Skip to content

research(track-a): feature systems static G0 - #560

Closed
blakinio wants to merge 3 commits into
mainfrom
research/OTC-20260819-track-a-features-static-model
Closed

research(track-a): feature systems static G0#560
blakinio wants to merge 3 commits into
mainfrom
research/OTC-20260819-track-a-features-static-model

Conversation

@blakinio

@blakinio blakinio commented Aug 19, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Terminal source disposition — superseded by clean promotion #564

Status: CLOSED UNMERGED AS SUPERSEDED
Task: OTC-20260819-track-a-features-static-g0
Source head: 2822de1bc916a581de5aa3eb0601c1708c468b39

Fresh coordinator review 4970396563 classified the source ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS.

Independent coordinator verification directly downloaded producer artifact 9356800104, reproduced ZIP SHA-256 779f2d1af266ad0327191a5fda1289a524884c1a9fdb2c4d351d3de3dcaab8d0, reproduced all four inner file hashes, and re-read raw QMeta/protocol evidence and producer methodology.

Accepted bounded result:

G01 NOT_STARTED -> PARTIAL
G04 NOT_STARTED -> PARTIAL
G05 NOT_STARTED -> PARTIAL
G06 NOT_STARTED -> PARTIAL

No row is DONE; PR #536 remains untouched.

FEATURE-AUD-001 corrected one provenance metadata error: source task text referenced PR #551 as the public-package fingerprint dependency, while current trusted fence authority is PR #555 merge 2e572789a2bc4b64c5e906c4515c15c625f6bc9e plus closeout #561. Underlying evidence remained sound because the producer independently fetched and fenced the exact package.

Clean promotion #564 was created from current trusted main@08c0b6f89ffddd4c75b8f60060ce3b2a62195d95 with ahead_by=1, behind_by=0, exactly four intended paths, source evidence/report byte-identical to this Draft, and coordinator-owned audit/archive metadata.

Promotion validation:

CI 32235952137 = SUCCESS
promotion review 4970434583 = PASS
promotion head 9b8ef32d6c263607bc2472a7526b3d614ca0d9be
promotion merge b239158a609d4b813b3f979580954e5ed28faac8

No runtime, login, credentials, gameplay, resource spending, GUI input or client-byte mutation occurred during coordinator promotion/closeout.

@blakinio
blakinio force-pushed the research/OTC-20260819-track-a-features-static-model branch from 9ae46d1 to 2822de1 Compare August 19, 2026 08:05

@blakinio blakinio left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Fresh coordinator audit on exact researcher head 2822de1bc916a581de5aa3eb0601c1708c468b39.

Classification: ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS.

Independent verification performed:

  • downloaded producer artifact 9356800104 from run 32229656311;
  • independently computed ZIP SHA-256 779f2d1af266ad0327191a5fda1289a524884c1a9fdb2c4d351d3de3dcaab8d0, exactly matching GitHub artifact metadata;
  • independently reproduced all four inner-file hashes recorded by the researcher;
  • re-read the producer workflow and raw features-qmeta.txt / protocol strings;
  • directly verified the reported exact QMeta class counts/surfaces for TCyclopediaProtocolMessageHandler, TCyclopediaDialogController, TBestiaryTrackerProtocolMessageHandler, TMonsterRaceStorage, TCreatureTrackerWidgetController, TMonsterDialogController, TQmlMonsterRace, TMonsterBonusEffectStorage, TMonsterBonusEffectsDialogController, and TQmlMonsterBonusEffect;
  • confirmed the producer records QMeta/static-metacall ownership only and does not manufacture per-method native targets or semantic dispatcher edges;
  • confirmed current source checks 32230904020 and 32230904257 are SUCCESS and review threads are zero.

Accepted bounded task-local deltas:
G01, G04, G05, G06: NOT_STARTED -> PARTIAL only. No row is DONE; message field schemas, handler->storage causality, cache lifetime/invalidation, resource/cost formulas, persistence, server validation, live success/error transitions and runtime causality remain UNKNOWN.

Material edit FEATURE-AUD-001 (LOW, high confidence): the task metadata incorrectly lists promoted public-package fingerprint from PR #551 as a dependency. #551 is the world/minimap promotion. The current canonical public-package/runtime fence is PR #555 merge 2e572789a2bc4b64c5e906c4515c15c625f6bc9e, with lifecycle closeout #561 on 34e41a04d62e642ef0ae67c79354f183473270a3. This is a provenance pointer error only; the producer independently fetched and fenced the exact package, so the underlying evidence remains sound.

Promotion requirements: preserve the evidence/report byte-for-byte where possible, correct current-fence provenance in coordinator-owned archive/promotion metadata, do not touch PR #536 shared coverage files, preserve runtime_access:none, and close source #560 unmerged as superseded after a clean current-main promotion succeeds.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant