Skip to content

docs(track-a): research FEATURES G01-G06 static model - #557

Closed
blakinio wants to merge 5 commits into
mainfrom
research/OTC-20260819-track-a-features-g01-g06-static-model
Closed

docs(track-a): research FEATURES G01-G06 static model#557
blakinio wants to merge 5 commits into
mainfrom
research/OTC-20260819-track-a-features-g01-g06-static-model

Conversation

@blakinio

@blakinio blakinio commented Aug 19, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Terminal source disposition — superseded by later current-build evidence

Status: CLOSED UNMERGED AS SUPERSEDED.

Task: OTC-20260819-track-a-features-g01-g06-static-model
Source head: 91e2d2bf4e082a9ba487fbc5dc3927faea2f4081
Coordinator review: 4971413034
Decision: REJECT/SUPERSEDE.

The source facts remain valid as bounded retained historical evidence, but this Draft should not become a standalone canonical package:

  • it recommends no canonical coverage change;
  • it only re-indexes already-retained primary evidence;
  • its PR #555 unmerged/current fence unknown framing is stale;
  • later independently audited source research(track-a): feature systems static G0 #560 and clean promotion docs(track-a): promote feature systems static G0 #564 established current-build G01/G04/G05/G06 evidence and moved those rows to PARTIAL;
  • G02 remains PARTIAL from existing structural evidence and G03 remains NOT_STARTED; this package adds no causal/live/current-build proof that changes either status.

No source-fact falsification was found. The package correctly preserves semantic_dispatcher_edge_proven=false, current-build/live semantics as UNKNOWN, and no-runtime/no-mutation boundaries.

No shared #536 matrix/checklist path was modified by this source. The task is being archived/released separately from current main.

@blakinio blakinio left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Coordinator independent review: REJECT/SUPERSEDE (source facts remain valid retained historical evidence; this Draft package should not be promoted as a standalone canonical package).

Reasoning:

  • The package itself recommends no canonical status change and only re-indexes already-retained primary evidence for G01-G06.
  • Its current-build authority statement is stale: PR #555 is now merged/closed and the exact current package fence is canonical.
  • Later source #560 was independently audited and cleanly promoted through #564, moving G01/G04/G05/G06 from NOT_STARTED to PARTIAL on the current build. That materially supersedes this Draft's retained-build recommendations for those rows.
  • G02 remains PARTIAL from existing structural evidence and G03 remains NOT_STARTED; this Draft adds no new causal/live/current-build proof to justify a status change for either.
  • No material source-fact falsification was found; semantic_dispatcher_edge_proven=false and the UNKNOWN boundaries are appropriately conservative.

Disposition: close #557 unmerged as superseded; archive the bounded researcher task with ownership released. Do not merge the stale duplicate package and do not modify the shared #536 matrix from this source branch.

@blakinio blakinio closed this Aug 19, 2026
blakinio added a commit that referenced this pull request Aug 19, 2026
Record #557 as closed unmerged/superseded after coordinator review and release task ownership without changing canonical coverage.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant