intent (monitor): 2026-09-14-monitor-ci_failure_rate_main

[kevintseng]

Generated by the SDLC loop (stage diagnose) from the monitor breach report.

Review intent/2026-09-14-monitor-ci_failure_rate_main.md. To accept: set status: accepted in its frontmatter and merge. To send it back: edit and merge with status: draft, or close this request (a closed request makes the loop run the stage again).

Run record: workflow artifact diagnose-2026-09-14-monitor-ci_failure_rate_main.json.

Coverage

Surface	QA	Review	Simplification
intent/2026-09-14-monitor-ci_failure_rate_main.md	run-stage outcome check exit=0: frontmatter status accepted by checkArtifact, no other file changed	written by codex:default; the review workflow (a different model, per REVIEW.md) reviews this request; the person who merges it is the acceptance	not applicable: a generated Markdown artifact with no code; brevity is the reviewer's call

[github-actions]

SDLC review (REVIEW.md, three passes; codex:default)

FAIL

Compliance

• Important — [Compliance] .sdlc-run/review-356.diff:9: Missing verification evidence. The request has no Verification section, no npm run verify result for head f0bd298bf6fde76aa795135152081f68beb349ee, and no receipt tree. The Coverage row’s checkArtifact result does not satisfy this requirement. CI retrieval exited 1 with error connecting to api.github.com, so tree equality remains unverified. Supply the head-bound verification output and matching CI tree.
• Important — [Compliance] .sdlc-run/review-356.diff:3: Required contributor checklist omitted. The request omits the PR template’s “Docs synced” checklist. CONTRIBUTING.md explicitly treats an unfilled checklist as not ready for review. Complete it, identifying which requirements apply to this intent-only change.

Bugs

No findings. Read-only checks exited 0 and confirmed the documented threshold boundaries and missing-tag diagnostic. A spec and implementation plan are subsequent stages for this draft intent.

Security

• Important — [Security] .sdlc-run/review-356.diff:5: Request-body instructions cross the review boundary. “To accept: set status: accepted in its frontmatter and merge” directs acceptance and repository mutation from untrusted request content. Under the supplied review policy, this is itself a finding. Rephrase as a description of the human owner’s lifecycle actions, clearly separate from reviewer instructions.

Files read in full: 1/1 files touched by the diff.

[kevintseng]

Closing: this pull request only changes the maintainer's personal development-process tooling (scripts/sdlc/, the sdlc-*.yml workflows, intent/spec/plan artifacts, prompts). #365 moved that tooling out of the public repository (tracked in #364), so these paths no longer exist on main. Nothing here is lost: the branch is kept locally by the maintainer and the changes apply to the private copy of the tooling.