ec67f0c6bb43705", + "review_packet_sha256": "be382469d216fa204a551bbd826747b34bbc49fc2e9581723266bd05df6a9690", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack", - "canonical_sha256": "0efa1a9d629192ea94613364015b159f0297afd09676a5633788f81b626ed675", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "66bc4b8a16d6100604ecc6c10e8fd489aed581208679ce6a3c847cb44b7b3d7c", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." + ] }, { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/disclose-genai-on-first-session.md", - "native_file_sha256": "964a825c8ad92c8e5a59ceda27d05433bd145b2b381af9edb7f6309681a55b71", + "native_file_sha256": "785f11886a59611ca6458facf971ef6bcf088085a4c12675492498d88380fc8d", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "416ca3ea40e4681bf3f0ccb9a00cd890d94214d1e9c0ffd262fbb6a8a17da163", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "c87615a8fc2a979ae02b7d3c833c2b2cfcb476b6b61bdfae0d86d17343eb787d", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "8086134b9fedbd88d7dd4e183a80419860da6b3e77dd75151942f662cdfca44c", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The obligation id and name still say 'first session'; renaming the id is a separate schema decision.", + "last_verified renewal requires a separate human review receipt." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack.json index 65378df1..571c9f0f 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack.json @@ -28,48 +28,64 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html", "source_locator": "Summary", "source_citation": "Utah HB 452 (2025 General Session)", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:source_heading": "Summary", "pub:source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed.", + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." ], - "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md", - "native_file_sha256": "fe72c5b4cc375bf679bc8f03edd4ccd7b7cddafad47ece6439f8a5449fd967e7", + "native_file_sha256": "c75fb508faa76236a1cd60e5ed221ff2df4bae4c426295098f1ac0cd9d7836fb", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8deea5bfdfb67ecb23276907a46d7d76dbe492525a4b401dfcad8a1933fbbea5", + "canonical_sha256": "823a6f04b847768379b4f8d5218794e3c88e31d2fcdd1032d881da4cc49eccde", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "38ad104b571b171500e69a42c94ef01bbc1f85d57335af6e7ec67f0c6bb43705", + "review_packet_sha256": "be382469d216fa204a551bbd826747b34bbc49fc2e9581723266bd05df6a9690", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack", - "canonical_sha256": "0efa1a9d629192ea94613364015b159f0297afd09676a5633788f81b626ed675", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "66bc4b8a16d6100604ecc6c10e8fd489aed581208679ce6a3c847cb44b7b3d7c", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/irs-plr-202506001-incentive-fee-irs-incentive-fee-not-net-profits-share.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/irs-plr-202506001-incentive-fee-irs-incentive-fee-not-net-profits-share.json index f79d819c..22793e0b 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/irs-plr-202506001-incentive-fee-irs-incentive-fee-not-net-profits-share.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/irs-plr-202506001-incentive-fee-irs-incentive-fee-not-net-profits-share.json @@ -60,7 +60,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:irs-plr-202506001-incentive-fee", "canonical_sha256": "c2145852b85e818957983272334c5f4d57d23b7aecb92fa4ab317cb205d88489", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/irs-plr-202506001-incentive-fee.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/irs-plr-202506001-incentive-fee.json index 0b2076be..7c223d99 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/irs-plr-202506001-incentive-fee.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/irs-plr-202506001-incentive-fee.json @@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:irs-plr-202506001-incentive-fee", "canonical_sha256": "c2145852b85e818957983272334c5f4d57d23b7aecb92fa4ab317cb205d88489", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/irs-tege-2026-001-501c3-adverse-irs-501c3-dual-test-failure.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/irs-tege-2026-001-501c3-adverse-irs-501c3-dual-test-failure.json index 5999d69a..23c51339 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/irs-tege-2026-001-501c3-adverse-irs-501c3-dual-test-failure.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/irs-tege-2026-001-501c3-adverse-irs-501c3-dual-test-failure.json @@ -61,7 +61,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:irs-tege-2026-001-501c3-adverse", "canonical_sha256": "baba5d8ce4007aca04c51194d650f7639c767679b1e300d0f35b9ce0f8cb88bc", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/irs-tege-2026-001-501c3-adverse.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/irs-tege-2026-001-501c3-adverse.json index aedc3079..1e000538 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/irs-tege-2026-001-501c3-adverse.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/irs-tege-2026-001-501c3-adverse.json @@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:irs-tege-2026-001-501c3-adverse", "canonical_sha256": "baba5d8ce4007aca04c51194d650f7639c767679b1e300d0f35b9ce0f8cb88bc", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-ai-authorized-rx-renewal.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-ai-authorized-rx-renewal.json index d5b632b0..93f563e7 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-ai-authorized-rx-renewal.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-ai-authorized-rx-renewal.json @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -43,25 +43,38 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.json index db22fb6f..6a476210 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.json @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/legion-rma-obligations-named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.json", "pub:id": "legion-rma-obligations-named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne", "title": "Named-Prescriber Enforcement Forborne", - "content": "DOPL forgoes unlawful-conduct and unprofessional-conduct enforcement under §58-1-501(1)-(2) and related professional-licensing provisions against any provider who (1) acts solely as the named prescriber for AI-authorized renewals, (2) does not interact directly with a patient or other provider, and (3) complies with the RMA terms. Forbearance applies only to conduct authorized by the agreement.", + "content": "DOPL forgoes unlawful-conduct and unprofessional-conduct enforcement under §58-1-501(1)-(2) and related professional-licensing provisions against any provider who (1) acts solely as the named prescriber for AI-authorized renewals and (2) does not interact directly with a patient or other provider. Legion §16(D) adds a condition that the provider abides by the agreement and any agreement with the participant; Doctronic §15(D) states no such condition. The covered chapter provisions differ by agreement. Forbearance applies only to conduct authorized by the agreement.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/legion-rma-obligations.json" ], @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -43,25 +43,40 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained.", + "The Doctronic signed text cites 59-67-502 and 59-70a-503, which appear to be typographical errors for chapter 58 provisions; reproduced as written with [sic].", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -73,14 +88,20 @@ { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne.md", - "native_file_sha256": "9bc50212ab23b5d835c423f3639e384f25ada45855f2c438e27f80bfef616083", + "native_file_sha256": "a387cda4d9c8ae0c04a890f5cb8f665334ded7bf384cdab2048006bcd0818164", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "3efcdd6116bdcae121cc7aa3a01540886abcc8f1c02fd41381410d06eeae01b2", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7dc4b7ad687deab2b549477c9e6f9630e149d7276ad1b2a14e5792a23ad39a2e", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "a0c3843be94bb884536528046719eb207d6b40ff0e8ab6bb43e4c49a484dbf75", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The Doctronic signed text cites 59-67-502 and 59-70a-503, which appear to be typographical errors for chapter 58 provisions; reproduced as written with [sic].", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-data-security-63a-19-102.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-data-security-63a-19-102.json index e6da32fb..d13108b4 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-data-security-63a-19-102.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-data-security-63a-19-102.json @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -41,25 +41,38 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-end-of-term-report.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-end-of-term-report.json index 8a5deb75..3354a4fc 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-end-of-term-report.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-end-of-term-report.json @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -41,25 +41,38 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-hold-harmless-state.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-hold-harmless-state.json index 69e17cd6..78b8d8e3 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-hold-harmless-state.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-hold-harmless-state.json @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -40,25 +40,38 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-monthly-report-to-oaip.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-monthly-report-to-oaip.json index a5b4e4d6..37eb89a4 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-monthly-report-to-oaip.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-monthly-report-to-oaip.json @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -42,25 +42,38 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-no-advertising-reference.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-no-advertising-reference.json index e89ab9f6..85f7bf38 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-no-advertising-reference.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-rma-no-advertising-reference.json @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -41,25 +41,38 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.json index 83ff815f..98efb625 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations-telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.json @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/legion-rma-obligations-telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.json", "pub:id": "legion-rma-obligations-telehealth-compliance-per-proposal", "title": "Telehealth Compliance Anchored To Participant Proposal", - "content": "A participant operating AI-assisted prescription renewal must adhere to Utah's telehealth provider requirements in §26B-4-704, with specific subsections deemed satisfied by following the patient-journey and escalation protocols described in the participant's Proposal (Schedule B). Certain subsections (e.g., the patient-records portability default) are inapplicable; others are substituted by Proposal-section conformance.", + "content": "A participant operating AI-assisted prescription renewal must adhere to Utah's telehealth provider requirements in §26B-4-704, with specific subsections deemed satisfied by following protocols described in the participant's Proposal (Schedule B): Doctronic Parts 2B and 3B; Legion Proposal section 4. Certain subsections (e.g., the patient-records portability default) are inapplicable; others are substituted by Proposal-section conformance.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/legion-rma-obligations.json" ], @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", @@ -42,25 +42,39 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained.", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -72,14 +86,19 @@ { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/telehealth-compliance-per-proposal.md", - "native_file_sha256": "7fc842d907a39f82bfca7bf5380ba6887404ff5693e1b473d807b424ffe49af0", + "native_file_sha256": "ee6e7f615e88f8defb62bb6c58442887c9f13e51afd01a63249deff01c8e9bda", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "9c48efe15d307aef5d471ed3f519cb58af70e2dcadfaa81b98f8ec49f3eb73a5", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "94a2bf8d07c1ef80630998be799cee2a47c2a9174e3daa33fb7299b79e149551", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "1310fbf27797da6fff4c35851151ae4515314be22eb50f876ae82212a3895657", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations.json index fb045689..286b3fad 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/legion-rma-obligations.json @@ -33,36 +33,49 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:source_heading": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "pub:source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense-ai-defense-elimination.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense-ai-defense-elimination.json index 9d20a2fd..e576a692 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense-ai-defense-elimination.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense-ai-defense-elimination.json @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense-ai-defense-elimination.json", "pub:id": "sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense-ai-defense-elimination", "title": "GenAI Is Not A Defense — Civil And Criminal", - "content": "Utah removed \"the AI did it\" as a defense in both civil and criminal contexts. A principal who uses, prompts, or acts through generative AI remains liable for the resulting statement or act. The criminal rule (§76-2-107, SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and the civil mirror (§13-75-102, SB 226, effective 2025-05-07) together eliminate the doctrine across Utah consumer-protection and criminal law.", + "content": "Utah removed \"the AI did it\" as a defense in both civil and criminal contexts. A principal who uses, prompts, or acts through generative AI remains liable for the resulting statement or act. The criminal rule (§76-2-107, SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and the civil mirror together eliminate the doctrine across Utah consumer-protection and criminal law. The civil rule was first enacted at §13-2-12(2) (SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and re-sited at §13-75-102 (SB 226, effective 2025-05-07).", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense.json" ], @@ -25,7 +25,7 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", "source_locator": "Summary", "source_citation": "Utah SB 149 (2024 General Session), Governor Signed March 13, 2024", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", "verified": "2026-04-21", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:primary_id": "ai-defense-elimination", @@ -41,58 +41,84 @@ "sb226" ], "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy.", + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt.", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." ], - "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md", - "native_file_sha256": "372a62e39b49fc961482974100e5f04e22b1a922fadce391e66c68dc3d4993f2", + "native_file_sha256": "6fb9a910496ef034a5b8b241d8859688cb39d2370fd3321b07649b32e3f49e2e", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "53b0d1aff53dcae4e0bd8e34ee2021069340673c56b979bf6a639b1ca589c202", + "canonical_sha256": "c1aca07ba833a22c5029c1afa612bd5aff05a91c2a2e3d30309c12a4ba792235", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "4f6f7ab0b94560d1e81548a417d56e0026eee2e21799079f7baa04f2b448aa7e", + "review_packet_sha256": "4638f21fae0dfa0223ba78a611e37ad1d1c900807b53ff46a89832c0ba759e74", "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "02db4dfb7fcc9c536f4aa7e006458da3ed0ba3567a7cc4478db9e3d5c3195514", "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884", "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense", - "canonical_sha256": "61f84dffd6d2394a4b68aa79f58c20c3ab31813efd1677bf8e94da2c8b88a21a", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "56836cab160c49426e9224ae78e504cdbfa8c30d175cba082b10d0b98f1a2b21", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." + ] }, { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/ai-defense-elimination.md", - "native_file_sha256": "ecda85918d33c2ebe2345f5cdef1e78e25f533d645c3efa2d7402022cf2bba33", + "native_file_sha256": "a55e45923f6c446174676808c25e74c677631fb8550f520ee92ba2786eb08151", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "0950aebbe08e66dce2babf56a5ea6f3671fbb8595b6c91b82ef2d4ad66a97d19", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "cfe3ca3e3ecabd66a2fae7c5efe481ad10b4a14f6ffb251c26b2e0ae99f45e26", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "d55ff8b00852b7a4a493871057a1dc3b033c434c83fef2eea19d1295f5a9cd8c", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense-learning-lab-agreement-participation.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense-learning-lab-agreement-participation.json index 866d93d4..11671d25 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense-learning-lab-agreement-participation.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense-learning-lab-agreement-participation.json @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense-learning-lab-agreement-participation.json", "pub:id": "sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense-learning-lab-agreement-participation", "title": "Learning Lab Agreement — Eligibility and Participation", - "content": "A person deploying AI in Utah may enter either a Regulatory Mitigation Agreement (RMA) — which waives specified law in exchange for safeguards, data sharing, and disclosures — or a Joint Interpretation Agreement (JIA) — which clarifies how existing statute applies to a specific AI use without waiver. Agreements run for an initial twelve months with up to two twelve-month extensions, counterparties include OAIP plus the relevant state agency (or judiciary, higher-ed, or political subdivision under HB 320), and participants must satisfy five statutory eligibility prongs.", + "content": "A person deploying AI in Utah may enter either a Regulatory Mitigation Agreement (RMA) — which waives specified law in exchange for safeguards, data sharing, and disclosures — or a Joint Interpretation Agreement (JIA) — which clarifies how existing statute applies to a specific AI use without waiver. Agreements run for an initial twelve months with up to two twelve-month extensions, counterparties include OAIP plus the relevant state agency (or the judiciary, a state-funded higher or public education institution, or a political subdivision under HB 320), and participants must satisfy five statutory eligibility prongs.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense.json" ], @@ -25,7 +25,7 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", "source_locator": "Summary", "source_citation": "Utah SB 149 (2024 General Session), Governor Signed March 13, 2024", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", "verified": "2026-04-21", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:primary_id": "learning-lab-agreement-participation", @@ -42,58 +42,85 @@ "hb320" ], "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy.", + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt.", + "Prongs (a), (d) and (e) in What Counts remain paraphrases and were not re-worded; \"limited to the statute, use case, and deployment period\" is not statutory wording for prong (e) (scale, scope, and duration of testing limited based on risk assessments).", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." ], - "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md", - "native_file_sha256": "372a62e39b49fc961482974100e5f04e22b1a922fadce391e66c68dc3d4993f2", + "native_file_sha256": "6fb9a910496ef034a5b8b241d8859688cb39d2370fd3321b07649b32e3f49e2e", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "53b0d1aff53dcae4e0bd8e34ee2021069340673c56b979bf6a639b1ca589c202", + "canonical_sha256": "c1aca07ba833a22c5029c1afa612bd5aff05a91c2a2e3d30309c12a4ba792235", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "4f6f7ab0b94560d1e81548a417d56e0026eee2e21799079f7baa04f2b448aa7e", + "review_packet_sha256": "4638f21fae0dfa0223ba78a611e37ad1d1c900807b53ff46a89832c0ba759e74", "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "02db4dfb7fcc9c536f4aa7e006458da3ed0ba3567a7cc4478db9e3d5c3195514", "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884", "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense", - "canonical_sha256": "61f84dffd6d2394a4b68aa79f58c20c3ab31813efd1677bf8e94da2c8b88a21a", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "56836cab160c49426e9224ae78e504cdbfa8c30d175cba082b10d0b98f1a2b21", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." + ] }, { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/learning-lab-agreement-participation.md", - "native_file_sha256": "efeebe2f9d9c60fcfc09d9cdddc438f311e27a5064b2d999d490d1835f67b45b", + "native_file_sha256": "c7f07d610d5c3bb5aa942d5d80fb3dad563ed73529770ed89888a4fca1d537eb", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "cedc5a7a4518542affc3c7518e31fc80696614382ab1ee3f976d1a8368ffd633", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "649cf9611b65c4fd518106a4ce461906db0953381bb5b342dc92b1bd149bfae3", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "342fac2ddf576b7837c36901ef92ee9abfa96c0e6b3d6bd8459a87b57058c8b6", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "Prongs (a), (d) and (e) in What Counts remain paraphrases and were not re-worded; \"limited to the statute, use case, and deployment period\" is not statutory wording for prong (e) (scale, scope, and duration of testing limited based on risk assessments).", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense.json index 4ca56c80..981363d8 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense.json @@ -27,52 +27,72 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", "source_locator": "Summary", "source_citation": "Utah SB 149 (2024 General Session), Governor Signed March 13, 2024", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:source_heading": "Summary", "pub:source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy.", + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." ], - "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md", - "native_file_sha256": "372a62e39b49fc961482974100e5f04e22b1a922fadce391e66c68dc3d4993f2", + "native_file_sha256": "6fb9a910496ef034a5b8b241d8859688cb39d2370fd3321b07649b32e3f49e2e", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "53b0d1aff53dcae4e0bd8e34ee2021069340673c56b979bf6a639b1ca589c202", + "canonical_sha256": "c1aca07ba833a22c5029c1afa612bd5aff05a91c2a2e3d30309c12a4ba792235", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "4f6f7ab0b94560d1e81548a417d56e0026eee2e21799079f7baa04f2b448aa7e", + "review_packet_sha256": "4638f21fae0dfa0223ba78a611e37ad1d1c900807b53ff46a89832c0ba759e74", "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "02db4dfb7fcc9c536f4aa7e006458da3ed0ba3567a7cc4478db9e3d5c3195514", "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884", "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense", - "canonical_sha256": "61f84dffd6d2394a4b68aa79f58c20c3ab31813efd1677bf8e94da2c8b88a21a", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "56836cab160c49426e9224ae78e504cdbfa8c30d175cba082b10d0b98f1a2b21", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense-ai-defense-elimination.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense-ai-defense-elimination.json index b7d860d7..d0e2909b 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense-ai-defense-elimination.