docs(track-a): promote economy panel static census - #547
Conversation
a8a3aa7 to
b6d4a32
Compare
dde33cd to
f691687
Compare
blakinio
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Fresh independent coordinator audit on exact promotion head 6cbfee92ca925a3e8d252c8a9b51f80203f14547.
Classification: ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS -> PASS_AFTER_REPAIR.
Independently verified:
- raw S1 C2S/S2C registries confirm the promoted G24-G31 generated-message names;
- complete
protocol-handler-code-xrefs.tsvconfirms all eight retained xrefs andsemantic_dispatcher_edge_proven=falsefor every row; - source #546 exact task record has the repaired Track A
runtime_access: noneadmission andmutation_authorized: false; - source exact-head governance
32219366592and CI32219366648are SUCCESS; - capability-census provenance at source base
a1368bbecd5b6a6bc2447d2c7debb1141efc2dcb, source head54dca602dfa38f1cc347716cf0f701b22c3fe6e9, and merged PR #293 all identify researched SHAe6c244bd39fe2e0632f6f000efd3147164696efa8e901718668e0442325ff7fe.
Material finding ECON-PROMO-AUD-001: the source/initial promotion claimed a capability-census digest conflict that is not present in the authoritative repository sources. The promotion-owned evidence/report/archive surfaces and PR body now remove that false conflict and retain capability-census UI/controller observations only as same-exact-build static report leads; no live GUI/dispatch/ABI/transaction/server-effect semantics are promoted.
Promotion exact-head CI 32220087932 = SUCCESS. The Track A runtime-governance workflow does not trigger for this promotion diff because its path filter covers active Track A task/runtime-governance surfaces, while #547 changes only promotion evidence/report/archive paths; the source active-task head already has the applicable governance PASS above.
Changed paths remain exactly four promotion-owned documentation/evidence/archive paths. PR #536 shared matrix/checklist is untouched. Runtime E2E = NOT_APPLICABLE for this static promotion (runtime_access: none, physical_e2e_required: false).
Open material findings after repair: 0.
Coordinator promotion result: PASS.
blakinio
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Final fresh coordinator revalidation on exact head f4457058c879d92a466647cf032160b800b6e90c after concurrent closeout-metadata update.
The concurrent commit was re-read rather than overwritten. It preserves the audited correction: ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS, false capability-census digest conflict rejected, same exact researched SHA e6c244bd39fe2e0632f6f000efd3147164696efa8e901718668e0442325ff7fe, static-only UI/controller leads, no live/causal/transaction semantics promoted, source Track A admission repair retained, PR #536 untouched.
Exact-head CI 32220130000 = SUCCESS. Track A runtime-governance workflow is not triggered by the #547 evidence/report/archive path set; applicable source active-task governance remains 32219366592 = SUCCESS on source head 54dca602dfa38f1cc347716cf0f701b22c3fe6e9.
Runtime E2E: NOT_APPLICABLE for this repository-only static promotion (runtime_access: none, physical_e2e_required: false).
Open material findings: 0.
Final classification: PASS_AFTER_REPAIR.
Objective
Promote the corrected bounded static checkpoint of
TIBIA-RE-ECONOMY-PANELSfor G24-G31 from source Draft PR #546 after fresh coordinator revalidation.Independent coordinator review
The source Draft was not trusted as-is. Fresh review re-read the raw S1 C2S/S2C registries, handler-xref catalogue, capability census at immutable source refs, PR #293/archive metadata, Track A admission contract and PR #536 ownership.
The source task had one real material governance defect: mandatory
runtime_access: noneadmission fields were missing and mutation state was inconsistent. Source head54dca602dfa38f1cc347716cf0f701b22c3fe6e9repairs that defect and passes Track A governance run32219366592plus CI run32219366648.An intermediate coordinator revision then hypothesized a capability-census SHA conflict. Fresh immutable re-reads disprove that hypothesis: capability census at both source base
a1368bb…and source head54dca602…, PR #293 and the archived capability-design task all usee6c244bd39fe2e0632f6f000efd3147164696efa8e901718668e0442325ff7fe. The false conflict is removed from the promotion artifacts.Current canonical alias boundary
PR #543 is merged on the promotion base. The canonical
TIBIA-RE-ECONOMY-PANELSalias includes read-only live panel/confirmation-boundary research. Therefore this PR does not mark the full alias runtime mission or G24-G31 coverage DONE; it promotes and archives only the bounded static census subtask.Promoted boundary
Safety
The static subtask is
runtime_access: none,mutation_authorized: false,physical_e2e_required: false. No login, credentials, GUI input, process control, gameplay, purchase/sale, market mutation, coin transfer, reward claim, auction/trade commitment, world transfer, main-character change or due-payment action is part of this promotion.After this promotion is exact-head CI clean and merged, source Draft PR #546 should be closed unmerged as superseded. The full canonical alias retains a separately admitted live read-only continuation.