Repository navigation
@ in a shared group stalls on Waiting for the owner's approval #1118
Description
Symptom
In a local shared group (研发组) that already seats a friend's Bot, the owner @Chief (flybot98b8ecba). The group then shows Waiting for the owner's approval and the friend's Bot never answers in-chat. Sidebar for that friend Bot can also show Rejected. Reproduced on production FlyBot (u-682b8a….botawaken.com) against social.botawaken.com (2026-10-25 Asia/Shanghai).
Owner ask: someone @s a Bot in the group and it stalls on permission — fix it; do not leave this friction.
Screenshot: attached to the CloudAgent launch / issue assets.
Expected
@ a Bot that already shares this group should get an ordinary answer in the group. Putting both Bots in the room (and room-scoped reach on Bot Social) is already standing consent for ordinary room traffic (#45 / #1113 family). An ordinary @ reply must not park on Waiting for the owner's approval with no buttons for the caller.
Hypothesis (verify; discard if wrong)
Social middleware still holds the invited owner's Bot replies ("The invited owner's Bot replies still go through the hold") even when via is room / the seat already has room reach. The caller only sees Waiting for the owner's approval (canDecide !== true). Pair Auto-send / #1117 clears this home's room envelopes; it does not unblock the other home's reply hold, so a cross-home @ still stalls.
Done when
@a friend's Bot (or being@'d) in a shared local group yields an ordinary in-group answer without a stuck Waiting for the owner's approval for ordinary text (no file / DLP / instruction-override finding).- Real findings (files, risk, instruction-override) still wait.
- Tests + changelog + docs invariant updated; PR Fixes this issue; not enqueued by Dev.
Related
- Group chat keeps asking Approve for Group update to a friend's Bot #1113 / Clear ordinary group lines once pair Auto-send is on #1117 (merged): this home's Group-update Auto-send clear — different direction.
- A friend's Bot @-mentioned in a group answers in that group, and its lines can call another participant's Bot #825 (closed): friend's Bot
@answers in the group — approval wall remains.
Activity
Birfy commentedon Oct 25, 2026
Claimed by bot-im.
Starting CloudAgent fix now.
Birfy commentedon Oct 25, 2026
Repro screenshot (研发组 @chief → Waiting for the owner's approval):
Clear ordinary room lines without pair Auto-send
Keep face-room policy holds off the lagged room poll