docs(track-a): add full-client RE 100% checklist - #536
Conversation
blakinio
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Fresh independent coordinator documentation audit: ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS.
The 169-row denominator, status contract, subsystem taxonomy and evidence-boundary design are sound. The source head is not merge-ready because it is 28 commits behind current main and its current-refresh/matrix are materially stale after today's promoted work.
Material findings to repair in a clean current-main promotion:
- COV-AUD-001 — stale current-client/login state. #555/#561 now establish the exact current official Linux fence (
15.32,52109920,ed5469…, Build IDd803…). #528/#577/#578 causally prove native login-to-world at the exact current build. PromoteA01 PARTIAL→DONE,A07 PARTIAL→DONE,A09 PARTIAL→DONE,A14 BLOCKED→DONE; preserveA15 BLOCKEDbecause post-handoff stability failed; promoteA16 BLOCKED→PARTIALbecause current-build form-less helper revalidation succeeded but update/restart stability remains open. - COV-AUD-002 — stale current-build RE blocker. Current-build packages #544/#551/#556/#558/#559/#560 plus #528 exact-SHA helpers prove substantial revalidation on the new binary. Promote
H21 BLOCKED→PARTIALandH22 BLOCKED→PARTIAL; neither is DONE. - COV-AUD-003 — missing accepted static G0 deltas. Promote
F11/F12,D06/D07,D12-D14,D19-D22,G01/G04-G06, andH07-H14fromNOT_STARTED→PARTIALaccording to their independently promoted source packages. Existing PARTIAL rows remain PARTIAL. - COV-AUD-004 — economy semantic-ID reconciliation. Accepted static census #547 maps by semantic row name, not by the source task's local G-number labels. Promote canonical
G24 Market,G25 Store,G26 Daily Reward,G27 Reward Wall,G28 Character Info,G29 Blessings/premium, andG30 Character auction/tradeto PARTIAL. Keep canonicalG31 World transfer/main-character changeNOT_STARTED: #547 found no dedicated transport mapping and #550's GUI observation is explicitly diagnostic/not promotable. - COV-AUD-005 — stale frontier prose. #539/S10 is no longer IN_PROGRESS; its terminal result is
BLOCKED_MISSING_RETAINED_CODE_WINDOWwith B04/C21 remaining PARTIAL. #550 is terminal withcanonical_live_G24_G31_status_delta=NONE. #557 is terminal superseded and adds no coverage delta. - Do not promote H01/H05 or other H01-H06/H15-H19 rows from compiled-name/controller presence alone; current-build static refresh preserves those semantic gaps.
After these edits the conservative current projection is exactly:
DONE 14
PARTIAL 95
NOT_STARTED 56
BLOCKED 4
TOTAL 169
Use a clean promotion from current main; preserve the original 169-row checklist as the historical denominator snapshot, and make the refreshed overlay/current matrix authoritative for present status. No runtime work is required or authorized for this coverage closeout.
Finalize source #536 lifecycle after audited current-main promotion and release coverage-task ownership.
Terminal source disposition — superseded by clean coordinator promotion #583
Status: CLOSED UNMERGED AS SUPERSEDED.
Task:
OTC-20260818-track-a-full-client-re-coverage-auditSource head:
24bdc5b959ff02733ada3967cae8ad1df1465f7d.Fresh independent coordinator review
4971484054classified the source ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS. The 169-row denominator/taxonomy/status contract was accepted; the source current-refresh/matrix was materially stale and the branch was 28 commits behind currentmain.Clean promotion #583 preserved the historical 169-row checklist byte-identically (
blob 306e94aa1e92e626ad6e9db8df0c35428dfa602c) and rebuilt the current overlay/matrix from independently promoted evidence.Current canonical projection:
Current blocked rows are exactly:
Promotion #583 facts:
The refresh intentionally does not promote #550 diagnostic GUI observations, does not infer #539's missing action-specific edge, keeps A15 blocked after observed session loss, keeps G31 NOT_STARTED, and does not advance H01-H06/H15-H19 from compiled-name presence alone.
No runtime, credentials, login, GUI input, gameplay, transaction, process-memory access or runtime mutation was performed by the coordinator audit/promotion. The source branch must not be merged after its corrected promotion landed.