research(track-a): recover world minimap static semantics

[blakinio]

Terminal source disposition — 2026-08-19

CLOSED UNMERGED AS SUPERSEDED.

This Draft was the bounded source researcher package for TIBIA-RE-WORLD-MINIMAP / OTC-20260819-track-a-world-minimap-static-g0.

Source exact head 55034d31a3cfd55c597f463c97ebf97065192c8b passed:

• Track A governance 32194785639 = SUCCESS;
• CI 32194785866 = SUCCESS;
• changed paths = exactly 3 source task/report/evidence paths;
• review threads = 0.

Fresh independent coordinator audit review 4969045959 classified the source ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS and found one material evidence defect:

WM-MINIMAP-AUD-001 — the producer's relative jump-table heuristic does not prove its emitted per-method target=... direct=true addresses. The retained artifact gives identical reported targets to unrelated metaobjects, so those per-method destinations are not admissible exact code-entry facts.

Corrected promotion PR #551 independently revalidated artifact 9345368809 (ZIP SHA-256 c3c32ad9ce527e5ff7d469ae41914f3802fb55d465a993c8dbb32be2840e9755), preserved exact public-package/QMeta/class-method/string evidence, rejected the target-address claims, kept F11/F12 as bounded static PARTIAL, F13 as PARTIAL, and left F08/F10 blocked. PR #536 shared matrix paths were not modified.

Promotion #551 exact head a86713c0f79190710cd437ed3b550ccaf7652436 passed CI 32223365501 = SUCCESS, promotion review 4969069217 reported 0 open material findings, and #551 squash-merged as 6071b237d70a11ab10e5050cc23730162b0e7e0b.

This source Draft must not be merged after its corrected promotion has landed. No runtime/login/credentials/gameplay/client mutation occurred in the source or promotion; E2E is NOT_APPLICABLE for this runtime_access:none static slice.

[blakinio]

Fresh independent coordinator audit on exact source head 55034d31a3cfd55c597f463c97ebf97065192c8b.

Classification: ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS for the bounded static F11/F12/F13 package; source Draft must not merge as-is.

Independent evidence checks:

• downloaded workflow artifact 9345368809; local SHA-256 exactly c3c32ad9ce527e5ff7d469ae41914f3802fb55d465a993c8dbb32be2840e9755, matching GitHub artifact digest;
• artifact contains exactly fence.txt, minimap-qmeta.txt, minimap-strings.txt; no raw client binary;
• fence values match the retained current public package fingerprint: packed 1fc26d66..., unpacked ed5469b9..., size 52109920, CURRENT_PACKAGE_FENCE=PASS;
• raw QMeta/string evidence independently supports the dedicated class/method ownership and persistence/action-name surfaces needed to move F11/F12 from NOT_STARTED to bounded static PARTIAL; F13 remains PARTIAL.

Material finding WM-MINIMAP-AUD-001 (MEDIUM, high confidence): the producer's jump-table heuristic does not prove the emitted target=... direct=true addresses. It selects a candidate table whenever all computed entries are executable, but unrelated metaobjects receive identical targets. Examples from the retained artifact: TMinimapMarkerStorage methods 0..4 and TMinimapTileStorage methods 0..4 map to the same five addresses; TMinimapVisibleArea::restoreZoomLevelFromOptions, TMinimapProtocolMessageHandler::handleCyclopediaMapDataMessage, and TMinimapTileManager::{publishGameAction,handleGameAction} all map to 0xde15a0. Those coincidences falsify the claim that these are exact per-method static-metacall destinations.

Required edit before promotion: retain class/method names, QMeta/static-metacall ownership, strings, package fence and conservative F11/F12/F13 status; remove or explicitly downgrade all per-method target addresses/directness as heuristic-unverified. Do not promote formulas/data layout/runtime semantics. F08/F10 stay blocked and #536 remains untouched.

Open material findings after source review: 1 until corrected promotion is produced. E2E remains NOT_APPLICABLE for this static runtime_access:none slice.