docs(agents): close Surveyor next-gap alias publication - #657
Conversation
blakinio
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
PASS_ZERO_MATERIAL_FINDINGS
Fresh independent closeout audit exact head: dad600df1ad3092836e1ca056bd786a08f090884
Trusted base/main: 84bf145ce3abe81a7a2378c3c5c75345e6bae75b
Verified:
- effective diff is exactly two lifecycle paths: the active task record is deleted and the matching archive record is added; no prompt, product, workflow, or runtime file is changed;
- archive state is
status: completed,phase: archived,runtime_access: none,owned_paths: [],ownership_released: true; runtime/login/gameplay/credential/process-control/mutation authority remains false orNOT_APPLICABLE; - implementation PR #656 is merged from exact head
3275bed7953eef83db8d0cb7c576ef9efff68195as84bf145ce3abe81a7a2378c3c5c75345e6bae75b; - implementation CI
32516770876and Track A governance32516770664are exact-head PASS; - independent re-audit
PRR_kwDOTVmdjs8AAAABKdGixwis on exact implementation head and returnsPASS_ZERO_MATERIAL_FINDINGS, explicitly resolvingAUD-656-001,AUD-656-002, andAUD-656-003; - canonical prompt, alias, and prompt-eval paths exist on current
main; the alias resolves exactly to the canonical prompt, and the eval explicitly reports a 16/16 deterministic contract matrix without claiming sampled model-behaviour execution; NOT_APPLICABLE_WITH_REASONis truthful for this documentation-only publication: PR #656 changed exactly four documentation/evidence/task paths and this closeout changes only the two lifecycle task-record paths; future typed-reader implementations still require their own real physical E2E;- closeout exact-head CI
32517203310PASS and Track A governance32517202982PASS; - unresolved review threads:
0at audit time; - no full-Surveyor completion is claimed: historical
169 / 12 / 8is explicitly checkpoint evidence only and the future worker must recompute live state.
Verdict: PASS_ZERO_MATERIAL_FINDINGS on exact head dad600df1ad3092836e1ca056bd786a08f090884.
blakinio
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
PASS_PROPORTIONATE_CLOSEOUT_AUDIT
Exact closeout head audited: dad600df1ad3092836e1ca056bd786a08f090884.
This is explicitly a proportionate same-session audit of a trivial documentation-only lifecycle move, not a fresh independent implementation audit. docs/agents/TASK_CLOSEOUT_AUDIT_E2E.md permits proportionate audit for trivial documentation-only closeout work; the material prompt implementation already received fresh independent audit review PRR_kwDOTVmdjs8AAAABKdGixw = PASS_ZERO_MATERIAL_FINDINGS on exact implementation head 3275bed7953eef83db8d0cb7c576ef9efff68195.
Closeout falsification result:
- effective diff is exactly 2 lifecycle paths: delete
docs/agents/tasks/active/OTC-20260821-surveyor-next-gap-alias.md, add matching archive path; - no prompt, alias, eval, product, workflow or runtime code changes are hidden in #657;
- archive says
status: completed,phase: archived,runtime_access: none,owned_paths: [],ownership_released: true; - implementation PR/head/merge are exact: #656 /
3275bed7953eef83db8d0cb7c576ef9efff68195/84bf145ce3abe81a7a2378c3c5c75345e6bae75b; - implementation CI
32516770876PASS and Track A governance32516770664PASS are recorded accurately; - implementation independent audit review and result are recorded accurately, including the resolved AUD-656-001/002/003 history;
- prompt contract v1.1.0, canonical prompt path, alias path, eval path and rollback statement are consistent with merged main;
- E2E
NOT_APPLICABLE_WITH_REASONis truthful for this docs/prompt publication and does not waive physical E2E for future reader slices; - current
mainis still exact implementation merge84bf145ce3abe81a7a2378c3c5c75345e6bae75b, so the closeout base has no drift; - exact closeout-head repository CI run
32517203310PASS and Track A governance run32517202982PASS; - unresolved review threads: 0;
- no authority, lease, credentials, gameplay, process-control or runtime ownership is retained.
Material closeout findings: 0.
Verdict: PASS_PROPORTIONATE_CLOSEOUT_AUDIT for exact head dad600df1ad3092836e1ca056bd786a08f090884.
Terminal lifecycle closeout for
OTC-20260821-surveyor-next-gap-aliasafter implementation PR #656 merged as84bf145ce3abe81a7a2378c3c5c75345e6bae75b.This PR performs only the lifecycle move:
docs/agents/tasks/archive/;The archive records implementation exact head
3275bed7953eef83db8d0cb7c576ef9efff68195, CI32516770876PASS, Track A governance32516770664PASS, fresh independent audit reviewPRR_kwDOTVmdjs8AAAABKdGixw=PASS_ZERO_MATERIAL_FINDINGS, 0 review threads, docs-only E2E classificationNOT_APPLICABLE_WITH_REASON, and released ownership/runtime access none.No product/runtime/prompt content changes are made in this closeout. Merge remains gated on exact-head closeout CI/governance, fresh proportionate closeout audit, zero review threads and normal protected merge.