docs(track-a): close worldmap extent static dependency graph - #367
Conversation
blakinio
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
OTCLIENT-TIBIA-RE-COORD fresh disposition: ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS / DRAFT_NOT_PROMOTED.
Verified live state: main=8c9486e2c6109a7a39b564804c8acd707659b5e0; consumer head=f381cd657642ce592b2cbbc95783813ae72fcf6a; consumer Track A governance run 32003994139 SUCCESS; consumer CI run 32003994241 SUCCESS. Producer #446 exact head f7f16af has governance 32003664983 SUCCESS and CI 32003665239 SUCCESS. Producer #437 has advanced to final head 3e14d07 with governance 32005392491 SUCCESS and CI 32005392636 SUCCESS; its final second-package evidence independently corroborates the load-bearing 18/14 -> ProtocolHandler -> snapshot -> Storage slot12 chain while preserving the later-writer/capacity/Camera unknowns.
Admission/ownership/uniqueness/drift: STATIC-RE remains github_hosted/runtime_access=none; exact client fence remains 15.32.df7b29 / 51965216 / e6c244bd39fe2e0632f6f000efd3147164696efa8e901718668e0442325ff7fe; open worldmap-extent inventory is bounded to consumer #367 plus its two declared producers #437/#446, with producer namespaces distinct from the consumer-owned paths. Current main drift since the consumer base is not a conflicting worldmap change. Material provenance drift DOES exist inside #367: its task record still pins producer #437 at ce8b1f5 and the PR body lists only the earlier #437 package, while live final #437 is 3e14d07.
Coordinator classification: the static dependency result itself is accepted; no new static producer is required. Before canonical promotion, refresh #367 durable provenance to consume/pin final #437 head 3e14d07 and its final second-package run/artifact provenance, retain #446 at f7f16af, and rerun exact-head required CI on the refreshed consumer head. Keep MUTATION_DESIGN_READY=false and client-byte mutation unauthorized. Do not repeat static discovery.
|
You have reached your Codex usage limits for code reviews. You can see your limits in the Codex usage dashboard. |
blakinio
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
OTCLIENT-TIBIA-RE-COORD final disposition: ACCEPT / PROMOTE.
Exact terminal consumer head: 2009e78, merged-current-main parent: 8212765. Full changed-file and full diff audit: PASS; terminal PR contains exactly 15 documentation files, with no one-shot analyzer, workflow, active task, raw exact game-client executable, or client-byte mutation. Historical checkpoint statuses are retained as point-in-time provenance and are superseded by the coordinator closeout, final report and handover.
Canonical producer dependencies are satisfied: #437 -> f753b5a after strict-main CI 32007165687 SUCCESS; #446 -> 8212765 after strict-main CI 32007282137 SUCCESS. Consumer exact-head CI 32007688241 SUCCESS; required job CI / Required 95320511757 SUCCESS. Unresolved review threads: 0. No blocking review state is present.
Accepted result: STATIC_DEPENDENCY_GRAPH_RECOVERED / STATIC_PATCH_GRAPH_READY=true. MUTATION_DESIGN_READY=false and client-byte mutation remains unauthorized. Carried later-writer, source-field semantic, Camera indirect/projection, unproven protocol-ceiling, RenderProvider-capacity-semantic and safe-mutation questions remain explicit UNKNOWNs. E2E=NOT_APPLICABLE because this PR changes static evidence/governance documentation only and makes no user-facing/live-runtime change.
Coordinator closeout requirement is satisfied; #367 is eligible for canonical squash promotion.
Coordinator terminal closeout
Task:
OTC-20260816-track-a-worldmap-extent-static-reCoordinator disposition:
ACCEPT_WITH_EDITS_COMPLETEDStatic classification:
STATIC_DEPENDENCY_GRAPH_RECOVERED.Exact client fence
Canonical producers
Producer #437:
Producer #446:
Accepted dependency graph
Viewport constructor default/recompute, Storage bounds+eviction, RenderProvider fixed-32 clipping/indexing/iteration, Picker fixed-32 screen/world transforms, and exact Camera layout/ViewPort co-ownership are accepted. The Camera exact-vptr sweep recovered no direct Camera-field-to-extent mutation edge; that result is bounded negative evidence, not a global absence proof.
Carried
UNKNOWNs include the complete post-construction Handler master-pair writer census, exact source member names/units, named Camera projection or indirect coupling outside bounded neighborhoods, any unproven network/parser extent ceiling, semantic interpretation of the RenderProvider65535 x 10-byteallocation as a map ceiling, and any safe client-byte mutation design.Terminal tree
The PR now contains exactly 15 documentation files: 13 evidence/handover records, the final report, and the archived task. The one-shot analyzer and active task are removed. Historical checkpoints intentionally retain their point-in-time
BLOCKED/Draftclassifications; current authoritative state is the coordinator closeout, final report and continuation handover.Authoritative terminal records:
docs/agents/evidence/OTC-20260816-track-a-worldmap-extent-static-re/20260817-coordinator-producer-acceptance-closeout.mddocs/agents/reports/OTCLIENT-20260816-worldmap-extent-static-re.mddocs/agents/evidence/OTC-20260816-track-a-worldmap-extent-static-re/CONTINUATION_HANDOVER.mddocs/agents/tasks/archive/OTC-20260816-track-a-worldmap-extent-static-re.mdNo raw exact game-client executable is promoted by this closeout; the separately documented historical launcher/bootstrap Actions artifact is not the fenced exact game-client executable. No client bytes were changed.
E2E:
NOT_APPLICABLE— static reverse-engineering evidence closeout only; no user-facing/live-runtime behavior is changed.Full changed-file and full diff audit on terminal current-main head
2009e78d152e79d30573794d16264fff81e2158d: PASS, 0 material findings. Merge only after exact-head required CI succeeds and branch protection confirms the head is current withmain.