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense-ai-defense-elimination.json @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense-ai-defense-elimination.json", "pub:id": "sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense-ai-defense-elimination", "title": "GenAI Is Not A Defense — Civil And Criminal", - "content": "Utah removed \"the AI did it\" as a defense in both civil and criminal contexts. A principal who uses, prompts, or acts through generative AI remains liable for the resulting statement or act. The criminal rule (§76-2-107, SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and the civil mirror (§13-75-102, SB 226, effective 2025-05-07) together eliminate the doctrine across Utah consumer-protection and criminal law.", + "content": "Utah removed \"the AI did it\" as a defense in both civil and criminal contexts. A principal who uses, prompts, or acts through generative AI remains liable for the resulting statement or act. The criminal rule (§76-2-107, SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and the civil mirror together eliminate the doctrine across Utah consumer-protection and criminal law. The civil rule was first enacted at §13-2-12(2) (SB 149, effective 2024-05-01) and re-sited at §13-75-102 (SB 226, effective 2025-05-07).", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense.json" ], @@ -43,25 +43,41 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it.", + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md", - "native_file_sha256": "518882b00ebe9515a3f4697a2da41a607c506c8d844a31895dcf1851d0f5dd3a", + "native_file_sha256": "9cb602b984427da4e4f0bdc1ba9f56458de93a54911769c20584ce105b1c6cf0", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "7e4a5fbb8f032549b461c3d8840b09b6dfe91587e3b95cde0269b6a9bd69ac2c", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "50b4e7a0685706064d5b50d211ba997047c14518a371a7ee1c859a4ccbe8e530", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "4ac77cfcca432ea01bcba7273922a36be25970b9c78729c8cd6241f6c3ee1733", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense", "canonical_sha256": "4a99aeb263d40980aeb761d4572a047a19b10322e712878efd9d8c5f3bdda649", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -73,14 +89,19 @@ { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/ai-defense-elimination.md", - "native_file_sha256": "ecda85918d33c2ebe2345f5cdef1e78e25f533d645c3efa2d7402022cf2bba33", + "native_file_sha256": "a55e45923f6c446174676808c25e74c677631fb8550f520ee92ba2786eb08151", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "0950aebbe08e66dce2babf56a5ea6f3671fbb8595b6c91b82ef2d4ad66a97d19", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "cfe3ca3e3ecabd66a2fae7c5efe481ad10b4a14f6ffb251c26b2e0ae99f45e26", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "d55ff8b00852b7a4a493871057a1dc3b033c434c83fef2eea19d1295f5a9cd8c", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense-disclose-genai-high-risk-proactive.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense-disclose-genai-high-risk-proactive.json index d7ccc9e9..faeee4bf 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense-disclose-genai-high-risk-proactive.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense-disclose-genai-high-risk-proactive.json @@ -42,25 +42,40 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md", - "native_file_sha256": "518882b00ebe9515a3f4697a2da41a607c506c8d844a31895dcf1851d0f5dd3a", + "native_file_sha256": "9cb602b984427da4e4f0bdc1ba9f56458de93a54911769c20584ce105b1c6cf0", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "7e4a5fbb8f032549b461c3d8840b09b6dfe91587e3b95cde0269b6a9bd69ac2c", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "50b4e7a0685706064d5b50d211ba997047c14518a371a7ee1c859a4ccbe8e530", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "4ac77cfcca432ea01bcba7273922a36be25970b9c78729c8cd6241f6c3ee1733", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense", "canonical_sha256": "4a99aeb263d40980aeb761d4572a047a19b10322e712878efd9d8c5f3bdda649", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense-disclose-genai-on-request.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense-disclose-genai-on-request.json index bd8b8e80..08e1e6f1 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense-disclose-genai-on-request.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense-disclose-genai-on-request.json @@ -42,25 +42,40 @@ "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md", - "native_file_sha256": "518882b00ebe9515a3f4697a2da41a607c506c8d844a31895dcf1851d0f5dd3a", + "native_file_sha256": "9cb602b984427da4e4f0bdc1ba9f56458de93a54911769c20584ce105b1c6cf0", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "7e4a5fbb8f032549b461c3d8840b09b6dfe91587e3b95cde0269b6a9bd69ac2c", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "50b4e7a0685706064d5b50d211ba997047c14518a371a7ee1c859a4ccbe8e530", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "4ac77cfcca432ea01bcba7273922a36be25970b9c78729c8cd6241f6c3ee1733", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense", "canonical_sha256": "4a99aeb263d40980aeb761d4572a047a19b10322e712878efd9d8c5f3bdda649", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense.json index 706625ad..6db6f92a 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense.json @@ -29,32 +29,47 @@ "source_locator": "Summary", "source_citation": "Utah SB 226 (2025 General Session)", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:source_heading": "Summary", "pub:source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md", - "native_file_sha256": "518882b00ebe9515a3f4697a2da41a607c506c8d844a31895dcf1851d0f5dd3a", + "native_file_sha256": "9cb602b984427da4e4f0bdc1ba9f56458de93a54911769c20584ce105b1c6cf0", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "7e4a5fbb8f032549b461c3d8840b09b6dfe91587e3b95cde0269b6a9bd69ac2c", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "50b4e7a0685706064d5b50d211ba997047c14518a371a7ee1c859a4ccbe8e530", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "4ac77cfcca432ea01bcba7273922a36be25970b9c78729c8cd6241f6c3ee1733", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense", "canonical_sha256": "4a99aeb263d40980aeb761d4572a047a19b10322e712878efd9d8c5f3bdda649", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb24-205-never-operative-obligations-high-risk-ai-consumer-notice-correction-and-appeal.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb24-205-never-operative-obligations-high-risk-ai-consumer-notice-correction-and-appeal.json index 74cfc0d5..e9549a78 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb24-205-never-operative-obligations-high-risk-ai-consumer-notice-correction-and-appeal.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb24-205-never-operative-obligations-high-risk-ai-consumer-notice-correction-and-appeal.json @@ -75,7 +75,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb24-205-never-operative-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "4849304cb37f40f5cb292b4ab29c1230e89a3dbce9c3f16ba17c1d63f50f8e1b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb24-205-never-operative-obligations-high-risk-ai-impact-assessment.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb24-205-never-operative-obligations-high-risk-ai-impact-assessment.json index 65c651fd..6cb314e3 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb24-205-never-operative-obligations-high-risk-ai-impact-assessment.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb24-205-never-operative-obligations-high-risk-ai-impact-assessment.json @@ -74,7 +74,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb24-205-never-operative-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "4849304cb37f40f5cb292b4ab29c1230e89a3dbce9c3f16ba17c1d63f50f8e1b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb24-205-never-operative-obligations-high-risk-ai-reasonable-care-against-algorithmic-discrimination.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb24-205-never-operative-obligations-high-risk-ai-reasonable-care-against-algorithmic-discrimination.json index 7f0f6364..3e83a72a 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb24-205-never-operative-obligations-high-risk-ai-reasonable-care-against-algorithmic-discrimination.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb24-205-never-operative-obligations-high-risk-ai-reasonable-care-against-algorithmic-discrimination.json @@ -74,7 +74,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb24-205-never-operative-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "4849304cb37f40f5cb292b4ab29c1230e89a3dbce9c3f16ba17c1d63f50f8e1b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb24-205-never-operative-obligations.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb24-205-never-operative-obligations.json index a45165bc..556ba15f 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb24-205-never-operative-obligations.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb24-205-never-operative-obligations.json @@ -66,7 +66,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb24-205-never-operative-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "4849304cb37f40f5cb292b4ab29c1230e89a3dbce9c3f16ba17c1d63f50f8e1b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-60-day-cure-period.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-60-day-cure-period.json index 6b2542b1..6eca37c6 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-60-day-cure-period.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-60-day-cure-period.json @@ -61,7 +61,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb26-189-admt-act-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8208176ce48fdbdfcd77357ea089231259a600b6827dd8a0fcd6ed41047afd4d", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-correction-and-human-review.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-correction-and-human-review.json index 7ec54711..96bbf1a7 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-correction-and-human-review.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-correction-and-human-review.json @@ -61,7 +61,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb26-189-admt-act-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8208176ce48fdbdfcd77357ea089231259a600b6827dd8a0fcd6ed41047afd4d", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-deployer-3-year-record-retention.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-deployer-3-year-record-retention.json index 7c76f8f1..f31413fd 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-deployer-3-year-record-retention.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-deployer-3-year-record-retention.json @@ -61,7 +61,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb26-189-admt-act-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8208176ce48fdbdfcd77357ea089231259a600b6827dd8a0fcd6ed41047afd4d", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-deployer-pre-decision-notice.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-deployer-pre-decision-notice.json index c7644334..c2d457ae 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-deployer-pre-decision-notice.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-deployer-pre-decision-notice.json @@ -61,7 +61,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb26-189-admt-act-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8208176ce48fdbdfcd77357ea089231259a600b6827dd8a0fcd6ed41047afd4d", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-developer-documentation-to-deployer.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-developer-documentation-to-deployer.json index 8f2461d1..4a2c84d5 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-developer-documentation-to-deployer.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-developer-documentation-to-deployer.json @@ -61,7 +61,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb26-189-admt-act-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8208176ce48fdbdfcd77357ea089231259a600b6827dd8a0fcd6ed41047afd4d", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-post-adverse-explanation-30-days.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-post-adverse-explanation-30-days.json index e7d27ce8..eaeee817 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-post-adverse-explanation-30-days.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations-admt-post-adverse-explanation-30-days.json @@ -61,7 +61,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb26-189-admt-act-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8208176ce48fdbdfcd77357ea089231259a600b6827dd8a0fcd6ed41047afd4d", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations.json index 5a82670d..06705648 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sb26-189-admt-act-obligations.json @@ -57,7 +57,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb26-189-admt-act-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8208176ce48fdbdfcd77357ea089231259a600b6827dd8a0fcd6ed41047afd4d", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001-rule-506c-sec-reg-d-506c-verification-safe-harbor.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001-rule-506c-sec-reg-d-506c-verification-safe-harbor.json index 7b128046..de295a44 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001-rule-506c-sec-reg-d-506c-verification-safe-harbor.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001-rule-506c-sec-reg-d-506c-verification-safe-harbor.json @@ -60,7 +60,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001-rule-506c", "canonical_sha256": "9c7546b5135751e232852b0e9fcdf18e02973c38dd7c819d999b897a259e32e4", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001-rule-506c.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001-rule-506c.json index 8f17cdf9..a5395625 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001-rule-506c.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001-rule-506c.json @@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001-rule-506c", "canonical_sha256": "9c7546b5135751e232852b0e9fcdf18e02973c38dd7c819d999b897a259e32e4", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149-issuance.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149-issuance.json index 81d3867d..8ea7cdc6 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149-issuance.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149-issuance.json @@ -27,36 +27,42 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", "source_citation": "Utah SB 149 (2024 General Session), Governor Signed March 13, 2024", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md", - "native_file_sha256": "372a62e39b49fc961482974100e5f04e22b1a922fadce391e66c68dc3d4993f2", + "native_file_sha256": "6fb9a910496ef034a5b8b241d8859688cb39d2370fd3321b07649b32e3f49e2e", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "53b0d1aff53dcae4e0bd8e34ee2021069340673c56b979bf6a639b1ca589c202", + "canonical_sha256": "c1aca07ba833a22c5029c1afa612bd5aff05a91c2a2e3d30309c12a4ba792235", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "4f6f7ab0b94560d1e81548a417d56e0026eee2e21799079f7baa04f2b448aa7e", + "review_packet_sha256": "4638f21fae0dfa0223ba78a611e37ad1d1c900807b53ff46a89832c0ba759e74", "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "02db4dfb7fcc9c536f4aa7e006458da3ed0ba3567a7cc4478db9e3d5c3195514", "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884", "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy." ] } ] diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.json index 8688acab..d9717b67 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.json @@ -39,7 +39,7 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", "source_citation": "Utah SB 149 (2024 General Session), Governor Signed March 13, 2024", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "enforcing", "pub:editorial_status": "published", @@ -48,30 +48,36 @@ "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md", - "native_file_sha256": "372a62e39b49fc961482974100e5f04e22b1a922fadce391e66c68dc3d4993f2", + "native_file_sha256": "6fb9a910496ef034a5b8b241d8859688cb39d2370fd3321b07649b32e3f49e2e", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "53b0d1aff53dcae4e0bd8e34ee2021069340673c56b979bf6a639b1ca589c202", + "canonical_sha256": "c1aca07ba833a22c5029c1afa612bd5aff05a91c2a2e3d30309c12a4ba792235", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "4f6f7ab0b94560d1e81548a417d56e0026eee2e21799079f7baa04f2b448aa7e", + "review_packet_sha256": "4638f21fae0dfa0223ba78a611e37ad1d1c900807b53ff46a89832c0ba759e74", "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "02db4dfb7fcc9c536f4aa7e006458da3ed0ba3567a7cc4478db9e3d5c3195514", "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884", "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy." ] } ] diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452-issuance.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452-issuance.json index fd2d56e0..c1592a1f 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452-issuance.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452-issuance.json @@ -23,36 +23,38 @@ "resulting_instrument": [ "https://publedge.org/instrument/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.json" ], - "notes": "Issuance record for Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations.", + "notes": "Issuance record for Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots).", "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html", "source_citation": "Utah HB 452 (2025 General Session)", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md", - "native_file_sha256": "fe72c5b4cc375bf679bc8f03edd4ccd7b7cddafad47ece6439f8a5449fd967e7", + "native_file_sha256": "c75fb508faa76236a1cd60e5ed221ff2df4bae4c426295098f1ac0cd9d7836fb", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8deea5bfdfb67ecb23276907a46d7d76dbe492525a4b401dfcad8a1933fbbea5", + "canonical_sha256": "823a6f04b847768379b4f8d5218794e3c88e31d2fcdd1032d881da4cc49eccde", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "38ad104b571b171500e69a42c94ef01bbc1f85d57335af6e7ec67f0c6bb43705", + "review_packet_sha256": "be382469d216fa204a551bbd826747b34bbc49fc2e9581723266bd05df6a9690", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." ] } ] diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.json index 49445ec8..16d73a66 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.json @@ -8,8 +8,8 @@ "@type": "of:Instrument", "@id": "https://publedge.org/instrument/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.json", "pub:id": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452", - "title": "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations", - "short_title": "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations", + "title": "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots)", + "short_title": "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots)", "issuedBy": [ "https://publedge.org/authority/utah-legislature.json" ], @@ -39,7 +39,7 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html", "source_citation": "Utah HB 452 (2025 General Session)", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "enforcing", "pub:editorial_status": "published", @@ -48,26 +48,28 @@ "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md", - "native_file_sha256": "fe72c5b4cc375bf679bc8f03edd4ccd7b7cddafad47ece6439f8a5449fd967e7", + "native_file_sha256": "c75fb508faa76236a1cd60e5ed221ff2df4bae4c426295098f1ac0cd9d7836fb", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8deea5bfdfb67ecb23276907a46d7d76dbe492525a4b401dfcad8a1933fbbea5", + "canonical_sha256": "823a6f04b847768379b4f8d5218794e3c88e31d2fcdd1032d881da4cc49eccde", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "38ad104b571b171500e69a42c94ef01bbc1f85d57335af6e7ec67f0c6bb43705", + "review_packet_sha256": "be382469d216fa204a551bbd826747b34bbc49fc2e9581723266bd05df6a9690", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." ] } ] diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226-issuance.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226-issuance.json index 1f36644b..9091241b 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226-issuance.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226-issuance.json @@ -26,26 +26,41 @@ "notes": "Issuance record for Utah SB 226 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments.", "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/SB0226.html", "source_citation": "Utah SB 226 (2025 General Session)", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md", - "native_file_sha256": "518882b00ebe9515a3f4697a2da41a607c506c8d844a31895dcf1851d0f5dd3a", + "native_file_sha256": "9cb602b984427da4e4f0bdc1ba9f56458de93a54911769c20584ce105b1c6cf0", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "7e4a5fbb8f032549b461c3d8840b09b6dfe91587e3b95cde0269b6a9bd69ac2c", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "50b4e7a0685706064d5b50d211ba997047c14518a371a7ee1c859a4ccbe8e530", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "4ac77cfcca432ea01bcba7273922a36be25970b9c78729c8cd6241f6c3ee1733", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.json index ada04da0..fce226cd 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.json @@ -38,29 +38,44 @@ "citation": "Utah SB 226 (2025 General Session)", "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/SB0226.html", "source_citation": "Utah SB 226 (2025 General Session)", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "enforcing", "pub:editorial_status": "published", "pub:canonical_url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-001/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md", - "native_file_sha256": "518882b00ebe9515a3f4697a2da41a607c506c8d844a31895dcf1851d0f5dd3a", + "native_file_sha256": "9cb602b984427da4e4f0bdc1ba9f56458de93a54911769c20584ce105b1c6cf0", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "7e4a5fbb8f032549b461c3d8840b09b6dfe91587e3b95cde0269b6a9bd69ac2c", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "50b4e7a0685706064d5b50d211ba997047c14518a371a7ee1c859a4ccbe8e530", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "4ac77cfcca432ea01bcba7273922a36be25970b9c78729c8cd6241f6c3ee1733", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332-issuance.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332-issuance.json index ef30359e..be320a9c 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332-issuance.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332-issuance.json @@ -26,26 +26,37 @@ "notes": "Issuance record for Utah SB 332 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Revisions (AIPA Sunset Extension).", "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/SB0332.html", "source_citation": "Utah SB 332 (2025 General Session), Governor Signed March 25, 2025", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "The effective field stays 2025-05-07. SB 332 took effect May 7, 2025, or on governor approval if passed by two-thirds of each house; the record votes (24-0-5, 74-0-1) would exceed two-thirds but are not confirmed against a retained status page.", + "enacted (2025-03-25) and all introduction, committee and floor-vote rows are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0332 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 332 amends 63I-2-213(5), the repeal date SB 149 set, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.md", - "native_file_sha256": "97e8084f429a9565d1b7e2d4eeb6ab7cb0d16c63762838c30c18afde1f436a83", + "native_file_sha256": "6de7ddf6525087ffe3f1e32b40dac48954dc0cfe7eceabd5e5717f24307a9a36", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "9a1f758c218403901c5d9dcd442ebd4dff0118a7c713feeb24efdc0656e853d9", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "bd4aa91c270b8033ecea8ff2cd6a4b7396df9b9e9ffdc9950d3bc69f10fe59b9", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "ad3c5755c52e64c6fba5d00117de2b57dba0291757f7084cc28f0b5641a1f09d", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The effective field stays 2025-05-07. SB 332 took effect May 7, 2025, or on governor approval if passed by two-thirds of each house; the record votes (24-0-5, 74-0-1) would exceed two-thirds but are not confirmed against a retained status page.", + "enacted (2025-03-25) and all introduction, committee and floor-vote rows are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0332 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 332 amends 63I-2-213(5), the repeal date SB 149 set, so the source does not contradict it." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.json index 88d65bb5..94e97ff7 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.json @@ -36,29 +36,40 @@ "citation": "Utah SB 332 (2025 General Session), Governor Signed March 25, 2025", "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/SB0332.html", "source_citation": "Utah SB 332 (2025 General Session), Governor Signed March 25, 2025", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "enforcing", "pub:editorial_status": "published", "pub:canonical_url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-003/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "The effective field stays 2025-05-07. SB 332 took effect May 7, 2025, or on governor approval if passed by two-thirds of each house; the record votes (24-0-5, 74-0-1) would exceed two-thirds but are not confirmed against a retained status page.", + "enacted (2025-03-25) and all introduction, committee and floor-vote rows are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0332 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 332 amends 63I-2-213(5), the repeal date SB 149 set, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332.md", - "native_file_sha256": "97e8084f429a9565d1b7e2d4eeb6ab7cb0d16c63762838c30c18afde1f436a83", + "native_file_sha256": "6de7ddf6525087ffe3f1e32b40dac48954dc0cfe7eceabd5e5717f24307a9a36", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "9a1f758c218403901c5d9dcd442ebd4dff0118a7c713feeb24efdc0656e853d9", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "bd4aa91c270b8033ecea8ff2cd6a4b7396df9b9e9ffdc9950d3bc69f10fe59b9", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "ad3c5755c52e64c6fba5d00117de2b57dba0291757f7084cc28f0b5641a1f09d", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The effective field stays 2025-05-07. SB 332 took effect May 7, 2025, or on governor approval if passed by two-thirds of each house; the record votes (24-0-5, 74-0-1) would exceed two-thirds but are not confirmed against a retained status page.", + "enacted (2025-03-25) and all introduction, committee and floor-vote rows are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0332 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 332 amends 63I-2-213(5), the repeal date SB 149 set, so the source does not contradict it." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320-issuance.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320-issuance.json index b489e9c0..51226edb 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320-issuance.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320-issuance.json @@ -23,29 +23,45 @@ "resulting_instrument": [ "https://publedge.org/instrument/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.json" ], - "notes": "Issuance record for Utah HB 320 (2026) — AI Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements.", + "notes": "Issuance record for Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements).", "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2026/bills/static/HB0320.html", "source_citation": "Utah HB 320 (2026 General Session)", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md", - "native_file_sha256": "111b246cf8bb2b1118face419aa81634e3eba290346e98be8e47761d2a8345d5", + "native_file_sha256": "01797df3b03a8a6d33869d8a1ed4a0575acea137ea8b84598087d3a0fca8008d", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8c4fba21742f0b6e177e6c4789075c6851acbcd3359335a24162d7f007393692", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "0602d5a250b66e24ed6f13779a1c055cc90a4f97b27249ef54d099a3e9eb9ad7", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "b140f99a901d8f1e6f4bf389765fa85c72c5b7972a9ddf3f63132f56646e5da3", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.json index 40c3c2c2..2ccf88ca 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.json @@ -8,8 +8,8 @@ "@type": "of:Instrument", "@id": "https://publedge.org/instrument/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.json", "pub:id": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320", - "title": "Utah HB 320 (2026) — AI Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements", - "short_title": "Utah HB 320 (2026) — AI Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements", + "title": "Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements)", + "short_title": "Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements)", "issuedBy": [ "https://publedge.org/authority/utah-legislature.json" ], @@ -38,29 +38,45 @@ "citation": "Utah HB 320 (2026 General Session)", "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2026/bills/static/HB0320.html", "source_citation": "Utah HB 320 (2026 General Session)", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "enforcing", "pub:editorial_status": "published", "pub:canonical_url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2026-001/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md", - "native_file_sha256": "111b246cf8bb2b1118face419aa81634e3eba290346e98be8e47761d2a8345d5", + "native_file_sha256": "01797df3b03a8a6d33869d8a1ed4a0575acea137ea8b84598087d3a0fca8008d", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8c4fba21742f0b6e177e6c4789075c6851acbcd3359335a24162d7f007393692", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "0602d5a250b66e24ed6f13779a1c055cc90a4f97b27249ef54d099a3e9eb9ad7", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "b140f99a901d8f1e6f4bf389765fa85c72c5b7972a9ddf3f63132f56646e5da3", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001-publedge-illustrative-requesting-party.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001-publedge-illustrative-requesting-party.json index e7bc8e5f..b686b635 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001-publedge-illustrative-requesting-party.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001-publedge-illustrative-requesting-party.json @@ -17,27 +17,36 @@ "roles": [ "requesting_party" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "1c73dcfdf1dc9dc14040426990fdd43ea4db8615ca0523c2914d7fda1e40d740", + "native_file_sha256": "639f19ea3a4b559894f32da3142be916fbd98e3b9fe5791edb9a05d80a6d61ad", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "c2190dfc51ff2893e9e1a4d49c9457f0fca3791cd8cca5878fe55c1a7b014c19", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "b935a9e9d2a81ec511b4f507e2086e60394cba0f5ca191721dfd405edb4c17d6", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "27b15547fb411ec37543f7deac2039683b39c228e9d71b8d5976e645c811d329", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001-utah-oaip.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001-utah-oaip.json index e84d42e3..5fa7d3f2 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001-utah-oaip.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001-utah-oaip.json @@ -17,27 +17,36 @@ "roles": [ "interpreting_authority" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "1c73dcfdf1dc9dc14040426990fdd43ea4db8615ca0523c2914d7fda1e40d740", + "native_file_sha256": "639f19ea3a4b559894f32da3142be916fbd98e3b9fe5791edb9a05d80a6d61ad", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "c2190dfc51ff2893e9e1a4d49c9457f0fca3791cd8cca5878fe55c1a7b014c19", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "b935a9e9d2a81ec511b4f507e2086e60394cba0f5ca191721dfd405edb4c17d6", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "27b15547fb411ec37543f7deac2039683b39c228e9d71b8d5976e645c811d329", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.json index 1081a764..9e54e820 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.json @@ -44,30 +44,39 @@ "territorial_scope": [ "us-ut" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "proposed", "pub:editorial_status": "draft", "pub:canonical_url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/jia/2026-001/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "1c73dcfdf1dc9dc14040426990fdd43ea4db8615ca0523c2914d7fda1e40d740", + "native_file_sha256": "639f19ea3a4b559894f32da3142be916fbd98e3b9fe5791edb9a05d80a6d61ad", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "c2190dfc51ff2893e9e1a4d49c9457f0fca3791cd8cca5878fe55c1a7b014c19", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "b935a9e9d2a81ec511b4f507e2086e60394cba0f5ca191721dfd405edb4c17d6", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "27b15547fb411ec37543f7deac2039683b39c228e9d71b8d5976e645c811d329", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-elizachat-inc.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-elizachat-inc.json index 0c21c0b3..dc337475 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-elizachat-inc.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-elizachat-inc.json @@ -17,28 +17,39 @@ "roles": [ "participant" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-issuance.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-issuance.json index c1f632be..dbdd2c0a 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-issuance.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-issuance.json @@ -24,28 +24,39 @@ "https://publedge.org/instrument/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.json" ], "notes": "Issuance record for Utah OAIP × ElizaChat — Teen Mental-Health App RMA (2024).", - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-utah-division-of-professional-licensing.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-utah-division-of-professional-licensing.json index 9160c8ad..457bf098 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-utah-division-of-professional-licensing.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-utah-division-of-professional-licensing.json @@ -17,28 +17,39 @@ "roles": [ "co_signatory_authority" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-utah-office-of-artificial-intelligence-policy.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-utah-office-of-artificial-intelligence-policy.json index b7fb2967..0d50c4eb 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-utah-office-of-artificial-intelligence-policy.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-utah-office-of-artificial-intelligence-policy.json @@ -17,28 +17,39 @@ "roles": [ "issuing_authority" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.json index 668d9535..61bf9f72 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.json @@ -55,31 +55,42 @@ "us-ut" ], "citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "expired", "pub:editorial_status": "published", "pub:canonical_url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2024-001/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-doctronic-llc.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-doctronic-llc.json index 0af03d5c..179b1f54 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-doctronic-llc.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-doctronic-llc.json @@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/doctronic/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", @@ -28,33 +28,38 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] } ] diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-issuance.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-issuance.json index 4ed7c108..6ca121c0 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-issuance.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-issuance.json @@ -27,7 +27,7 @@ "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/doctronic/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", @@ -35,33 +35,38 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] } ] diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-utah-division-of-professional-licensing.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-utah-division-of-professional-licensing.json index 1c25f398..22389397 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-utah-division-of-professional-licensing.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-utah-division-of-professional-licensing.json @@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/doctronic/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", @@ -28,33 +28,38 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] } ] diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-utah-office-of-artificial-intelligence-policy.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-utah-office-of-artificial-intelligence-policy.json index 12fa550b..79c6a454 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-utah-office-of-artificial-intelligence-policy.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-utah-office-of-artificial-intelligence-policy.json @@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/doctronic/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", @@ -28,33 +28,38 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] } ] diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.json index 8fda5b8a..14021f0b 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.json @@ -58,7 +58,7 @@ "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/doctronic/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "enforcing", "pub:editorial_status": "published", @@ -69,33 +69,38 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] } ] diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-issuance.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-issuance.json index cd42ae69..7efa5900 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-issuance.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-issuance.json @@ -24,28 +24,41 @@ "https://publedge.org/instrument/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.json" ], "notes": "Issuance record for Utah OAIP × Legion Health — AI Maintenance Psychiatric Refill RMA (2026).", - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-legion-health-inc.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-legion-health-inc.json index 5fe23f75..ee5b8e7c 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-legion-health-inc.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-legion-health-inc.json @@ -17,28 +17,41 @@ "roles": [ "participant" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-legion-health-pa.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-legion-health-pa.json index 527d0b35..eb965cf8 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-legion-health-pa.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-legion-health-pa.json @@ -17,28 +17,41 @@ "roles": [ "participant" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-utah-division-of-professional-licensing.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-utah-division-of-professional-licensing.json index 7430178b..0d448878 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-utah-division-of-professional-licensing.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-utah-division-of-professional-licensing.json @@ -17,28 +17,41 @@ "roles": [ "co_signatory_authority" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-utah-office-of-artificial-intelligence-policy.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-utah-office-of-artificial-intelligence-policy.json index dd5b78bc..f2fff21a 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-utah-office-of-artificial-intelligence-policy.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-utah-office-of-artificial-intelligence-policy.json @@ -17,28 +17,41 @@ "roles": [ "issuing_authority" ], - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.json index 62b038dd..94ec30bf 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.json @@ -59,31 +59,44 @@ "us-ut" ], "citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:status": "enacted", "pub:editorial_status": "published", "pub:canonical_url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2026-001/", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session-disclose-genai-on-first-session.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session-disclose-genai-on-first-session.json index 1890d860..4d6b3683 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session-disclose-genai-on-first-session.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session-disclose-genai-on-first-session.json @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ "@id": "https://publedge.org/obligation/utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session-disclose-genai-on-first-session.json", "pub:id": "utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session-disclose-genai-on-first-session", "title": "Disclose GenAI on First Session", - "content": "A consumer-facing GenAI service must display a clear, prominent disclosure that the consumer is interacting with an AI system at the start of each session.", + "content": "Disclose plainly that the person is interacting with generative AI and not a human. When the disclosure is due depends on the Utah provision: on a clear request in a consumer transaction (§13-75-103(1)); at the start of a high-risk interaction in a regulated occupation (§13-75-103(2)-(3)); and for a mental health chatbot, before access, again after seven days without access, and whenever asked (§13-72a-203(2)). No Utah provision anchored here requires re-display at every session or after a fixed inactivity period.", "created_by": [ "https://publedge.org/term/utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session.json" ], @@ -25,9 +25,9 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", "source_locator": "Utah Code §13-72a-203", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", "verified": "2026-04-18", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:primary_id": "disclose-genai-on-first-session", @@ -41,35 +41,47 @@ "chatbot" ], "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field.", "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", - "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law." + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt.", + "The obligation id and name still say 'first session'; renaming the id is a separate schema decision.", + "last_verified renewal requires a separate human review receipt." ], - "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "1c73dcfdf1dc9dc14040426990fdd43ea4db8615ca0523c2914d7fda1e40d740", + "native_file_sha256": "639f19ea3a4b559894f32da3142be916fbd98e3b9fe5791edb9a05d80a6d61ad", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "c2190dfc51ff2893e9e1a4d49c9457f0fca3791cd8cca5878fe55c1a7b014c19", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "b935a9e9d2a81ec511b4f507e2086e60394cba0f5ca191721dfd405edb4c17d6", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "27b15547fb411ec37543f7deac2039683b39c228e9d71b8d5976e645c811d329", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session", "canonical_sha256": "c307d8182e42993daa76516e2a364800ab0cccdea4fa8febf65c53f4371cb5d6", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "476523ef2974b11f96c887c77c8135e1b4e835d70264833e80b5204eccc4d75f", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], @@ -77,20 +89,28 @@ "unresolved": [ "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", - "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law." + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." ] }, { "kind": "obligation-definition", "native_path": "data/examples/obligations/disclose-genai-on-first-session.md", - "native_file_sha256": "964a825c8ad92c8e5a59ceda27d05433bd145b2b381af9edb7f6309681a55b71", + "native_file_sha256": "785f11886a59611ca6458facf971ef6bcf088085a4c12675492498d88380fc8d", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "416ca3ea40e4681bf3f0ccb9a00cd890d94214d1e9c0ffd262fbb6a8a17da163", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "c87615a8fc2a979ae02b7d3c833c2b2cfcb476b6b61bdfae0d86d17343eb787d", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "8086134b9fedbd88d7dd4e183a80419860da6b3e77dd75151942f662cdfca44c", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The obligation id and name still say 'first session'; renaming the id is a separate schema decision.", + "last_verified renewal requires a separate human review receipt." + ] } ] } diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/records/utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session.json b/docs/api/v1/of/records/utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session.json index 8ee961c0..f8fc146b 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/records/utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/records/utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session.json @@ -11,7 +11,7 @@ ], "@id": "https://publedge.org/term/utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session.json", "pub:id": "utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session", - "text": "Provider must display the standardized GenAI disclosure on first session and on session resumption after 30 minutes of inactivity.", + "text": "Proposed interpretation: provider displays the standardized GenAI disclosure before first access and again on session resumption after 30 minutes of inactivity. The 30-minute re-display is a proposed term stricter than the statute's seven-day trigger, not a statutory requirement.", "section": "Utah Code §13-72a-203", "parent_instrument": "https://publedge.org/instrument/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.json", "creates": [ @@ -23,50 +23,59 @@ "lifecycle_status": "draft", "operative_status": "future", "enforcement_status": "unsignaled", - "effective": "2026-04-15", "jurisdiction": { "@type": "of:Jurisdiction", "territorial_scope": [ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", "source_locator": "Utah Code §13-72a-203", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-04-18", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:source_heading": "First-Session Disclosure (§13-72a-203)", "pub:source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field.", "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", - "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law." + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." ], - "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "1c73dcfdf1dc9dc14040426990fdd43ea4db8615ca0523c2914d7fda1e40d740", + "native_file_sha256": "639f19ea3a4b559894f32da3142be916fbd98e3b9fe5791edb9a05d80a6d61ad", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "c2190dfc51ff2893e9e1a4d49c9457f0fca3791cd8cca5878fe55c1a7b014c19", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "b935a9e9d2a81ec511b4f507e2086e60394cba0f5ca191721dfd405edb4c17d6", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "27b15547fb411ec37543f7deac2039683b39c228e9d71b8d5976e645c811d329", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session", "canonical_sha256": "c307d8182e42993daa76516e2a364800ab0cccdea4fa8febf65c53f4371cb5d6", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "476523ef2974b11f96c887c77c8135e1b4e835d70264833e80b5204eccc4d75f", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], @@ -74,7 +83,9 @@ "unresolved": [ "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", - "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law." + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." ] } ] diff --git a/docs/api/v1/of/terms.json b/docs/api/v1/of/terms.json index af04a652..e53d0dad 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/of/terms.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/of/terms.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "@context": "https://obligationfirst.org/v1/context.jsonld", - "generated": "2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z", + "generated": "2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z", "terms": [ { "@context": [ @@ -15,7 +15,7 @@ ], "@id": "https://publedge.org/term/utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session.json", "pub:id": "utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session", - "text": "Provider must display the standardized GenAI disclosure on first session and on session resumption after 30 minutes of inactivity.", + "text": "Proposed interpretation: provider displays the standardized GenAI disclosure before first access and again on session resumption after 30 minutes of inactivity. The 30-minute re-display is a proposed term stricter than the statute's seven-day trigger, not a statutory requirement.", "section": "Utah Code §13-72a-203", "parent_instrument": "https://publedge.org/instrument/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.json", "creates": [ @@ -27,50 +27,59 @@ "lifecycle_status": "draft", "operative_status": "future", "enforcement_status": "unsignaled", - "effective": "2026-04-15", "jurisdiction": { "@type": "of:Jurisdiction", "territorial_scope": [ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/", "source_locator": "Utah Code §13-72a-203", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-04-18", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:source_heading": "First-Session Disclosure (§13-72a-203)", "pub:source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field.", "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", - "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law." + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." ], - "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "1c73dcfdf1dc9dc14040426990fdd43ea4db8615ca0523c2914d7fda1e40d740", + "native_file_sha256": "639f19ea3a4b559894f32da3142be916fbd98e3b9fe5791edb9a05d80a6d61ad", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "c2190dfc51ff2893e9e1a4d49c9457f0fca3791cd8cca5878fe55c1a7b014c19", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "b935a9e9d2a81ec511b4f507e2086e60394cba0f5ca191721dfd405edb4c17d6", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "27b15547fb411ec37543f7deac2039683b39c228e9d71b8d5976e645c811d329", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "Lawyer review and authority sign-off remain pending; the draft is not issued.", + "The EveryAILaw amended-stack correspondence for the SB 149 slug was not compared field by field." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:utah-mental-health-chatbot-disclosure-2026q2-first-session", "canonical_sha256": "c307d8182e42993daa76516e2a364800ab0cccdea4fa8febf65c53f4371cb5d6", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "476523ef2974b11f96c887c77c8135e1b4e835d70264833e80b5204eccc4d75f", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], @@ -78,7 +87,9 @@ "unresolved": [ "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", - "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law." + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." ] } ] @@ -112,52 +123,72 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0149.html", "source_locator": "Summary", "source_citation": "Utah SB 149 (2024 General Session), Governor Signed March 13, 2024", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:source_heading": "Summary", "pub:source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy.", + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." ], - "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149.md", - "native_file_sha256": "372a62e39b49fc961482974100e5f04e22b1a922fadce391e66c68dc3d4993f2", + "native_file_sha256": "6fb9a910496ef034a5b8b241d8859688cb39d2370fd3321b07649b32e3f49e2e", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "53b0d1aff53dcae4e0bd8e34ee2021069340673c56b979bf6a639b1ca589c202", + "canonical_sha256": "c1aca07ba833a22c5029c1afa612bd5aff05a91c2a2e3d30309c12a4ba792235", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "4f6f7ab0b94560d1e81548a417d56e0026eee2e21799079f7baa04f2b448aa7e", + "review_packet_sha256": "4638f21fae0dfa0223ba78a611e37ad1d1c900807b53ff46a89832c0ba759e74", "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "02db4dfb7fcc9c536f4aa7e006458da3ed0ba3567a7cc4478db9e3d5c3195514", "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", "40fc7c8eb86e26fe4c8529dec31ee94c740ab9bb221640fb1ee7dab0d7301884", "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "Boyd appointment date (2024-04-30) is not in the SB 149 enrolled copy or the retained bill status page; the row is kept but marked unconfirmed.", + "amended_by still lists us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 although HB 452 amends no section SB 149 enacted (it amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118). The schema relation was left for a human decision; the body text now states the non-amending relation.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; whether a dedicated current Learning Lab page exists needs human confirmation.", + "That SB 149 is Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 186 is inferred from HB 320 amendment citations, not stated in the SB 149 enrolled copy." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense", - "canonical_sha256": "61f84dffd6d2394a4b68aa79f58c20c3ab31813efd1677bf8e94da2c8b88a21a", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "56836cab160c49426e9224ae78e504cdbfa8c30d175cba082b10d0b98f1a2b21", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." + ] } ] }, @@ -192,32 +223,47 @@ "source_locator": "Summary", "source_citation": "Utah SB 226 (2025 General Session)", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:source_heading": "Summary", "pub:source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226.md", - "native_file_sha256": "518882b00ebe9515a3f4697a2da41a607c506c8d844a31895dcf1851d0f5dd3a", + "native_file_sha256": "9cb602b984427da4e4f0bdc1ba9f56458de93a54911769c20584ce105b1c6cf0", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "7e4a5fbb8f032549b461c3d8840b09b6dfe91587e3b95cde0269b6a9bd69ac2c", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "50b4e7a0685706064d5b50d211ba997047c14518a371a7ee1c859a4ccbe8e530", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "4ac77cfcca432ea01bcba7273922a36be25970b9c78729c8cd6241f6c3ee1733", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2025-03-25) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy and the le.utah.gov SB0226 status table is not retained; rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether SB 226 passed each house by two-thirds (so its 63I-2-213 amendment took effect on governor approval rather than May 7, 2025) is not confirmed.", + "The 404 status of the 13-75-S102/S103/S104 URLs and HTTP 200 for 13-75.html come from ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks, not a retained snapshot; a human should confirm the current le.utah.gov section URL pattern.", + "Whether an OAIP annual report was filed for 2024 or 2025 is unverified.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; SB 226 repeals 13-2-12, which SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb226-disclosure-and-ai-defense", "canonical_sha256": "4a99aeb263d40980aeb761d4572a047a19b10322e712878efd9d8c5f3bdda649", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -258,48 +304,64 @@ "source": "https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0452.html", "source_locator": "Summary", "source_citation": "Utah HB 452 (2025 General Session)", - "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "evidence_type": "reviewed-source-reference", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:source_heading": "Summary", "pub:source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", + "admission_status": "source-consistency-reviewed-changes", "source_review_conflicts": null, "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed.", + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." ], - "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", + "pub:source_review_state": "declared", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452.md", - "native_file_sha256": "fe72c5b4cc375bf679bc8f03edd4ccd7b7cddafad47ece6439f8a5449fd967e7", + "native_file_sha256": "c75fb508faa76236a1cd60e5ed221ff2df4bae4c426295098f1ac0cd9d7836fb", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8deea5bfdfb67ecb23276907a46d7d76dbe492525a4b401dfcad8a1933fbbea5", + "canonical_sha256": "823a6f04b847768379b4f8d5218794e3c88e31d2fcdd1032d881da4cc49eccde", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "38ad104b571b171500e69a42c94ef01bbc1f85d57335af6e7ec67f0c6bb43705", + "review_packet_sha256": "be382469d216fa204a551bbd826747b34bbc49fc2e9581723266bd05df6a9690", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ - "The retained Utah source establishes the described Utah enactment but does not establish nationwide uniqueness or comparative comprehensiveness.", - "This agent review removes unsupported comparative language and does not renew last_verified or authenticate human currentness review." + "enacted (2025-03-26) and the Introduced month (2025-02) are not in the enrolled copy, and the le.utah.gov HB0452 status table is JavaScript-rendered and not retained; the Timeline rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "amends still names us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 although HB 452 amends 13-2-1 and enacts Chapter 72a and 58-60-118, amending no section SB 149 enacted; the schema relation was left for a human decision and the Summary now states the non-amending relation.", + "The §13-72a-101(10)(b) carve-out citation was not re-reviewed." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack", - "canonical_sha256": "0efa1a9d629192ea94613364015b159f0297afd09676a5633788f81b626ed675", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "66bc4b8a16d6100604ecc6c10e8fd489aed581208679ce6a3c847cb44b7b3d7c", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "85eb4b8d00b8965fb04bca01487c0a599fa1b9b6351bc56518fd2ed0c56be3d4", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "279184eb1ee69adb7c9ada3e29763f9766b0705c87770b6330c13bada07c60e8", + "4a46dfa2524603d0ae5b90b9941c755206c19b16b269add496f55191749c4e9f" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "The PubLedge JIA and its 30-minute re-display term remain an unpublished draft and are not statutory terms.", + "Utah HB 452 section 13-72a-203 uses a seven-day interaction condition rather than the draft JIA 30-minute resumption condition.", + "The EveryAILaw target identities and cross-owner existence remain federation assertions; this receipt does not make EveryAILaw an issuing authority or certify current law.", + "The sb149-learning-lab-and-ai-defense and hb452-mental-health-chatbot-stack mappings are kept and qualified, not removed; whether to remap them is a human decision.", + "The disclose-genai-on-first-session obligation id and name still say 'first session'; its text was corrected in a separate receipt." + ] } ] }, @@ -332,32 +394,48 @@ "source_locator": "Summary", "source_citation": "Utah HB 320 (2026 General Session)", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:source_heading": "Summary", "pub:source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320.md", - "native_file_sha256": "111b246cf8bb2b1118face419aa81634e3eba290346e98be8e47761d2a8345d5", + "native_file_sha256": "01797df3b03a8a6d33869d8a1ed4a0575acea137ea8b84598087d3a0fca8008d", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "8c4fba21742f0b6e177e6c4789075c6851acbcd3359335a24162d7f007393692", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "0602d5a250b66e24ed6f13779a1c055cc90a4f97b27249ef54d099a3e9eb9ad7", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "b140f99a901d8f1e6f4bf389765fa85c72c5b7972a9ddf3f63132f56646e5da3", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "bfa2cca6c0a5a1f6e8c7ab123127d7c0263ef8f5f5a582672c8185af6c865835", + "d27d659781af84c97cfffb677089c1f91711edd76b47c692be3adb62380e1211" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "enacted (2026-03-19) and the Introduced month (2026-01) are not in the enrolled copy; the le.utah.gov HB0320 static page renders no status table. Rows are marked unconfirmed and the enacted field is unchanged.", + "Whether OAIP filed annual reports in 2024 or 2025 (and so the ordinal of the 2026 report) is unverified; the row is relabeled without an ordinal.", + "The PubLedge closing paragraph still characterizes the JIA as the \"interpretation\" instrument; the statute's own term is \"clarifies the application of a provision of state law or rule\". Whether JIAs support reliance is left to a human editor.", + "The commerce.utah.gov/ai/learning-lab/ link (404 on 2026-09-24 per ops/evidence/utah-overdue-dispositions-2026-09-23.json url_checks) was replaced with the retrieved OAIP home page; a dedicated current Learning Lab page needs human confirmation.", + "amends (us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149) is unchanged; HB 320 amends and renumbers sections SB 149 enacted, so the source does not contradict it." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:hb320-joint-interpretation-agreements", "canonical_sha256": "b85f1f2ef1628ab2a223640d36314be87543371986c0cb7fdd43099d48765c2e", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -403,36 +481,47 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/elizachat/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/elizachat/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Signed-Elizachat-Agreement-November-2024.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:source_heading": "Obligations summary (Section VI and Schedule A §XV–XVI)", "pub:source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "68266cdbb989ed85f06c0b2dc6a96f0007462ce569d77816590a479da020a7d7", + "native_file_sha256": "c623da93f7b652f8273c9fbfc5cec5da27e2e21939f25df14955b397dbaaba18", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "57ffb3356c78bfb68741fdbedba549d2ca8bcc62841b5dc53fb55691d0f12de7", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "dc16f4911a1457d822c7b30f08257abbfd613fa398912ef18a8b25f3d750bdaf", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "3cfcfa15a7248efe0fa5a379df4447eeeb143b72bca2d37102a664188a3de623", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "3b02de08d771cfe3b90f3f7913cb84c3516d61fd7041fcd60fd6deffb6b7cf1c", + "602cdd9fd4fcfb3770543bda79f99cb42f02ebc67377345e88a2206105ded8e6", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision, a termination, a replacement, or which rollout phases OAIP approved.", + "Expired status rests on the initial 12-month term and the OAIP register entry retrieved 2026-09-24; no expiry notice was reviewed." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:elizachat-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "ea5e274a5d4a57593803cccd6055995a1064f1e3fc60fde6b76f2267c223154a", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -507,7 +596,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:dentacor-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "e9dab4526948a1a8bc2c9a496d9aceec2a9dbd7998b36eb976e7b1099c444602", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -557,7 +646,7 @@ "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §16)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Doctronic-Final-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:source_heading": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §16)", "pub:source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", @@ -567,39 +656,44 @@ "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ], "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002.md", - "native_file_sha256": "79d84f0bd41f212f1f727d46b4d16f59a3d307e3e4d59e347a5e500e9f3d3984", + "native_file_sha256": "8793088d93de032d8f5b2ed3a50e9441d911ece3d01083ad61cd01d8c8672724", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "1759e1674fbadb47cba1b551681ec11249cc20c5749a0564bb3138ef472ebcbc", + "canonical_sha256": "3239d831c257b9d90b0ba33e8c45f2412d43e78dc36bb7def8c7cc596085a156", "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", - "review_packet_sha256": "5e3c426d9dbdfa30f065801d88ed39cd3355f7e1b23bed008fbd4c70a48fe299", + "review_packet_sha256": "0477b1b8256179798966ac53d86e5df9576f461bf5ba91e3e7948311ada05165", "retained_primary_sha256": [ "01be9384b07d7be04b9c24eab9760cea302dea48631cd8b8d4f7d96875bd386f", "66a376b02eebcd2c0c92dfbe7f51a59cbf9c1b6e4eaf59fd95d167530edf9b75", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", "a608ae66c362d6b6dd87a68d25055642d6dfcc6a19685aa614c9bb48c5340f7f", + "cd39386fe85beb33c49e4ab63ec82dc76212171be1bb16cef403dc7483a2cd37", "ebddbd00bd97e950eba215ecabcbeac7b0ff08a41929bba24f76e58cea0cd940" ], "unresolved_review_state": "declared", "unresolved": [ "The signed source PDF body retains the title DRAFT AGREEMENT although the official OAIP page and filename present it as final and the PDF contains signatures dated October 23-24, 2025.", "The May 19, 2026 outcomes report says its limited sample is based on reports from Doctronic physicians and that OAIP initiated a separate independent review.", - "The September 9, 2026 OAIP FAQ describes changed Phase 2 criteria and formulary removals that conflict with the retained signed agreement, but the current pilot page links no signed amendment establishing the mechanism or effective date.", - "No retained source establishes OAIP approval to enter Phase Two, compliance, extension, termination, or the pilot current phase or status.", - "This agent review does not renew last_verified or authenticate human review." + "OAIP's register and FAQ describe a 2026 amendment changing the Phase 2 criteria and removing two medications, which conflicts with the retained signed agreement; no amendment document is linked, so its date, signatories, and exact text are unverified.", + "No retained source shows an extension request or decision under Section 13, a termination, or compliance; the register's Active status and Phase 1 statement are agency web statements retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register's third-party adversarial testing term and the FAQ's malpractice insurance expectation do not appear in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:doctronic-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "983a05b1054d5be1992813ca2c6de182c8a4f269fd1e44cec124a8d4f7cc13c3", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -645,36 +739,49 @@ "us-ut" ] }, - "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/agreements/ai-legion-health/", + "source": "https://commerce.utah.gov/ai/regulatory-relief-4/authorized-pilots/ai-legion-health/", "source_locator": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "source_citation": "https://commerce.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Legion-Agreement.pdf", "evidence_type": "legacy-unreviewed-source-reference", - "verified": "2026-06-04", + "verified": "2026-09-23", "asserted_by_adopter": "https://publedge.org/", "pub:source_heading": "Obligations summary (Section 6 and Schedule A §17)", "pub:source_file": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", "projection_basis": "native-record-projection", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", "source_review_conflicts": null, - "pub:source_review_unresolved": null, - "pub:source_review_state": "unknown", + "pub:source_review_unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ], + "pub:source_review_state": "known-and-unknown", "pub:evidence_inputs": [ { "kind": "instrument", "native_path": "data/examples/instruments/us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001.md", - "native_file_sha256": "d9942ac7d573be8ea95f9bcba5f06d058b827ca69624601dba9a30990581fa2a", + "native_file_sha256": "3ebe2f0525a6e5fcf469b3f5c09afff35b357a3624445d3acd40065a91217788", "canonical_unit": null, - "canonical_sha256": "21b64100d29aee93b3dded419790b3a9b43869849be85a714de251d8282ebc10", - "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", - "review_packet_sha256": null, - "retained_primary_sha256": null, - "unresolved_review_state": "unknown", - "unresolved": null + "canonical_sha256": "7c95e7f547b4cf0c4592491e74bef6c9c30e45b4a307dc03be5b4fd0cec0b3d0", + "admission_status": "reviewed-changes", + "review_packet_sha256": "96c3ecc5b7baa5e3e85256a2b6662f29042fc2a7267586bb883da0f69dfd37ea", + "retained_primary_sha256": [ + "6b7c88c3117323ed84ac2e7e59820193aec5677a8d6cda04637cba9edff36b8d", + "80655c9373edb6aa99613311c0dcc6e7339c50612704df24b1b8e7b0a1c3087c", + "8b9be8a722a44067aa49121a01729188bad79262843a01b21dc9e37ed7c7f42b", + "c6ad09dd7b25a91cb3e141289850b8d46a63a0b7efe39f48d7ce1fa6572e890e" + ], + "unresolved_review_state": "declared", + "unresolved": [ + "No retained source gives a Commencement Date or publishes the Section 2.B commencement notice; the register said the demonstration period had not started when retrieved 2026-09-24.", + "The register lists malpractice insurance covering AI-related liability, but no insurance term appears in the retained signed agreement text.", + "The UAC R156-1 link returned HTTP 404 and was removed; no current official Office of Administrative Rules URL was retained." + ] }, { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:legion-rma-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8d53ca4c492a4efbde8299ec0998d2b0966db016cf54e627ddca6fae7aa8e88b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -739,7 +846,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:cfpb-ao-2022-001-pay-to-pay", "canonical_sha256": "e20e0bcb6fa5c62776f77e650f41e715b8d0ce8458a1f56e75a3a91709f998e5", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -804,7 +911,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:cftc-il-17-65-cta-unbundled-fee", "canonical_sha256": "cb56b0ebd2521dd3f2e355886a0b19d77ceda42cd5ad315aa03459673efec377", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -869,7 +976,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:irs-plr-202506001-incentive-fee", "canonical_sha256": "c2145852b85e818957983272334c5f4d57d23b7aecb92fa4ab317cb205d88489", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -934,7 +1041,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:irs-tege-2026-001-501c3-adverse", "canonical_sha256": "baba5d8ce4007aca04c51194d650f7639c767679b1e300d0f35b9ce0f8cb88bc", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -999,7 +1106,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001-rule-506c", "canonical_sha256": "9c7546b5135751e232852b0e9fcdf18e02973c38dd7c819d999b897a259e32e4", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -1078,7 +1185,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb24-205-never-operative-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "4849304cb37f40f5cb292b4ab29c1230e89a3dbce9c3f16ba17c1d63f50f8e1b", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", @@ -1148,7 +1255,7 @@ { "kind": "mapping-entry", "native_path": "data/examples/mapping/index.yml", - "native_file_sha256": "3d3aa26d49f430fdaee16e1e423fa59b6a28cddc26721072ce5a860041a1b592", + "native_file_sha256": "b2bd75074c27efe6713cd7bdc7c0f5504225ce58f5767b822771f1768201c19f", "canonical_unit": "entry:sb26-189-admt-act-obligations", "canonical_sha256": "8208176ce48fdbdfcd77357ea089231259a600b6827dd8a0fcd6ed41047afd4d", "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed", diff --git a/docs/api/v1/primaries.json b/docs/api/v1/primaries.json index caec444f..c59dd4c6 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/primaries.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/primaries.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "meta": { - "generated": "2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z", + "generated": "2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z", "count": 35 }, "items": [ diff --git a/docs/api/v1/recently_changed.json b/docs/api/v1/recently_changed.json index f05f6d9c..b2649455 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/recently_changed.