research(track-a): validate economy panels read-only runtime

[blakinio]

Terminal source disposition — superseded by clean coordinator promotion #579

Status: CLOSED UNMERGED AS SUPERSEDED.
Task: OTC-20260819-track-a-economy-panels-runtime-readonly
Source head: 32294c6491e56447c2b5f82112f3c65bd9732d81.

Coordinator review 4971299542: ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS, zero open material findings after bounded repair.

Controlling result

The earlier GUI sequence used unsupported Track A admission value:

runtime_access=bounded_gui_readonly_navigation

Governance run 32240817177 failed the deterministic admission-policy job exactly on that value. Therefore the GUI observations remain factual diagnostics only and are not promotion-grade Track A evidence.

Final source head corrected itself fail-closed to runtime_access:none, no GUI input/no mutation and passed:

Track A governance 32242818055 = SUCCESS
CI                 32242818269 = SUCCESS
review threads = 0

Terminal bounded classification

bounded_task_result = BLOCKED_RUNTIME_ADMISSION_UNAVAILABLE
canonical_live_G24_G31_status_delta = NONE
physical_e2e_promotion_grade = NOT_ACHIEVED

Diagnostic-only group disposition remains:

G25 Store/Coin History                    DIAGNOSTIC_OBSERVED_NOT_PROMOTABLE
G28 Character/Premium                     DIAGNOSTIC_OBSERVED_NOT_PROMOTABLE; Blessings NOT_REACHED
G30 World Transfer/Main Character surface DIAGNOSTIC_OBSERVED_NOT_PROMOTABLE
G31 Generic modal                         DIAGNOSTIC_OBSERVED_NOT_PROMOTABLE
G24/G26/G27/G29                           NOT_REACHED

NOT_REACHED is not absence evidence. No G24-G31 live row is promoted by this task.

Clean promotion

Source history was stale and was not merged directly. Clean promotion #579 used current main, preserved four exact source evidence blobs plus coordinator audit/archive, stayed behind_by=0, passed exact-head CI 32244909100, promotion review 4971322909, zero threads, and squash-merged as:

bc6c14c972181fc73209cd20d95cad43f80fd3c9

No coordinator runtime observation, GUI input, login, credential use, gameplay or economy/account transaction was performed for closeout. Native-login #528 is now terminal/released; any future live economy-panel advancement requires a separately valid Track A admission and minimal revalidation rather than retroactive promotion of this diagnostic sequence.

[blakinio]

Coordinator independent review classification: ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS for terminal bounded closeout, with no promotion-grade live G24-G31 status delta.

Verified from the source evidence and exact workflow logs:

• the earlier GUI sequence was performed while the task used unsupported runtime_access=bounded_gui_readonly_navigation;
• Track A governance run 32240817177 failed exactly on that unsupported admission value;
• after the defect was identified, the task was corrected fail-closed to runtime_access:none, gui_input_authorized:false, mutation_authorized:false and no further GUI input was authorized;
• source exact head 32294c6491e56447c2b5f82112f3c65bd9732d81 later passed Track A governance 32242818055 and CI 32242818269;
• review threads are zero;
• retained preflight/passive evidence has clear historical/diagnostic boundaries and does not turn NOT_REACHED into absence;
• GUI observations for G25, partial G28, G30 and G31 remain DIAGNOSTIC_OBSERVED_NOT_PROMOTABLE, not PASS/DONE;
• G24/G26/G27/G29 and G28 Blessings remain NOT_REACHED;
• no transaction, purchase, market mutation, Coin transfer, reward claim, character trade, world-transfer commit, main-character-change commit, gameplay movement or credential re-entry is claimed.

The current source branch is stale in Git ancestry and must not merge directly. Clean promotion may preserve the diagnostic evidence and the terminal admission blocker, but must correct stale lifecycle references (notably #528 is now completed/released) and archive this bounded task as completed-with-blocker rather than pretending physical semantic validation succeeded.

Canonical programme consequence of #550 itself: NONE for G24-G31 live status. Any future promotion-grade economy-panel semantics require a separately valid Track A runtime admission and minimal revalidation; no such revalidation is performed for this closeout.