Repository navigation
chore(bench): record the review-code last-push replacement run - #131
Conversation
One run replaces the saved review-code reviews of the ten re-cut tasks, 30 reviews on Sonnet 5.5, as the owner approved on 2026-10-11. It keeps the saved arm file, skill tree, execution policy and per-attempt bound, and runs on the client the earlier replacement runs used. The files of the pinned skill tree are in the run's inputs. This repository held no object of that tree, so the runner could not extract it. Part of #30. Refs #60.
…eue to a shorter work root
… its cell's result
…ent run The run finished on 2026-10-12 at 06:04 UTC with 31 attempts: 26 valid reviews, four reviews kept after the reviewer ended its session without a result, and one attempt the harness stopped and att-002 replaced. Priced usage is $25.83 of the $60 cap. transcripts.json maps the 31 attempts to their transcript archives. The archives are not in release storage yet, and Git ignores their paths. Part of #30. Refs #60.
The record and the run's README now give the results by task, the five attempts without a result and what was decided for each, the queue's second version, the usage, what the first review showed, the cleanup state and what is not done. The transcript archives are packed for the release evidence-last-push-review-code-transcripts-2026-10-12-v1 and not published. The run is not in the registry, and the four kept stops still carry the cause skill-timeout. Part of #30. Refs #60.
…stock skills, as the saved ones did
…bel the four in the review-code run review_queue.py gains the kept cause reviewer-stop, a reviewer that ended its own session without a result. The four reviews of the review-code last-push run that gave up after one refused command were filed under skill-timeout while the run was frozen, as the owner chose, and now carry the new cause.
kamui
left a comment
kamui
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Changes Requested (advisory) — 1 must-fix finding.
Findings
- [P2] [must-fix] Share the transcript evidence with the run record — anchor
bench/runs/2026-10-12-last-push-claude-review-code-sonnet/transcripts.json:3-6
Reviewed 9be8a11. All 417 changed files accounted for. Reviewed run metadata, prompts, accounting, diagnoses, queue behavior and test coverage; the imported skill was verified by pinned tree and provenance hashes. Required independent verification is complete.
Review details
Intent: Record the last-push review-code replacement run and keep reviewer-stop attempts as cell results.
Issue fit: The scoped contribution to #30 is recorded, with selection and grading left for separate work. The base evidence-sharing requirement remains unmet.
Reviewed: 9be8a11 against merge-base 914a5f5.
Checks:
- Exact-head CI passed, including the changed reviewer-stop test and 919 benchmark tests with 18 skips.
- Read-only checks matched the run counts, $25.826306 total, frozen inputs and 31 pinned packets. A clean-tree transcript collection failed because the new archives are unavailable.
- PR-reported local checks without exact-head logs were not reused as proof.
|
Addressed at
Checks at this clean tracked head: The independent review of this head and the reply drafts completed with no blocking defects or unsupported claims. Updated the PR description for the published manifest and restoration receipt. The thread is resolved, with no remaining feedback or verification gap for this fix. The round is finished. Re-requesting review from @kamui. |
1 participant
Why
Record the 30-cell last-push run of
review-code-sonnet-5-5so #30 can later replace its saved reviews and remove the three matching off-roster built-ins. Share its complete execution evidence through an immutable public release. Selection and grading follow separately.Scope
bench/runs/2026-10-12-last-push-claude-review-code-sonnet/: frozen inputs, provenance, 31 attempts, five diagnoses and transcript mappings.docs/research/last-push-review-code-2026-10-12/: run plan, queue files, accounting and evidence disclosure authorization.bench/tools/review_queue.pyandtest_review_queue.py: accept the kept causereviewer-stop.bench/evidence/manifests/last-push-review-code-transcripts-2026-10-12-v1.json, its restoration receipt and.gitignore: retrieve all 31 exact archives from release storage.Result: 26 valid reviews, four kept stops, 55 comments and $25.83 list price against a $60 cap.
Tradeoffs
The first attempt hit the sandbox socket path limit and was replaced using a shorter work root. Four reviews ended without a result after a command refusal; their stops remain their cell results. Failed evidence and replacement usage are preserved. The client listed 15 stock account skills beside the pinned skill, although none was invoked. The record discloses this clean-context limitation.
Blast Radius
Current grading and the published selection remain unchanged. The queue adds one accepted cause without changing existing verdicts. Preserve branch history because it retains frozen commit
764cd032. Public transcript disclosure, including recorded account metadata and a preview URL, has explicit owner approval.Verification
9a5e436c,bun run verify:importpassed.9a5e436cretrieved all 31 transcripts withtools/collect_run.py; frozen hashes matched.evidence_store.py verifydownloaded the exact published package into an empty temporary directory and verified every member. Restoration receipt.Part of #30