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/recently_changed.json @@ -1,48 +1,48 @@ { "meta": { - "generated": "2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z", - "count": 5, + "generated": "2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z", + "count": 11, "window_days": 30 }, "items": [ { - "record_id": "us-co-legislature-statute-2025-sb25b-004", - "title": "Colorado SB 25B-004 (2025) — Increase Transparency for Algorithmic Systems (Colorado AI Act Effective-Date Delay)", - "url": "https://publedge.org/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2025-001/", + "record_id": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149", + "title": "Utah SB 149 (2024) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments", + "url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2024-001/", "change_type": "updated", - "created": "2026-05-21", - "modified": "2026-09-05", - "last_verified": "2026-09-05", - "jurisdiction": "us-co", - "authority": "colorado-legislature", + "created": "2026-04-21", + "modified": "2026-09-23", + "last_verified": "2026-09-23", + "jurisdiction": "us-ut", + "authority": "utah-legislature", "type": "statute", "source": "authoritative-reference", "status": "enforcing", "editorial_status": "published" }, { - "record_id": "us-co-legislature-statute-2024-sb24-205", - "title": "Colorado SB 24-205 (2024) — Consumer Protections for Interactions with Artificial Intelligence Systems", - "url": "https://publedge.org/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2024-001/", + "record_id": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452", + "title": "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots)", + "url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-002/", "change_type": "updated", - "created": "2026-05-21", - "modified": "2026-09-09", - "last_verified": "2026-07-25", - "jurisdiction": "us-co", - "authority": "colorado-legislature", + "created": "2026-04-21", + "modified": "2026-09-23", + "last_verified": "2026-09-23", + "jurisdiction": "us-ut", + "authority": "utah-legislature", "type": "statute", "source": "authoritative-reference", - "status": "superseded", + "status": "enforcing", "editorial_status": "published" }, { - "record_id": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149", - "title": "Utah SB 149 (2024) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments", - "url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2024-001/", + "record_id": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226", + "title": "Utah SB 226 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments", + "url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-001/", "change_type": "updated", "created": "2026-04-21", - "modified": "2026-09-12", - "last_verified": "2026-06-04", + "modified": "2026-09-23", + "last_verified": "2026-09-23", "jurisdiction": "us-ut", "authority": "utah-legislature", "type": "statute", @@ -51,13 +51,28 @@ "editorial_status": "published" }, { - "record_id": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452", - "title": "Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations", - "url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-002/", + "record_id": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332", + "title": "Utah SB 332 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Revisions (AIPA Sunset Extension)", + "url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-003/", + "change_type": "updated", + "created": "2026-06-04", + "modified": "2026-09-23", + "last_verified": "2026-09-23", + "jurisdiction": "us-ut", + "authority": "utah-legislature", + "type": "statute", + "source": "authoritative-reference", + "status": "enforcing", + "editorial_status": "published" + }, + { + "record_id": "us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320", + "title": "Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements)", + "url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2026-001/", "change_type": "updated", "created": "2026-04-21", - "modified": "2026-09-12", - "last_verified": "2026-06-04", + "modified": "2026-09-23", + "last_verified": "2026-09-23", "jurisdiction": "us-ut", "authority": "utah-legislature", "type": "statute", @@ -65,20 +80,95 @@ "status": "enforcing", "editorial_status": "published" }, + { + "record_id": "us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001", + "title": "Utah Mental Health Chatbot Disclosure — Joint Interpretation", + "url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/jia/2026-001/", + "change_type": "updated", + "created": "2026-04-15", + "modified": "2026-09-23", + "last_verified": "2026-09-23", + "jurisdiction": "us-ut", + "authority": "utah-oaip", + "type": "jia", + "source": "publedge-original-draft", + "status": "proposed", + "editorial_status": "draft" + }, + { + "record_id": "us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001", + "title": "Utah OAIP × ElizaChat — Teen Mental-Health App RMA (2024)", + "url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2024-001/", + "change_type": "updated", + "created": "2026-04-19", + "modified": "2026-09-23", + "last_verified": "2026-09-23", + "jurisdiction": "us-ut", + "authority": "utah-oaip", + "type": "rma", + "source": "demonstration-remap", + "status": "expired", + "editorial_status": "published" + }, { "record_id": "us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002", "title": "Utah OAIP × Doctronic — AI Prescription Renewal RMA (2025)", "url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2025-002/", "change_type": "updated", "created": "2026-04-19", - "modified": "2026-09-09", - "last_verified": "2026-06-04", + "modified": "2026-09-23", + "last_verified": "2026-09-23", + "jurisdiction": "us-ut", + "authority": "utah-oaip", + "type": "rma", + "source": "demonstration-remap", + "status": "enforcing", + "editorial_status": "published" + }, + { + "record_id": "us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001", + "title": "Utah OAIP × Legion Health — AI Maintenance Psychiatric Refill RMA (2026)", + "url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2026-001/", + "change_type": "updated", + "created": "2026-04-19", + "modified": "2026-09-23", + "last_verified": "2026-09-23", "jurisdiction": "us-ut", "authority": "utah-oaip", "type": "rma", "source": "demonstration-remap", + "status": "enacted", + "editorial_status": "published" + }, + { + "record_id": "us-co-legislature-statute-2025-sb25b-004", + "title": "Colorado SB 25B-004 (2025) — Increase Transparency for Algorithmic Systems (Colorado AI Act Effective-Date Delay)", + "url": "https://publedge.org/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2025-001/", + "change_type": "updated", + "created": "2026-05-21", + "modified": "2026-09-05", + "last_verified": "2026-09-05", + "jurisdiction": "us-co", + "authority": "colorado-legislature", + "type": "statute", + "source": "authoritative-reference", "status": "enforcing", "editorial_status": "published" + }, + { + "record_id": "us-co-legislature-statute-2024-sb24-205", + "title": "Colorado SB 24-205 (2024) — Consumer Protections for Interactions with Artificial Intelligence Systems", + "url": "https://publedge.org/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2024-001/", + "change_type": "updated", + "created": "2026-05-21", + "modified": "2026-09-09", + "last_verified": "2026-07-25", + "jurisdiction": "us-co", + "authority": "colorado-legislature", + "type": "statute", + "source": "authoritative-reference", + "status": "superseded", + "editorial_status": "published" } ] } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/api/v1/upcoming.json b/docs/api/v1/upcoming.json index 66eedd9d..00f52ee6 100644 --- a/docs/api/v1/upcoming.json +++ b/docs/api/v1/upcoming.json @@ -1,14 +1,14 @@ { "meta": { - "generated": "2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z", + "generated": "2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z", "count": 2, - "today": "2026-09-12" + "today": "2026-09-23" }, "items": [ { "kind": "term-end", "date": "2026-10-24", - "days_until": 42, + "days_until": 31, "record_id": "us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002", "title": "Utah OAIP × Doctronic — AI Prescription Renewal RMA (2025)", "url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2025-002/", @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ { "kind": "effective", "date": "2027-01-01", - "days_until": 111, + "days_until": 100, "record_id": "us-co-legislature-statute-2026-sb26-189", "title": "Colorado SB 26-189 (2026) — Automated Decision-Making Technology (ADMT) Act", "url": "https://publedge.org/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2026-001/", diff --git a/docs/assets/data.json b/docs/assets/data.json index f59d1e86..01212b65 100644 --- a/docs/assets/data.json +++ b/docs/assets/data.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -[{"type":"legal instrument","name":"CFPB Advisory Opinion — Pay-to-Pay Fees (Regulation F)","id":"us-cfpb-ao-2022-001","href":"/us/federal/cfpb/ao/2022-001/","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"cfpb advisory opinion — pay-to-pay fees (regulation f) us us-cfpb-ao-2022-001 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"CFTC Letter 17-65 — CTA Registration Exemption Survives MiFID II Fee Unbundling","id":"us-cftc-dsio-il-2017-001","href":"/us/federal/cftc-dsio/il/2017-001/","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"cftc letter 17-65 — cta registration exemption survives mifid ii fee unbundling us us-cftc-dsio-il-2017-001 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Colorado SB 24-205 (2024) — Consumer Protections for Interactions with Artificial Intelligence Systems","id":"us-co-legislature-statute-2024-sb24-205","href":"/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2024-001/","jurisdiction":"us-co","_search":"colorado sb 24-205 (2024) — consumer protections for interactions with artificial intelligence systems us-co us-co-legislature-statute-2024-sb24-205 superseded"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Colorado SB 25B-004 (2025) — Increase Transparency for Algorithmic Systems (Colorado AI Act Effective-Date Delay)","id":"us-co-legislature-statute-2025-sb25b-004","href":"/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2025-001/","jurisdiction":"us-co","_search":"colorado sb 25b-004 (2025) — increase transparency for algorithmic systems (colorado ai act effective-date delay) us-co us-co-legislature-statute-2025-sb25b-004 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Colorado SB 26-189 (2026) — Automated Decision-Making Technology (ADMT) Act","id":"us-co-legislature-statute-2026-sb26-189","href":"/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2026-001/","jurisdiction":"us-co","_search":"colorado sb 26-189 (2026) — automated decision-making technology (admt) act us-co us-co-legislature-statute-2026-sb26-189 enacted"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"IRS Private Letter Ruling 202506001 — Management Contract Private Business Use (§141)","id":"us-irs-chief-counsel-plr-2025-001","href":"/us/federal/irs-chief-counsel/plr/2025-001/","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"irs private letter ruling 202506001 — management contract private business use (§141) us us-irs-chief-counsel-plr-2025-001 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"IRS PLR 202614036 — Adverse Determination: §501(c)(3) Exemption Denied, Mixed-Use Facility","id":"us-irs-tege-plr-2026-001","href":"/us/federal/irs-tege/plr/2026-001/","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"irs plr 202614036 — adverse determination: §501(c)(3) exemption denied, mixed-use facility us us-irs-tege-plr-2026-001 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"SEC No-Action Letter — Latham & Watkins (Rule 506(c) Verification)","id":"us-sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001","href":"/us/federal/sec-corpfin/nal/2025-001/","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"sec no-action letter — latham & watkins (rule 506(c) verification) us us-sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah SB 149 (2024) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments","id":"us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149","href":"/us/utah/legislature/statute/2024-001/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah sb 149 (2024) — artificial intelligence amendments us-ut us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations","id":"us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452","href":"/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-002/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah hb 452 (2025) — mental health chatbot regulations us-ut us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah SB 226 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments","id":"us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226","href":"/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-001/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah sb 226 (2025) — artificial intelligence consumer protection amendments us-ut us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah SB 332 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Revisions (AIPA Sunset Extension)","id":"us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332","href":"/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-003/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah sb 332 (2025) — artificial intelligence revisions (aipa sunset extension) us-ut us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah HB 320 (2026) — AI Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements","id":"us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320","href":"/us/utah/legislature/statute/2026-001/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah hb 320 (2026) — ai learning lab restructure + joint interpretation agreements us-ut us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah Mental Health Chatbot Disclosure — Joint Interpretation","id":"us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001","href":"/us/utah/oaip/jia/2026-001/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah mental health chatbot disclosure — joint interpretation us-ut us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001 proposed"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah OAIP × ElizaChat — Teen Mental-Health App RMA (2024)","id":"us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001","href":"/us/utah/oaip/rma/2024-001/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah oaip × elizachat — teen mental-health app rma (2024) us-ut us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001 expired"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah OAIP × Dentacor — AI-Assisted Dental Radiograph Diagnosis RMA (2025)","id":"us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-001","href":"/us/utah/oaip/rma/2025-001/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah oaip × dentacor — ai-assisted dental radiograph diagnosis rma (2025) us-ut us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-001 expired"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah OAIP × Doctronic — AI Prescription Renewal RMA (2025)","id":"us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002","href":"/us/utah/oaip/rma/2025-002/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah oaip × doctronic — ai prescription renewal rma (2025) us-ut us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah OAIP × Legion Health — AI Maintenance Psychiatric Refill RMA (2026)","id":"us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001","href":"/us/utah/oaip/rma/2026-001/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah oaip × legion health — ai maintenance psychiatric refill rma (2026) us-ut us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001 enacted"},{"type":"obligation","name":"ADMT Sixty-Day Cure Period Before Enforcement","id":"admt-60-day-cure-period","href":"primary/admt-60-day-cure-period/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"admt sixty-day cure period before enforcement admt-60-day-cure-period permission beginning january 1, 2027, violations of the colorado admt act are enforced by the attorney general as deceptive trade practices, with no private right of action. a regulated party may cure an alleged violation within 60 days of notice; the cure route is available through january 1, 2030. admt cure period attorney general deceptive trade practice colorado sb26-189"},{"type":"obligation","name":"ADMT Data Correction And Human Review Of Adverse Outcomes","id":"admt-correction-and-human-review","href":"primary/admt-correction-and-human-review/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"admt data correction and human review of adverse outcomes admt-correction-and-human-review requirement beginning january 1, 2027, consumers subject to an adverse consequential decision made using covered automated decision-making technology may correct inaccurate personal data used in that decision and may request meaningful human review and reconsideration of the outcome. the deployer must provide both paths. admt human review data correction reconsideration colorado sb26-189"},{"type":"obligation","name":"ADMT Deployer Three-Year Record Retention","id":"admt-deployer-3-year-record-retention","href":"primary/admt-deployer-3-year-record-retention/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"admt deployer three-year record retention admt-deployer-3-year-record-retention requirement beginning january 1, 2027, a deployer of covered automated decision-making technology must retain its compliance documentation for at least three years. the retention floor is what makes the notice, explanation, and review duties auditable by the attorney general after the fact. admt record keeping retention three years colorado sb26-189"},{"type":"obligation","name":"ADMT Deployer Notice Before Consequential Decision","id":"admt-deployer-pre-decision-notice","href":"primary/admt-deployer-pre-decision-notice/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"admt deployer notice before consequential decision admt-deployer-pre-decision-notice requirement beginning january 1, 2027, before a consequential decision is made using covered automated decision-making technology, the deployer must notify the consumer that an automated system is in use and disclose the purpose and nature of the decision. the notice is pre-decision; a post-hoc disclosure does not satisfy it. admt consumer notice consequential decision deployer colorado sb26-189"},{"type":"obligation","name":"ADMT Developer Documentation To Deployer","id":"admt-developer-documentation-to-deployer","href":"primary/admt-developer-documentation-to-deployer/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"admt developer documentation to deployer admt-developer-documentation-to-deployer requirement beginning january 1, 2027, a developer of covered automated decision-making technology must disclose to deployers the technology's intended uses, the categories of data used to train it, its known limitations, and instructions for meaningful human review. the duty runs developer-to-deployer, not developer-to-consumer. admt developer documentation training data known limitations colorado sb26-189"},{"type":"obligation","name":"ADMT Post-Adverse Explanation Within 30 Days","id":"admt-post-adverse-explanation-30-days","href":"primary/admt-post-adverse-explanation-30-days/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"admt post-adverse explanation within 30 days admt-post-adverse-explanation-30-days requirement beginning january 1, 2027, within 30 days of an adverse consequential decision made using covered automated decision-making technology, the deployer must give the consumer a plain-language explanation covering the ai's role in the decision, its degree of contribution, the types of data processed, and the sources of that data. admt adverse decision explanation 30 days colorado sb26-189"},{"type":"obligation","name":"AI-Authorized Prescription Renewal (Utah Pilot)","id":"ai-authorized-rx-renewal","href":"primary/ai-authorized-rx-renewal/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"ai-authorized prescription renewal (utah pilot) ai-authorized-rx-renewal permission during the mitigation period, a participant may use its ai technology to authorize the renewal of a verified prescription for a utah resident and issue such prescriptions to a pharmacist licensed under utah code §58-17b. mitigation applies solely to the renewal workflow described in the proposal; it does not extend to new prescriptions, other services, or products outside the authorized scope. prescription renewal ai rx telehealth doctronic legion 58-17b"},{"type":"obligation","name":"GenAI Is Not A Defense — Civil And Criminal","id":"ai-defense-elimination","href":"primary/ai-defense-elimination/index.html","group":"restriction","_search":"genai is not a defense — civil and criminal ai-defense-elimination restriction utah removed \"the ai did it\" as a defense in both civil and criminal contexts. a principal who uses, prompts, or acts through generative ai remains liable for the resulting statement or act. the criminal rule (§76-2-107, sb 149, effective 2024-05-01) and the civil mirror (§13-75-102, sb 226, effective 2025-05-07) together eliminate the doctrine across utah consumer-protection and criminal law. ai defense liability civil criminal sb149 sb226"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Pay-To-Pay Fee Prohibited Without Express Authorization","id":"cfpb-pay-to-pay-fee-prohibited","href":"primary/cfpb-pay-to-pay-fee-prohibited/index.html","group":"restriction","_search":"pay-to-pay fee prohibited without express authorization cfpb-pay-to-pay-fee-prohibited restriction a debt collector subject to the fair debt collection practices act may not charge a pay-to-pay convenience fee for online or phone payments unless the fee is either expressly authorized by the agreement creating the debt or affirmatively permitted by a specific law. silence, absence of prohibition, and third-party payment-processor routing do not cure the violation. fdcpa pay-to-pay convenience fee debt collection regulation f"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Unbundled Advice Fee Does Not Trigger CTA Registration","id":"cftc-unbundled-fee-not-cta-trigger","href":"primary/cftc-unbundled-fee-not-cta-trigger/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"unbundled advice fee does not trigger cta registration cftc-unbundled-fee-not-cta-trigger permission a registered fcm, swap dealer, or introducing broker that qualifies for the cta exclusion or exemption does not lose that status solely because it begins receiving a separate unbundled fee for commodity trading advice. the \"solely incidental\" or \"solely in connection with\" test continues to govern under a facts-and-circumstances analysis; separate compensation is one factor but is not dispositive. cta registration mifid ii fcm swap dealer introducing broker unbundled fee"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Mental Health Chatbot — No Third-Party Data Sharing","id":"chatbot-data-no-third-party-sharing","href":"primary/chatbot-data-no-third-party-sharing/index.html","group":"restriction","_search":"mental health chatbot — no third-party data sharing chatbot-data-no-third-party-sharing restriction a mental health chatbot supplier may not sell or share identifiable health information or user inputs with third parties. narrow exceptions exist for user-consented or user-requested transfers to a health care provider or plan. third-party sharing for functionality requires hipaa-equivalent controls (45 cfr parts 160 and 164, subparts a and e) as if the supplier were a covered entity. chatbot mental health data protection hipaa hb452"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Mental Health Chatbot — File 15-Element Safety Policy","id":"chatbot-safety-policy-filing","href":"primary/chatbot-safety-policy-filing/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"mental health chatbot — file 15-element safety policy chatbot-safety-policy-filing requirement a mental health chatbot supplier must draft, file with utah's division of consumer protection, and operationally comply with a fifteen-element written safety policy covering purposes, clinical practices, testing, risk protocols, user reporting, hipaa posture, and more. compliance with the filed policy at the time of an alleged violation provides an affirmative defense against §58-1-501(1)-(2) unauthorized-practice actions. chatbot mental health safety policy safe harbor filing hb452"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Dentacor — §58-69-5 Enforcement Forborne","id":"dentacor-58-69-5-enforcement-forborne","href":"primary/dentacor-58-69-5-enforcement-forborne/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"dentacor — §58-69-5 enforcement forborne dentacor-58-69-5-enforcement-forborne permission during the dentacor demonstration period, the utah division of professional licensing (dopl) forgave enforcement of unlawful and unprofessional-conduct actions under utah code §58-69-5 solely for conduct authorized by the rma. the initial mitigation period ended may 31, 2026, and no public extension instrument was located as of july 25, 2026. dentacor enforcement 58-69-5 unlawful conduct forbearance"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Dentacor — Hygienist + AI Concurrence Diagnosis","id":"dentacor-hygienist-ai-concurrence-diagnosis","href":"primary/dentacor-hygienist-ai-concurrence-diagnosis/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"dentacor — hygienist + ai concurrence diagnosis dentacor-hygienist-ai-concurrence-diagnosis permission during the initial dentacor rma term, licensed utah dental hygienists employed by dentacor could diagnose periodontal disease, complete edentulism, and complete anodontia using an ai-assisted radiograph diagnostic tool in place of general dentist supervision. the permission required concurrence of both the hygienist and the ai system and expired with the initial mitigation period on may 31, 2026; no public extension instrument was located as of july 25, 2026. dentacor hygienist radiograph diagnosis ai concurrence"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Dentacor — Informed Consent Disclosing Absence Of Dentist","id":"dentacor-informed-consent-no-dentist","href":"primary/dentacor-informed-consent-no-dentist/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"dentacor — informed consent disclosing absence of dentist dentacor-informed-consent-no-dentist requirement during the initial dentacor rma term, a dentacor-employed hygienist had to obtain patient informed consent before any rma-authorized procedure, explicitly disclosing the absence of dentist supervision and the hygienist's narrower training and scope. the requirement expired with the initial mitigation period on may 31, 2026; no public extension instrument was located as of july 25, 2026. dentacor informed consent dentist supervision patient disclosure"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Proactive GenAI Disclosure In High-Risk Interactions","id":"disclose-genai-high-risk-proactive","href":"primary/disclose-genai-high-risk-proactive/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"proactive genai disclosure in high-risk interactions disclose-genai-high-risk-proactive requirement a supplier engaged in a \"high-risk ai interaction\" in a regulated occupation must proactively disclose genai use before the interaction begins — verbally at the start of an oral exchange, and in writing before a written exchange. the high-risk tier is statutorily defined and narrower than general consumer interactions. disclosure high-risk regulated occupation proactive sb226"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Disclose GenAI on First Session","id":"disclose-genai-on-first-session","href":"primary/disclose-genai-on-first-session/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"disclose genai on first session disclose-genai-on-first-session requirement a consumer-facing genai service must display a clear, prominent disclosure that the consumer is interacting with an ai system at the start of each session. disclosure genai first session chatbot"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Disclose GenAI On Consumer Request","id":"disclose-genai-on-request","href":"primary/disclose-genai-on-request/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"disclose genai on consumer request disclose-genai-on-request requirement a supplier using generative ai in a consumer transaction must disclose that fact when the consumer makes a clear and unambiguous request. a safe harbor is available: a clear and conspicuous disclosure at the outset and throughout the interaction eliminates enforcement exposure, regardless of whether a request is made. disclosure genai consumer request safe harbor sb226"},{"type":"obligation","name":"ElizaChat — Three-Phase Rollout Gate","id":"elizachat-phased-rollout","href":"primary/elizachat-phased-rollout/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"elizachat — three-phase rollout gate elizachat-phased-rollout requirement elizachat must be released in three sequential phases — oaip trusted-tester cohort, oaip-reviewed limited student cohort, and full utah-district student availability — with written oaip approval required before advancing to each subsequent phase. elizachat phased rollout trusted tester phase gate"},{"type":"obligation","name":"ElizaChat — Pre-Access Disclosure Bundle","id":"elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle","href":"primary/elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"elizachat — pre-access disclosure bundle elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle requirement before granting any user access to elizachat app functionality, the participant must present a five-element disclosure — participant identity, genai use notice, testing-risk notice, data use and sharing practices, and oaip complaint channel — in clear and conspicuous form, and must secure user acknowledgment before access is granted. elizachat disclosure pre-access disclosure bundle"},{"type":"obligation","name":"High-Risk AI Consumer Notice, Correction, And Appeal","id":"high-risk-ai-consumer-notice-correction-and-appeal","href":"primary/high-risk-ai-consumer-notice-correction-and-appeal/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"high-risk ai consumer notice, correction, and appeal high-risk-ai-consumer-notice-correction-and-appeal requirement deployers would have been required to notify consumers before using a high-risk artificial intelligence system in a consequential decision and, after an adverse decision, provide the principal reasons, an opportunity to correct incorrect personal data, and an appeal with human review where technically feasible. the obligation is retained from the predecessor colorado sb 24-205 framework. predecessor operative history remains unresolved; sb 26-189 section 5 qualifies replacement timing, and signature alone does not establish when predecessor duties ceased or whether they operated. high-risk artificial intelligence consumer notice adverse consequential decision data correction appeal human review colorado sb24-205"},{"type":"obligation","name":"High-Risk AI Impact Assessment","id":"high-risk-ai-impact-assessment","href":"primary/high-risk-ai-impact-assessment/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"high-risk ai impact assessment high-risk-ai-impact-assessment requirement deployers would have been required to complete an impact assessment for each covered high-risk artificial intelligence system, repeat it at least annually and after intentional and substantial modifications, and retain the assessment records. the obligation is retained from the predecessor colorado sb 24-205 framework. predecessor operative history remains unresolved; sb 26-189 section 5 qualifies replacement timing, and signature alone does not establish when predecessor duties ceased or whether they operated. high-risk artificial intelligence impact assessment annual assessment algorithmic discrimination deployer colorado sb24-205"},{"type":"obligation","name":"High-Risk AI Reasonable Care Against Algorithmic Discrimination","id":"high-risk-ai-reasonable-care-against-algorithmic-discrimination","href":"primary/high-risk-ai-reasonable-care-against-algorithmic-discrimination/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"high-risk ai reasonable care against algorithmic discrimination high-risk-ai-reasonable-care-against-algorithmic-discrimination requirement developers and deployers of high-risk artificial intelligence systems would have been required to use reasonable care to protect consumers from known or reasonably foreseeable risks of algorithmic discrimination. the obligation is retained from the predecessor colorado sb 24-205 framework. predecessor operative history remains unresolved; sb 26-189 section 5 qualifies replacement timing, and signature alone does not establish when predecessor duties ceased or whether they operated. high-risk artificial intelligence reasonable care algorithmic discrimination developer deployer colorado sb24-205"},{"type":"obligation","name":"§501(c)(3) Exemption Denied — Organizational And Operational Test Failure","id":"irs-501c3-dual-test-failure","href":"primary/irs-501c3-dual-test-failure/index.html","group":"restriction","_search":"§501(c)(3) exemption denied — organizational and operational test failure irs-501c3-dual-test-failure restriction an organization fails §501(c)(3) exemption where its articles of incorporation neither limit purposes to exempt activities nor dedicate assets to exempt purposes on dissolution, and where a substantial portion of its activities consists of unrestricted commercial leasing coupled with fundraising that benefits a for-profit entity controlled by one of its own directors. bylaws containing the required provisions do not cure deficient articles; a single substantial non-exempt purpose is disqualifying regardless of any exempt purposes present. 501c3 organizational test operational test private inurement commercial leasing adverse determination"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Incentive-Fee Management Contract Not A Share Of Net Profits","id":"irs-incentive-fee-not-net-profits-share","href":"primary/irs-incentive-fee-not-net-profits-share/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"incentive-fee management contract not a share of net profits irs-incentive-fee-not-net-profits-share permission on the facts represented, an incentive-fee management contract between a §501(c)(3) bond issuer and a hotel manager — where the incentive fee is calculated on gross revenue subject to an adjustment contingent on a net-profit-variant metric — does not constitute sharing of net profits under rev. proc. 2017-13 §5.02(2) and therefore does not cause private business use under irc §141. the ruling applies only to the requesting taxpayer on the specific facts presented. private business use 501c3 bonds rev proc 2017-13 safe harbor incentive fee"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Learning Lab Agreement — Eligibility and Participation","id":"learning-lab-agreement-participation","href":"primary/learning-lab-agreement-participation/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"learning lab agreement — eligibility and participation learning-lab-agreement-participation permission a person deploying ai in utah may enter either a regulatory mitigation agreement (rma) — which waives specified law in exchange for safeguards, data sharing, and disclosures — or a joint interpretation agreement (jia) — which clarifies how existing statute applies to a specific ai use without waiver. agreements run for an initial twelve months with up to two twelve-month extensions, counterparties include oaip plus the relevant state agency (or judiciary, higher-ed, or political subdivision under hb 320), and participants must satisfy five statutory eligibility prongs. learning lab regulatory mitigation joint interpretation oaip sandbox sb149 hb320"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Named-Prescriber Enforcement Forborne","id":"named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne","href":"primary/named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"named-prescriber enforcement forborne named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne permission dopl forgoes unlawful-conduct and unprofessional-conduct enforcement under §58-1-501(1)-(2) and related professional-licensing provisions against any provider who (1) acts solely as the named prescriber for ai-authorized renewals, (2) does not interact directly with a patient or other provider, and (3) complies with the rma terms. forbearance applies only to conduct authorized by the agreement. named prescriber enforcement forbearance unprofessional conduct 58-1-501 doctronic legion"},{"type":"obligation","name":"RMA — Data Security Under §63A-19-102","id":"rma-data-security-63a-19-102","href":"primary/rma-data-security-63a-19-102/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"rma — data security under §63a-19-102 rma-data-security-63a-19-102 requirement an rma participant must implement data security measures conforming to utah code §63a-19-102 and maintain a cybersecurity framework that is updated on an ongoing basis to address emerging threats and vulnerabilities. no statutory or common-law cybersecurity obligation is waived by the rma. rma data security cybersecurity 63a-19-102"},{"type":"obligation","name":"RMA — 30-Day End-Of-Term Report","id":"rma-end-of-term-report","href":"primary/rma-end-of-term-report/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"rma — 30-day end-of-term report rma-end-of-term-report requirement within thirty days after the end date of an rma, the participant must file a written report with oaip summarizing the demonstration, any incidents of harm, any legal actions, and any complaints filed against the participant in connection with the mitigation period. rma reporting termination end of term"},{"type":"obligation","name":"RMA — Hold Harmless The State","id":"rma-hold-harmless-state","href":"primary/rma-hold-harmless-state/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"rma — hold harmless the state rma-hold-harmless-state requirement an rma participant agrees to hold oaip, the relevant division, and their agents, officers, and employees harmless from any claims, liabilities, damages, losses, or expenses arising from the participant's work performed under the mitigation. rma indemnification hold harmless"},{"type":"obligation","name":"RMA — 24-Hour Incident Notification","id":"rma-incident-notification-24hr","href":"primary/rma-incident-notification-24hr/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"rma — 24-hour incident notification rma-incident-notification-24hr requirement an rma participant must notify oaip within 24 hours of any incident that results in harm to the health, safety, or financial well-being of a user of the mitigated technology. rma incident notification harm 24 hours"},{"type":"obligation","name":"RMA — Monthly Report To OAIP","id":"rma-monthly-report-to-oaip","href":"primary/rma-monthly-report-to-oaip/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"rma — monthly report to oaip rma-monthly-report-to-oaip requirement each learning lab rma participant submits a monthly report to oaip at `ai@utah.gov` covering user data, incidents, complaints, research findings, and any other information specified by the office. the report is the primary ongoing accountability mechanism between participant and regulator during the mitigation period. rma reporting monthly oaip learning lab"},{"type":"obligation","name":"RMA — No Advertising Reference To Agreement","id":"rma-no-advertising-reference","href":"primary/rma-no-advertising-reference/index.html","group":"restriction","_search":"rma — no advertising reference to agreement rma-no-advertising-reference restriction an rma participant may not reference the existence of the agreement in advertising, media, or promotional materials. the mitigation is a regulatory posture, not a marketable endorsement by the state of utah. rma advertising promotion marketing"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Rule 506(c) Verification Via High-Minimum + Representation","id":"sec-reg-d-506c-verification-safe-harbor","href":"primary/sec-reg-d-506c-verification-safe-harbor/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"rule 506(c) verification via high-minimum + representation sec-reg-d-506c-verification-safe-harbor permission an issuer conducting a rule 506(c) offering satisfies the \"reasonable steps to verify\" accredited-investor requirement when it (1) imposes a minimum investment amount high enough that only accredited investors would reasonably be expected to meet it, (2) obtains written representations of accredited status and that the investment is not financed by a third party for purposes of the investment, and (3) has no actual knowledge of contradictory facts. the position restates the principles-based standard; it does not create an exclusive verification method. rule 506c accredited investor reasonable steps to verify regulation d private placement"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Telehealth Compliance Anchored To Participant Proposal","id":"telehealth-compliance-per-proposal","href":"primary/telehealth-compliance-per-proposal/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"telehealth compliance anchored to participant proposal telehealth-compliance-per-proposal requirement a participant operating ai-assisted prescription renewal must adhere to utah's telehealth provider requirements in §26b-4-704, with specific subsections deemed satisfied by following the patient-journey and escalation protocols described in the participant's proposal (schedule b). certain subsections (e.g., the patient-records portability default) are inapplicable; others are substituted by proposal-section conformance. telehealth 26b-4-704 proposal compliance doctronic legion"},{"type":"authority","name":"Consumer Financial Protection Bureau","id":"cfpb","href":"authority/cfpb/index.html","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"consumer financial protection bureau cfpb us"},{"type":"authority","name":"CFTC Division of Swap Dealer and Intermediary Oversight","id":"cftc-dsio","href":"authority/cftc-dsio/index.html","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"cftc division of swap dealer and intermediary oversight cftc-dsio us"},{"type":"authority","name":"Colorado General Assembly","id":"colorado-legislature","href":"authority/colorado-legislature/index.html","jurisdiction":"us-co","_search":"colorado general assembly colorado-legislature us-co"},{"type":"authority","name":"IRS Office of Chief Counsel","id":"irs-chief-counsel","href":"authority/irs-chief-counsel/index.html","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"irs office of chief counsel irs-chief-counsel us"},{"type":"authority","name":"IRS Tax Exempt and Government Entities Division","id":"irs-tege","href":"authority/irs-tege/index.html","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"irs tax exempt and government entities division irs-tege us"},{"type":"authority","name":"SEC Division of Corporation Finance","id":"sec-corpfin","href":"authority/sec-corpfin/index.html","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"sec division of corporation finance sec-corpfin us"},{"type":"authority","name":"Utah State Legislature","id":"utah-legislature","href":"authority/utah-legislature/index.html","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah state legislature utah-legislature us-ut"},{"type":"authority","name":"Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy","id":"utah-oaip","href":"authority/utah-oaip/index.html","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah office of artificial intelligence policy utah-oaip us-ut"}] \ No newline at end of file +[{"type":"legal instrument","name":"CFPB Advisory Opinion — Pay-to-Pay Fees (Regulation F)","id":"us-cfpb-ao-2022-001","href":"/us/federal/cfpb/ao/2022-001/","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"cfpb advisory opinion — pay-to-pay fees (regulation f) us us-cfpb-ao-2022-001 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"CFTC Letter 17-65 — CTA Registration Exemption Survives MiFID II Fee Unbundling","id":"us-cftc-dsio-il-2017-001","href":"/us/federal/cftc-dsio/il/2017-001/","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"cftc letter 17-65 — cta registration exemption survives mifid ii fee unbundling us us-cftc-dsio-il-2017-001 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Colorado SB 24-205 (2024) — Consumer Protections for Interactions with Artificial Intelligence Systems","id":"us-co-legislature-statute-2024-sb24-205","href":"/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2024-001/","jurisdiction":"us-co","_search":"colorado sb 24-205 (2024) — consumer protections for interactions with artificial intelligence systems us-co us-co-legislature-statute-2024-sb24-205 superseded"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Colorado SB 25B-004 (2025) — Increase Transparency for Algorithmic Systems (Colorado AI Act Effective-Date Delay)","id":"us-co-legislature-statute-2025-sb25b-004","href":"/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2025-001/","jurisdiction":"us-co","_search":"colorado sb 25b-004 (2025) — increase transparency for algorithmic systems (colorado ai act effective-date delay) us-co us-co-legislature-statute-2025-sb25b-004 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Colorado SB 26-189 (2026) — Automated Decision-Making Technology (ADMT) Act","id":"us-co-legislature-statute-2026-sb26-189","href":"/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2026-001/","jurisdiction":"us-co","_search":"colorado sb 26-189 (2026) — automated decision-making technology (admt) act us-co us-co-legislature-statute-2026-sb26-189 enacted"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"IRS Private Letter Ruling 202506001 — Management Contract Private Business Use (§141)","id":"us-irs-chief-counsel-plr-2025-001","href":"/us/federal/irs-chief-counsel/plr/2025-001/","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"irs private letter ruling 202506001 — management contract private business use (§141) us us-irs-chief-counsel-plr-2025-001 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"IRS PLR 202614036 — Adverse Determination: §501(c)(3) Exemption Denied, Mixed-Use Facility","id":"us-irs-tege-plr-2026-001","href":"/us/federal/irs-tege/plr/2026-001/","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"irs plr 202614036 — adverse determination: §501(c)(3) exemption denied, mixed-use facility us us-irs-tege-plr-2026-001 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"SEC No-Action Letter — Latham & Watkins (Rule 506(c) Verification)","id":"us-sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001","href":"/us/federal/sec-corpfin/nal/2025-001/","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"sec no-action letter — latham & watkins (rule 506(c) verification) us us-sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah SB 149 (2024) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments","id":"us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149","href":"/us/utah/legislature/statute/2024-001/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah sb 149 (2024) — artificial intelligence amendments us-ut us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots)","id":"us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452","href":"/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-002/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah hb 452 (2025) — artificial intelligence amendments (mental health chatbots) us-ut us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah SB 226 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments","id":"us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226","href":"/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-001/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah sb 226 (2025) — artificial intelligence consumer protection amendments us-ut us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah SB 332 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Revisions (AIPA Sunset Extension)","id":"us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332","href":"/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-003/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah sb 332 (2025) — artificial intelligence revisions (aipa sunset extension) us-ut us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements)","id":"us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320","href":"/us/utah/legislature/statute/2026-001/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah hb 320 (2026) — office of artificial intelligence policy amendments (learning lab restructure + joint interpretation agreements) us-ut us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah Mental Health Chatbot Disclosure — Joint Interpretation","id":"us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001","href":"/us/utah/oaip/jia/2026-001/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah mental health chatbot disclosure — joint interpretation us-ut us-ut-oaip-jia-2026-001 proposed"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah OAIP × ElizaChat — Teen Mental-Health App RMA (2024)","id":"us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001","href":"/us/utah/oaip/rma/2024-001/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah oaip × elizachat — teen mental-health app rma (2024) us-ut us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001 expired"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah OAIP × Dentacor — AI-Assisted Dental Radiograph Diagnosis RMA (2025)","id":"us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-001","href":"/us/utah/oaip/rma/2025-001/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah oaip × dentacor — ai-assisted dental radiograph diagnosis rma (2025) us-ut us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-001 expired"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah OAIP × Doctronic — AI Prescription Renewal RMA (2025)","id":"us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002","href":"/us/utah/oaip/rma/2025-002/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah oaip × doctronic — ai prescription renewal rma (2025) us-ut us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002 enforcing"},{"type":"legal instrument","name":"Utah OAIP × Legion Health — AI Maintenance Psychiatric Refill RMA (2026)","id":"us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001","href":"/us/utah/oaip/rma/2026-001/","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah oaip × legion health — ai maintenance psychiatric refill rma (2026) us-ut us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001 enacted"},{"type":"obligation","name":"ADMT Sixty-Day Cure Period Before Enforcement","id":"admt-60-day-cure-period","href":"primary/admt-60-day-cure-period/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"admt sixty-day cure period before enforcement admt-60-day-cure-period permission beginning january 1, 2027, violations of the colorado admt act are enforced by the attorney general as deceptive trade practices, with no private right of action. a regulated party may cure an alleged violation within 60 days of notice; the cure route is available through january 1, 2030. admt cure period attorney general deceptive trade practice colorado sb26-189"},{"type":"obligation","name":"ADMT Data Correction And Human Review Of Adverse Outcomes","id":"admt-correction-and-human-review","href":"primary/admt-correction-and-human-review/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"admt data correction and human review of adverse outcomes admt-correction-and-human-review requirement beginning january 1, 2027, consumers subject to an adverse consequential decision made using covered automated decision-making technology may correct inaccurate personal data used in that decision and may request meaningful human review and reconsideration of the outcome. the deployer must provide both paths. admt human review data correction reconsideration colorado sb26-189"},{"type":"obligation","name":"ADMT Deployer Three-Year Record Retention","id":"admt-deployer-3-year-record-retention","href":"primary/admt-deployer-3-year-record-retention/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"admt deployer three-year record retention admt-deployer-3-year-record-retention requirement beginning january 1, 2027, a deployer of covered automated decision-making technology must retain its compliance documentation for at least three years. the retention floor is what makes the notice, explanation, and review duties auditable by the attorney general after the fact. admt record keeping retention three years colorado sb26-189"},{"type":"obligation","name":"ADMT Deployer Notice Before Consequential Decision","id":"admt-deployer-pre-decision-notice","href":"primary/admt-deployer-pre-decision-notice/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"admt deployer notice before consequential decision admt-deployer-pre-decision-notice requirement beginning january 1, 2027, before a consequential decision is made using covered automated decision-making technology, the deployer must notify the consumer that an automated system is in use and disclose the purpose and nature of the decision. the notice is pre-decision; a post-hoc disclosure does not satisfy it. admt consumer notice consequential decision deployer colorado sb26-189"},{"type":"obligation","name":"ADMT Developer Documentation To Deployer","id":"admt-developer-documentation-to-deployer","href":"primary/admt-developer-documentation-to-deployer/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"admt developer documentation to deployer admt-developer-documentation-to-deployer requirement beginning january 1, 2027, a developer of covered automated decision-making technology must disclose to deployers the technology's intended uses, the categories of data used to train it, its known limitations, and instructions for meaningful human review. the duty runs developer-to-deployer, not developer-to-consumer. admt developer documentation training data known limitations colorado sb26-189"},{"type":"obligation","name":"ADMT Post-Adverse Explanation Within 30 Days","id":"admt-post-adverse-explanation-30-days","href":"primary/admt-post-adverse-explanation-30-days/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"admt post-adverse explanation within 30 days admt-post-adverse-explanation-30-days requirement beginning january 1, 2027, within 30 days of an adverse consequential decision made using covered automated decision-making technology, the deployer must give the consumer a plain-language explanation covering the ai's role in the decision, its degree of contribution, the types of data processed, and the sources of that data. admt adverse decision explanation 30 days colorado sb26-189"},{"type":"obligation","name":"AI-Authorized Prescription Renewal (Utah Pilot)","id":"ai-authorized-rx-renewal","href":"primary/ai-authorized-rx-renewal/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"ai-authorized prescription renewal (utah pilot) ai-authorized-rx-renewal permission during the mitigation period, a participant may use its ai technology to authorize the renewal of a verified prescription for a utah resident and issue such prescriptions to a pharmacist licensed under utah code §58-17b. mitigation applies solely to the renewal workflow described in the proposal; it does not extend to new prescriptions, other services, or products outside the authorized scope. prescription renewal ai rx telehealth doctronic legion 58-17b"},{"type":"obligation","name":"GenAI Is Not A Defense — Civil And Criminal","id":"ai-defense-elimination","href":"primary/ai-defense-elimination/index.html","group":"restriction","_search":"genai is not a defense — civil and criminal ai-defense-elimination restriction utah removed \"the ai did it\" as a defense in both civil and criminal contexts. a principal who uses, prompts, or acts through generative ai remains liable for the resulting statement or act. the criminal rule (§76-2-107, sb 149, effective 2024-05-01) and the civil mirror together eliminate the doctrine across utah consumer-protection and criminal law. the civil rule was first enacted at §13-2-12(2) (sb 149, effective 2024-05-01) and re-sited at §13-75-102 (sb 226, effective 2025-05-07). ai defense liability civil criminal sb149 sb226"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Pay-To-Pay Fee Prohibited Without Express Authorization","id":"cfpb-pay-to-pay-fee-prohibited","href":"primary/cfpb-pay-to-pay-fee-prohibited/index.html","group":"restriction","_search":"pay-to-pay fee prohibited without express authorization cfpb-pay-to-pay-fee-prohibited restriction a debt collector subject to the fair debt collection practices act may not charge a pay-to-pay convenience fee for online or phone payments unless the fee is either expressly authorized by the agreement creating the debt or affirmatively permitted by a specific law. silence, absence of prohibition, and third-party payment-processor routing do not cure the violation. fdcpa pay-to-pay convenience fee debt collection regulation f"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Unbundled Advice Fee Does Not Trigger CTA Registration","id":"cftc-unbundled-fee-not-cta-trigger","href":"primary/cftc-unbundled-fee-not-cta-trigger/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"unbundled advice fee does not trigger cta registration cftc-unbundled-fee-not-cta-trigger permission a registered fcm, swap dealer, or introducing broker that qualifies for the cta exclusion or exemption does not lose that status solely because it begins receiving a separate unbundled fee for commodity trading advice. the \"solely incidental\" or \"solely in connection with\" test continues to govern under a facts-and-circumstances analysis; separate compensation is one factor but is not dispositive. cta registration mifid ii fcm swap dealer introducing broker unbundled fee"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Mental Health Chatbot — No Third-Party Data Sharing","id":"chatbot-data-no-third-party-sharing","href":"primary/chatbot-data-no-third-party-sharing/index.html","group":"restriction","_search":"mental health chatbot — no third-party data sharing chatbot-data-no-third-party-sharing restriction a mental health chatbot supplier may not sell or share identifiable health information or user inputs with third parties. narrow exceptions exist for user-consented or user-requested transfers to a health care provider or plan. third-party sharing for functionality requires hipaa-equivalent controls (45 cfr parts 160 and 164, subparts a and e) as if the supplier were a covered entity. chatbot mental health data protection hipaa hb452"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Mental Health Chatbot — File 15-Element Safety Policy","id":"chatbot-safety-policy-filing","href":"primary/chatbot-safety-policy-filing/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"mental health chatbot — file 15-element safety policy chatbot-safety-policy-filing requirement filing is a condition of an affirmative defense, not a free-standing mandate. a mental health chatbot supplier has an affirmative defense against §58-1-501(1)-(2) unauthorized-practice actions if it shows that it created, maintained, and implemented a written policy meeting §58-60-118(3), including the fifteen procedure elements in (3)(c)(i)-(xv); maintains the development and implementation documentation required by (2)(b); filed the policy with utah's division of consumer protection; and complied with the filed policy at the time of the alleged violation. chatbot mental health safety policy safe harbor filing hb452"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Dentacor — §58-69-5 Enforcement Forborne","id":"dentacor-58-69-5-enforcement-forborne","href":"primary/dentacor-58-69-5-enforcement-forborne/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"dentacor — §58-69-5 enforcement forborne dentacor-58-69-5-enforcement-forborne permission during the dentacor demonstration period, the utah division of professional licensing (dopl) forgave enforcement of unlawful and unprofessional-conduct actions under utah code §58-69-5 solely for conduct authorized by the rma. the initial mitigation period ended may 31, 2026, and no public extension instrument was located as of july 25, 2026. dentacor enforcement 58-69-5 unlawful conduct forbearance"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Dentacor — Hygienist + AI Concurrence Diagnosis","id":"dentacor-hygienist-ai-concurrence-diagnosis","href":"primary/dentacor-hygienist-ai-concurrence-diagnosis/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"dentacor — hygienist + ai concurrence diagnosis dentacor-hygienist-ai-concurrence-diagnosis permission during the initial dentacor rma term, licensed utah dental hygienists employed by dentacor could diagnose periodontal disease, complete edentulism, and complete anodontia using an ai-assisted radiograph diagnostic tool in place of general dentist supervision. the permission required concurrence of both the hygienist and the ai system and expired with the initial mitigation period on may 31, 2026; no public extension instrument was located as of july 25, 2026. dentacor hygienist radiograph diagnosis ai concurrence"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Dentacor — Informed Consent Disclosing Absence Of Dentist","id":"dentacor-informed-consent-no-dentist","href":"primary/dentacor-informed-consent-no-dentist/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"dentacor — informed consent disclosing absence of dentist dentacor-informed-consent-no-dentist requirement during the initial dentacor rma term, a dentacor-employed hygienist had to obtain patient informed consent before any rma-authorized procedure, explicitly disclosing the absence of dentist supervision and the hygienist's narrower training and scope. the requirement expired with the initial mitigation period on may 31, 2026; no public extension instrument was located as of july 25, 2026. dentacor informed consent dentist supervision patient disclosure"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Proactive GenAI Disclosure In High-Risk Interactions","id":"disclose-genai-high-risk-proactive","href":"primary/disclose-genai-high-risk-proactive/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"proactive genai disclosure in high-risk interactions disclose-genai-high-risk-proactive requirement a supplier engaged in a \"high-risk ai interaction\" in a regulated occupation must proactively disclose genai use before the interaction begins — verbally at the start of an oral exchange, and in writing before a written exchange. the high-risk tier is statutorily defined and narrower than general consumer interactions. disclosure high-risk regulated occupation proactive sb226"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Disclose GenAI on First Session","id":"disclose-genai-on-first-session","href":"primary/disclose-genai-on-first-session/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"disclose genai on first session disclose-genai-on-first-session requirement disclose plainly that the person is interacting with generative ai and not a human. when the disclosure is due depends on the utah provision: on a clear request in a consumer transaction (§13-75-103(1)); at the start of a high-risk interaction in a regulated occupation (§13-75-103(2)-(3)); and for a mental health chatbot, before access, again after seven days without access, and whenever asked (§13-72a-203(2)). no utah provision anchored here requires re-display at every session or after a fixed inactivity period. disclosure genai first session chatbot"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Disclose GenAI On Consumer Request","id":"disclose-genai-on-request","href":"primary/disclose-genai-on-request/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"disclose genai on consumer request disclose-genai-on-request requirement a supplier using generative ai in a consumer transaction must disclose that fact when the consumer makes a clear and unambiguous request. a safe harbor is available: a clear and conspicuous disclosure at the outset and throughout the interaction eliminates enforcement exposure, regardless of whether a request is made. disclosure genai consumer request safe harbor sb226"},{"type":"obligation","name":"ElizaChat — Three-Phase Rollout Gate","id":"elizachat-phased-rollout","href":"primary/elizachat-phased-rollout/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"elizachat — three-phase rollout gate elizachat-phased-rollout requirement elizachat must be released in three sequential phases — oaip trusted-tester cohort, oaip-reviewed limited student cohort, and full utah-district student availability — with written oaip approval required before advancing to each subsequent phase. elizachat phased rollout trusted tester phase gate"},{"type":"obligation","name":"ElizaChat — Pre-Access Disclosure Bundle","id":"elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle","href":"primary/elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"elizachat — pre-access disclosure bundle elizachat-pre-access-disclosure-bundle requirement before granting any user access to elizachat app functionality, the participant must present a five-element disclosure — participant identity, genai use notice, testing-risk notice, data use and sharing practices, and oaip complaint channel — in clear and conspicuous form, and must secure user acknowledgment before access is granted. elizachat disclosure pre-access disclosure bundle"},{"type":"obligation","name":"High-Risk AI Consumer Notice, Correction, And Appeal","id":"high-risk-ai-consumer-notice-correction-and-appeal","href":"primary/high-risk-ai-consumer-notice-correction-and-appeal/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"high-risk ai consumer notice, correction, and appeal high-risk-ai-consumer-notice-correction-and-appeal requirement deployers would have been required to notify consumers before using a high-risk artificial intelligence system in a consequential decision and, after an adverse decision, provide the principal reasons, an opportunity to correct incorrect personal data, and an appeal with human review where technically feasible. the obligation is retained from the predecessor colorado sb 24-205 framework. predecessor operative history remains unresolved; sb 26-189 section 5 qualifies replacement timing, and signature alone does not establish when predecessor duties ceased or whether they operated. high-risk artificial intelligence consumer notice adverse consequential decision data correction appeal human review colorado sb24-205"},{"type":"obligation","name":"High-Risk AI Impact Assessment","id":"high-risk-ai-impact-assessment","href":"primary/high-risk-ai-impact-assessment/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"high-risk ai impact assessment high-risk-ai-impact-assessment requirement deployers would have been required to complete an impact assessment for each covered high-risk artificial intelligence system, repeat it at least annually and after intentional and substantial modifications, and retain the assessment records. the obligation is retained from the predecessor colorado sb 24-205 framework. predecessor operative history remains unresolved; sb 26-189 section 5 qualifies replacement timing, and signature alone does not establish when predecessor duties ceased or whether they operated. high-risk artificial intelligence impact assessment annual assessment algorithmic discrimination deployer colorado sb24-205"},{"type":"obligation","name":"High-Risk AI Reasonable Care Against Algorithmic Discrimination","id":"high-risk-ai-reasonable-care-against-algorithmic-discrimination","href":"primary/high-risk-ai-reasonable-care-against-algorithmic-discrimination/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"high-risk ai reasonable care against algorithmic discrimination high-risk-ai-reasonable-care-against-algorithmic-discrimination requirement developers and deployers of high-risk artificial intelligence systems would have been required to use reasonable care to protect consumers from known or reasonably foreseeable risks of algorithmic discrimination. the obligation is retained from the predecessor colorado sb 24-205 framework. predecessor operative history remains unresolved; sb 26-189 section 5 qualifies replacement timing, and signature alone does not establish when predecessor duties ceased or whether they operated. high-risk artificial intelligence reasonable care algorithmic discrimination developer deployer colorado sb24-205"},{"type":"obligation","name":"§501(c)(3) Exemption Denied — Organizational And Operational Test Failure","id":"irs-501c3-dual-test-failure","href":"primary/irs-501c3-dual-test-failure/index.html","group":"restriction","_search":"§501(c)(3) exemption denied — organizational and operational test failure irs-501c3-dual-test-failure restriction an organization fails §501(c)(3) exemption where its articles of incorporation neither limit purposes to exempt activities nor dedicate assets to exempt purposes on dissolution, and where a substantial portion of its activities consists of unrestricted commercial leasing coupled with fundraising that benefits a for-profit entity controlled by one of its own directors. bylaws containing the required provisions do not cure deficient articles; a single substantial non-exempt purpose is disqualifying regardless of any exempt purposes present. 501c3 organizational test operational test private inurement commercial leasing adverse determination"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Incentive-Fee Management Contract Not A Share Of Net Profits","id":"irs-incentive-fee-not-net-profits-share","href":"primary/irs-incentive-fee-not-net-profits-share/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"incentive-fee management contract not a share of net profits irs-incentive-fee-not-net-profits-share permission on the facts represented, an incentive-fee management contract between a §501(c)(3) bond issuer and a hotel manager — where the incentive fee is calculated on gross revenue subject to an adjustment contingent on a net-profit-variant metric — does not constitute sharing of net profits under rev. proc. 2017-13 §5.02(2) and therefore does not cause private business use under irc §141. the ruling applies only to the requesting taxpayer on the specific facts presented. private business use 501c3 bonds rev proc 2017-13 safe harbor incentive fee"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Learning Lab Agreement — Eligibility and Participation","id":"learning-lab-agreement-participation","href":"primary/learning-lab-agreement-participation/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"learning lab agreement — eligibility and participation learning-lab-agreement-participation permission a person deploying ai in utah may enter either a regulatory mitigation agreement (rma) — which waives specified law in exchange for safeguards, data sharing, and disclosures — or a joint interpretation agreement (jia) — which clarifies how existing statute applies to a specific ai use without waiver. agreements run for an initial twelve months with up to two twelve-month extensions, counterparties include oaip plus the relevant state agency (or the judiciary, a state-funded higher or public education institution, or a political subdivision under hb 320), and participants must satisfy five statutory eligibility prongs. learning lab regulatory mitigation joint interpretation oaip sandbox sb149 hb320"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Named-Prescriber Enforcement Forborne","id":"named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne","href":"primary/named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"named-prescriber enforcement forborne named-prescriber-enforcement-forborne permission dopl forgoes unlawful-conduct and unprofessional-conduct enforcement under §58-1-501(1)-(2) and related professional-licensing provisions against any provider who (1) acts solely as the named prescriber for ai-authorized renewals and (2) does not interact directly with a patient or other provider. legion §16(d) adds a condition that the provider abides by the agreement and any agreement with the participant; doctronic §15(d) states no such condition. the covered chapter provisions differ by agreement. forbearance applies only to conduct authorized by the agreement. named prescriber enforcement forbearance unprofessional conduct 58-1-501 doctronic legion"},{"type":"obligation","name":"RMA — Data Security Under §63A-19-102","id":"rma-data-security-63a-19-102","href":"primary/rma-data-security-63a-19-102/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"rma — data security under §63a-19-102 rma-data-security-63a-19-102 requirement an rma participant must implement data security measures conforming to utah code §63a-19-102 and maintain a cybersecurity framework that is updated on an ongoing basis to address emerging threats and vulnerabilities. no statutory or common-law cybersecurity obligation is waived by the rma. rma data security cybersecurity 63a-19-102"},{"type":"obligation","name":"RMA — 30-Day End-Of-Term Report","id":"rma-end-of-term-report","href":"primary/rma-end-of-term-report/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"rma — 30-day end-of-term report rma-end-of-term-report requirement within thirty days after the end date of an rma, the participant must file a written report with oaip summarizing the demonstration, any incidents of harm, any legal actions, and any complaints filed against the participant in connection with the mitigation period. rma reporting termination end of term"},{"type":"obligation","name":"RMA — Hold Harmless The State","id":"rma-hold-harmless-state","href":"primary/rma-hold-harmless-state/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"rma — hold harmless the state rma-hold-harmless-state requirement an rma participant agrees to hold oaip, the relevant division, and their agents, officers, and employees harmless from any claims, liabilities, damages, losses, or expenses arising from the participant's work performed under the mitigation. rma indemnification hold harmless"},{"type":"obligation","name":"RMA — 24-Hour Incident Notification","id":"rma-incident-notification-24hr","href":"primary/rma-incident-notification-24hr/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"rma — 24-hour incident notification rma-incident-notification-24hr requirement an rma participant must notify oaip within 24 hours of any incident that results in harm to the health, safety, or financial well-being of a user of the mitigated technology. rma incident notification harm 24 hours"},{"type":"obligation","name":"RMA — Monthly Report To OAIP","id":"rma-monthly-report-to-oaip","href":"primary/rma-monthly-report-to-oaip/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"rma — monthly report to oaip rma-monthly-report-to-oaip requirement each learning lab rma participant submits a monthly report to oaip at `ai@utah.gov` covering user data, incidents, complaints, research findings, and any other information specified by the office. the report is the primary ongoing accountability mechanism between participant and regulator during the mitigation period. rma reporting monthly oaip learning lab"},{"type":"obligation","name":"RMA — No Advertising Reference To Agreement","id":"rma-no-advertising-reference","href":"primary/rma-no-advertising-reference/index.html","group":"restriction","_search":"rma — no advertising reference to agreement rma-no-advertising-reference restriction an rma participant may not reference the existence of the agreement in advertising, media, or promotional materials. the mitigation is a regulatory posture, not a marketable endorsement by the state of utah. rma advertising promotion marketing"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Rule 506(c) Verification Via High-Minimum + Representation","id":"sec-reg-d-506c-verification-safe-harbor","href":"primary/sec-reg-d-506c-verification-safe-harbor/index.html","group":"permission","_search":"rule 506(c) verification via high-minimum + representation sec-reg-d-506c-verification-safe-harbor permission an issuer conducting a rule 506(c) offering satisfies the \"reasonable steps to verify\" accredited-investor requirement when it (1) imposes a minimum investment amount high enough that only accredited investors would reasonably be expected to meet it, (2) obtains written representations of accredited status and that the investment is not financed by a third party for purposes of the investment, and (3) has no actual knowledge of contradictory facts. the position restates the principles-based standard; it does not create an exclusive verification method. rule 506c accredited investor reasonable steps to verify regulation d private placement"},{"type":"obligation","name":"Telehealth Compliance Anchored To Participant Proposal","id":"telehealth-compliance-per-proposal","href":"primary/telehealth-compliance-per-proposal/index.html","group":"requirement","_search":"telehealth compliance anchored to participant proposal telehealth-compliance-per-proposal requirement a participant operating ai-assisted prescription renewal must adhere to utah's telehealth provider requirements in §26b-4-704, with specific subsections deemed satisfied by following protocols described in the participant's proposal (schedule b): doctronic parts 2b and 3b; legion proposal section 4. certain subsections (e.g., the patient-records portability default) are inapplicable; others are substituted by proposal-section conformance. telehealth 26b-4-704 proposal compliance doctronic legion"},{"type":"authority","name":"Consumer Financial Protection Bureau","id":"cfpb","href":"authority/cfpb/index.html","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"consumer financial protection bureau cfpb us"},{"type":"authority","name":"CFTC Division of Swap Dealer and Intermediary Oversight","id":"cftc-dsio","href":"authority/cftc-dsio/index.html","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"cftc division of swap dealer and intermediary oversight cftc-dsio us"},{"type":"authority","name":"Colorado General Assembly","id":"colorado-legislature","href":"authority/colorado-legislature/index.html","jurisdiction":"us-co","_search":"colorado general assembly colorado-legislature us-co"},{"type":"authority","name":"IRS Office of Chief Counsel","id":"irs-chief-counsel","href":"authority/irs-chief-counsel/index.html","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"irs office of chief counsel irs-chief-counsel us"},{"type":"authority","name":"IRS Tax Exempt and Government Entities Division","id":"irs-tege","href":"authority/irs-tege/index.html","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"irs tax exempt and government entities division irs-tege us"},{"type":"authority","name":"SEC Division of Corporation Finance","id":"sec-corpfin","href":"authority/sec-corpfin/index.html","jurisdiction":"us","_search":"sec division of corporation finance sec-corpfin us"},{"type":"authority","name":"Utah State Legislature","id":"utah-legislature","href":"authority/utah-legislature/index.html","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah state legislature utah-legislature us-ut"},{"type":"authority","name":"Utah Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy","id":"utah-oaip","href":"authority/utah-oaip/index.html","jurisdiction":"us-ut","_search":"utah office of artificial intelligence policy utah-oaip us-ut"}] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/atom.xml b/docs/atom.xml index c8a46b96..14a6a8db 100644 --- a/docs/atom.xml +++ b/docs/atom.xml @@ -5,41 +5,83 @@ https://publedge.org/ - 2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z + 2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z PubLedge - - https://publedge.org/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2025-001/ - Colorado SB 25B-004 (2025) — Increase Transparency for Algorithmic Systems (Colorado AI Act Effective-Date Delay) - - 2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z - Colorado SB 25B-004 (2025) — Increase Transparency for Algorithmic Systems (Colorado AI Act Effective-Date Delay) - - - https://publedge.org/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2024-001/ - Colorado SB 24-205 (2024) — Consumer Protections for Interactions with Artificial Intelligence Systems - - 2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z - Colorado SB 24-205 (2024) — Consumer Protections for Interactions with Artificial Intelligence Systems - https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2024-001/ Utah SB 149 (2024) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments - 2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z + 2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z Utah SB 149 (2024) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-002/ - Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations + Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots) - 2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z - Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations + 2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z + Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots) + + + https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-001/ + Utah SB 226 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments + + 2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z + Utah SB 226 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments + + + https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-003/ + Utah SB 332 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Revisions (AIPA Sunset Extension) + + 2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z + Utah SB 332 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Revisions (AIPA Sunset Extension) + + + https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2026-001/ + Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements) + + 2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z + Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements) + + + https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/jia/2026-001/ + Utah Mental Health Chatbot Disclosure — Joint Interpretation + + 2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z + Utah Mental Health Chatbot Disclosure — Joint Interpretation + + + https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2024-001/ + Utah OAIP × ElizaChat — Teen Mental-Health App RMA (2024) + + 2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z + Utah OAIP × ElizaChat — Teen Mental-Health App RMA (2024) https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2025-002/ Utah OAIP × Doctronic — AI Prescription Renewal RMA (2025) - 2026-09-12T00:00:00.000Z + 2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z Utah OAIP × Doctronic — AI Prescription Renewal RMA (2025) + + https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2026-001/ + Utah OAIP × Legion Health — AI Maintenance Psychiatric Refill RMA (2026) + + 2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z + Utah OAIP × Legion Health — AI Maintenance Psychiatric Refill RMA (2026) + + + https://publedge.org/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2025-001/ + Colorado SB 25B-004 (2025) — Increase Transparency for Algorithmic Systems (Colorado AI Act Effective-Date Delay) + + 2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z + Colorado SB 25B-004 (2025) — Increase Transparency for Algorithmic Systems (Colorado AI Act Effective-Date Delay) + + + https://publedge.org/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2024-001/ + Colorado SB 24-205 (2024) — Consumer Protections for Interactions with Artificial Intelligence Systems + + 2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z + Colorado SB 24-205 (2024) — Consumer Protections for Interactions with Artificial Intelligence Systems + diff --git a/docs/calendar.ics b/docs/calendar.ics index 56dfdc95..b9b33fc5 100644 --- a/docs/calendar.ics +++ b/docs/calendar.ics @@ -7,7 +7,7 @@ X-WR-CALNAME:PubLedge Enforcement Calendar X-WR-CALDESC:Key dates for every record in the PubLedge registry. BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-cfpb-ao-2022-001-effective@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20220629 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20220629 SUMMARY:Effective: CFPB Advisory Opinion — Pay-to-Pay Fees (Regulation F) @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/federal/cfpb/ao/2022-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-cftc-dsio-il-2017-001-effective@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20171211 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20171211 SUMMARY:Effective: CFTC Letter 17-65 — CTA Registration Exemption Survives MiFID II Fee Unbundling @@ -25,7 +25,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/federal/cftc-dsio/il/2017-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-co-legislature-statute-2024-sb24-205-enacted@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20240517 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20240517 SUMMARY:Enacted: Colorado SB 24-205 (2024) — Consumer Protections for Interactions with Artificial Intelligence Systems @@ -34,7 +34,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2024-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-co-legislature-statute-2024-sb24-205-effective@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20260630 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20260630 SUMMARY:Effective: Colorado SB 24-205 (2024) — Consumer Protections for Interactions with Artificial Intelligence Systems @@ -43,7 +43,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2024-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-co-legislature-statute-2025-sb25b-004-enacted@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20250828 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20250828 SUMMARY:Enacted: Colorado SB 25B-004 (2025) — Increase Transparency for Algorithmic Systems (Colorado AI Act Effective-Date Delay) @@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2025-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-co-legislature-statute-2025-sb25b-004-effective@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20251125 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20251125 SUMMARY:Effective: Colorado SB 25B-004 (2025) — Increase Transparency for Algorithmic Systems (Colorado AI Act Effective-Date Delay) @@ -61,7 +61,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2025-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-co-legislature-statute-2026-sb26-189-enacted@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20260514 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20260514 SUMMARY:Enacted: Colorado SB 26-189 (2026) — Automated Decision-Making Technology (ADMT) Act @@ -70,7 +70,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2026-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-co-legislature-statute-2026-sb26-189-effective@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20270101 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20270101 SUMMARY:Effective: Colorado SB 26-189 (2026) — Automated Decision-Making Technology (ADMT) Act @@ -79,7 +79,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/colorado/legislature/statute/2026-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-irs-chief-counsel-plr-2025-001-effective@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20250207 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20250207 SUMMARY:Effective: IRS Private Letter Ruling 202506001 — Management Contract Private Business Use (§141) @@ -88,7 +88,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/federal/irs-chief-counsel/plr/2025-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-irs-tege-plr-2026-001-effective@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20260112 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20260112 SUMMARY:Effective: IRS PLR 202614036 — Adverse Determination: §501(c)(3) Exemption Denied\, Mixed-Use Facility @@ -97,7 +97,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/federal/irs-tege/plr/2026-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-sec-corpfin-nal-2025-001-effective@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20250312 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20250312 SUMMARY:Effective: SEC No-Action Letter — Latham & Watkins (Rule 506(c) Verification) @@ -106,7 +106,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/federal/sec-corpfin/nal/2025-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149-enacted@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20240313 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20240313 SUMMARY:Enacted: Utah SB 149 (2024) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments @@ -115,7 +115,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2024-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-legislature-statute-2024-sb149-effective@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20240501 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20240501 SUMMARY:Effective: Utah SB 149 (2024) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments @@ -124,25 +124,25 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2024-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452-enacted@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20250326 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20250326 -SUMMARY:Enacted: Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations -DESCRIPTION:Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations — enacted. https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-002/ +SUMMARY:Enacted: Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots) +DESCRIPTION:Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots) — enacted. https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-002/ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-002/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-hb452-effective@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20250507 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20250507 -SUMMARY:Effective: Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations -DESCRIPTION:Utah HB 452 (2025) — Mental Health Chatbot Regulations — effective. https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-002/ +SUMMARY:Effective: Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots) +DESCRIPTION:Utah HB 452 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Amendments (Mental Health Chatbots) — effective. https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-002/ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-002/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226-enacted@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20250325 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20250325 SUMMARY:Enacted: Utah SB 226 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments @@ -151,7 +151,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb226-effective@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20250507 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20250507 SUMMARY:Effective: Utah SB 226 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Consumer Protection Amendments @@ -160,7 +160,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332-enacted@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20250325 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20250325 SUMMARY:Enacted: Utah SB 332 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Revisions (AIPA Sunset Extension) @@ -169,7 +169,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-003/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-legislature-statute-2025-sb332-effective@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20250507 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20250507 SUMMARY:Effective: Utah SB 332 (2025) — Artificial Intelligence Revisions (AIPA Sunset Extension) @@ -178,25 +178,25 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2025-003/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320-enacted@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20260319 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20260319 -SUMMARY:Enacted: Utah HB 320 (2026) — AI Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements -DESCRIPTION:Utah HB 320 (2026) — AI Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements — enacted. https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2026-001/ +SUMMARY:Enacted: Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements) +DESCRIPTION:Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements) — enacted. https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2026-001/ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2026-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-legislature-statute-2026-hb320-effective@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20260506 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20260506 -SUMMARY:Effective: Utah HB 320 (2026) — AI Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements -DESCRIPTION:Utah HB 320 (2026) — AI Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements — effective. https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2026-001/ +SUMMARY:Effective: Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements) +DESCRIPTION:Utah HB 320 (2026) — Office of Artificial Intelligence Policy Amendments (Learning Lab Restructure + Joint Interpretation Agreements) — effective. https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2026-001/ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/legislature/statute/2026-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-effective@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20241118 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20241118 SUMMARY:Effective: Utah OAIP × ElizaChat — Teen Mental-Health App RMA (2024) @@ -205,7 +205,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2024-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-term-start@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20241118 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20241118 SUMMARY:Term Start: Utah OAIP × ElizaChat — Teen Mental-Health App RMA (2024) @@ -214,7 +214,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2024-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-oaip-rma-2024-001-term-end@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20251118 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20251118 SUMMARY:Term End: Utah OAIP × ElizaChat — Teen Mental-Health App RMA (2024) @@ -223,7 +223,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2024-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-001-effective@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20250531 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20250531 SUMMARY:Effective: Utah OAIP × Dentacor — AI-Assisted Dental Radiograph Diagnosis RMA (2025) @@ -232,7 +232,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2025-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-001-term-start@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20250531 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20250531 SUMMARY:Term Start: Utah OAIP × Dentacor — AI-Assisted Dental Radiograph Diagnosis RMA (2025) @@ -241,7 +241,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2025-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-001-term-end@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20260531 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20260531 SUMMARY:Term End: Utah OAIP × Dentacor — AI-Assisted Dental Radiograph Diagnosis RMA (2025) @@ -250,7 +250,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2025-001/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-effective@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20251024 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20251024 SUMMARY:Effective: Utah OAIP × Doctronic — AI Prescription Renewal RMA (2025) @@ -259,7 +259,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2025-002/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-term-start@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20251024 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20251024 SUMMARY:Term Start: Utah OAIP × Doctronic — AI Prescription Renewal RMA (2025) @@ -268,7 +268,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2025-002/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-oaip-rma-2025-002-term-end@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20261024 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20261024 SUMMARY:Term End: Utah OAIP × Doctronic — AI Prescription Renewal RMA (2025) @@ -277,7 +277,7 @@ URL:https://publedge.org/us/utah/oaip/rma/2025-002/ END:VEVENT BEGIN:VEVENT UID:us-ut-oaip-rma-2026-001-enacted@publedge.org -DTSTAMP:20260912T000000Z +DTSTAMP:20260923T000000Z DTSTART;VALUE=DATE:20260319 DTEND;VALUE=DATE:20260319 SUMMARY:Enacted: Utah OAIP × Legion Health — AI Maintenance Psychiatric Refill RMA (2026) diff --git a/docs/compare.html b/docs/compare.html index b3fbbdb7..50bc7bd3 100644 --- a/docs/compare.html +++ b/docs/compare.html @@ -112,19 +112,19 @@

Compare Legal Instruments

- + - +
-

Comparisons with shared obligations

+

Comparisons with shared obligations

+ + + + + + + + + +