research(track-a): feature systems static G0 - #560
Conversation
9ae46d1 to
2822de1
Compare
blakinio
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Fresh coordinator audit on exact researcher head 2822de1bc916a581de5aa3eb0601c1708c468b39.
Classification: ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS.
Independent verification performed:
- downloaded producer artifact
9356800104from run32229656311; - independently computed ZIP SHA-256
779f2d1af266ad0327191a5fda1289a524884c1a9fdb2c4d351d3de3dcaab8d0, exactly matching GitHub artifact metadata; - independently reproduced all four inner-file hashes recorded by the researcher;
- re-read the producer workflow and raw
features-qmeta.txt/ protocol strings; - directly verified the reported exact QMeta class counts/surfaces for
TCyclopediaProtocolMessageHandler,TCyclopediaDialogController,TBestiaryTrackerProtocolMessageHandler,TMonsterRaceStorage,TCreatureTrackerWidgetController,TMonsterDialogController,TQmlMonsterRace,TMonsterBonusEffectStorage,TMonsterBonusEffectsDialogController, andTQmlMonsterBonusEffect; - confirmed the producer records QMeta/static-metacall ownership only and does not manufacture per-method native targets or semantic dispatcher edges;
- confirmed current source checks
32230904020and32230904257are SUCCESS and review threads are zero.
Accepted bounded task-local deltas:
G01, G04, G05, G06: NOT_STARTED -> PARTIAL only. No row is DONE; message field schemas, handler->storage causality, cache lifetime/invalidation, resource/cost formulas, persistence, server validation, live success/error transitions and runtime causality remain UNKNOWN.
Material edit FEATURE-AUD-001 (LOW, high confidence): the task metadata incorrectly lists promoted public-package fingerprint from PR #551 as a dependency. #551 is the world/minimap promotion. The current canonical public-package/runtime fence is PR #555 merge 2e572789a2bc4b64c5e906c4515c15c625f6bc9e, with lifecycle closeout #561 on 34e41a04d62e642ef0ae67c79354f183473270a3. This is a provenance pointer error only; the producer independently fetched and fenced the exact package, so the underlying evidence remains sound.
Promotion requirements: preserve the evidence/report byte-for-byte where possible, correct current-fence provenance in coordinator-owned archive/promotion metadata, do not touch PR #536 shared coverage files, preserve runtime_access:none, and close source #560 unmerged as superseded after a clean current-main promotion succeeds.
Terminal source disposition — superseded by clean promotion #564
Status: CLOSED UNMERGED AS SUPERSEDED
Task:
OTC-20260819-track-a-features-static-g0Source head:
2822de1bc916a581de5aa3eb0601c1708c468b39Fresh coordinator review
4970396563classified the sourceACCEPT_WITH_EDITS.Independent coordinator verification directly downloaded producer artifact
9356800104, reproduced ZIP SHA-256779f2d1af266ad0327191a5fda1289a524884c1a9fdb2c4d351d3de3dcaab8d0, reproduced all four inner file hashes, and re-read raw QMeta/protocol evidence and producer methodology.Accepted bounded result:
No row is
DONE; PR #536 remains untouched.FEATURE-AUD-001corrected one provenance metadata error: source task text referenced PR #551 as the public-package fingerprint dependency, while current trusted fence authority is PR #555 merge2e572789a2bc4b64c5e906c4515c15c625f6bc9eplus closeout #561. Underlying evidence remained sound because the producer independently fetched and fenced the exact package.Clean promotion #564 was created from current trusted
main@08c0b6f89ffddd4c75b8f60060ce3b2a62195d95withahead_by=1,behind_by=0, exactly four intended paths, source evidence/report byte-identical to this Draft, and coordinator-owned audit/archive metadata.Promotion validation:
No runtime, login, credentials, gameplay, resource spending, GUI input or client-byte mutation occurred during coordinator promotion/closeout.