Skip to content

research(track-a): classify writer vtable group - #305

Closed
blakinio wants to merge 8 commits into
mainfrom
research/OTC-20260815-track-a-p2-writer-vtable-group
Closed

research(track-a): classify writer vtable group#305
blakinio wants to merge 8 commits into
mainfrom
research/OTC-20260815-track-a-p2-writer-vtable-group

Conversation

@blakinio

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Draft-only Track A P2 research dispatch from exact main@8fca1c3eee453d0d4ef8a47e0f15c9dbae491b45.

Hypothesis: classify 0x2f69e30 / RTTI 0x3080748 as a structurally emitted address point within the canonical TProtocolWriter vtable group and determine whether its exact type/method boundary narrows writer transformation/framing order.

This task explicitly does not duplicate queued final-socket run 31825417040, generic QIODevice enumeration, or superseded 0xb5b880 / disproven 0xb46bd0 models. It consumes only reviewed exact-build text artifacts and current canonical #299/#301 evidence.

Research output remains Draft-only. Promotion authority is coordinator PR #300. No proprietary client bytes, credentials or account state may be committed/uploaded.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Research handoff complete for exact final Draft head 9329e338235b7f9997d74d4db5313f329662378b.

Validation: task-specific exact-head run 31884379539 / job 95011421555 = SUCCESS; final standard PR CI 31884381191, including CI / Required, = SUCCESS; changed paths remain confined to declared task roots; review threads = 0.

FACT: 0x2f69e30 is a distinct normal Itanium address point with offset-to-top=0, own typeinfo 0x3080748, first targets 0x7de7f0/0x7dfd60, and a separately allocated retained object receives this vptr. Typeinfo differs from canonical TProtocolWriter RTTI 0x3080728 and TIODeviceWriter RTTI 0x3080718.

DISPROVEN: the simple interpretation that 0x2f69e30 is merely a secondary/base address point of canonical TProtocolWriter based on adjacency.

INFERENCE: 0x7de7f0/0x7dfd60 are teardown-like from exact cleanup behavior.

UNKNOWN: semantic name/base relation for RTTI 0x3080748, first writer transform/framing boundary, gameplay framing order, final binary egress, and relationship of historical 0x3084c70/+0xd0 -> 0xb40630 family to the canonical writer branch.

Researcher proposal: ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS as bounded negative/type-structure evidence. P2 remains incomplete. Task is ready; ownership is released for independent coordinator review.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Coordinator disposition for exact final Draft head 9329e338235b7f9997d74d4db5313f329662378b: ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS.

Independent review confirms final task-specific exact-head run 31884379539 / job 95011421555 = SUCCESS; final standard PR CI 31884381191, including CI / Required, = SUCCESS; changed paths are confined to declared task roots; review threads = 0; all three reviewed historical source artifacts are digest-fenced before parsing.

FACT — accepted bounded type structure: 0x2f69e30 is a normal Itanium-style address point with offset-to-top=0, distinct typeinfo 0x3080748, first targets 0x7de7f0/0x7dfd60, and a separately allocated retained object receives this vptr. Typeinfo differs from canonical TProtocolWriter RTTI 0x3080728 and TIODeviceWriter RTTI 0x3080718.

DISPROVEN — accepted: address adjacency is insufficient to treat 0x2f69e30 as merely a secondary/base address point of canonical TProtocolWriter; distinct typeinfo plus separate object provenance reject that collapse.

INFERENCE — accepted with label: 0x7de7f0/0x7dfd60 are teardown-like from exact vptr-install/cleanup behavior.

UNKNOWN — preserved: semantic name/base relation for RTTI 0x3080748; first writer transform/framing boundary; gameplay framing order; final binary egress; relationship of historical 0x3084c70/+0xd0 -> 0xb40630 family to the canonical writer branch. The accepted #301 retention relation remains valid; the intermediate object is now structurally typed but semantically unnamed.

This slice improves P2 structural truth but does not close P2. I will promote exact reviewed source blobs under coordinator-owned evidence, validate the coordinator head, and close #305 unmerged.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Lifecycle closeout after coordinator promotion: exact source head 9329e338235b7f9997d74d4db5313f329662378b received ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS; exact reviewed source blobs are preserved under coordinator PR #300 at docs/agents/evidence/OTC-20260815-track-a-promotion-coordination/p2-writer-vtable-group/source-snapshot/; coordinator integration head 0ade6404c5b43f5fe468b8dd748846406d4c856e passed required CI run 31884644268. Closing this Draft unmerged so the accepted bounded type/provenance evidence has one promotion authority. P2 remains incomplete.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant